Member Reviews
Reviewer 550193
“She can invade your dreams, posses your mind, force you to do her will...” A nice little witch tale that starts out strong. As far as I’m concerned, any novella set in Cornwall already has my attention. Ghosts, witches, mermaids...everything! Robyn slips away to a cottage leant out by her sister on the outskirts of St. Oswell , hoping to cope with the loss of her recently deceased husband. The summer retreat is not all seaside comfort and sunshine, however, as Robyn starts dealing with the usual symptoms of an uneasy holiday gone wrong story; noises, nightmares, and warnings from the cautionary villagers. I actually liked Robyn’s correspondence with the locals: most of these small town horror stories place characters against each other, and in the process, it takes while before anything actually happens. Turns out that Robbyn’s cottage is tied to the Malan sisters, two hideous witches who are out for revenge. The witches are scary enough, and even though this is a short read, I feel like the author could’ve provided more of a showy presentation with this-the Tudor dynasty, hag stones, and psychic powers are some of the traits I wanted to read more about. That and a stronger backstory. Thanks to NetGalley and Silver Shamrock Publishing for providing me with a free e-ARC for my honest feedback. |
Couldn't get into this one, sorry wasn’t for me. Plus I had other books on the go, sorry think I timed out on it too. |
Jessica P, Reviewer
This was my first time reading Catherine Cavendish. I had seen her name a bit over the past few years, and decided it was finally time - especially seeing it from Silver Shamrock Publishing. I’ve experienced great stories from these publishing group and was excited to try another. A story that is haunting, atmospheric and a strong witchy presence, I expected to love this tale. Unfortunately, I just could not connect to any of the characters and felt quite bored though-out. Their motivations never seem to fit in with their character, and seemed more as a plot device instead of fully fleshing out the story. This is especially shown with the quick acceptance of witches and magic. I can see how people love this tale. Unfortunately, it was just not for me. |
This is a brilliant read. Wonderful well written plot and story line that had me engaged from the start. Love the well fleshed out characters and found them believable. Great suspense and action with wonderful world building. Can't wait to read what the author brings out next. Recommend reading. I was provided an ARC from NetGalley and the publisher. This is my own honest voluntary review. |
The Malan Witch reminded me that I don’t read enough witchy stories. This story had the eerie creepiness that made you realise that witches aren’t so ugly old hag with warts on her face, a long misshapen nose, and a pointy hat. It was easy to imagine sitting around a campfire having this story read, it was cosy and mildly unsettling. The Malan Witch has central themes of grief and loneliness being at the epicentre. Robyn has lost the love of her life in the most traumatic of consequences. Her husband died of cancer. She had to endure watching him be fit and healthy and robust what seemed like one minute to a shadow of his former self, not knowing who she was just that she was there supporting him. Incredibly sad. Her sister Holly suggests that she take some time to recuperate and heal at their holiday home. A little cottage on the Cornwall coast. Beautiful scenery, quiet and tranquil, everything that she is needing right now. The cottage has existed in one form or another for generations, her sister being the most recent occupants after it ended up derelict. The house has an instant creepy feel. For one it stinks, kind of like a sulphuric smell. If you’ve read as much paranormal stories as I have, you know this isn’t good news. She finds out from a local (who also seems to be related to everyone in the village) that the house is seeped in legend. Two sister witches used to stay there and that the house is well named, translated into Devil’s cottage. The witches subjected the village to hell, and they were finally burned at the stake. Their spirits came back but where held in place by two dolls that were effigies of the witches. Robyn’s sister set one free by burning the doll and now one witch has come back with vengeance on her mind. The Malan witch had a few moments that made me gasp but I felt it failed to really hit its mark. It was an intriguing story that could have been executed better, I guess I just didn’t find it that frightening. The fact that the witch could shapeshift was very cool and even more so that one of them was a crow. I have a massive thing for crows and ravens. I think ultimately I just wanted more from this story. |
Robyn escapes to a cottage her sister owns following the death of her husband. The cottage happens to be the spot where two evil witches had been burned at the stake. Things take an eerie turn when a crow shows up and begins to taunt her. Are the sisters behind this? You'll have to read to figure out. I had high expectations going into this book. It fell flat for me. There were aspects/explanations that wrapped up too quickly. This book was short but it was a long read for me. I just didn't have drive to keep going at points. Good idea but the execution fell short. |
An uncomplicated horror novel. The novel kicked off with Robyn Crowe, a young widow, moving to her sister’s newly purchased holiday house (The Malan Cottage), in an attempt to find a way out of the grief that was brought along with her husband’s death. The cottage was standing on a rather isolated place, with the nearest village being a pretty good distance away. The house had its own dark history, and it did not take long for Robyn to come across the truth. Centuries back, the place had been owned by two hideous witch sisters, Jowanet and Zenobie, who were burnt to death for their wicked deeds. No sign of their bodies was left behind but their soul remained back with an unquenchable thirst for revenge, and not long after the incident the village was once again being tormented. Although the souls were suppressed and locked away by a brave woman later on, a small mistake by Robyn’s sister set one of the witches free. The free soul of the witch was desperate for her sister, and Robyn stood between them. With the nefarious witch hanging around, the tour that was meant to fetch relief for Robyn ended up as a battle to secure the cottage and her sister’s family. ‘The Malan Witch’ is a rather plain novel with a very easy-to-follow storyline and simple characters. An ideal pick for someone looking for a horror story with plans of having a sound sleep. The author has done a pretty good job with the details, allowing the readers to catch a glimpse of what is going on inside Robyn’s head. The story flows smoothly, making it an effortless read. Most of the time, the spotlight is on Robyn and only Robyn, and therefore, it cannot take much for the reader to grasp her emotions and thoughts. There were a few places where the standard narration appeared to be a little disturbed. Other than that, in a place, the author had accidentally got the surname of a character wrong. I cannot claim that the story worked for me but that is more of a personal opinion. I did not find the overall wrapping up quite satisfactory but once again, taste varies from reader to reader, so it’s better not to take my words too seriously before giving the book a shot. Recommended for readers who are not looking for gruesome tales. |
I did enjoy The Malan Witch although I thought the story could have had a bit more depth and thought that it was wrapped up too quickly. It is a novella rather than a full novel and I think it would have worked a lot better as a full novel with a more in-depth story maybe with a bit more examination of the witches past lives and their evil deeds. The characters lacked a bit of depth and the antagonist manifested itself as a crow and for the first part worked well but didn’t add enough to the terror as the story progressed. The witches themselves did not play a big enough part of the story, except mostly as an evil crow that watches over the house which was a shame. As it is a novella, the story progresses at a really fast rate, which for me lost some of the terror, suspense and intensity. For a quick slightly creepy read just before bed The Malan Witch is an enjoyable read without being too frightening. Expanding it into a full novel, I feel, would make a much better ghost story. |
True rating would be a 2.5, but rounded up to 3 due to Goodreads' star system. This was... okay. Decent, basic witch story that doesn't at all reinvent the wheel. Which is fine, not everything has to, but nothing really stood out to me in this tale. Overall, it felt a bit rushed and strangely emotionless, especially towards the end. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing a free copy in exchange for an honest review. |
I finished this book in less than 24 hours. That’s how much I enjoyed myself. If you like: spooky settings, atmosphere, terrifying transformations, witches and haunted dwellings you’ll love this book. One of the things that stood out to me was the theme of sisterhood. I found it a compelling part of the story. Two present day sisters intertwined with malevolent twin witches from the past. And I despise crows. Well, actually I’m scared of them. “Another tap came, what sounded like claws jumping down from one stair to the next.” This made me visibly cringe. Looking forward to devouring everything by Catherine Cavendish! |
This started off as a great compelling read. The story pulled me in, Robyn was a great tragic character, and the setting was idyllic. After Robyn has some issues at the cottage, she does too many things that I found to be not believable. Tension melted away and there was a lackluster ending. Thank you to NetGalleyand Silver Shamrock Press for a copy of the ebook in exchange for an honest review. |
Vanessa G, Reviewer
Really enjoyed this book. Its a shorter book and things escalate fast. Once you start you wont want to put it down . If you enjoy books about witches this is a great one to read . |
Robyn Crowe is looking for a retreat from life after the death of her husband, Simon. Luckily, her sister Holly has recently purchased and renovated an old seaside cottage known as Malan Cottage in a tiny, sleepy village in the English countryside. It should be perfect place for Robyn to grieve and recharge her batteries. That is, until weird feelings and events begin to disturb her plans of relaxation. Strange, unpleasant smells. The most creepy and aggressive crow ever. After some research and meeting with a village resident, Robyn learns that there is a lot of history and legend attributed to Malan cottage. It was said to be the birthplace and the final resting place of two powerfully evil witch sisters who were the daughters of Satan's right hand assistant. This sounds far-fetched but, to Robyn, feels all too real based on her unusual experiences in the house. I won't say more and spoil any of the fun. I went into this book without any idea of what to expect, and I was very pleasantly surprised. This is everything I love in a book. A super-creepy atmosphere, local lore woven into the story line, a fast-paced plot and a scare factor through the roof. I read this book in two sittings - late at night, of course - with the covers pulled up to my ears because I was sure a witch might be sneaking up on me at any moment. I was honestly holding the hand of my sleeping husband because I needed something to hold onto. If you enjoy stories about witch lore, ghosts and hauntings, you will love this book. I will be adding more books by @CatherineCavendish to by TBR list - her writing is very fun and appealing, in the darkest way possible. Thank you to @silvershamrockpublishing and @netgalley for providing this book in exchange for my review. |
I love atmospheric little seaside cottage locations in stories, and Catherine Cavendish is amazing at giving these salty, windy places the justice they deserve. The Malan Cottage gave me the creeps even before the spookiness really picked up the pace, and that’s because there’s just something so haunting to me about cliffside waves and choppy waters. And if the moodiness of the story’s setting isn’t enough to give you goosebumps, there’s a witch or two here that definitely will! The Malan Witch introduces us to Robyn, a woman visiting her sister’s recently purchased and renovated cottage in an attempt to relax and take a bit of a vacation after the passing of her husband shakes her world. Robyn was an easy character to get to know and relate to – an avid reader, she curled up with one of my favorite horror books within the first few chapters and that was enough for me to take a liking to her immediately! Shortly after arriving, Robyn starts to encounter some weird happenings in the house. On a trip to the nearby small town, she meets with a few locals who tell her the story of sister witches that lived and practiced dark magic right where her sister’s new cottage is situated. I won’t go into too much of the witchy backstory here, because finding out about it was part of the fun of discovering what exactly what was happening to Robyn. There were a few small things I wish had gotten a bit more expanding upon, like the relationship between Robyn & her late husband, which I feel would’ve packed a bit more of an emotional gutpunch. As it stands, without some extra bit tugging at our heartstrings and making us care, the mentions of Robyn’s husband could honestly have been omitted for me since they didn’t seem to make much of a difference either way. I also think that there were a couple bits of dialogue that seemed a bit too simple or easy for the story, things that were too convenient almost, like a particular phone call with Robyn’s sister, or happening upon the same few people that the characters need when they’re in the town. That said, none of these things dampened my enjoyment of it overall, to be honest! I still had a lot of fun. I loved the symbolism in the story, from the small poppets (dolls) to the terrifying crow. If you love books featuring scary witches and spooky magic, this is a quick one that you’ll be able to jump into and finish in a day. It’d make perfect oceanside reading for anyone on vacation, but even curled up on bed like I was, it was a heck of a good time! I usually love everything Silver Shamrock Publishing puts out, and although this is my first book by Catherine Cavendish, I can already tell you it won’t be my last! |
A classic witch story in a small coastal town with a dark legend. Robyn is still recovering from losing her boyfriend and decides to spend some time away at her sister's new cottage. Cut off from the world she looks for peace and time to grieve and move on. However what she will find is an old legend and a witch that is coming for her. A fast paced witch story with all the classic elements for a good ghost/witch story. Perfect for a quick spooky read. However the story and characters are really typical and there is nothing really new added to the stories we all have heard of many times before. |
#CatherineCavendish pulled off a remarkable feat with the release of #TheMalanWitch, quite possibly even better than #StephenKing or #DeanKoontz would have been able to, and I am a HUGE fan of Mr. Koontz's books and Mr. King's movies, even if his books are lacking a bit of the action for me. Ms. Cavendish's books are very similar to Mr. King's books in the sense that she is continuously describing everything in the book, drawing everything out, even the most minute details, and in some ways that can be frustrating - and this just so happens to be my one objection with Mr. King's books, but she saves herself - and her book - by also putting quite a bit of action in the book, as well as suspense, keeping you on the edge of your seat, and forcing you to hold your breath to find out just what happened to the main character, and whether or not she is going to be okay. Ms. Cavendish is a Gothic style horror writer, very similar to #DaphneDuMaurier's #JamaicaInn, only instead of playing mind games like like Ms. Maurer, Ms. Cavendish throws in a hint of the supernatural, just like Mr. King and Mr. Koontz, giving the best of both worlds - now if only we (or I, LoL) can get her books made into a movie, the world would be a nearly perfect place! |
A good mix of mystery and fantasy, it's an enjoyable read. I liked the storytelling and the world building. The plot kept me hooked and entertained. Recommended. Many thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this ARC, all opinions are mine |
Author #Catherine Cavendish has a new novel out "#The Malan Witch". Without giving to much this is a novella about a haunted cottage. Two witch sisters once lived there long ago. And the place has been renovated by Robyn's sister, Holly, who has mistakenly released one.......well you just have to read the book!!😉🐾🐾 Head over to my Instagram blog #Maddie_approves_,book_reviews for a review this week please!!😉🐾🐾💜 Thank you, #Netgalley, #Catherine Cavendish, and # IBPA |
Reviewer 734035
Great read by a new author for me. The plot is well written and enticing to the reader. The author writes in a way that makes the reader feel like part of The story. |
After a gentle start this book snowballs into a wonderfully sinister witchy tale that will keep you glued to the page. Like witches and ghosts and haunted houses? You will enjoy this ride. |




