Cover Image: The Summer Island Swap

The Summer Island Swap

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

A delightful story about family, friendship, and new beginnings, THE SUMMER ISLAND SWAP by Samantha Tonge is a great way to pass an afternoon, relaxing in the garden.

​Sarah is used to looking after her younger sister, Amy, as it is the role she has always played, ever since their mother died. And now Amy wants to thank Sarah and show her that she is no longer a little girl by organising a once-in-a-lifetime luxury trip for them both to somewhere far-flung and exotic. Sarah cannot wait!!! Except, Amy decides to throw a curveball and has booked them on a working holiday on an island where it is more wooden shacks than luxurious bedsheets and where emptying the compost toilet is supposed to help you become one with your surroundings. Sarah is horrified but as she begins to meet new people, learn new skills, and start to let go of the past, it could just be the best holiday she never wished for ...

With witty and fresh characters and a unique setting that grabbed my attention, THE SUMMER ISLAND SWAP by Samantha Tonge is enjoyable from beginning to end. Each character is distinctly different which worked well for me and while parts are predictable, I found that comforting and endearing.

A good story, THE SUMMER ISLAND SWAP is sure to please fictions fans everywhere.

Was this review helpful?

Sarah has been dreaming of going on holiday for years but with work, looking after her younger sister Amy and no spare cash that dream has never come true, that is until Amy wins some money on the lottery and declares she is taking them both on a five-star luxury break.

Sarah didn’t want her sister to spend all her money on a holiday but was looking forward to being pampered for two weeks, especially as she has just been sacked from her hospitality job.

Amy though has a secret, she decided to swap their holiday at the last minute. They are going to spend their time abroad on an island that was hit by a Hurricane and needs a lot of work doing to it. No five-star hotel rooms, more wooden shacks without aircon. Sarah is livid but she doesn’t want to let Amy down, so she is going to have to muck in and clean toilets, rescue turtle eggs, and make pathways in her fancy clothes and manicured nails.

There is one ray of hope though, the gorgeous man who loves on the island, now he is worth staying for, isn’t he?

Can you imagine getting all excited about your first holiday in years and after pampering other guests in your joy you can’t wait for someone to be pampering you? You have your hair cut, nails manicured, pack your fancy clothes, and your heels and then turn up in a place with no running water, a compost toilet, no shops, or even proper roads. The place feels like hell on earth to you but you have to put a brave face so as not to destroy your little sister’s happiness who is all excited about a working holiday.

Sarah is a very likeable woman who has always tried to do her best for her younger sister after what happened in their past with their father. She is hardworking and although the situation isn’t ideal and at first wants to leave right away, she realises she has to knuckle down and get on with things and maybe that the place isn’t that bad, nor are the other guests or the grandson of the owner.

The book moved at a nice pace and kept me entertained throughout. As well as the human characters there were some animals too, including a blind monkey that had been rescued from being forced to perform on the streets.

The plot is so full-on that it felt like the guests never stopped trying to fix up the island. The romance aspect was nicely handled, though, I do feel that the book would have even worked as a great read without a romance within it.

Overall, The Summer Island Swap is a wonderful summery read that is pure escapism. It is enjoyable and realistic too. I’m not sure I would have stuck around, I think I might have been on the first boat out of there!

Was this review helpful?

Samantha Tonge is one of the authors whose books I just can't wait to read and this proved another brilliant story to escape into from her! This is a fantastic story of siblings, looking after each other and discovering more about yourself, your abilities and your dreams - as well as a heartwarming romance. It is about expectations, being out of your comfort zone and finding inspiration and another superb story from this highly talented author.

How would you react if your much loved younger sibling won a prize on the lottery and booked you both a whole month away at a fabulous luxury holiday resort? Excited? Eager? Delighted? Despite problems with her boss, Sarah feels all those things. However, imagine her reaction when it turns out Amy revised their plans. Instead of a luxury holiday they're going to work on a conservation project..... forget the luxurious accommodation and activities, think emptying communal compost toilets, showers with only cold running water - and tarantulas - and no air conditioning. To say Sarah is shocked is an understatement! However, sometimes unexpected changes can have life changing impacts . . . . what you are disappointed has changed can actually lead to something even better and help not only yourself but others, too.

With great insights into sibling relationships, the need for conservation projects, more than one romance, fabulous characters, a superb setting and a delightful, mischievous monkey I absolutely loved this story and have no hesitation at all in highly recommending it.

I requested and was gifted a copy of this via NetGalley and this is my honest review after thoroughly enjoying reading it.

Was this review helpful?

Sarah has looked after her sister Amy since their mother succumbed to breast cancer when Sarah was eleven and Amy seven. It was a difficult childhood for them both, their father was demanding and verbally abusive, and at eighteen Sarah left to ‘make her own way’, starting as a receptionist at a mid-level hotel. Now years later, Sarah’s been promoted to Assistant Manager, Amy is working as a veterinary rurse, and has just won a small windfall from the lottery. Amy’s plan is to take Sarah away on a dream holiday – a month of five-star relaxation in the British Virgin Islands.

But just before they left, Amy changed the holiday to a conservation-themed one, with shacks, compost toilets, work rotas and working various projects to help native flora and fauna in the recovery from a hurricane three years earlier. Surprise!


I’ll be honest, initially it was difficult to get into the story as there was a ton of self-doubt and recrimination (and more than a few control issues) from Sarah, and the surprises, along with some withholding of pertinent information from Sarah, was troubling. But soon, the space, Amy’s excitement, Sarah’s determination and innovation when it came to the ‘resort’ and their money troubles, and Rick’s appeal to Sarah, and her fighting it if not making friends with Cheeky the monkey was addictive. Soon, things are changing, Rick and Sarah are getting closer, we understand Sarah’s struggles with self-esteem and Rick’s similar battles with his older brother, and the balance between making a difference to conservation while simultaneously amassing profits and a sustainable model to keep the family’s island in business. Tonge’s ability to combine pertinent issues, flawed characters and a cute monkey to spur on healing and hope worked – and as each page passed, I needed to know more. A lovely getaway with several twists, that left me smiling and happy for them all.

I received an eArc copy of the title from the publisher via NetGalley for purpose of honest review. I was not compensated for this review: all conclusions are my own responsibility.

Review first appeared at <a href=” https://wp.me/p3OmRo-aJa/” > <a> I am, Indeed </a>

Was this review helpful?

I picked this up because I thought it would be a cute book about a camaraderie between sisters and that is what I got. It gives you such a heartwarming feeling which I think the world needs/wants right now!

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book so much although, to be perfectly honest, if my sister had played that trick I'd never have spoken to her again!!! Perfectly written summer read, which is only to be expected from a writer of Tonge's caliber.

Was this review helpful?

Summer Island Swap is an easy to read story about Sarah, who is dreaming of the perfect relaxing get-away with her sister. In a twist, she is not going on the all-inclusive, glamourous getaway but instead she is on a conservation trip for the whole month (her sister secretly swapped trips before they were set to go
Will Sarah stick at it or will she decide that it really isn’t her thing and head home?
I have to admit, it took me a good while to get into this one… I found it a bit slow at first but once we really got into the project on the island, I was all in. To be honest I was angry for Sarah and would have been fully supportive if she’d had upped and left, by the end though I was so glad she stays to suffer it out.
With a whole cast of interesting characters, all with their own wonderful backgrounds and story, you will laugh out loud, by sympathetic and even be annoyed by people at various parts of the story. Keep an eye out for the fantastic, fun and entertaining Chatty though – my favourite character.
The Summer Island Swap is a sweet book to read and was enjoyable, I definitely saw things from a new point of view. It’s well written and had me dreaming of the next time I can go on holiday!

Was this review helpful?

This is just a gorgeous novel. The setting of the British Virgin Islands is exquisite and a fantastic escapist location especially as I read the book during lockdown and approaching an Australian winter. The setting is not only beautiful but provides an interesting location for the novel – and the two sisters who travel there for their volunteer experience and to help save the island and the wildlife that live there. I loved the relationship between the sisters and their entwined history together. They were believable and fun. Rick the owner of Seagrass Island is to die for and the rugged man everyone would want to find on a desert island. The author’s detail of the conservation was admirable and the characters she adds into the mix were enjoyable to learn about. Such a great story.

Was this review helpful?

I am sorry to say that this was not one of Samantha Tonge's best novels, her writing and information was really good but it just didn't do it for me. I judged this book by its cover not the write up which was a pity and I have learnt from that. I wish Samantha well with this book, I am sure that plenty of people out there will really enjoy this and think I have been stupid to give this review.

Was this review helpful?

A sweet summer read. I was looking forward to Reading this book, but I just could not connect with the characters in this book. Maybe I just read it when my heart craved a different types of book. Thank you to netgalley for this e arc in exchange for an honest opinion

Was this review helpful?

A really enjoyable read. Cosy and comfortable. A book you can really snuggle down with. I liked the various characters and the storyline. Lovely ending! Well worth picking up and reading.

Thank you Netgalley

Was this review helpful?

Loved this! Great summer read and made me want to visit Seagrass Island.

Sisters Amy & Sarah couldn't be more different. One is more carefree, the other more the role of protector and parent.

Amy wants to treat her big sister and books a luxury break away, but then secretly changes it after a comment from her sister. Sarah is lusting after the white sands, massages, and laying in the sun with a cocktail.

Amy truly believes what she has changed it to is something her sister will love and will be a true break.... But is it.... When it turns out they are staying at a conservation project.

Amy is all for getting stuck in, whilst Sarah feels disappointment. However the girls both learn about themselves along the way, with some truths revealed and a romance blossoming maybe this getaway is just what they both need.

Was this review helpful?

Enjoyable, a story that flows, characters to love and cheer for. What more could you wish for?

I wish I could tell you anything about the characters, describe who I loved the most, who I was most affected by...but I won't. You need to find this out for yourselves. This is a beautiful read and my only regret is that I wasn't able to read it on a beach myself.

Ms Tonge is a writer whose novels always affect me and leave me...thinking, pondering life's questions, and this is no exception. Suffice to say, you should purchase this novel, pull up your favourite seat and enjoy; I did!

My thanks to Netgalley and Aria for the review copy!

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately this just wasn’t a good fit for me. I just couldn’t connect with either Sarah or Amy. In fact the set up really bothered me. I ended up giving up around 35%.

Was this review helpful?

A great summer read and escape (the only way I’m getting them is books) so this is perfect, full of fun, sunshine, perfect escapism. The characters are nice, the book is well written and it’s a lovely easy read.

Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for a free copy for an honest opinion

Was this review helpful?

“The Summer Island Swap” is the perfect book for a lazy summer day. A nice quick read about family, friendship, and romance all set on a Caribbean Island.

Was this review helpful?

An engrossing and enjoyable read that made me smile and root for the characters.
The characters are well written, the plot flows and the setting is lovely.
I liked the style of writing and the humour.
Recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this ARC, all opinions are mine.

Was this review helpful?

Brilliant read, characters were great and I loved the friendships. The humour in this book was spot on and the plot easy to follow. I enjoyed this one a lot.

Was this review helpful?

The Summer Island Swap tells the story of Sarah, a hardworking and ambitious hospitality worker who gets lucky when her sister Amy wins a small amount of money in the lottery. Having big ideas for how she can enter the world of first class hospitality, Sarah is thrilled when Amy decides to spend the money on a luxurious vacation for the two of them. Sarah and Amy head on their surprise trip and Sarah can't wait to enjoy the amazing benefits of the island vacation, including doing some on site research of fancy accommodations, until they arrive at their destination and Sarah realizes that Amy switched the trips as a surprise without her knowing. Sarah is now on a conservation trip on a island that was devastated by a hurricane. Her duties (yes, duties), include cleaning out toilets, hacking away plants with a machete to create paths, and sleeping in a non air conditioned hut, with bugs and creepy crawlies all around. Sarah is devastated, and ready to leave, but her support for Amy is unwavering, she doesn't want to disappoint her. She decides to stick it out for Amy, and maybe to see what kind of romance blossoms with the director of the conservation, Rick. Sarah undergoes a journey or perseverance and self-discovery, realizing her talents and that sometimes things are better than they first seem.

I really wanted to love this book. I should start by saying I clearly did not read the entire description close enough when I requested it. I honestly expected a book about two sisters going to a luxurious island and finding love on an amazing trip! That's what I was expecting, so when Sarah found out her dream trip had been ruined-so did I. At that point, I stopped reading. I left the book for awhile and then realized that the publication date was coming up and I wanted to finish it to review, so I continued. I made my way through but by hand way through I still wasn't into the story. I found it predictable from page 35, I knew how it was going to end. I ended up skimming my way to the end. Honestly, I loved the beginning, until they got to the island. I just wasn't interested in reading about conservation and everything that went along with living on the island. I wanted a story about luxury and romance-but that was my fault, I should've been more careful when reading the description. The book is well written and the characters are likeable and relatable. I thought Sarah was a pretty good character. She did come off and immature, way too hung up on her past, it was mentioned way too much throughout the entire story. The romance aspect was okay, nothing great. Rick was also just okay, a pretty bland character, and I didn't enjoy a lot of his reactions in the story. I thought the story had the body of a good story, the side stories were developed, the characters were developed and so on. As much as I wanted to love it, it just wasn't for me. I'm happy so many others enjoyed it!

Was this review helpful?

Sometimes the surprise switch makes for a better experience- or life in this instance. Sarah is not happy when she discovers her sister Amy didn't book the luxury trip to the Virgin Islands she promised to fund with her lottery winnings. Turns out, though, that once Sarah sheds a bit of her annoyance and loosens up, an eco-vacation (with wonderful turtles, among other things) is just what she needs. Rick is an unexpected bonus. He's not very nice to Sarah initially (you can understand why these two might clash before they loosen their shells) but eventually, no surprise, things blossom. Thanks to netgalley for the ARC. A light read than will cheer you up (and make you long for the beach!)

Was this review helpful?