Sadly this book was not what I had expected. I thought it was something like a YA version of Lord of Flies from the premise. It would be a nice, easy summer suspense to enjoy a good read.
The book is character driven, but too much. It took ages for the writer to do the set up. I lost my interest to read the rest. 20% of the book is spent to talk about how the main character is bullied by others at school. All characters being unlikeable, in addition. This character development is done at the expense of the plot and pace, which makes it boring. The character development was not in depth as well, to make it a story of characters you'd care about. It was just flat.
Also, the twists were quite obvious. You could guess early on.

So, with characters not to care for, slow pace and missing the plot in action, this book didn't satisfy my expectations.

Thanks a lot to NetGalley and the publisher for granting a copy in exchange for an honest review.

Sadly found it very difficult to engage with this story and was unable to finish reading it. This one wasn't for me..

Very enjoyable—I flew through it in under two days. I found the social dynamics on the island and Link's attempts to exert control while holding a mutiny at bay fascinating, even when he went mad with power.

M.A. Bennett is an author that I've heard a lot about in recent months and despite not reading S.T.A.G.S I was intrigued to read The Island.

The first part of the book I really did like although there were a few points during some of the bullying scenes when I felt a bit uncomfortable (this is due to past bullying experiences). Despite this I was really into the story and felt like there was a connection between Link and I and I do love when I can relate to a protagonist.

However, come the middle of the book this started to slip. I became annoyed with Link and how he was acting. His behaviour in my opinion was immature. Mind you, I can see why this was the case but it made for pretty uncomfortable reading.

Although there were a few problems I did like how character driven the story was. I am definitely someone who prefers character driven stories over plot driven ones and I felt that each character developed perfectly throughout. There were a few that stood out to me and these were the ones that I did love the most.

The Island was an okay read but I'll admit I was expecting better after all the hype. This hasn't deterred me from reading S.T.A.G.S at some point in the future though.

Thank You Netgalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest and fair review.

I had high expectations for this novel and unfortunately i don't feel like they were met however i did love the ending.

The middle of the novel started to grow tedious for me as being stuck on an island can only do so much for the characters.

However the plot twist and epilogue definitely made up for my original feelings and pushed this to the 3 star for me!

Anyone who liked One Of Us Is Lying and S.T.A.G.S would certainly enjoy this! I would recommend!

I received this book from the publisher via Net Galley in exchange for an honest review.

I really enjoyed the middle part of this book, where they were beginning to sort things out and before it started getting weird. But I have issues with the start and the end.

The start, mostly because I didn’t feel that Lincoln’s parents would send him to that school in the first place! They’ve done no sports with him at all and send him to a sports centric school? I get that there’s a deal with the university but just didn’t seem right at all. Other than that though, while it was a little long winded, I really liked how well it showed the impact of the bullying.

The end is more complicated. I’ll talk about the middle first - I loved the start on the island. I liked how Lincoln took charge, and I even liked how he was pushing to keep it and how he dealt with every thing initially. I liked how the team pulled together (mostly!) and settled into island life.

I’m not going to spoil anything, but it’s hard to talk about the end without doing so! I saw part of the twist. I didn’t see the main bit, though wasn’t that surprised by it. But I sort of liked how far things all went, even if I was busy being creeped out by it all. The main issue I had was with basically everything post twist. I would NOT have been okay with that reveal.

Also the epilogue was definitely ott for me. Unnecessary!

The other thing I want to mention is that, for a British author, there were definitely some moments that weren’t. Not just cause of link either - one of the others says High School at some point which threw me. Oh and also, in year 9, when Link would have started, Seb was already toppers? Ahead of all the other people in the entire school? Seemed unrealistic even if he is the only quarters man in the school. And I know private schools are odd, but the whole system being based on one race time, down to what unrelated clubs you could join? Ugh.

This is a lot of rant for a book I didn’t hate, and I think that’s because I really wanted there to be more to it.

Having been gripped by M. A. Bennett's debut offering 'S.T.A.G.S.' I was excited about getting to read a copy of 'The Island', Both books are from the Teens & Young Adult market, feature prestigious private schools for those with more money than sense, and have thrilling elements and a deceptive darkness to them.

Link is a 16-year old American boy who has relocated to the UK with his parents after they're offered lecturing posts at the University of Oxford. Back in the U.S. he received home schooling so when his parents enrol him at the prestigious local private school Osney, he is more than a little anxious. When he turns out to be the slowest runner in an activity designed to determine school order, one of the strange traditions at the school, he immediately attracts the attention of the bullies. So when he is offered the chance to go on a summer school trip, voluntarily spending extra time with people who either mistreat or ignore him is certainly not something Link wants to subject himself to. But his parents only agree to let him leave Osney if he goes on the trip and he decides it is worth enduring to be able to leave them all behind for good later. Of course, the plane crashes and they find themselves stranded on an island (à la 'Lost') and somewhat predictably the dynamic shifts considerably. Link may not be an athlete but one thing he is is well read and is the only one who knows the things needed to survive on a desert island such as how to build a fire, how to find food and how to create shelter. What actually is sporting prowess going to achieve in your fight for survival on a desert island with noone but your peers?

This book took me back to my school days and a time when I endured a lot. Not only was I diagnosed with two debilitating illnesses at age fifteen, I was going through some pretty horrible bullying too. Don't get me wrong, there were a lot of other people who endured far worse but I wanted to highlight that I understand the narrative and the harrowing outcomes this behaviour causes at such a young age. I recognise the home schooling too, having also had the same. All of this meant I had an enormous amount of empathy for Link and his situation. The fact that he ends up becoming bigheaded from the power in the end is sad but not really much of a surprise given the lack of control he's had over his life and happiness in the majority of this novel. We learn a lot of important messages from the story with the statement 'treat others as you would like to be treat' being a moral message to take away from it. I hope that many young people pick up this book for that very reason, the messages it sends out are certainly crucial ones for a well-rounded, happy and upstanding individual to uphold. Other issues the book explores include misogyny, responsibility, abuse of power, revenge/retribution and desperation - the author does this with tact and in a way that is suitable for a teenage audience.

All in all, Bennett's characterisation was exquisite, she did a great job of making most of the characters detestable and the twist during the concluding pages of the book was satisfying - I certainly hadn't predicted it. If you enjoyed S.T.A.G.S. then this will also strike a chord with you.

Many thanks to Hot Key Books for an ARC. I was not required to post a review and all thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.

If you know me then you'll know that I loved STAGS by MA Bennett when I read it last year. So going in to The Island I had high hopes... And I was not disappointed. Another fantastic exploration of the darker side of humanity set against a background of privilege and desperation.

5 Words: Power, responsibility, school, resentment, revenge.

Take one of each high-school stereotypes and dump them on a desert island, then sit back and watch the horror-show commence. The Island explores the darker realities of humanity, looking at abuse of power, misogyny, desperation, and revenge.

I imagine that this book will not be for everybody - the characters as a whole are intensely unlikable ,and it is very much a character driven story. But I loved the power struggles and how the situations unfolding turned everything on its head. The character development was incredible.

My favourite character was (predictably?) Flora. She's not the main character, and Link often pushes her aside and disregards her, but I loved those glimpses that we saw. She's probably the "best" character morally, and I loved that she could stand her ground under intense pressure and in almost unimaginable situations.

I think that the only bit of the book that I didn't like was the epilogue, as I'd have liked it to end on the last chapter and keep everything open - but that's just personal preference.

Breakfast Club meets Lord of the Flies.

Another great, dark read from M A Bennett. I think STAGS is still probably my favourite, but some excellent moments of dry humour and another fun, dark thrill ride into the human psyche.

This book was amazing, even though I hated almost every single one of the characters. As with STAGS, this is a novel full of privilege teenagers who treat each other in the most hideous ways. Link starts off as pretty much the slave of the school, forced to do everything his classmates tell him to do. So when he ends up with them on the island and is the only one able to make fire... Well shall we just say he takes full advantage.

The thing is, as much as I grew to hate Link throughout the book, it was still exciting to see what he was going to do next. It was like watching a disaster movie, you want to see just how bad it can get.

A lot of the plot twists, I saw coming, but that didn't put me off reading further the way that it sometimes can. It just made me look forward to when the character discovered what I'd guessed.

As with STAGs, this is a great book, but be prepared to see some awful sides of humanity

After loving Bennett's first book, I was so excited to hear she was bringing out a second and over the moon when I won a pre-pub copy. YA mystery is my favourite genre to read and I'm a sucker for any story that involves a plane crash.

This novel was so well-written, with so many clever hints and clues scattered throughout but not so many that the average reader will figure it out. I absolutely loved this unique take on the stranded on a island tale, which was masterfully written and left me wishing I had another hundred pages to go. The first hundred or so we're a little slow but set up the characters and relationships. I loved how Link wasn't made to be a loveable character but a realistic one, and this story was a triumph.

The Island follows Link, a newcomer to a prestigious American school, as he’s thrown into a world of traditions, bullies and rankings. Forced on a summer school trip with the worst of his tormentors, his life is thrown into turmoil as rivalries and alliances come to a head on a deserted island, where only the fittest and smartest survive.

I was drawn to this as it looked like a good summer novel, and overall I found it was easy to read, written well, and kept me interested enough to want to know how it ended. It’s like a YA version of Survivor and Lord of the Flies which made for an interesting world that’s a little bit different from the average contemporary YA. However, aside from the descriptive settings I found this isn’t really developed well. It’s character driven - which I found to be at the detriment of the plot and pace as it spends too much time setting up backstories rather than telling the actual story.

I also found the plot ‘twists’ rather obvious, and I worked them out quite early on - meaning nothing came as a surprise or shocked me during the course of the story. If there had been some kind of mystery or set up that I wasn’t expecting I think this would have propelled my enjoyment of this a bit more. I felt I was constantly anticipating a twist that I knew was coming rather than having the carpet swept out from under me - which is what I wanted.

I also found all of the main characters deeply unlikeable with no redeeming features. Link in particular is misogynistic with little emotional depth. Despite being bullied himself, he shows little sympathy for others and seems to take an almost pride in being horrible to his peers. There’s no emotional connection, and with this lack of sympathy, this made me not care about what happened to any of the characters.

The biggest let down for me was the far fetched epilogue that didn’t fit with the rest of the novel. It completely changed the outlook and tone of the whole novel, and ruined whatever redeeming features I might have felt towards it. I found it essentially unnecessary and unrealistic in terms of character development.

This had the promise of an easy summer read with a hint of mystery, but fell a little flat in character development and pace.

I would like to thank the publisher and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC for this book. I really felt for Link throughout this book, the bullying he had to endure for three years at Osney is horrible, but unfortunately this is something that happens to so many kids. As much as a school might say "we do not tolerate bullying and take this very seriously" it's not often taken seriously, which I've learnt from my own experiences.

So on the Island Ralph and Flora actually started to grow on me, I begun to dislike Gil more, and with Seb I felt that he was getting off lightly and didn't deserve for Link to be as nice as he was - I don't think I would have been as rational as Link if I were in his shoes. I think the best character development was definitely Link, he went from being this shy, bullied kid to the bully and then Flora gave him the wake up call he needed and they finally managed to work together as a team.

I don't want to give too much away but the plot twist near the end was my favourite part. Thinking back on it now I'm shocked with myself for not seeing it sooner but I'm quite glad I didn't because the story had me gripped until the end.

Really enjoyed this 'how could 'Lord of the Flies' happen now?' extended thought experiment. If I were teaching LotF again, would definitely recommend to interested/higher ability students as a great side-project (only not mid- to lower-ability during GCSE teaching to avoid confusion in answers - would be good to discuss afterwards), but would rec as an engaging read anyway (and - heresy of heresies, expect most contemporary teens would enjoy it more).

I found the protag Link engaging, if not always likable - but definitely easy to understand/relate to. The other kids were exactly as enraging as they were supposed to be and I enjoyed the twists and turns of the plot. I know that some GR reviewers have expressed frustration with the balance between the 'before' of Link's school life and the island experience, feeling that there was too much of the school (since you know they're going to end up on the island), but I felt it was appropriately balanced for pace and tension and gave me the info and character development I needed for everything to work. I also really liked the organising conceit of Desert Island Discs. All in all, a good follow-up to Stags with linked themes of school bullying and how school hierarchies work and definitely recommended.

I went into this pretty blind. At first I was interested but once I stopped at around 25% to go eat I found I struggled to get back into it.
Majority of the book felt slow and the only thing we really saw was Link become more unlikable.
The ending sadly didn't make up for the rest of the book. The epilogue is ridiculous.
Link, the main character is so unlikable. The type of person I would avoid in real life. The fact he made the girls dress in the skirt for him, starved them if they didn't do what he wanted and mocked them disgusted me. He felt so entitled and like he can treat them this way because he was bullied for years. Wrong type of message to send.
The other characters felt very stereotypical as well.

I went into this not knowing what to expect. It was a bit like The Breakfast Club mixed with Lord of the Flies. I liked the idea, but to be honest I was more than frustrated with how the book turned out. It wasn’t the ending I was expecting, and it definitely threw me for a loop. I still don’t know how to feel about it, but I don’t think it was for me!

5out of 5!!! I love the film Castaway and the TV show lost, so I loved the premise to this book!! It got me thinking how I'd be if I'd crash landed on a desert island.
I didn't like how Link acted considering he'd been bullied, he should've known what it was like, I felt he was just as bad as them...however I had to backtrack my thoughts as soon as this issue was resolved, I don't want to spoil it but I think it's clever how "the breakfast club" (teens from each clique/group) acted once stranded on the island and it produced some interesting results!!! Brilliantly paced and a refreshingly good plot.

Having previously read STAGS, I was keen to pick this up but was initially worried that the plot may be too similar to the authors first book.

However, this book quickly established itself as being not only vastly different from its predecessor, but to be a clever, gripping novel which explores morals, friendships, and power.

I would recommend this to anyone and am eagerly awaiting the authors next work

When heavily bullied Link decides he wants to drop out of school, his parents want him to go to a camp first. He agrees, but he could never have imagined how life changing it would be.

Having read S.T.A.G.S. last year, I had high hopes for The Island. However, those hopes had no idea how brilliant this book would really be. Like with S.T.A.G.S. , the author has produced an unputdownable novel that had me hooked from the start. Just 30% in, I knew this would recieve the highest of ratings from me.

So where do I start? From the start, I felt a sense of dread. This feeling stayed with me for a long time and I loved it. We got some well thought out character backstory which I whizzed through and figured it was leading to something bad.

Lincoln thinks he's the sole survivor of a plane crash, he has the whole island to himself. Finally, something that's just his! But soon enough, the Jock, the Cheerleader, the Prodigy, the Emo and the Nerd are all stranded together. What could possibly go wrong?

Self entitlement, a big ego, greed, several years of built up anger, perhaps? And as you can guess, these aren't the best things to be stuck with in any place. Lincoln goes rather mad, and my thriller loving mind enjoyed it. I was so repulsed by his actions but I loved seeing how he dealt with situations with his twisted mind.

I'd have loved to know a bit more about the rest of the characters, especially Flora. The focus wasn't on them and I'm glad about that, but if the author fancies writing a spin off about those characters' lives I would be the first to buy it.

I loved The Island and I can't wait to see what the author cooks up next. Thank you to Hot Key Books via Netgalley for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

There was more to this book than I expected.I liked the sound of it when I requested it but even though I am not in the intended audience far from being a young adult I didn't feel that I was reading a book that wasn't aimed at me.I thought it was a well written and a very interesting and original take on a coming of age story.I am not going to give anything away as I wouldn't want to spoil the read for others, all I can say is I didn't know what to expect.I did work out some things but really had no clue how it was going to pan out.I thought it was a great story with well drawn characters and with plenty of surprises .I looked forward to my time reading this book over 3 nights and haven't a clue what I want to read now as I am still thinking of this story.I will be looking out for more books by this author she has an original voice and spins a good tale.Thanks to netgalley and the Publisher for an ARC.