Cover Image: Flight Of A Starling

Flight Of A Starling

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Teenage forbidden love; so far, so 'Romeo and Juliet'
But it's told anew through the sisters of the circus, the semi magical world they inhabit, and the unexpected events that end their story
Was this review helpful?
Amazing coming of age novel - just wow, hit me in all the right places. Highly recommended if you feel like bawling your eyes out and feeling like all life is precious and every moment should be appreciated.
Was this review helpful?
I read  Paper Butterflies by Lisa Heathfield last year and it simply blew me away. Given this I couldn't wait to read Flight of a Starling.  This author knows how to turn the simple into the extraordinary. The language is engaging, unusual and evocative, you won't find any padding or filler here. I raced through this book and the end came far to quickly. The characters are engaging and real, and the view of circus life was a nice touch. I read the last few chapters of this book in a state of appalled tension. I knew the ending would be devastating and beautiful in equal measure, and whilst I  knew what was coming the reality of it made me shift in my seat and read through partially closed eyes.  Then suddenly alongside the sadness comes the hope - this really is great writing. Recommended to anyone who enjoys YA books - it's great.
Was this review helpful?
After reading Paper Butterflies by Lisa Heathfield last year I knew that I needed to read her latest book out. Lisa is UKYA author and I don’t think she gets enough credit for her work. This is another book that delivers a believable story with such rawness and emotion.

Our story follows Rita and Lo, two sisters that are travelers and the trapeze act in their circus that moves around England on a regular basis. Life is how it has always been for the girls, set up their tent, do a few shows and move on to the next village – they haven’t known any other life and don’t really question it. They travel with another family and it’s presumed the girls will marry the boys of the other family and carry on the legacy of the circus. One evening when they explore the local area they start talking to some of the locals and sparks start to ignite between Lo and ‘a flattie'(a term for non traveler folk). With Lo slowly falling in love she starts to question her life,her role and existence in the circus – with wanting her freedom she finds cracks starting to appear and her life crumbling around her.

‘Flight of a Starling’ didn’t fail to deliver,  I knew from past works that this was going to be an emotional, gritty and raw read. Heathfield has a great writing style that manages to evoke emotions – even from me who has a heart of stone. The story is told in dual perspective, swapping from Rita to Lo with just the right sized chapters. The first half of this book is rather slow what with it building a picture of what it was like to be in a travelling community and their traditions and beliefs. I loved learning about the performances that the girls were involved in such as the trapeze and their big costumes.

I must admit that I wasn’t too keen on the romance side of the book, It was lacking emotion and connection between the characters, I wanted the warm fuzziness that you get from reading about a couple that first meet, the excitement of it…which didn’t happen and it’s sad as it has such a big part of the story.

The second half of the book takes a change in pace, it was amazing and what really made the story for me. My heart was in my mouth and I could feel the blood pulsing around my body with anxiety. I was scared for the characters,I was hoping for a silver lining but Heathfield never shies away from her writing and sucker punches you in the gut.

I recommend if you want something gritty yet believable.

I rated this book 4 out of 5 stars
Was this review helpful?
Having read Paper Butterflies I was expecting another good read with this one and I wasn't disappointed. This is another heartbreaking, disturbing book which should go down well with its YA target audience. 
Told from two POV, Lo and Rita are sisters who have been brought up in a circus life. Having never questioned this, Lo's world is thrown into turmoil when she discovers a betrayal in her own family and falls in love with a local boy, much to the disapproval of her family.  Secrets and deceit have devastating consequences on all concerned. 

If I'm honest I loved Paper Butterflies so much that it would have been hard to match it.  Lisa Heathfield writes beautifully and tackles difficult subjects with skill and empathy.  Whilst I haven't rated this quite as highly I would still strongly recommend it. 
My thanks to Netgalley for this copy.
Was this review helpful?
She's done it again. Another brilliant book by Lisa Heathfield. 
A YA family saga and romance following the lives of a travelling circus and in particular Rita and Lo two inseparable sisters who have been brought up flying high as trapeze artists.
As Lo started to question if there was more to life outside of the circus family then the story really starts to develop. She falls for an 'outsider' and you really get a sense of the turbulence she goes through trying to follow her circus culture, whilst wanting to break free, become independent and follow her heart. This book gives an excellent insight into the travelling circus community and how difficult it can be for teenagers maturing into early adulthood. Hard to have their own voice and just  be themselves.
It is a very emotional yet beautiful read. It tackles coming of age issues of drug and alcohol abuse, teenage depression and suicide, which are important subjects to highlight.
This made me cry and that's due to the excellent writing, so be warned, not all good books have a happy ending.
Was this review helpful?
Thank you very much for allowing me to read this title; I am trying to read as widely as possible ahead of the Carnegie/Greenaway nominations and awards for 2018 and your help is much appreciated.
As a Carnegie/Greenaway judge, I'm not allowed to comment about my opinions on specific titles so I can't offer an individual review on any title as I stated on my profile.
Was this review helpful?
I don't think I'm the right age for this book, just wasn't my cup of tea I'm afraid.
Was this review helpful?
This is my review of Flight of a Starling by Lisa Heathfield. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own. The beginning of this review does not contain spoilers and I will indicate when spoilers come in.
 
This story follows the lives of two sisters, Lo and Rita. The book is told in the first person narrative, from these two character’s points of view. Their family is part of a circus, and they are all performers. 

This is a very character driven story, and we gradually learn more about secrets the characters have, and their desires. Love is also prominent in this story, as Lo begins to fall for a settled boy, Dean. One line that I thought was memorable to describe how she felt when she met him was:
				“It felt like the air stopped.”
They call non-circus people flatties, and they are not supposed to get involved with them. 

I thought the descriptions of the circus performances were beautiful. We get to see the performances as both a performer (through the eyes of Lo and Rita) and as a spectator (through the eyes of Dean). Lo gives a poignant description of the difference between nerves and fear in the lines:
	“Being nervous keeps you aware. It brightens everything around you, so that you
	Notice it all. Being scared just burns everything, so nothing is clear.”
This was a very memorable read, and is a story that will stay with me. I give it four out of five stars, recommending it to both teenagers and young adults.
Was this review helpful?
This is not immediately appealing. We spend a lot of time getting to know Rita and Lo, and learning about their life. However, once the main story kicks in...
This was almost a book of two parts for me. 
Elements that worked? The relationships between Lo and her family. I was less convinced by the setting.
Was this review helpful?
Rita and Lo are inseparable – sisters and best friends. Always on the move, and always flying through the air, holding on to each other for support for their trapeze act. Fearless and weightless, they find the magic in everything. Behind the act they put on, they know that the true magic in their family, not the circus. However, in one insignificant town, Lo meets a boy and decides she wants to be on the ground and stood still. Rita can’t understand, and suddenly their close-knit circus community is under threat when secrets are revealed.

I’ve only read one of Lisa Heathfields other books, Paper Butterflies, and I really enjoyed it. It was a chilling and harrowing book. So when I saw Flight of a Starling available on NetGalley, I jumped at the chance to read, and also, that cover is just beautiful.

Flight of a Starling was an enchanting and powerful book. It is raw, honest, and full of emotion. I loved the setting of the circus, and I loved the passion Rita and Lo had for the circus and for the art they produced. The atmosphere was very magical and enchanting, definitely a highlight of the book.

Flight of a Starling is a very character driven story. Both Rita and Lo, having lived in the circus their whole lives and being surrounded by the same people were innocent and naive, but each had some really great development. I liked how Lo started to question what she wanted, and how she discovered there was a world that existed outside of the circus, and she was trying to find her place in that world. The ‘forbidden romance’ was a nice element, it was interesting to see the struggle Lo had and the conflict it caused within her community and, more importantly, with her sister. I really liked Rita as well and her passion and support for her community. I loved her love she felt and the conflict she had with her sister. It was a really well developed and complex relationship.

The ending was emotional and heart-wrenching. I’d like to take this opportunity to warn readers (so, spoilers), but I’d like to add trigger warnings for drug abuse, overdose, accidental suicide, and depression.

Overall, Flight of a Starling was a compelling and emotional read that I do highly recommend.
Was this review helpful?
I generally love Lisa Heathfield's book and Paper Butterflies completely blew me away.
This novel definitely did not disappoint.
Right from the beginning I was drawn in to the world of Lo and Rita and am continually impressed at Heathfield's ability to deal with teenage issues in such a profound way.
Definitely will recommend.
Was this review helpful?
I recently read Lisa Heathfield's other books, Seed and Paper Butterflies, and absolutely loved them. I had high expectations for this one but I went into it without having much of an idea what it was about.

I loved the circus setting - it was so interesting to read! The set up almost felt similar to Seed - the setting in Seed is within a small cult family, and the circus atmosphere where no one leaves the circus and only very particular people join felt very similar. There were similar themes too, with the main character wondering about life on the outside and wanting to escape the claustrophobic world she's stuck in.

It look a little while for me to really get into the story. I flew through Seed and Paper Butterflies in a couple of days, but it took a good couple of weeks to read this one. (Maybe it was down to me being a bit more distracted though, rather than the book itself.) I instantly liked the characters (and disliked others) and I really liked the dynamic between sisters Lo and Rita. It was interesting too that the story switched between their perspectives - I didn't see why this was happening to begin with but as I got closer to the end, I started to see why.

I can't even believe what happened at the end. I was in so much shock! I almost never cry at anything, especially books, but I was so shocked and upset by the ending that my throat hurt. I'm still in disbelief - everything happened so quickly which matched the reality of what was really happening, and I couldn't stop reading.

Lisa Heathfield, you've done it again. She's definitely now an author on my auto-buy list!
Was this review helpful?
Oh this is a lovely book, so beautifully written and engaging. I enjoyed the world she created and was invested from the first chapter in what happened to these well written characters. The unusual setting was fascinating and the relationship between the sisters was wonderful.
Was this review helpful?
There were so many things that I loved about this book! I'm a huge fan of stories set in the circus and this captured the performers' lives in a way that seemed very real. The writing was gorgeous and the plot really gripped me (and broke my heart too). I'd strongly recommend this book to fans of Lisa Heathfield's writing and intense, dramatic YA.
Was this review helpful?
A wonderfully emotional novel that has you feeling everything you thought you couldn't.
Was this review helpful?
This book managed to draw so many emotions from me. It had the perfect balance to family and relationships that showed what a teenager can go through. I was in love with the setting of this book, there was something about a circus that made this also seem so much more magical, even at the most heart breaking of times
Was this review helpful?
What an unbelievably powerful storyteller. What a heart wrenching story. Heathfield makes you stroll through sadness until you realise too late that you're waist deep in pain and then somehow you have to trudge through a crap load of emotions that stick to you long after the book is finished. She did it with a her first book Paper Butterflies and she has done it yet again. 

I don't want to give too much away but this is a story of a young female circus traveller who falls in a 'forbidden' love with a non traveler. It's a muted slow build drama and I say muted only because this type of forbidden love is not the crazy taboo we've started to have shoved down our throats as writers try to outdo each other with wacky plots. 
It's simple but realistic in that it's about two people from two different stations in society falling in love. It also deals with the burdens and restrictions placed from family loyalties and the secrets that can grow from such ironically close knit relationships. 
It's beautiful, haunting and realistically compelling as it weaves the reader through the struggles we can internalise from trying to find our place in the world. 

Amazing, can't wait to read more from this author.
Was this review helpful?
There's such a magical quality to Lisa Heathfield's writing and the worlds she builds; even when I knew my heart would be run through the wringer by Flight of a Starling, I couldn't help falling in love with Rita and Lo, their rootless lives with the circus, and the boy whose arrival means everything is about to change. It was a magnificent book, very much alive and pulsing with feeling. 

*I received a copy of this book from Netgalley for review.*
Was this review helpful?