Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I am so grateful to @hodderbooks and @netgalley for approving my ARC copy of this book. After reading When Dimple Met Rishi in April I was so excited to get my hands on more of Menon’s writing. While I wasn’t as invested in the characters in this one I still enjoyed the story. I loved the characters of Sahil and Twinkle’s grandma. I loved the plot line about Twinkle and Maddie’s relationship. I also loved the relationship development between Twinkle and her Mum, it made me cry and I wish more time had been spent on it. I loved all the interactions between the characters, sometimes teen characters are written so overly wise and mature but these felt realistic. I liked that Twinkle was a flawed character but that she learnt from her mistakes in the end. I did enjoy the letter format but I wish you got to hear more of the story from Sahil’s point of view. For me, that was one of the biggest strengths for WDMR, and in this I really missed it. You get to see some of his perspective through text messages but these are few and far between and honestly, they were some of my favourite parts. That said, I understand if Menon doesn’t want to be pigeonholed into a certain style so I’ll just have to adjust my expectations for her next book!! All in all, I think if you like YA romances with feisty female leads and abundant pop culture references, do yourself a favour and check this out when it’s published in the U.K. on the 22nd May!

Was this review helpful?

I wasn't able to finish From Twinkle With Love. I reached about 10%, but I couldn't connect to the characters. This is probably because of the format of the story - it's written in a chat and message style, which meant I wasn't able to get to know the characters like I wanted.

Was this review helpful?

I read When Dimple Met Rishi last year after hearing the editor talk about it at a work event and thought it sounded right up my street. I wasn’t disappointed - it was one of my favourite books of the year! So when I saw this on Netgalley, I didn’t hesitate to request it! It took me a bit longer to get into, and I think this is largely because it’s set back in high school rather than having slightly older protagonists. That was something I really enjoyed about Dimple. I also found the format of the letters (though not the texts) and Twinkle’s teenage angst about 2/3 of the way through really jarring. Nevertheless, the book is full of Menon’s signature swoonworthy love interests and heated moments which kept me interested until the end! I also was kept guessing about the mysterious elements until Twinkle was - something that NEVER happens so I was pretty happy! Just would have preferred older protagonists who I could identify with more! Thank you so much for the opportunity to read, I had a great time!

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely loved this story. It had real believable, relatable heart. From the imperfection of the characters to the occasionally awkward dialogue it was perfect as a true reflection of a budding romance you could really root for.

Was this review helpful?

Sunny, delightful, uplifting - everything I expect from Sandhya Menon and more. I loved When Dimple Met Rishi and so was very happy to be approved for this title, and not disappointed

Was this review helpful?

If you loved When Dimple Met Rishi, then you will adore From Twinkle, With Love! I fell completely in love with Sandhya Menon's first book and I didn't know how her second could touch me in quite the same way, but it really did live up to expectations.

From Twinkle, With Love is full of new, vibrant characters for you to fall in love with, especially Sahil (Twinkle's producer) who is amazingly adorable! Twinkle is an engaging central character, however, I did find myself getting very frustrated with her in parts.

Was this review helpful?

From twinkle with love, follows our main character Twinkle who wants to tell stories and so when a guy called Sahil Roy partners up with her to direct and create a film for the summer festival she is ecstatic. But the only thing is, she has a massive crush on sahil’s brother, and sahil has a massive crush on her. Talk about unrequited love. So when an email comes through from an admirer called ‘n’ she automatically thinks it’s Neil. But in the meantime she falls for Sahil and it’s just this big love triangle. Kind of a cliché I know but Neill doesn’t even know about it. The story is also told in the form of letters to amazing female filmmakers and one day I hope to be among those names because it’s exactly what I want to do so this book really resonated with me on a personal level.

4 out of 5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

The book is about Twinkle, a junior student/aspiring director who navigates the world of relationships (family, friends, love) as she directs a film to be entered at her school's Midsummer Night Festival. There's Maddie, her best friend who seems to be spending less time with her. There's also Neil, her crush. Lastly, there's Sahil, Neil's twin brother whom Twinkle might be actually falling for.

I was already hooked with the filmmaking arc, but this was a wonderful story. There was a lot to unpack as Twinkle discovers more about herself and her demons. She had a lot of insecurities, most which were addressed and resolved one way or another. I love her chemistry with Sahil and her relationship with Dadi. Her friendship with Maddie was very important to her, and I liked how it was handled. This also has a variety of characters involved; my favorite supporting character is Victoria. I also liked how she was writing to female directors. I felt that this was one way to inform people of their work (after a bit of research) and make a more conscious effort to watch more films directed by women.

I did find some parts to be tied up too neatly, but it doesn't deter from the reading experience. This was an enjoyable contemporary novel to read, and had more than what I expected it to have.

Was this review helpful?

This story is so awe inspiring that talks about chasing your dreams and goals, no matter if you think you won't be able to do it unless you try your hardest and your best. It's also empowering for women and especially for a POC since the character is going over the horizon to make a difference in society—to be able to be seen by the people around her.

Twinkle is such a lovable character that only wants the best for herself and though she don't mention it, wants the best for the people around her too. Yes, conflicts between friends may appear but it would be for the best most of the time to be the better person.

It's so nice to see for a change that the boy, Sahil Roy has a crush on the girl, Twinkle for as long as he can remember. Gradually, Twinkle starts to love him for who he is instead of just making a reality for her idea where she dates Neil and manage to be seen by everyone. I'm so glad that she snapped back into reality and make a deserved change for herself instead of hoping for something that could never happen.

I'm so glad I gave the author, Sandhya Menon a second chance because this book is now on my favourites list and a story that I would love to recommend to everyone!

Was this review helpful?

I didn't think When Dimple met Rishi could be outdone on the meetcute scale...boy was I wrong! From Twinkle, With Love is perfect for fans of Holly Bourne or anyone who enjoys feminist contemporary YA books. The romance is enormously endearing, but my favourite thing about this book was Twinkle's ambition and brains! The diverse cast was a breath of fresh air and I laughed my way through every moment of this book. Will 100% re-read!

Was this review helpful?

This book was fun to read, and so swoony, but at the same time I found it frustrating and annoying at times too.

It was nice to see Twinkle grow over the book and realise she doesn't need to change herself at all.

Also Sahil is such a sweetheart.

Was this review helpful?

IN SUMMARY: Proving Menon’s ability to write fun, diverse, laugh-out-loud rom-coms with drama to taste, FROM TWINKLE, WITH LOVE features unique narration, an authentic voice, and a heart-warming read about friendship and love worth every word.

MY THOUGHTS:

I was always a little wary about reading this because, funnily enough, I know someone eeriely similar to a character in this book. I'm glad I forgot that though, because I loved the narration style, the voice, the humour and, most importantly, I thought Sahil was a great worthy love interest, and should be the standard for teenage romances. Some parts I did find implausible enough to get leery, but on the whole, this book delivered a satisfying and endearing conclusion.

Definitely recommended for anyone who enjoyed WHEN DIMPLE MET RISHI!

WILL I READ MORE FROM THIS AUTHOR? Yes!

Was this review helpful?

Sometimes in life you just need to let yourself read a fluffy, happy, sunshiney contemporary book and last year my favourite contemporary read was "When Dimple met Rishi". I loved it so much as soon as "From Twinkle, with Love" was announced I pre-ordered it straight away. I still couldn't resist requesting it on Netgalley as well and I definitely did a happy dance when I got the notification that I was approved.

"From Twinkle, with Love" follows Twinkle Mehra, an aspiring filmmaker with a huge amount of ambition and talent and a massive crush on swim-superstar Neil Roy, but when she is approached by Neil's twin brother Sahil to direct a film for the upcoming Summer festival, Twinkle starts to fall for the other Roy brother.

I loved how cute this book was. The characters all seemed genuinely high school age, they weren't trying to be older than they are and the things they were concerned with were all refreshingly normal.

Twinkle's family dynamic was also a strong factor to the book, helping to explain the attitude problem she has at times. Whilst her relationship with her parents was complicated, the constant unwavering love from Dadi was beautiful and she stole the scene whenever she appeared.

The romance between Twinkle and Sahil was heart meltingly adorable and I read most of the book desperate for Twinkle to come to her senses and drop her fixation with boring athlete Neil and fall head over heels for nerdy, film obssessed, devoted Sahil instead.

The cultural identity of this book is so strong, as it was for "Dimple", and whilst it's not Sandhya Menon's job to teach us about Indian culture, I enjoy being able to read a book in which the culture is so integral to the story because you do end up learning a lot. More importantly, it's so vital and wonderful that many young people will see themselves represented in this book where previously they haven't been.

"From Twinkle, with Love" is a must read book for the summer if you love fun, flirty contemporary reads.

Was this review helpful?

Very very cliche in parts, but aren't all good romance novels?! I have to admit, not as good as Dimple, and I felt like the story could have been wrapped up a whole lot sooner. I was even shocked when I checked the percentage of my reading and found there was a whole lot left! I feel like Twinkle was a good character, and I completely understood her hatred for Hannah who was a complete bitch. (Side note though, wouldn't it have been a lot better if it was revealed that Hannah had a crush on Maddie??)

Was this review helpful?

This is the second book from the author of When Dimple Meet Rishi, and as soon as I saw it I knew I had to read it. This book was so good Twinkle is a lovely and flawed character who makes mistakes throughout the book, but learned from them and made me love her character more and had me rooting for her. That being said I do prefer Dimple as Twinkle did feel a little younger.
Overall I would highly recommend this book and you have not read When Dimple Meet Rishi I would recommend reading that as well.

Was this review helpful?