Cover Image: All the Hidden Truths

All the Hidden Truths

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Loved this book, i couldn’t put it down, I found the plot very exciting and it was thrilling the way the story unfolded. I enjoyed the main characters in this book. Highly recommended.

Many thanks to Netgalley and Claire Askew for the copy of this book. I agreed to give my unbiased opinion voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to the publishers and Netgalley for this arc in exchange for an honest review.
This follows a college shooting and its aftermath through 3 POVs:
* Moira: The shooter’s mother
* Ishbel: One of the 13 victim’s mother
* DI Birch, who’s investigating the case.
While the writing was good, and emotional, I personally found the story lacking in suspense; the ‘why’, the motivation was obvious and I was anticipating that the writer would explore it further and probe toxic masculinity, instead I didn’t get any sense of Ryan, the shooter, at all who by the end of the novel felt like a caricature and instead got a hammered in critique of the hounding of media.
Overall this book didn’t work for me, and I fail to understand the praise this book is getting. While the theme of a college shooting is topical this book offers nothing new at all, and I personally much preferred We Need to Talk About Kevin and 19 Minutes, which explored this subject in a much more unique, bold and original way. The problem is in how this book is being marketed creating incorrect expectations: this isn’t really a crime/thriller/mystery, rather its general fiction exploring grief and the aftermath of a horrific trauma.

Was this review helpful?

This is a compelling and disturbing read. One morning a young male student, Ryan Summers, walks into an education college and shoots 13 female students before taking his own life. Newly promoted DI Helen Birch is the first police officer to arrive at the scene and is then assigned to the case. The story is then told from three perspectives- Helen’s, the first victims mother and from Ryan’s mother. We then follow their grief and torment as to why the shooting happened and why Ryan did it. They have to come to terms with the tragedy and we follow all the events that led to it. We also discover Helen’s secret past and why she finds the journalist, Grant Lockley, so cruel and relentless in his pursuit of the story. This is a brilliant debut novel which had me completely hooked with the agony all three women went throug. One of my best reads of the year. I hope this is the beginning of a series featuring DI Helen Birch. A highly recommended read.
Thanks to NetGalley and Hodder and Stoughton for giving me the opportunity to read and review this book.

Was this review helpful?

Gives the reader real pause for thought.

In all the headlines and tweets and snatches of opinion coming from everywhere these days, this is a very well-written and extremely well-researched novel, focused on the points of view of several of those caught up in a mass shooting tragedy. Brave too, to imagine getting inside the heads of such a disparate group of characters at this moment in their lives and doing it so believably.

The author chose very wisely with her sources as you get a strong sense of the chaos, frustration and futility of such an investigation; the lack of psychological closure for all concerned, including the police force.

It really is 'power to the people' as the fallout from collective fears and mass hysteria, one little comment or article can now whip up is formidable.

Huge plaudits must go to the editor as well for helping to craft a brilliantly constructed narrative (it was this which tipped it into the five star bracket for me) as the 'hidden truths' were divulged, both large and small. I even liked that the main antagonist, certainly the main living one, was not permitted any personal back story and the possible sympathy it would allow, as if his actions were too grotesque to be excused no matter what was in his past. One little suggestion at the very end of the book is all we get and it's not followed up and for once that seemed apt. Unless of course, Ms Askew is planning a Grant Lockley spin-off which will have us all in tears - I rather suspect not.

There are some truly lovely descriptive observations, especially at the beginning of the book, but there are a lot. At one point, I did feel there were almost too many that, ironically, it took me away from the narrative. Too much of a good thing can start to pall and become slightly a case of the author proving how wonderfully she can write, which she most definitely can, but this is a tiny niggle in an otherwise thought-provoking work.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Net Galley and Hodder and Stoughton for an ARC of this book in exchange for a review. Wow - this is definitely a page turner.
Ryan Summers opens fire at Three rivers College campus instantly killing thirteen beautiful young women and then using the last bullet on himself.
The story follows the horrific days that follow for the grieving families, in particular Ishbel and Aiden Hodgekiss who lost their 17 year old daughter Abigail. Isbhel is in shock and can’t stop crying, doesn’t wash dress or eat, Aiden is angry and a lot of his anger is being directed toward Moira Summers, Ryan Summers mother, the dark brooding boy who carried out this horrific crime
Moira Summers is a practically a prisoner in her own home, round the clock police protection, journalists camped outside her house. One persistent journalist Grant Lockley, has his own column and many followers on twitter and will do anything for a story.
Detective Inspector Helen Birch is running the investigation and has personal history with the determined underhanded journalist.
This is a brilliant debut novel, as we know from the beginning who is responsible, the question then is why? A heartbreaking gripping read
Let’s hope there will be another book from this author featuring DI Helen Birch.

Was this review helpful?

This book absolutely drew me in & just didn't let go. Such a shocking but amazing story. So cleverly written from different perspectives. This truly is a fantastic read. I can't recommend this enough. My advice would be to make sure you have no plans when you start to read this book as you will not want to put it down. I can't wait for the next book by Claire Askew. Well done Claire!

Was this review helpful?

After shooting 13 young women dead at the college he attends and then turning the gun on himself, Ryan Summers will forever be known as the Three Rivers Shooter. But what now? All the Hidden Truths documents the ‘what nows’ from the perspective of three women, Ryan’s mum (Moira Summers), the mum of the first victim, Abigail (Ishbel Hodgekiss) and the police officer in charge of the investigation (DI Helen Birch).

Dubbed a psychological thriller, this book is so much more, in fact as we know the ‘what’, the ‘who’ and even where are all the bodies are the categorisation seems not only inaccurate but also inadequate. Having said that, I see the problem - how do you categorise it? Yes, it is a crime novel but it’s also a social commentary. It calls into question the power wielded by the media (in particular our reliance of social media) and spotlights the vulnerabilities and dysfunctionality present within any family unit.
At its essence is the question ‘why’, why did he do it? In this scenario can we ever uncover the ‘why? And if we do, what else will be unearthed alongside?

Askew has written a thoughtful, layered, gripping and heart wrenching novel that had me hook, line and sinker from the first page. This is SO worth spending time with.

Thanks to Netgalley for providing an advance copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I must be on a very short list in not finding this book compelling or even that interesting. Great choice of subject matter and yet all the characters seemed rather dull, and I found the writing style self conscious, so I was not in any way drawn in

Was this review helpful?

When Ryan Summers enters his school in Edinburgh and shoots 13 female students and himself does his mother Moira count as one of the victims or should she be seen as guilty by association? The story concentrates on how the shooting affects 3 women, Moira, Ishbel, mother of the first student killed, and DI Helen Birch, the lead investigating officer. The story slowly reveals secrets to try and establish why a young man would resort to doing what he did and to show if Moira knew what her son was planning and chose to ignore it. Isabel discovers a hidden secret that blows her marriage apart and adds to her already considerable grief which gets worse as more information is unearthed regarding her daughters activities leading up to her death. The obnoxious reporter that tried to inveigle his way into their life by using the grief of the mothers added to the story but was a little far fetched in places. The story itself was well written but I found it slow paced at times and found myself skim reading to get through some of it. A difficult and uncomfortable subject to tackle which didn't quite pack the same punch that Picoult did in her novel of the same subject. Well worth a read through.

Was this review helpful?

All The Hidden Truths is a stunning, emotional read which addresses some very difficult themes with sensitivity and realism. Although classed as a crime novel, this novel feels more like a portrait of the feelings and effects of such a horrible crime - a college shooting - on a community, and the way it's dealt with by police, families of the victim and, most powerfully for me anyway, the family of the killer. There are still elements of your 'typical' crime novel, such as a police investigation and a narrative from the perspective of the detective, but because we know almost right from the start who is to blame, and that person is dead, it's not about who did it but why and what happens afterwards. Without the 'whodunnit' element that I'm usually so interested in, I wondered if I'd be as engrossed - I definitely was! I raced through this novel and couldn't put it down.

There's so much grief and heartbreak within these pages, and I really felt for the people living through it; Claire Askew makes you really consider what this situation must be like for everyone. Some of the characters are truly horrible people (and it's obvious who falls into this category once you start reading) but, for the most part, the people in this novel feel real, each with their own problems and flaws, and it really highlights the way that everyone deals with terrible situations differently. Askew's portrayal of Moira, the mother of the gunsman Ryan, was incredibly powerful to read as she battled with her guilt at not having seen it all coming, as was Ishbel's struggles to come to terms with the death of her daughter and the breakdown of her marriage. I also really liked DI Helen Birch, and hope to see more of her in the future - fingers crossed for a second book featuring Helen!

Claire Askew beautifully weaves together various stories and experiences, all around one central storyline - that of the college shooting - and creates a truly heart-breaking, gripping read.

Was this review helpful?

All The Hidden Truths was a great psychological thriller that hooked me from the first few pages. It follows the story of a school shooting and focuses on 3 main characters, the mother of a victim, the mother of the shooter and the police officer in charge of the investigation.
A great read.

Was this review helpful?

Wow – this book is one hell of an emotional ride! All The Hidden Truths tells the story of a mass shooting by a student at his college in Edinburgh and its devastating fall out. On what seems like a morning like any other, Ryan Summers enters the cafeteria of his campus at Three Rivers College and begins a rampage that will take the lives of thirteen fellow students – all of them female, before taking his own life. This horrendous act brings grief and horror to the lives of everyone involved and begs that most unanswerable of questions – why?!

Written with an exquisite sense of people and their emotions this book takes us through the aftermath of the shooting following the lives of two key characters; Ishbel, the mother of Abigail, the first girl shot and killed and Moira, the mother of Ryan, the shooter. The event takes place on the first day of Helen Birch’s life as a Detective Inspector at a new station and she is faced with the most difficult and sensitive case of her career.

We witness the characters navigating their lives through circumstances that are one of the worst nightmares anyone can imagine and all this whilst besieged by the demon that is the media. What results is a novel which is in equal parts enthralling and heart breaking. The author’s writing is so spot on when depicting the characters’ feelings throughout; their confusion, horror and grief are palpable and I found myself in tears a good few times whilst reading.

This is a very good read, tackling a subject we hear of so terribly often elsewhere in the world – it makes you really think of the unfathomable devastation and the consequences this type of act brings about for everyone involved, setting it within the UK brings those thoughts home even more. Written sensitively and yet hard hitting too, I recommend this book wholeheartedly.

My thanks to #NetGalley and #Hodder&Stoughton for a copy of #AllTheHiddenTruths in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely fantastic debut. I couldn't put it down and devoured it in one sitting. An emotional, realistic read. Can't wait to read more by this author.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book in as much as one can enjoy a story so emotionally charged. The torment and anguish felt by the mothers of the victim and perpetrator was so well described. I liked the police detective, newly promoted and I know I’d enjoy reading more with her as the investigator.

I can certainly recommend this well written and thought provoking book.

Was this review helpful?

I didn't love this, but I liked the premise and the characters, I thought it was nicely written and deserves to be lauded.

Was this review helpful?

Although the subject matter (school shooting) waS difficult to think about, this was a great debut that read well. By focusing on few characters, you get really pulled into the story.

Was this review helpful?

This was more of a family drama than a crime/thriller as expected but it did not detract from my enjoyment of it. I would liken it to a Jodi Picoult/Liane Moriarty style moral dilemma sort of tale where there has been a tragedy and the people left behind are trying to make sense of it. I found the character of Grant Lockley so abhorrent, he was making my blood boil but I appreciate this was the author's intent! I would definitely read more from this author as it was well written and I enjoyed the use of inserting newspaper, Wikipedia and Twitter articles. Thank you to Netgalley, the author and Hodder & Stoughton for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Explosive thriller that deals with the aftermath of a school shooting. The story focuses mainly on three women that are affected and brings an interesting perspective. There was a raw intensity to the writing which really brought to life the complexity of the situation.

Was this review helpful?

This is an absolute beauty of a first book, can't wait for more to come...The storey is set in the now and tells of the abuse the press made of itself. Oh and how good did it feel when he got his come uppance. It deals with the trauma of a mass shooting from the parents point of view, but also the shooter mother. Well written and thought out.

Was this review helpful?

This book really shouldn’t work. A mass murder is committed but we know the victims and we know the murderer who takes his own life. What else is there to say? Well, plenty it appears. Viewed from the perspectives of the police inspector, a victim’s mother and the murderer’s mother it gives a glimpse into the horrific nature of the intrusion by the media into the lives of ordinary people who have been touched by tragedy. It makes uncomfortable reading at times as we are all guilty of wanting to learn more of a tragic newsworthy story. This book was quite different in its approach to a crime but worked well and had me hooked throughout.

Was this review helpful?