Sometimes you read a book and you realise that you don't have the right frame of reference to appreciate it fully. Jin Yong's A Hero Born (review copy from Quercus) is just such a book. This is the first time that this classic of Wuxia fiction has been translated into English. Anna Holmwood has done a fantastic job of translating the text, but I suspect there are whole layers of meaning and allegory that are invisible to a Western reader without further explanation.

A Hero Born is the first in the Condor trilogy, following two boys in 13th century China. Before their birth they were bonded to each other by their fathers, who were best friends and comrades in arms. The boys also become the subject of a rash bet about which school of martial arts can raise the best fighter, with each school pledging to train one of the boys ahead of a competition when they are older. But an attack on their village saw their fathers killed and their mothers separated. One flees north and raises her son amongst Genghis Khan's Mongolian Empire. The other's beauty catches the eye of a nobleman who lures her away with the promise of helping her get revenge on her husband's killer.

It's easy to see why this is regarded as a literary classic. It is woven through with Chinese history and it extols the principal Confucian virtues of benevolence, kindness, loyalty, courage and righteousness. The story principally follows Guo Jing as he grows up in Genghis Khan's tribe. He is trained by the Seven Freaks of the South in various aspects of martial arts and weapons, and the novel is riddled through with the names of various moves and techniques. They aspire to teach him the almost supernatural levels of skill familiar to Western audiences from wuxia films.

The Seven Freaks was where I struggled most with this book. To a Western reader they appear as grotesques and caricatures, and it is difficult to take them seriously as experts and teachers in their field. They are easily duped, and spend a lot of time fighting and arguing amongst themselves. They are not good teachers, and frequently get frustrated with the rather pedestrian Guo Jing. Yet we are apparently meant to revere and admire them.

Lying at the heart of this book is a story about a kind boy growing up far away from home and trying to make his way in a confusing world. The book is strongest in its critique of corruption and unfettered power, and the importance of the Confucian values.

Goodreads rating: 3*

i was very lucky to be accepted to read this book early for a review via netgalley. it isnt my usual genre but i wanted to give something new a go, and im so glad i did. what a story!
the book can be a little confusing at the start, getting used to the funny classic kung-fu names like "wild goose leaves the flock" was abit strange at first, but i soon forgot about that as i was drawn in to the story. this book is actually a translation of a classic chinese fantasy series, but Anna holmwood has done a fantastic job and given the story a fresh and new feel in my opinion. i would highly recommend you read this book, i was captivated from the very first pages.
the downside? i have to wait a whole year for the next in the series. if i had more confidence in my linguistic capabilities i would learn chinese so i can read-on, although it will be quicker for me to just wait for the next transpated version.
happy reading.

‪A Hero Born by Jin Yong (translated by Anna Holmwood) https://www.runalongtheshelves.net/blog/2018/3/17/a-hero-born-by-jin-yong-translated-by-anna-holmwood‬

This Chinese martial arts series started in the 1950’s and has already sold 300 million copies (and rumours suggest in bootleg form up to 1 billion!) Its however only just made its way across the world thanks to an excellent English translation by the translator Anna Holmwood. Safe to say I was not sure what I was in for and I was pleasantly surprised to find a fast-paced epic fantasy that has a unique way of storytelling and some surprisingly modern approaches to the genre.

The saga starts with two friends (and highly trained martial artists) Skyfury Guo and Ironheart Yang who are living in a Chinese empire where the enemy Jin empire secretly has control. The two meet a Taoist monk Qui Chuji who is carrying the head of a Jin spy he recently despatched. This minor misunderstanding is quickly over but draws the attention of enemy Jin forces who order both men for execution. The pregnant wives of both are made to flee as their husbands are mortally injured and we focus on Lily Li who moves to the Mongol Empire, Qui Chuji is desperate to know what happened to his friends and after some epic battles with the mighty kung Fu sect The Seven Freaks of the South its agreed that to make up for lost time the two factions will each search for one child. Lily Li gives birth to Guo Jing and we see him grow up to become a sensible young man in search of a destiny and has a major role in uniting the Mongol groups!

This is a true epic plot, and this is just volume 1! But it never feels overloaded. In comparison with many western epics where you can appear to live every mile of a quest it’s more as if a vast selection of short stories/key scenes are being told by a storyteller. Each one stands on its two feet but there is a larger story slowly evolving leading to potentially the defeat of the Jin. For example, a scene where Guo Jing tames a wild horse is quickly turned into Guo and his shifus (The seven Freaks) working to free a victim from a would be serial killer and then shortly after that the final battle in the Mongol Civil war. The pace is indeed frenetic, but it flows very organically. Yong ensures there is an emotional kick to each scene be that the heroic last stand of Ironheart and Skyfury to the tragic scene where Timujan (shortly to be Genghis Khan) buries his best friend’s toys in the soil as a sign their friendship is over on the eve of war. Moving from epic history to these moments especially considering the pace it goes at is immensely skilful. Its perhaps notable for post-revolutionary China there is an ongoing theme of good people taking on corrupt nobles and creating a better world. Happily, not overly done but you can sense that at the time this message would not have been popular.

The action scenes are also a highlight. In this world we have many Kung Fu sects all with key sills. This can range from the humorous (a monk who can in drinking contest force the alcohol from their skin!) to the deadly. There are networks are touring shifus who either feud with or teach each other. Rather than describe each kick and punch instead we get beautiful terms such as Nine Yin Skelton Claw, Shoot the Arrow moving from the ability to fight hordes of armed guards to climbing steep mountains at high speed. As you get used to the world you will notice the different styles and the bigger history of the various groups. By not explaining everything in detail it really allows your imagination to add the visual spectacle, but the pace really makes it all come across as if it was a movie scene.

The final standout is character. Our lead character Guo Jing who we see growing up isn’t entirely the standard hero born to rule the kingdom later. He’s kind and good natured rather than an adventurer. Keen to help those in need but very shy when it comes to potential relationships. In contrast and it’s so welcome are the large number of female characters in the story. For a 1950’s tale the number and variety of women in different roles we see from Lily the doting mother who is prepared to hide in the steppes to Temujin’s daughter Khojin who is happy to defy her arranged marriage to the totally independent, playful and certainly skilled martial artist Lotus Huang and finally the mysterious powerful Consort who holds secrets that will bring about the story’s confusion. Yes, there are elements of sexism; Ironhearts’s wife is viewed as too kind leading to their enemy’s attack but overall, it’s a world where women can act and talk and often match the lead male. Compare that with Tolkien’s ‘vast array’ of women in key roles…. ahem.

So, for me this was a very immersive reading experience introducing me to a world and style of storytelling I was not previously familiar with. It’s epic, heartfelt, funny and has breath-taking pace. Possibly it may be too fast for readers more used to watching someone grow up year by year in one volume but I think it’s a fascinating experience and will be watching out for volume 2 next year.

I thought this was a great book. I did think that the translation was a little awkward at times, especially in some fight scene, but then I don't think any translated work will read as well when not read in it's original language. It did mean that it took me a little while to get into the flow of the writing though. I thought the characters were well written, the story was engaging and there are some great action scenes. Overall I enjoyed this and I'm definitely interested in checking out the rest of this series, if there are translation of it.

This was sadly not a book for me, I just did not get on with the translation and had not realised how heavily it would focus on fight scenes.