Member Reviews
Jill T, Reviewer
I was looking forward to this second novel by Ruth, and it didn’t disappoint. A more intense story this time, dealing with deeper subjects. But yet again, a great book. It has a warmth to it, despite dealing with cancer, the death of a child and lots of other things that life throws at you. Very much in the genre of Eleanor Oliphant, and A Man Called Ove. In summary, it has a lot of life and love in it. It made me smile, think and ponder. , |
Apologies this has taken so long to review. I loved this story - it's different to other books out there at the moment which is very hard to achieve. My book club is now reading. Thanks. |
GILLIAN M, Reviewer
I enjoyed The keeper of Lost things so much I was a little worried that Ruth Hogans 2nd book would fall short - it most definitely did not. It is a glorious book with wonderful characters that touch your heart and make you cry and laugh and get totally involved in their lives. An absolute must read |
Adding this to the list of books that left me sobbing!! And I wasn't expecting that from this book going in! Having loved The Keeper of Lost Things I have been eager to read this, and a little scared too, but my fears were soon put to rest with another stunning book from Ruth Hogan that just captures human emotions in such astonishing detail.The striking start so beautifully staged had me hooked immediately. It's the story of 2 women - both suffering at what life has thrown their way, but both surviving.... just. Masha is living with loss. A huge tragedy changed her life 12 years ago, and now she finds peace by hanging out at the local cemetery, and counts those departed as her friends alongside the character of Sally who is always there feeding the crows. She imagines their lost lives with clarity, and when she's not there she is at the local Lido, practicing drowning. Alice is a single mother and dealing with a son growing up and all that brings with it. She is trying her best but life is throwing curve balls her way too and she is consumed by worries for life for her son Mattie and what will happen to him in the future. This book looks long and hard about our attitudes to death, grieving and how that has changed over the years. The author wasn't afraid of confronting the subject head on, and introduced some lovely characters along the way to help those grieving make sense of the world again and deal with their losses. Sometimes help comes from those we expect it from less. And two quotes stuck with me.... 'Life is full of small joys if you know where to look for them' 'I find the living far more alarming' At times this was heartbreaking - hence the tears as i read! - but it was also full of so much joy and inspiration that these characters become part of you and you end up cheering every positive step they take, alongside sobbing along with them when things all become too much. Wonderful!! |
What a beautiful book. There were some real laugh out loud one liners in it, alongside deep sadness too. The author brought real life into this book. I loved how one of the characters would go and talk to residents of ‘God’s Acre’. Don’t we all talk to loved ones that have gone? Sally Red Shoes, whilst having the title role of the book, for me, was an ethereal person in the background - dispensing her wisdom and philosophy. The whole.book, both sad and happy parts, are just so moving. If you’ve never been in a position of losing a child or suffering a devastating illness, this story will still make you feel that pain. There’s every feeling in this book; including the unconditional love of animals. The ending of the book was a surprise. Not a scenario that I’d even considered and was set out, again, with a real feeling of poignancy and yet a hope of things to come. Just lovely. |
This book was an absolute pleasure to read. I laughed out loud on numerous occasions. It was very entertaining even when dealing with circumstances that we experience in every day life. I was not familiar with this author before reading The Wisdom of Sally Red Shoes but I will certainly look out for her future and past books. I enjoyed it so much I have started reading it again. |
Joanne C, Reviewer
Thanks to netgalley for an ARC of this book in return for an honest review. Rather than regurgitate the plot, I just want to focus on how it made me feel. A simple story about love, loss and mourning which I could totally connect with. Grief is a hard subject to write about but I feel that the author did this with care, understanding and empathy. I very much enjoyed this book and really look forward to more from Ruth in the future. |
What an absolute joy this book was! This book will hold you in thrall right from the first page. Narrated from the point of view of Masha and also Alice, you sense really early that Alice plays a pivotal role in Masha’s life. Masha lost her son many years ago. She believes he drowned. She is a wonderfully complex character who I loved instantly. She frequents her local cemetery and tends to the graves of many people. She encounters a wonderfully eccentric woman, whom she dubs Sally, and this character adds a lovely layer of depth to the unfolding story. Masha life is shrouded in grief. The loss of her young son has left a void in her life and the lives of those closest to her. The love that Masha had for her son has been transferred to her beloved Wolfhound, Haizum. The dog’s character is every bit as lovable as Masha. The book deals with grief and how it engulfs people. It also deals with cancer. We discover Alice has cancer and her life seems to unravel because of this illness. The secret that Alice has been keeping for many years spills out towards the end of the book. The author draws us into Alice’s world by writing about how cancer is sucking the life out of her and exposing her secrets. The characters in this book are colourful and they invite you into the story. Kitty Muriel is adorable. Elvis comes alive, having first being presented as just another eccentric. Masha’s friendship with both Sally and Kitty Muriel feels so vibrant and exciting. These two ladies offer Masha so much love and hope and those feelings jump out of the book and envelope the reader with the warmth that is being evoked within the story. I am not writing anything about the plot because I want you to go and read this book and allow yourself to be drawn into the story. Every aspect of the story has such a colourful depth to it and to disclose any details would distract from the enjoyment you will feel once you read this book for yourself. I loved everything about this book, from start to finish. I highly recommend it and give it a resounding five plus stars!!! |
I appreciated this book, it was beautifully written and cleverly crafted, however, I wasn’t clamouring to get back to it, I didn’t feel I had to put things on hold so that I could hide away and read it. I really, really wanted to like this book - I’d put it to the bottom of my pile so it would be a real treat when I finally got to it but, in the end, it just didn’t do it for me I’m afraid. In the acknowledgement Ruth Hogan quotes Dolly Parton stating ‘if you want the rainbow, you gotta put up with the rain’, I think that, in a nutshell was my problem - too much rain and not enough rainbow. It was clear fairly early on in the piece where the storylines of Marsha and Alice were going to intertwine and that was the storyline I was waiting for but that storyline never got going it ended before it even started. Thanks to Netgalley for providing an advance copy in exchange for an honest review. |
I've been mulling over how to write this review for quite a while as, sadly, Sally Red Shoes just was not for me. I loved The Keeper of Lost Things which made my apathy towards this book all the more painful. I will certainly keep an eye out for more from this author but I cannot recommend this book. |
Yes, as any blurb or review will immediately alert you, The Wisdom of Sally Red Shoes is a novel about death. Large portions of the story take place in a Victorian cemetery, main character Masha’s grief is raw and deep, and the very details of death (and how we deal with it today compared to generations past) are examined in depth. But through its plot and eccentric cast of characters (keep an eye out for Kitty Muriel and Sally Red Shoes), The Wisdom of Sally Red Shoes also tells a story about the joy of life, and the wonder of living, even – and maybe especially – in the face of terrible grief. |
Heather N, Librarian
Entrancing, magical and life-affirming - despite dealing with death, cancer and loss this is joyous,. Ruth Hogan is rapidly becoming one of my favourite authors. She tells the story of a woman who lost her child and couldn't move on until she met some very unlikely characters who would be dismissed out of hand as barking by most people. Read this to feel uplifted and feel a smile grow on your face, despite some real anguish. |
Ruth Hogan’s debut novel, The Keeper of Lost Things was a huge hit last year and received plenty of attention when it was included in The Richard and Judy Book Club. I loved the book and told so many people about it. I was very excited to be contacted about the author’s latest book, The Wisdom of Sally’s Red Shoes but also a little anxious in case it didn’t live up to expectations. I needn’t have worried as it is brilliant and once again showcases Ruth Hogan’s beautiful talent as a writer. The book focuses on Masha who has suffered a tragedy over 12 years ago. She is still getting by day by day yet she is merely coping rather than actually living. She spends a lot of time in her local Victorian Cemetery and also at the local lido. Then she meets Kitty Muriel and Sally, both of these women are extraordinary in their own way. They make Masha take a step back and look at her life and maybe start hoping and living again. Ruth Hogan is the Queen of eccentric characters; The Wisdom of Sally’s Red Shoes has many memorable and quirky characters, you cannot fail to remember them long after the last page. I loved all of the details about the cemetery and the way they dealt with mourning. Hogan demonstrates how there is no right or wrong way, Masha is the only one who can control her grief, the only one who can start living again and embracing the future. She just needs that spark and Kitty and Sally may be the ones to provide it. If you haven’t ready anything by Ruth Hogan yet then I urge you to get her books. Her writing is beautiful, raw and poignant and this one has a cover just as stunning as her debut! |
Amy L, Reviewer
Masha is drowning. She does it in order to feel close to her dead son, Gabriel, who drowned many years before. But with the help of a truly fabulous array of friends, old and new, Masha starts to swim back to her life. Parallel to this is Alice, mother to teenage Mattie, who clings to him as if he were vanishing, and who knows the time has come to confess her past. I loved the characters in this book. They are so varied and vivid that encountering them is like finding a new surprising favourite in a tin of Quality Street - you will want to savour them and come back for more. The twist in the tale is predictable after a certain point, but it doesn't feel like the main point of the story. It is simply a tangential thread that needs to be woven in at the end. I would certainly be interested to know what happened to all the characters after this too! For something dealing with such emotionally weighty material, you come away from it with a sense of joy and hope. Wonderful writing. |
Rosemary G, Educator
I absolutely loved Ruth Hogan's Keeper of Lost Things but found this book so very much harder to get into. It's initially disconcerting having three different narratives and it was quite confusing at first. Eventually it did become easier and I did enjoy some laugh out loud moments but there were many that made me feel sad and brought me to tears. I am glad that I stuck with it though and did enjoy it but wouldn't read it again. |
The Wisdom of Sally Red Shoes is the second novel by Ruth Hogan. With the author’s first novel The Keeper of Lost Things being such a well-received and heart-warming narrative, could Ruth pull another successful ‘up-lit’ out of the bag. Read on to find out! Nicknamed Masha after Chekov’s character in The Seagull, twelve years after her young son (Gabriel) drowned, the protagonist is still in mourning and unable to move on with her own life. A frequent visitor to the cemetery, in particular the children’s section, Masha meets Sally Red Shoes a bag lady who goes to the cemetery to feed the birds, and the vivacious Kitty Muriel. As the friendships develop and the events surrounding Gabriel’s death are unveiled, Masha realises she isn’t the only one with a tragic past. Masha is also a regular visistor the local lido where she carries out regular ‘drowning sessions’ to punish herself, but with Sally and Kitty taking on the role of cupid maybe it’s time for Masha to put the past behind her and rebuild her life. But just as she starts to accept what happened in the past, her life is about to take her on a completely unexpected path. Starting with an omniscient third-person narrative that introduces Sally Red Shoes, the novel continues with a multi-faceted perspective. Masha’s story is in first-person; this runs in tandem with Alice’s story which has a limited third-person point-of-view. Not only does this writing style showcase the author’s ability to write from a multitude of narrative perspectives, it also leaves the reader in no doubt as to whom the protagonist is. Alice is a lonely single mother whose life revolves around her son, Mattie. Alice has had a tragic past with a history of miscarriage, still birth, and Mattie’s father leaving her. Her story appears to be quite separate from Masha’s but as the narrative strands converge the story really kicks up a gear and this is where I found myself turning the pages unable to put the book down. Although this is a sad story and largely set in a cemetery, the theme of death is offset by the themes of friendship and making the most out of life. The narrative is also full of hilarious analogy and there are quite a few laugh out loud moments. I would recommend this book for anybody who likes Kit de Waal or Emma Cooper. Under Literature Love’s rating scheme this book has been awarded 4 out of 5 stars. |
Julie G, Educator
I struggled with this book. The main character is dealing with the loss of her child several years before and the book seems to dwell on this without going anywhere. Really didn't enjoy it. |
Oh, Ruth Hogan has done it again. #SallyRedShoes has completely stolen my heart. Absolutely on my Books of the Year 2018 list. Gentle, quirky, hopeful. So clever, so beautiful. LOVED it. |
I LOVED the keeper of lost things so I was really excited to read this one. I AM happy to say I wasn't disappointed. The book wasn't fast paced but sometimes that's a good thing. The only criticism that I do have about it is the ending felt rushed and left open in a way. Already I am looking forward to the next book from Ruth. |
Masha's life has stopped. Once a spirited, independent woman with a rebellious streak, her life has been forever changed by a tragic event twelve years ago. Unable to let go of her grief, she finds solace in the silent company of the souls of her local Victorian cemetery and at the town's lido, where she seeks refuge underwater - safe from the noise and the pain. But a chance encounter with two extraordinary women - the fabulous and wise Kitty Muriel, a convent girl-turned-magician's wife-turned-seventy-something-roller-disco-fanatic, and the mysterious Sally Red Shoes, a bag lady with a prodigious voice - opens up a new world of possibilities, and the chance to start living again. But just as Masha dares to imagine the future, the past comes roaring back . Ruth Hogan's second novel after The Keeper of Lost Things, which I adored. This novel introduces a cast of wonderful characters, both ordinary and charmingly eccentric, who guide us through a moving exploration of the simple human connections that make life worth living. This book has real heart and is another really interesting enjoyable read from Ruth, you really become involved with the characters and are captivated from the start to finish. |




