Cover Image: The Long Weekend

The Long Weekend

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

A psychological thriller that keeps your interest with all the twists and turns of a really good thriller.. Based in Northumbria it follows 3 couples who have rented a barn for a long weekend. Story was great with a fab twist will definitely read more from this author..

Was this review helpful?

Although this is a stereotypical thriller, full of suspense and excitement, this is my least favourite by this author. Her earlier work was better, and I was left entertained but deflated. I was expecting more.

Was this review helpful?

Mystery that had you hooked from the off. The book was very well written. Great plot. Very exciting. Fast paced to get your heart racing. Loved this book

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed the first half of this book. The setup is amazing, with three women trapped by the weather in a remote farmhouse. We don't know very much about them and it's exciting to unravel their secrets and the links between them. There's a great atmosphere of menace with the storm outside making it impossible for them to leave. So, five stars for this part of the book.

But then we get to the second half. This is where the story started to unravel for me. I mean, I expected one of the characters (amongst the three women trapped, and the three men and another woman who did not make it on the trip) to be a depraved killer, but <spoiler>several of them?? </spoiler> That really got too much for me and it tipped the story into the unbelievable.

For this reason, I didn't like the second half nor the ending and it gave me an overall dissatisfied feeling, which is why I gave it three stars overall. It was a shame the story went this way, because the writing was really good.

Was this review helpful?

Separated into sections - days of the weekend making chapters/parts a bit lengthy at times! Overall a very good read but not my favourite by this author. Would recommend :)

Was this review helpful?

Imagine you’re going on a weekend away with your husbands best friends and their wives, but all the husbands suddenly have excuses for not coming the first night and you arrive to a gift with a card saying:
“By the time you read this, I’ll have killed one of your husbands.”
This was a dramatic way to get the book going, got me intrigued and immediately guessing with the wives as to who’s husband it could be.
The women were not very likeable to be honest, I actually don’t think I liked any of the characters which is probably why I found it hard to persist and finish the book quicker as I didn’t have motivation to read on to hope for my ‘favoured’ character but I did indeed persevere as I was determined to find out who the hell had been killed and what had the other husbands been up to?
I am glad I continued as it was quite a blooming journey we went on! Plenty of unexpected twists as to who’s actually telling you the story, constantly leaving you second guessing who the killer is.
This story was a rollercoaster of mystery, I think it was worth it in the end but I personally found it had to stay motivated and took a very long time dipping in and out of this book. But I’d still recommend as a good mystery.

Was this review helpful?

Gilly Macmillan can always be relied on to deliver a great thriller, The Long Weekend does nothing to ruin that record. Three women alone in a secluded country cottage receive a note telling them one of their husbands will die. Jayne, ex military and ever the pragmatist is sure it's a sick joke. Ruth, a supposed high flying doctor and new mother takes solace in vodka. Emily, younger and newer to the group is convinced it's true and panics enough to make rash decisions. They're stranded by nasty weather and with no way to contact the outside world things begin to fall apart.

So if you want gritty realism walk on by. The author throws every type of secret and drama into this she could possibly thought of and runs with it. And whilst occasionally a bit mental it's highly enjoyable. It's a bit like a Christmas soap opera episode...everything happens! I read this during a bout of illness which stopped me from reading much and oh my god it was frustrating. Under normal circumstances this would have been a one sit read.

Was this review helpful?

This was a creepy tension building novel set in a vast desolate landscape with no phone service....what could possibly go wrong?

I didn't like the characters, but I think that's the way the author meant it to be. There was a lot of extra detail that prevented the book from being as page turning as it could be.

That said, there were twists and turns that left you wanting to know more. I would have liked the POV switching to have been more cleat though...

Was this review helpful?

*Thanks to NetGalley for an ARC copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.*

Right. Where to begin?

The initial plot behind this was solid. Three women go to a remote barn for a weekend away, expecting their husbands to come and join them the day after. These wives don't know each other all that well so expect some arguments and fallings out.

The farmer and his wife who own the barn seem like a lovely couple, but the farmer has a degenerative brain disease and his wife is struggling to deal with it and his mood swings.

There is a fourth wife who doesn't attend; her husband died a while back and she isn't really a part of these gatherings due to that (all four husbands were best friends). This wife has apparently sent a bottle of fancy champagne to the farmhouse for the wives to receive on arrival, along with a note saying that she'd killed one of their husbands (but not which one).

Cue madness.

It felt like every possible secret a person could have was crammed into this book. One wife is a secret alcoholic, one has PTSD, and the other is quite sensible but is painted as the silly naïve younger wife. One of the husbands *could* be a paedophile, one is perfectly "normal" and one is older than the others and is therefore suspicious because he could be having an affair with a wife who is closer to his age. The farmer kills himself to end his suffering (this came so quickly and out of nowhere that I read back a few pages, convinced I had missed something). There are also red herrings all over the shop, including a historic burial sit that you *think* is going to have more significance. Oh and the farmer's son is a policeman who happens to be able to travel over and solve the mystery ... Sure thing.

Reading through the end of this book, where all the explanations are tied up, was confusing as all hell. I definitely lost the plot a bit as to who was who, and was hoping against hope that nothing would happen to Izzy, the 17 year old daughter of one of the wives who is definitely treated younger. She was completely innocent in the whole thing and the scenes between here and Mark (one of the husbands) made me feel sick.

Overall, it wasn't a bad book, just super unbelievable. Some plot lines could have been taken out, it was a bit messy, but I did enjoy it.

Was this review helpful?

First read of this author and won't be my last.
Read it at a pace as I was keen to get yo end. Would definitely recommend.

Was this review helpful?

Wowser! You certainly had to concentrate on this one to work out what was going on and who was doing what, but having said that, it was a great read, full of intrigue, deception and tragedy. Very entertaining, very fast paced, but as I said, if you don´t concentrate its very easy to get confused and lose which character is currently being described as it jumps from character to character a lot.

My thanks to NetGalley and Random House UK for giving me the opportunity to read an advanced copy in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with an ARC in exchange of an honest review.

This thriller almost gave me a heart attack! I was so scared for the characters. The twists and turns I never saw coming kept me hooked till the end.

Was this review helpful?

After reading The Long Weekend and one other book by Gilly Macmillan, I really don't think she's an
author for me. The premise of this book sounded fantastic to me, as I really enjoy thrillers about groups
of friends going away on holiday. It's a niche I didn't realise I loved until recently.

Unfortunately, something I really don't like in my thrillers is a plot line that is ridiculous, verging on
nonsensicle. I didn't get much out of this book because I wasn't made to care for any of the characters -
apart from maybe Imogen - before they were thrown into the plot.

I didn't like the setting, either, because despite what the synopsis implies, it's barely set during the
weekend away trip in the farmland. It goes back and forth between what's happening in the barn (not
much), and what's happening elsewhere (most of the plot).

I certainly didn't hate The Long Weekend, but it wasn't what I was expecting at all. I feel really let down
by it, and I think I might be done with this author.

Was this review helpful?

I struggled to finish this book as I felt it dragged a lot and I prefer fast paced thrillers. There are no chapters and the different POV the women use is confusing, as they run in to one and other.

Just OK for me.

Was this review helpful?

My first Gilly Macmillan book and I can’t help wondering why I waited so long.

This was a fast paced, engrossing psychological thriller that had some great twists and turns. There was one moment in particular that completely threw me, and it’s moments like that that make a book memorable.

It’s refreshing to read a book that utilises its non-visual medium to create subterfuge and subsequent revelations to such brilliant levels. So often books are written with the intention of a hopeful movie adaptation. The Long Weekend, however, drew on the factors that simply couldn’t work in a movie and used them very well.

Thank you NetGalley and Random House UK, Cornerstone for a Review Copy.

Was this review helpful?

You definitely need to be paying attention and be fully concentrating to keep up with this book. The book starts as a basic thriller set up type of book but then everything gets turned on it’s head. I was left guessing the entire way through this book and thoroughly enjoyed it, although it did get a tad confusing jumping from character to character.

Was this review helpful?

This novel starts with the three women arriving early at Fell Barn, an "specifically isolated" retreat which is booked by the husband's who are lifelong friends only they are missing the four couple after a recent death. What was expected to be a retreat turns into a horror when they receive a beautifully wrapped gift but it turns out to be a note saying one of there husband will be murdered. Is it a hoax ,there is no phone service so they are completely cut off. Things all go downhill from there for this group of dysfunctional group of friends.

I struggled to finish this book as I felt it dragged a lot and I prefer fast paced thrillers.
There are no chapters and furthermore the different POV the women use is confusing, as they run in to one and other.

Thanks to Netgally and the publishers for giving me a copy of this book in exchange for a full,crank and honest review

Was this review helpful?

Oh boy I love unlikeable characters when they are written that way.
Let me root for their destruction!

The more you read the less you care about what happens to the characters and more about the HOW.
A REALLY fun thriller with a brilliant atmosphere. My enjoyment of this outranked my problems with the logic of what was happing, or the pacing of the story (quite slow at times).

Was this review helpful?

Overall the story concept was interesting. However, the execution was messy. The characters were unlikable. I, especially, struggled with maintaining empathy for Ruth. I found myself frustrated with her and wanting to skim over her internal dialogue which felt like they prattled on for too long. The story of the couple who owned the farm felt out of place and almost unnecessary.

Was this review helpful?

They have been friends since childhood and every year they take a long weekend break to unwind and enjoy each others’ company. This year is the first since the death of Rob, so four couples have become three. As the women head to Dark Fell Barn, a remote place they’ve found on the web, the men find excuses to delay their arrival, leaving Jayne, Ruth and the much-younger Emily to have a bit of a girls’ night on Friday. When they arrive at the barn to discover no mobile signal and a road only passable by the farmer’s Land Rover, there’s one extra surprise: a note, seemingly from Rob’s wife, Edie, that puts the women on edge and the brakes on the weekend plans.

Hi ladies,

Your weekend starts here! I hope you have a great time! I didn’t come along because I know I’m not welcome. This is goodbye. I’m going away. But I wouldn’t want you to forget me.

By the time you read this, I’ll have killed one of your husbands.

E

At first, The Long Weekend seems like your average, run-of-the-mill thriller that doesn’t require anything from the reader beyond enjoying the ride. We are introduced to the three central characters – Jayne, Ruth and Emily – as they travel to Dark Fell and deal with what they find there. These women are friends by circumstance: their husbands have been friends since childhood, and the women have become part of the gang organically. As a result, they have little in common, though all are carrying their own burdens, and each has reason to believe that the letter might be more than one of Edie’s practical jokes. To compound this, the farmer who owns the barn in which they are staying is suffering from dementia, and has begun terrorising guests as everything he knows crumbles around him.


As the story progresses, alternating between multiple points of view – the three women, the farmer and his wife, Edie’s teenage daughter, Imogen – Macmillan soon makes it clear that this is not your average thriller as she pulls the carpet from under our feet on more than one occasion. Not everything is as it seems, and there is much more meat on the bones of The Long Weekend than we, as readers, originally anticipated. Suddenly we have a mystery to solve, and burst after burst of adrenaline as the revelations keep on coming. This is one of the most surprising books I have read in a long time, the kind of book that laughs in the face of your preconceptions and makes you realise that, no matter how well-read you are in any given genre, there is always an author and a book out here that will make you feel a bit less smug and reignite your love for the genre.


Macmillan’s characters pop off the page, in no small part because of the baggage they each carry. The book explores topics as diverse as childhood abuse and post-traumatic stress, dementia and the strain that having a baby can put on the marital relationship. Condensed into a single weekend, there’s hardly time to take a breath as Macmillan drives us relentlessly towards the climax. All of the clichés apply here: page-turner, edge-of-your-seat, rollercoaster; but in the end the most important thing about this novel is that it keeps us entertained from the opening page to the satisfying conclusion.


The Long Weekend is my first look at the work of Gilly Macmillan. I can say with some confidence that it definitely won’t be my last. Well-written, with a cast of characters that feel we already know and a finely-crafted mystery, it’s a fast-paced thriller that impresses and surprises at every turn. This is the domestic thriller at its finest and I can’t recommend it highly enough.

Was this review helpful?