Skip to main content

Member Reviews

TL/DR: You’ve read the synopsis, right? Great! Now what you need to know is this is not your average, quick read paranormal. It takes everything we think we know and the author makes it her own. Be prepared for a rollercoaster of emotions, use caution when drinking any liquid (you’ll get it, trust me) and be prepared for an exceptional story. I’ve already ordered a copy for my trophy shelf. Yeah, it’s that good.

I was expecting a fun, quick, little paranormal read. What I wasn’t expecting was for the author to break my heart, gently put it back together and then leave me in a puddle of heartbreak and happiness. Weird combo, I’ll give you that, but this book had everything and if it is not at the very least a duology, even better a trilogy or series, I am going to cry.

The characters and the world are so rich it makes the town of Avondale feel like it doesn’t just exist in the author’s mind, but somewhere along the California coast.

Allie, 16, one of our FMC has recently lost her Mom to a tragic event, and our other FMC, Selene, has lost her best friend, her found family. She has also been granted guardianship of Allie. She is no longer just the fun aunt, she is responsible for her in every way and because of this, she brings Allie back to Avondale, to something familiar, albeit with a new routine, in a home that is comforting while they are still grieving and growing.

To learn that Avondale, a place Allie’s mom said felt like home was just a little different than what she expected was a shock. She didn’t think they kept anything from each other.

Then Allie throws another shock at her, she has a boyfriend, he’s paranormal and oh yeah, Selene’s biggest donor (to her campaigns, usually environmental in nature) is kinda like his Dad.

This book will have you sympathizing with how quickly Selene’s world is changing, laughing at her reactions and faux-pas, and then getting swept up in everything that happens from the first page to the last.

I want to thank the author, Montlake publishing and NetGalley for a copy of this book. I definitely need a copy for my trophy shelf. All opinions are my own and my review is voluntarily given. As always, I wish you happy reading.

#AlwaysCarryASilverCross #NetGalley #Montlake #NetGalley #Paranormal #NotQuiteHuman
#Werewolves #Fae #Witches #Vampires #ParanormalRomance
#ContemporaryParanormal #ContemporaryFantasy #ContemporaryParanormalRomance

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun read, nothing amazing but it enjoyed it as i was reading it and didn't wabt to put it down i found our FMC selean very quirky and animated/cheeky i liked how the world building was low key but still drew a interesting picture of the town and environment I'd definitely recommend if you need a fun read thats not too serious and flows easy

Was this review helpful?

What a great read! I loved the rom-com vibes in this fantasy world to pieces.
The world building was great and the story line easy to follow. A overall win!

Was this review helpful?

Dark, dreamy, and just the right amount of dangerous.

This book hooked me from the first page. Always Carry a Silver Cross has that perfect mix of gothic mystery, supernatural tension, and slow-burn romance that keeps you turning the pages way past bedtime.

The atmosphere? On point. Creepy forests, lurking shadows, and secrets that unravel with every chapter. The world feels eerie but beautiful—like you know something’s not quite right, but you want to stay anyway. And the characters? So layered and compelling. I couldn’t get enough of the tension and emotional pull between them.

*thank you to netgalley and the publisher for an early copy of this book in exchange for an honest review*

Was this review helpful?

This was a perfect thrilling, fun & playful paranormal romance! From the very first page it had be captivated and interested!

Was this review helpful?

1.5 Stars

Unfortunately this book was very disappointing for me. I found that the pacing was very inconsistent, the characters had little to no depth, and I found that the main characters had no chemistry.

Like I understand Fen is a wolf but like home dog was straight up possessive and controlling. I didn't like him at all. And like he was 100% going to go ahead with executing Natalie for literally helping arm and defend domestic abuse victims?? I don't care that he changed his mind last minute, he did that out of 'love' for Selene and not out of guilt.

I think this book needed a lot more work into giving the characters in-depth personalities and character traits. More work I think should have been put into the plot, as realistically there actually wasn't much going on in terms of a continuous storyline.

Was this review helpful?

This was a perfect fun, thrilling and whimsical paranormal romance. The opening premise of this book was really interesting. I was intrigued to see how Selene would settle into a new life becoming Allie’s guardian and moving into a magical small town.

I enjoyed being in Selene’s perspective as she dealt with everything she discovered. I did find some of it repetitive as what was revealed to her would be recalled to friends and family constantly.
I loved our introduction to Fen and his world. I also loved that we got POV’s from other characters, it added more intrigue to the book.

This book was just the right amount of magic and romance without it being overpowered by either. I’ve read a few werewolf romances and have found them to be focused on the spice. I enjoyed that this was a cozier book that reminded me of The Ex Hex and Well Met. BUT it wasn’t all cozy romance and magic as things get deeper and more troubling I found myself desperate to know what would happen next. I actually didn’t know this book was a series so I was surprised with how it finished but i’m so excited to continue being in this world and see what’s to come.

Overall I really enjoyed this book, thought it was really well written and executed. I’ve never read anything by Andrea Robertson before this but i’ll definitely look into more of her books in the future.

Thank you NetGalley, the publisher and author for the opportunity to read and review this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, Andrea Robertson, and the publisher for allowing me to read this ARC in exchange for honest review.

I throughly enjoyed this story. It is written in a third person point of view. So that was a bit different for me, but I felt as if it was well done.

Selene, the main character drew me in. I found her quite quirky and cheeky in some regards. Plot development was well.

World building in the story could have had a little more to draw the reader in. But the book had good dialogue and overall character development which I enjoyed. I would recommend this book to others!

Was this review helpful?

𝓐𝓵𝔀𝓪𝔂𝓼 𝓬𝓪𝓻𝓻𝔂 𝓪 𝓼𝓲𝓵𝓿𝓮𝓻 𝓬𝓻𝓸𝓼𝓼 🌔

“She'd confessed she loved him. He'd believed. He'd known it in his heart, his blood, his bones."

Hello, my sweet, awful creatures! 🦇

It is Official! I got my first ever ARC!!!

If that wasn't already amazing news, I absolutely loved this book! As you all know, I'm usually more of a vampire girly, having reviewed nearly every vampire-related book out there. That's also why I signed up for this book. However, after reading the first chapter, I realized that this was a werewolf romance. We all remember the Team Edward vs. Team Jacob feud and have likely chosen our sides since then. I am firmly Team Edward, but for the first time, I began to understand why someone might choose a strong, attractive werewolf who is completely devoted to them. Why? The answer lies in my review. Let's get started!

Our story begins with our female protagonist, Selene, who moves to a new town called Avondale to care for her deceased friend's daughter, Allison, who has been left parentless since her father disappeared ten years ago. What Selene doesn't realize is that Allison is not entirely alone; she has a secret boyfriend who may appear to be an ordinary seventeen-year-old, but is much more than that—Josh is a werewolf. Unprepared to parent a sixteen-year-old girl, Selene never imagined in her wildest dreams that she would not only take on the role of guardian but also delve into the depths of a new, magical, and dangerous life. What if Josh isn’t the only mythical being in Avondale?

Ahhhhhh! I can’t begin to express how much I loved this story! I finished the book in just two days, which is unusual for me, especially considering it is written in the third person. The narrative is so well-crafted that I couldn’t put it down whenever I had a moment to read. Selene and Fen are a match made in heaven—literally. Their love story is both intriguing and exhilarating, keeping me on the edge of my seat the entire time! (You could say I'm still on edge since the book ends on a cliffhanger.) They are drawn to each other from the moment they first meet, as if their fates were intertwined long before she even moved to Avondale. However, as romantic and passionate as their relationship is, there are also many heartbreaking scenes that brought tears to my eyes, so keep a box of tissues nearby. Although their initial connection is driven by animalistic instinct, time reveals the depth of their love for one another. Will Fen's position in the pack create obstacles for them, or is their love strong enough to defy the rules of his pack?

The scene that truly captivated me in this story was the bonfire ritual. Let me tell you, it was the most exhilarating, giggle-inducing, foot-kicking type of smut I have ever read. I gasped when he declared that he would own her—that's apparently what werewolf romance is all about.

My rating is as follows: I want the prequel now! 5/5 bats. 🦇

If you're a fan of werewolf or monster romance, preorder this book now and be prepared for a steamy ride!

Until next time!

Mira 💗

Was this review helpful?

When I read the premise of Always Carry a Silver Cross, I was excited. Unfortunately, that early excitement faded pretty quickly.

The main character, Selene, just didn’t draw me in. Her internal thoughts didn’t feel compelling, and her dialogue often felt flat or forced. I think there was an attempt to make her quirky or cheeky, but it didn’t quite land. As a reader, I wanted more build-up or emotional weight to such a major reveal. Instead, the moment felt glossed over, and Josh’s character didn’t add much beyond being polite and helpful which, while nice, didn’t make him stand out.

That said, the concept behind the story is genuinely strong. I wanted to enjoy this book. The world-building had real potential, and the idea of integrating supernatural creatures into a contemporary setting is always fun when done well. With stronger character development and dialogue, this could have been an engaging, entertaining read.

Was this review helpful?

While the premise had potential and I usually enjoy paranormal stories, this one just didn’t work for me. The pacing felt rushed, the characters weren’t fleshed out, and the dialogue often came across as cringy. Disappointing overall.

Was this review helpful?

A story filled with magical creatures this is a unique read although one that I didn’t enjoy. To be honest this isn’t my go to genre but decided to give it a try, I didn’t enjoy it. Also didn’t like the fact that it was written on the third person. I couldn’t get into this book.
Thank you to Netgalley for an advanced copy of this book, all opinions expressed are my own.

Was this review helpful?

When I read the premise of Always Carry a Silver Cross, I was excited. A world where magical creatures like vampires and werewolves coexist with humans (who are actually aware of their existence)? It gave me major Sookie Stackhouse meets Halloweentown vibes, and I was definitely intrigued.

Unfortunately, that early excitement faded pretty quickly. From page one, I realized the book is written in third-person point of view—something that’s not usually my preference, but I’ve enjoyed many third-person narratives before. However, by the end of the first chapter, I knew this would be a tough read for me.

The main character, Selene, just didn’t draw me in. Her internal thoughts didn’t feel compelling, and her dialogue often felt flat or forced. I think there was an attempt to make her quirky or cheeky, but it didn’t quite land. For example, thoughts like “You’re in the country now, Selene. Chill.” felt more like filler than insight into her personality.

There was also a missed opportunity with a key plot moment. When Selene’s niece, Allie, introduces her boyfriend and casually says, “Josh is a werewolf,” it felt rushed. As a reader, I wanted more build-up or emotional weight to such a major reveal. Instead, the moment felt glossed over, and Josh’s character didn’t add much beyond being polite and helpful—which, while nice, didn’t make him stand out.

That said, the concept behind the story is genuinely strong. I wanted to enjoy this book. The world-building had real potential, and the idea of integrating supernatural creatures into a contemporary setting is always fun when done well. With stronger character development and dialogue, this could have been an engaging, entertaining read.

Ultimately, I stopped reading around the 50-page mark. I skimmed a few later chapters hoping for deeper character arcs or a spark of momentum, but I didn’t quite find it. Still, I appreciate the creative vision behind the story and hope others may connect with it more than I did.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Selene se muda al pequeño pueblo de Avondale para cuidar de Allie, la hija adolescente de su mejor amiga fallecida. Mientras ambas luchan por adaptarse a esta nueva etapa, la historia toma un giro inesperado cuando Selene descubre que Josh, el encantador y aparentemente perfecto novio de Allie, es un hombre lobo.. A partir de ahí, Selene se ve arrastrada a una realidad insólita en la que los hombres lobo, vampiros, brujas y hadas conviven discretamente entre los humanos. Y no solo eso: Josh pertenece a una poderosa manada, cuyo líder, Fenris Hall, resulta ser también un misterioso y filantrópico benefactor del trabajo ambientalista de Selene.



Necesito el siguiente libro.

Thanks to NetGalley, the publisher and the author for the ARC in exchange for an honest

Was this review helpful?