Reparations

A Christian Call for Repentance and Repair

This title was previously available on NetGalley and is now archived.
Buy on Amazon Buy on Waterstones.com
*This page contains affiliate links, so we may earn a small commission when you make a purchase through links on our site at no additional cost to you.
Send NetGalley books directly to your Kindle or Kindle app

1
To read on a Kindle or Kindle app, please add kindle@netgalley.com as an approved email address to receive files in your Amazon account. Click here for step-by-step instructions.
2
Also find your Kindle email address within your Amazon account, and enter it here.
Pub Date 6 Apr 2021 | Archive Date 1 May 2021

Talking about this book? Use #Reparations #NetGalley. More hashtag tips!


Description

Christianity Today 2022 Book Award Winner (Politics & Public Life)

Outreach 2022 Resource of the Year (Social Issues and Justice)

Foreword INDIES 2021 Finalist for Religion

"Kwon and Thompson's eloquent reasoning will help Christians broaden their understanding of the contemporary conversation over reparations."--Publishers Weekly

"A thoughtful approach to a vital topic."--Library Journal

Christians are awakening to the legacy of racism in America like never before. While public conversations regarding the realities of racial division and inequalities have surged in recent years, so has the public outcry to work toward the long-awaited healing of these wounds. But American Christianity, with its tendency to view the ministry of reconciliation as its sole response to racial injustice, and its isolation from those who labor most diligently to address these things, is underequipped to offer solutions. Because of this, the church needs a new perspective on its responsibility for the deep racial brokenness at the heart of American culture and on what it can do to repair that brokenness.

This book makes a compelling historical and theological case for the church's obligation to provide reparations for the oppression of African Americans. Duke Kwon and Gregory Thompson articulate the church's responsibility for its promotion and preservation of white supremacy throughout history, investigate the Bible's call to repair our racial brokenness, and offer a vision for the work of reparation at the local level. They lead readers toward a moral imagination that views reparations as a long-overdue and necessary step in our collective journey toward healing and wholeness.

Christians are awakening to the legacy of racism in America like never before. Reparations explores the church's responsibility for the deep racial brokenness at the heart of American culture, investigates the Bible's call to repair it, and offers a vision for the work of reparation at the local level. The authors lead readers toward a moral imagination that views reparations as a long-overdue and necessary step in our collective journey toward healing and wholeness.

This book won a Christianity Today 2022 Book Award (Politics & Public Life) and an Outreach 2022 Resource of the Year Award (Social Issues and Justice). It was also a Foreword INDIES 2021 Finalist for Religion.

"Kwon and Thompson's eloquent reasoning will help Christians broaden their understanding of the contemporary conversation over reparations."--Publishers Weekly
Christianity Today 2022 Book Award Winner (Politics & Public Life)

Outreach 2022 Resource of the Year (Social Issues and Justice)

Foreword INDIES 2021 Finalist for Religion

"Kwon and Thompson's eloquent...

Advance Praise

“We are at an inflection point in our nation. We can either continue with the racial status quo or earnestly engage in the long-overdue process of repair. Reparations is a book for this moment. It is a call to action to offer tangible restitution for the historic exploitation of Black labor. While Christians should have been leading the way on this all along, sadly, too many have demonstrated compromise and complicity instead. Kwon and Thompson marshal deep research, theological acumen, and pastoral tenderness to make a timely call for reparations and the dignity of all people.”—Jemar Tisby, CEO of The Witness Inc.; author of the bestselling book The Color of Compromise 

“Reparations is challenging in the best way: it challenges Christians to look squarely at our history, to take responsibility for our complicity in evil, and, most importantly, to take our mission as the church seriously. This book is a clarion call to understand the context of our mission and how that context must shape our work and community. Reparations is passionate, clear, smart, thoughtful, and blessedly troubling. I hope every American Christian leader—especially White Christian leaders—will read it because it is truly the rare book that, if taken up with an open heart, has the potential to change the world.”—Tish Harrison Warren, Anglican priest; author of Liturgy of the Ordinary and Prayer in the Night 

“How do we make things whole? That is the question Reparations: A Christian Call for Repentance and Repair helps us answer. Kwon and Thompson walk us through our complicated racial past and give us a glimpse of a future that is reconciled, just, and ultimately more like Christ. This book should be essential reading in classrooms and Bible studies, in religious sanctuaries and the halls of Congress, and for every single believer who cares about justice and equality. The history is sound, the facts are compelling, and the ultimate case must not be ignored.”—Joshua DuBois, CEO, media commentator, and former director, White House Office of Faith-based and Neighborhood Partnerships 

“What hope do we have of racial reconciliation unless we right the wrongs of our past? Duke Kwon and Greg Thompson have argued convincingly that reparations is a necessary part of the healing of our churches and our nation, and that people of faith should be leading the way. They have listened to their African American brothers and sisters. They tell us the sad truth about the significant role the church has played in the problem of racism. They demonstrate that reparations is a thoroughly biblical concept and a work of the gospel. And most importantly, with empathy and hope, they show us how we can start repairing our racial brokenness through local and community-based efforts that every one of us can be part of. Read this book and learn how to be a bridge builder for reparations.”—Latasha Morrison, founder of Be the Bridge and New York Times bestselling author of Be the Bridge: Pursuing God’s Heart for Racial Reconciliation

“Duke Kwon and Greg Thompson do a compelling job of laying out the historic legitimacy, the moral necessity, and the biblical urgency for reparations from slavery. With a kind of whiplash effect, they frequently let centuries-old voices speak into this very moment with shocking immediacy. American Christians, especially those of us who are White, should read, internalize, and act upon these arguments with our whole being. May Christ’s loving reign over new hearts, minds, and systems reorder the powers of this world that all may freely and justly live.”—Mark Labberton, president, Fuller Theological Seminary 

“The subject of reparations has been the cause of much heat and little light in some Christian circles. The objections to the very idea range from ‘it’s an injustice committed against people who had nothing to do with slavery’ to ‘it’s a ploy used by those who never suffered under slavery to take the hard-earned wealth of others.’ Arguments for reparations have often veered into emotional and moral appeals without careful theological, biblical, and historical reasoning. This book ends the era of poor pro-reparations arguments and silences the criticisms of those who suspect reparations as a kind of ‘reverse injustice.’ Duke Kwon and Greg Thompson have given us the careful yet daring, gracious yet trenchant, historical yet relevant, principled yet persuasive teaching the church and the world has desperately needed. Here is a study written with a rare combination of pastoral tenderness and intellectual rigor. I hope it ends the debate about reparations and helps many to begin the work toward achieving it.”—Thabiti M. Anyabwile, pastor, Anacostia River Church 

“Two words encapsulate this book for me: indictment and invitation. Writing in the prophetic tradition, Kwon and Thompson are unrelenting in indicting the American church for its complicity and collusion in keeping its relative silence regarding the ongoing cries of the African American communities in the Civil War, during the civil rights movement, and in contemporary contexts. With crisp historical details and analysis, combined with a wide-ranging engagement with sources, the authors are to be commended for exposing America’s original sin. However, along with stinging words of indictment come words of invitation. Kwon and Thompson invite the readers to reimagine the shape of human flourishing in the church if we were to seek ways to repent for past sins, repair the breaches of the present, and rejuvenate communities for a more beautiful future. This will not be easy reading, but it will be absolutely indispensable reading for all churches. For by engaging with their pastoral counsel and prophetic courage, we will have a better understanding of what it means to see the image of God in every human person.”—Paul Chang-Ha Lim, award-winning historian and professor, Vanderbilt University 

“As our country awakens to the difficult truth of our shared story and more and more of us are compelled to engage in the reparative work at the intersection of race and economics, Duke Kwon and Greg Thompson’s book Reparations is a powerful and important step in the exploration of what repair looks like, not just for African American communities but for the soul of our country.”—Anasa Troutman, CEO of The BIG We 

“In a Nazi concentration camp, the theologian, pastor, conspirator, and Christian martyr Dietrich Bonhoeffer pondered the future of the German church as it lay in the ruins of its fatal allegiance to Hitler. ‘What is bothering me incessantly is the question what Christianity really is, or indeed who Christ really is, for us today.’ Has the church so cheapened its witness to the gospel that it now seems incapable of speaking a redemptive word to humanity and the world? Duke Kwon and Gregory Thompson give us a profound and urgent answer in the context of the American church crisis. Reparations is an exemplary work of public theology, born of chastened Christian conviction and pastoral anguish. Beautifully written and generous in tone, Kwon and Thompson’s book illuminates the costs and joys of discipleship in a nation marked by White privilege and its theological disfigurations—to which I can imagine Bonhoeffer replying, ‘Yes and amen.’”—Charles Marsh, Commonwealth Professor of Religious Studies, University of Virginia; author of Strange Glory: A Life of Dietrich Bonhoeffer 

“Admittedly, I am still working through what my own response will be to this convicting, sometimes disorienting book written by two pastors whom I respect greatly. I respect Duke and Greg especially for their careful scholarship, their love for Jesus and Scripture, their sense of prophetic urgency, and their deep empathy toward people of color in particular. Likewise, I respect them for the moral courage it took to put their convictions in book form. Wherever you end up landing in relation to their message and conclusions, I pray that this book will stir you up as it has me toward deeper introspection, deeper curiosity, deeper humility, deeper repentance, deeper love, and above all deeper freedom in Christ, who came to redeem, restore, and repair all that is broken in you.”—Scott Sauls, senior pastor of Christ Presbyterian Church; author of Jesus Outside the Lines and A Gentle Answer

“We are at an inflection point in our nation. We can either continue with the racial status quo or earnestly engage in the long-overdue process of repair. Reparations is a book for this moment. It...


Available Editions

EDITION Other Format
ISBN 9781587434501
PRICE US$24.99 (USD)
PAGES 256

Available on NetGalley

NetGalley Shelf App (EPUB)
Send to Kindle (EPUB)

Average rating from 14 members


Featured Reviews

Duke L. Kwon and Gregory Thompson’s “Reparations,” is an extremely challenging yet necessary book for our current times. All Christians should read it and pay close attention to its prophetic and pastoral invitations.

Was this review helpful?

Reparations is something that I have never really known what to do with. I've heard the concept and largely found it uncomfortable. Seeing this book fueled my curiosity. Is their a Christian argument in favor of reparations? The authors not only say yes. But they believe that the church should be at the forefront of repairing the racial issues in our country. The chapters that explained the biblical and christian roots of reparations are worth the price of the book. This is impeccably written and very timely. Plenty will get angry and disagree from the title alone, but their work will not be easily dismissed. This is an important work that any Christian writing about reparations will be forced to acknowledge and wrestle with.

Was this review helpful?

I found this book to be a great primer of the subject. Many individuals will turn their heads due to the title alone, but this book is very worth the read. Kwon and Thompson take a look from a historical context and a biblical context to provide a framework for their reasoning for reparations. They brought into question why has the church been silent on issues of ethnicity historically in America, but yet speaks freely about the pain and hurt caused from the Holocaust. I think even if you disagree, it will serve you well to read the arguments they present. Before I read the book, I sought individuals who would be against reparations and their reasonings why. Once I read the book, the majority of the questions had been answered by the authors and for that I am grateful. This book is worth the read and helps to expand one's thoughts to the subject even if you find yourself disagreeing in the end.

Was this review helpful?

The authors begin with a challenge to readers to see and understand racism in the first chapter. They discuss various ways to see racism and offer that it isn't simply a matter of personal prejudice, relational division, or institutional injustice, but fundamental cultural disorder. There are many reasons we resist seeing the truth, but ultimately they are all fleeing from reality. We must not blind ourselves if we are to heal.

In the second chapter, they approach the topic of White supremacy. Two insights they highlight are that race is a modern invention and it has a social function. Over time, slavery became linked to Blackness, which led to the creation of its mirror opposite, Whiteness. These ideas eventually shifted from skin color to much deeper issues, that of inferiority and supremacy. Moreover, this White supremacy was pervasive throughout American history and endured through various eras and attempts to create equality.

Chapter 3 provides depictions of the effects of White supremacy. Beginning with the example of hiding of slave workers from view at the University of Virginia and the forgotten and unmarked cemetery of African Americans. The effect the authors are pointing out is not simply the difference between marked and unmarked cemetery, but one of pervasive theft, "a massive, and multigenerational project of cultural theft." This theft is one of truth, power, and wealth; it is also at the heart of their case for reparations. Identity, history, personal and political power, and extraction and obstruction of wealth are all areas in which White supremacy has stolen from African Americans.

Diving into the heart of the book, which is directed towards Christians, the authors examine the church's mission and history in chapter 4. They begin with the church's mission in a world of theft. At the heart of the church's identity is a call to love, which it has the capacity to do. The church has a missional responsibility to a particular work of love in its local context which means it has the obligation to confront White supremacy. Yet, there is also the contradictions in the church's history it must own. It has a history of at times and places being faithful, but also failing and being perpetrators, accomplices, or silent bystanders.

Our moral history and tradition, while sometimes filled with the failures previously mentioned, provides an ethic to deal with those guilty of stealing and the victim. It is in this fifth chapter that they address the biblical foundation of restitution. The authors start with the story of Zacchaeus before looking at three Old Testament passages supporting and providing principles for restitution. With the understanding that Scripture teaches what is stolen must be paid back, the authors cover both the past few generations' understanding of restitution and then as it relates specific to White supremacy.

Reparations are not about restitution alone, but also the work of restoration, returning and restoring your neighbor even if you aren't directly responsible or culpable. This argument is drawn of the parable of the good Samaritan. Restoration is a work of love; it can be left undone because of anxiety, casuistry, invisibility, and hostility. Ultimately, the Samaritan did not follow cultural norms, restored the person fully, showed the call of being a neighbor, and was a witness.

The last chapter offers some options for churches as they begin to step in the direction of reparations. Through listening to others, particularly African American voices the authors suggest that that the work of reparations should be comprehensive, local, and deeply spiritual.

I would encourage all Christians to read and engage with the call to reparation set forth in this book. As I recommend this book, there are two things I would make note of. First, I'm conflicted on my desire for the authors to have included more. Seeing more specific applications would have been nice. Being a more concrete minded person, I would like to see ways to follow through. At the same time, I recognize that this has been done in some ways by others (I'm also currently reading a book by John Perkins), and it is probably not the authors desire to go that far at this point. The book in incredibly readable and more time should be spent reflecting on the ideas. Secondly, I wonder who will read this book within Christian circles. My hope is people will read it thoughtfully, but I sadly expect people to balk at the title "Reparations" and to be generally averse to the idea.

Overall, the arguments set forth for reparations are at the level of introductory and I would like to see more discussion on this topic. No where is the more true than the idea of reparation involving restitution and restoration. This book would be a great topic for a group study and preamble to starting a local reconciliation group.

Was this review helpful?

Reparations: A Christian Call for Repentance and Repair offers some critical insight into the history of racism and white supremacy while offering solutions rooted in Scripture and the Christian tradition. However, the author's theological paradigms of the Church's mission are fundamentally flawed and weaken the Church and its spirituality. The authors fail to implicate the Christian in public policy based on their civil citizenship and resort to turning the Church into a civil institution with the responsibility of fixing the world (p. 17).

The authors spend almost half of the book walking through a historical account of racism and white supremacy in the United States. While this is important, it does not strengthen the book's thesis as a historical and theological call for reparations. Other Christian and secular authors have already provided this history and in more detail. Some might object that the historical account strengthens the thesis that racism and white supremacy are "a cultural order" within which we live, but without a clear definition of a cultural order or even culture at all, a historical account does nothing to strengthen the main ideas (p. 4). The book also seems to ignore precisely how this persists as a cultural order today. Statistics centered around the number of black Americans in jail are not enough to argue that this is a pervasive and enduring cultural order today (p. 26).

Within this arbitrarily defined cultural order of white supremacy, the Church lives and moves and has its being. And according to the authors, it's the Church's responsibility to "engage culture, transform cities, and bring the kingdom of God" (p. 6). It's easy to gloss over that line, but it is pregnant with a view of the Church that is foreign to Scripture and damaging to the Church's mission. One can see the heart of this paradigm when the authors go so far as to call the Church a "civil organization" differing from the federal government only in size and resources (p. 11). We should be clear, the end of a civil institution is civil, and the end of a spiritual institution is spiritual. God does not design means that lead to different ends. The end of the Church is eschatological glory. The end of civil institutions is preserving the world until the Judgment.

The bright spot of this book is the chapter on restitution in the Christian tradition. Removed from redefining the Church as a political arm and a cultural order of white supremacy that somehow permeates all of society, this chapter made a clear case for restitution, not only at the individual level but in circumstances where the individuals are deceased, or the heirs are unidentifiable (p. 127). The authors attempt to broadly apply the Mosaic law under the phrase "If you steal something, give it back" (p. 122). Still, it would've been more helpful to see the Mosaic law as a culturally specific natural law appropriation. On that basis, the authors could've easily claimed that these are broader moral ideas that are merely codified in the Mosaic economy.

Concerning restitution and restoration examples in the New Testament, the authors curiously give two examples from Scripture: Zacchaeus and the Good Samaritan. The authors do not show examples of the Church in the Old Testament or the New Testament giving restitution or some restorative act, as in the Good Samaritan case. Zacchaeus did this purely in response to receiving God's grace and mercy in the Gospel (p. 121). Nevertheless, this was an individual, not an institution. In the case of the Good Samaritan, this is even more complex. Did the Good Samaritan do this from a Christ-redeemed mind, or is the Good Samaritan a model of perfect obedience to the law? Since Christ uses this parable to illustrate that He is the true Good Samaritan, the latter seems more likely. This is only to say that this example does not make sense in the context of calling a spiritual institution to restitution.

It's important to note that the authors mention Kuyper's Church Institution/Organism paradigm and acknowledge that Christians are responsible as citizens of a common kingdom with unbelievers (p. 87). But they see this as an addition to calling the Church as a spiritual institution to the task. That leaves us with the following question: If Christians should advocate for restitution and reparations as common citizens, why does the Church as an institution need to be involved? The Church ought to seek after a better country, whose builder and maker is God (Heb. 11:14, 10). That's not to say that the Church doesn't engage with sin, even corporate sin. It may even be the case that Church's that have held slaves or participated in slavery should engage in the work of restitution and restoration. But to draw this out to engaging every church in social work and public policy is distracting and weakens the spiritual mission of the Church.


The most helpful and theologically informed chapters of this book were on restitution and restoration in the Christian tradition. It would've been more valuable and conducive to expand the latter half of the book and drop the initial chapters. While it's understandable that these initial chapters illustrate that racism and white supremacy are a cultural order, without defining what a cultural order is and how it works, historical accounts are not enough to prove this claim. To that end, reparations may be the answer. But this book does not verify or bolster the thesis in the civil sphere for Christians.

Was this review helpful?

Reparations: A Christian Call for Repentance and Repair by Duke L Kwon and Gregory Thompson is a call to the Church, in particular white Christians to be awakening to the legacy of racism in America. The public cry and conversations regarding the issues of racial division and inequalities have been in the forefront recently. The authors feel it is an overdue response. As Christianity has the view of reconciliation has its sole purpose but are at a loss as to offer a solution for their black neighbors, the authors offer a new perspective on the Church’s responsibility for the deep racism at the heart of American culture and what it can do to repair that brokenness. The book’s main goal is to make a compelling historical and theological case for the Church’s obligation to provide reparations for the oppression of blacks. The authors focus on the church’s responsibility for its promotion and preservation of white supremacy throughout history, the Bible’s call for repair, and offer a vision for the work that needs to be done at the local level. Are they successful?
For most of the book, the authors focus on how white supremacy was created in our system and the why it still persists. It wasn’t until about 57% into the book, do they talk about reparations. They focus more on community repair than just cutting a check and handing it over. They use the story of the Good Samaritan in Luke 10:25-37 as the Samaritan chose to help the injured Jew in love with his eyes, his heart, his hands and his resources. The authors do their best to make a compelling case for reparations; however, at times I felt like they were talking in circles. And while they make a case that white churches need to share the wealth to help repair balck churches and communities and add black voices to the conversation, they don’t really offer how with specifics. They talk about the obstacles that white supremacy has created for the black community, again without saying specifically what the obstacles are, just ways they can be overcome. Overall, I recommend Reparations is a place to start the conversation.

Reparations: A Christian Call for Repentance and Repair is available in hardcover, eBook, and audiobook.

Was this review helpful?

There are few things less popular than the concept of reparations. According to two general polls, 26% of the US supports reparations. It is much less popular among White Evangelicals, around 4%, according to sociologist Samuel Perry. I do not think that Kwon and Thompson believe that this is going to be an easy case to make. And I want to commend Brazos Press for publishing the book because I can't imagine that an explicitly Christian case for reparations, something that is only supported by 4% of White Evangelicals, is going to become a best seller.

The center point of the claim for Reparations is that "White supremacy's most enduring effect, indeed its very essence is theft." They use white supremacy here and throughout the book in the sense of a racial hierarchy with a cultural belief in white racial superiority. The sense of theft here is also broad but nuanced, "...theft is best understood not merely in terms of wealth but also in the more comprehensive terms of truth and power."

One of the complaints about the book that I predict is that Kwon and Thompson frequently use language that is associated in the minds of many with Critical Race Theory and Social Justice. The complaints will be about the method of argument more than the content of the argument and the reality of the harm done, or the need theologically for repair because of that harm. One of the book's strengths is that Kwon and Thompson attempt to define what they mean all through the book clearly. It is hard for me to adequately evaluate how well they accomplish this for readers that are new to these concepts since I am not new to this discussion. But the concept of whiteness and the social construction of race do matter significantly to the case that Kwon and Thompson are trying to make.

The process of this expanded meaning of Whiteness mirrored the expanding of Blackness; as Blackness took on new meaning, Whiteness took on its opposite. Where Blackness signified inferior personal capacity, Whiteness signified superior personal capacity. Where Blackness signified inferior moral deficiency, Whiteness signified superior moral virtue. Where Blackness signified the margins of society, Whiteness signified a rightful claim to the center. To be White came to mean not only having lighter skin, but also possessing elevated personal capacity, inherent moral virtue, and an assumed place at the center of the social order. And, as with Blackness, by the middle of the nineteenth century, the presence of this newly invented notion of Whiteness was clearly visible in American cultural life."

Reparations are not a new concept, even if there has been renewed interested. John Hepburn, in 1715, wrote a pamphlet, The American Defence of the Christian Golden Rule, which called explicitly for reparation using Christian theology before the US was founded as a country.

"I am of Opinion, that such Sins cannot be repented of without Restitution made to them that they have wronged; for until the Cause be removed, I know not how the Effect should cease. But they that live and dye without making Restitution to them that they have wronged, how they can expect the Forgiveness of God..."

Reparations were also clearly known about and understood during and after the Civil War. Union slave owners and some confederate slave owners were given reparations for the loss of their 'property.' But the 40 acres and mule that General Sherman ordered in Field Order 15 were not given to most slaves. Those few who initially got 40 acres and a mule had the rule overturned and their land and property confiscated. (Note that in 1862 with the Homestead Act, the federal government gave land to any citizen that claimed it, but Freedmen before the end of slavery and former slaves after the Civil War were not eligible because they were not legally citizens until the 14th Amendment.)

In 1969, James Forman interrupted the 11 AM service at Riverside Church to read the Black Manifesto, a 2500 word statement calling for reparations. (Riverside Church was the same church Martin Luther King, Jr. announced his opposition to the Vietnam war less than two years earlier). The statement was specifically calling for Christian white churches and Jewish synagogues to give $500,000,000 in reparations, $15 per Black citizen at the time. Most notably today, HR 40 is a bill to create a study commission to investigate the feasibility of reparations. HR40 has been introduced every year since 1989.

The center of Kwon and Thompson's book explores the concepts of reparations in the bible, a broader look at justice, and an in-depth look at Zacchaeus and the parable of the Good Samaritan about reparations as biblical principles. It is here that there is real value to this book. Other books like From Here to Equality: Reparations for Black Americans in the Twenty-First Century explore the economic impact and potential methods of reparations. While the last chapter explores some practical steps for reparations, the book's main point is the biblical basis for the concept and the need that gives rise to the discussion.

Reparations in a secular sense are about justice, rightness, or economics. But for Kwon and Thompson, reparations are primarily about the repair.

"Reparations as an actuarial calculations simply will not do. The work of restoration demands, in the end, the giving not of a check but of one's soul--the giving of one's very self."
And again,

"...the call of reparations is not merely for a check to be written or for a debt to be repaid but for a world to be repaired."

And even clearer,

"The parable of the good Samaritan, set againsts the backdrop of multigenerational cultural theft of White supremacy, make a crucial contribution to a Christian account of reparations. It reminds us that the work of restoring all that was unjustly taken from our neighbors is the calling not only of the culpable but of all who seek to live a life of love in the world. Because of this, the church in America, a community whose very purpose is love, must own the ethic of restoration and give itself to this work of healing. Indeed, it is the church's vocation both to dress wounds and to redress wrongs."

Was this review helpful?

Link here to full review: https://garrettvogele.medium.com/review-reparations-a-christian-call-for-repentance-and-repair-7141e3a3cbe6

"This book was great in many ways. For me the best part was the look at the history and stories surrounding chattel slavery, Jim Crow, segregation, and the role that American institutions and the church played throughout. It showed the bad, but also the stories of African American men and women that challenged the norms that were formed over hundreds of years.
The book showed that the story and ideas surrounding a topic like reparations is one that is not purely binary, but one that requires an open heart and a willingness to be vulnerable and honest. Sadly, I know that many will throw out the sum total of the book and the ideas within because of their issues with certain phrases, words, stories, examples, references, etc. For me, I would not say the book is perfect, nor would I want to say that any book or article like it is the solution to the problems discussed. Though I will argue that denial is, and never will be, the answer.
My biggest issue with the book is this. I finished it and wanted to hear more. I wanted to hear more stories from the past. I wanted to hear more of the thoughts of those in the final chapter that consulted with Kwon and Thompson. For some this was a reason to detract from the value of the book.
For some this was not enough, and for others it is too much. For me I think that it is a great introduction. It looked at history, at Scripture, and engage the arguements. My hope is that this is just the beginning. Not just for the readers, but also for the authors. I would love to see a follow up. Perhaps a companion guide from those they consulted with. If the readers agree and are challenged to do more, then a more prescriptive text would be something worth exploring.
This is something that is worth reading regardless of where you are at, and I plan on continuing to learn more and listen to those great voices that were given a venue through the work of Kwon and Thompson."

Was this review helpful?

A Call for Christians to Actually Live Out the Story of the Good Samaritan in Following Our Savior

This is one of the most difficult, most important, and most helpful books that I have read all year.

I commend Duke Kwon and Greg Thompson for courageously talking about some of the most difficult, controversial, and important issues in our culture today by looking at the issues of racism, white supremacy, and restorative justice, considering what role has the church played in the issues throughout the history of our country, and reflecting on how the Scriptures call us as believers to respond to these issues. The authors have done a phenomenal job of researching to present a moving, accurate, and well-documented history of and theological response to these issues. Whether or not you end up agreeing with their final conclusion, this is a book that all Christians who have a heart for living for Christ need to read if they are to healthily respond to the racial divide and inequities that exist today.

The book starts out with a revealing and compelling letter from a former slave writing in 1865 to his former slaveowner who is wanting him to come back to work for him, laying out the harm that has taken place and what sort of actions would genuinely speak of a desire for reconciliation (to really be inviting him back).

Ch 1 calls us as readers, and especially as believers, to see the problems of racism throughout the history of our country.
Ch 2 & 3 unpack this problem and lay out one of the clearest pictures of what White Supremacy and one of the most compelling cases of why White Supremacy is truly a problem for the American church both in the past with continuing effects for the present day.

Ch 4 offers a call for believers to own and to address the effects of these problems in response both to what the Bible teaches in the Old and New Testaments and to the model that Jesus gave us in redeeming us through His life and death.
Ch 5 looks at the Ethics of Restitution, especially from Luke 19 and the story of Zaccheaus. This chapter lacked the connections needed to create a compelling case for reparations as a function of restitution involving those not directly committing the offense.
Ch 6 looks at the Ethics of Restoration through the story of the Good Samaritan. This chapter is one of the strongest, as it presents a compelling case that we need to own the care of those who have been plundered and beaten up by racism and white supremacy if we are to own the mission of our Savior and to truly live as His people. If we do not, we are the very ones that Jesus was seeking to rebuke, as “Jesus’s purpose was to expose how bigotry treats certain plundered neighbors as unworthy of restorative love.”

Finally the authors in Ch 7 issue a call to repair, calling for reparations and looking at what African Americans have said regarding the need for reparations and its importance if reconciliation and healthy race relations are going to be able to move forward.

In the end, I’m not sure that this book makes the sort of persuasive, compelling case in order to move skeptics towards embracing reparations. But I believe that this book does something more important...it calls for the Church and Christians to see that racism and white supremacy exists and that they are a HUGE problem, it calls us to see our African American brothers and sisters and to be moved to genuine compassion and love towards them in light of the injustices that they have and continue to live under, and it calls us to care and to act to help these brothers and sisters to be restored in light of a Savior who has come to make right what is wrong and even to reconcile us to the Father by paying a price He didn’t even owe that we might be restored and healed and to create a people with that same heart for those who are needy and who have been wronged.

Reading this book made me care more about my black brothers and sisters, see and feel more clearly the great racial injustices that have taken place in our country and often by the church, and to reflect on and moved to act to address the inequities that I see in my local community as a function of representing the Good Samaritan (Jesus) better through my life.

(I received a free digital copy of this work in exchange for this my honest review of the book.)

Was this review helpful?

ARC/NetGalley

If you can get through the text of the catechism that some enslaved people were required to memorize (2nd slide) and not immediately understand the need for Christian accountability for our sins against Black Americans then I really don’t know how to convince you. Fortunately Duke Kwon and Gregory L. Thompson have written an entire book on the subject.
Reparations: A Christian Call for Repentance and Repair is accessible and convicting. I encourage every Christian to read it with an open mind. While we should advocate for movement from our national government we also don’t have to wait to do what’s right.

Was this review helpful?

This is a well-researched, well-written, and persuasive argument that Christians should advocate for reparations to African Americans. The authors do a great job incorporating historical information and Scripture into their book. They also offer a well-rounded look at reparations and argue that it needs to include not only financial resources but also widespread change in how Black people are treated by the government and by individuals. A must-read for Christians who care about justice, as well as non-Christians who want to understand a Christian perspective (perhaps to help them convince Christians in their lives).

Was this review helpful?

I loved the opening letter in this book written by a formerly enslaved person to the person who enslaved him. It calculates how much his labor was worth and asks for payment in response to a request for him to come back and work for this man.
This book is best read by people who are new to the idea of reparations. It gives a broad review of the history of systemic racism in the U.S. to people who have not been willing to notice it previously.

Was this review helpful?