Cover Image: The Binding

The Binding

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I very nearly gave up on this book as the beginning was very pedestrian and the characters definitely did not bind me! It was hard going! However, once we went back in time, it was as if another author had taken over the story and this reader did indeed become spellbound! The pace changed, things began to happen and it became an excellent read from past to present!

Was this review helpful?

if you could bind away your memories in a book – once written and bound you forget. You can leave the bad behind. Is that good? Or would it empty you of that which makes you who you are?..
A young farmer, Emmett receives a letter inviting him to become the local binder’s apprentice. Weakened by a sudden and debilitating illness, he sees no alternative as he is struggling to work on the farm. Whilst his parents are distressed by the invite, between them all it is evident that he needs to leave.
He learns that he is destined to become a binder himself, which initially he fights, but under the old fashioned wing of Seredith he learns to accept his fate and settles into the quiet, rhythmical life in the isolated binders house. Just as he starts to adjust to his new life and just begin to learn a few things, Seredith dies. This means he is then made to work for another binder who is a less scrupulous binder out to make profit.
Things take a fascinating twist when Emmet learns that he has had his memories binded previously – and all his memories return. A story within a story this makes for absorbing reading. This changes him
With a gorgeous cover this books offers a dark and magical, escapist historical/fantasy read. the pace slows a litle for me midway, but does not have a critical effect on the read. It has a message to be carefulwhat you wish for. It captures the human nature of explotation/corruption, but also depicts homosexual romance that crosses social and wealth boundaries. It is essentially told in 3 parts pre binding/ apprentiship and accepting who he is and who he wants to be. it has a great ending too.

Was this review helpful?

“ (...) underneath it all was a silence so deep the sounds skittered over it like pebbles on ice.”
How precious is a memory? This is Emmet Farmer’s story. I don’t want to spoil it for other readers by posting a synopsis. This is a book you have to probe, discover and sink into by yourself. You will be puzzled, lonesome, angry and marvelling. You will view and taste and smell Emmet’s landscape, his despair, breathe in when he takes a breath, shiver when the cold seeps into his bones. You will feel the love he feels for his sister Alta and you will feel his absolute compulsion to protect her even if that leads to his own unhappiness.After all, he is one of the chosen ones, a “binder” of memories. And then there is Lucian Darney, from as different a background as is possible. Watch their poetic tale unfold...

Was this review helpful?

The summary is misleading. Yes, Emmett is a book binder, well, he binds one book in this whole story. This is a tale of an illicit love affair and how both parties end up trying to bind it to forget and help their families, but forgetting is not the solution. So, it is a story about the effects of binding on those that do it and those that use it. So, I was looking forward to a different story to the one I read, and was therefore, a little disappointed.

Was this review helpful?

I very much enjoyed this highly imaginative novel. The setting was interesting - an imaginary alternative England where memories can be deleted from a person's mind by a "binder" who converts the memories into a specially bound book which will supposedly be held securely. The binders have mysterious powers and seem to be divided into those who see the calling as almost a sacred mission and those who are merely looking for profit.
The story is in sections wit flashbacks which explain how the main protagonist, Emmett Farmer had been ill as a result of having been made to submit to a "binding".and who himself becomes a binder. The originality of the of the story is crafted beautifully and is truly spellbinding

Was this review helpful?

What an original idea. For me, this story went deeper than just a tale of magic craft. It put across the idea of being able to erase and expunge unwanted events and memories. I particularly enjoyed how the three parts of the story blended together to give a whole picture and part of that picture was a snapshot of a different kind of love that wasn’t accepted in the time of its setting. Very well written and crafted.
A thoroughly enjoyable book which I would highly recommend

Was this review helpful?

Beautifully written novel set in a fantasy time and fantasy place which are so like real times and places I kept hoping for a clue as to when and where we were. Ultimately though, that didn't matter as the plot and descriptions carried me along. At times Gothic and at times full of light and wonder, it is a painful and delicately drawn love story. The concept - of the bindings - is fascinating.

I very much enjoyed reading this and wanted to stay in its world even after I had finished it.

Was this review helpful?

I wasn't sure at first about this book, not my usual kind at all, I'm absolutely flabbergasted to find that it knocked me sideways, brilliant, I just didn't see it coming, lots of twists and turns, all I can say is, get it, you won't regret, even if, like me, you don't normally go for this genre, I'm nearly 60 and can honestly say it's brilliant .

Was this review helpful?

Spellbinding!
This novel has received rave reviews following its publication and deservedly so. It's a mixture of various book genres and should appeal to most readers. This is Bridget Collins's first foray into adult novels having written many novels previously for younger readers.
The central theme of the novel is a truly innovative one: what if all your bad memories could be wiped from your memory, leaving only the good ones. In "The Binding", set in an undefined past time, this is a possibility if you employ the services of a "Binder". Your memories are wiped out and stored in a book. The security of the book is paramount or your enemies could gain access to dark deeds.
Characterisation and plot are both gripping and the story revolves around a love affair which seems doomed to failure. Surely set to become a modern classic this novel should be on every readers must read list. The novel involves an element of fable and mysticism so be prepared to be whipped away on a magical trip to a world where the profession of Binding is available to those who can afford it, to facilitate memories which are only wholesome.

Was this review helpful?

Emmett Farmer is struggling with a debilitating illness which is making life hard on the farm. When a letter is received from The Bookbinder Emmett becomes her apprentice, initially against his wishes, and slowly he learns the basics of their craft. Books are memories of people, trapped in pages and removed from their minds. However when his mistress dies and Emmett moves to another bindery he discovers that he has also been the subject of a binding.
This book seems to polarise opinions and it is easy to see why. The first part of the book is magical, Emmett's story about becoming a binder is unusual and carefully managed. I just wish the book had continued in this vein. The second part about the reasons behind Emmett's binding is OK, it was pretty obvious to see where this was heading but the writing still persuaded. My issue is with the last section of the book and the relationship between Lucian and Emmett. It just felt forced and almost as if the first third of the book had been written by someone else. Some readers love the change in emphasis, I didn't.

Was this review helpful?

This was an absolutely wonderful read. I genuinely couldn't put it down. Exciting, dark, mysterious, romantic and magical, The Binding delivered everything that it promised to and more.

Was this review helpful?

This book comes with a beautiful cover and quite a lot of hype. It is promoted as the author’s first foray into adult fiction, she is better known for YA novels, and I think that this shows.
I actually checked who it was aimed at when I was reading it because the characters, events, plot seemed to indicate a younger target market.
There are two main threads to the story, the ‘Binding’, which plays on fantasy, magic, witchcraft and superstition and forbidden love. I’m not sure that these two are blended successfully. There seem to be parallels between the Binding and historical methods of trying to control ‘unacceptable’ behaviour or what were considered to be perversions through such things as electric shock treatments.
For me, I would have enjoyed it more without the fantasy element.
My thanks to Netgalley for this copy.

Was this review helpful?

Well this is an interesting one. The Binding by Bridget Connell is the story of how stories are made. The promise is that there are people called ‘Binders’ who will take away any bad memories and lock them securely in a book. The book will then be locked away. The only way for the people to regain their memories is if the books are burned. So far, so mystical.

We then have the main story which revolves around Emmett Farmer. He is sent to work as a binder but as the story evolves we see that he too has been bound.

I cannot lie to you, I found The Binding really difficult to get into. I wasn’t instantly lost in this world. Then something clicked and I was gone. I mean completely lost. I couldn’t put it down. It is a book that covers so many issues: class, power, LGBT. There is so much in here.

This is definitely a must read for 2019.

The Binding by Bridget Collins is available now.

For more information regarding Bridget Collins (@Br1dgetCollins) please visit www.thebindingbook.com.
For more information regarding Harper Collins (@HarperCollinsUK) please visit their Twitter page.
For more information regarding The Borough Press (@BoroughPress) please visit www.boroughpress.co.uk.

Was this review helpful?

Such a great book with wonderful writing and deftly drawn characters. Set in the olden days, it is the story of Emmett, born on a farm but also born to be a binder. Binders can take memories from those who want to give them up. They write them down and the person has no recollection of the binding nor the memory that has been bound. Emmett is apprenticed to a local binder after a long illness but has to move to a more commercial binder shortly afterwards. There is a lurid black market for real books. The ending is very satisfactory and I would recommend it to young adults as well as adults.

Was this review helpful?

Struggled to understand the hype here. Yes, the novel is well written. And yes, the concept of books being used as actual memories bound by paper was well thought... but it feels, like a wasted opportunity. Instead of developing this world of book binding magic, the novel focus more on a forbidden love story that fails to compel. In particular, the second act just drags on and on, and I just wanted the book to end so that I could move on to the next... never a good sign. So, all in all... just not that good.

Was this review helpful?

This book promised so much. First of all even the proof copy which I received was beautifully produced. They say never judge a book by its cover, but several customers have bought this book on the strength of the cover itself.
Secondly it was a "meta book" that is a book about books. Thirdly it melded fantasy with a unique concept- that is that parts of lives (usually difficult) can be"bound" into books and then forgotten. The drawback of this is that there are unscrupulous bookbinders and people who take advantage of this situation. As a part time counsellor I found this concept intriguing.


Part 1 deals with young Emmett after an unspecified "illness" is apprenticed to an ethical bookbinder called Seredith. There he takes a dislike to a visitor, Lucian Darnay

Part 2
This follows Emmett in what I took to be a "parallel" Ireland but other reviewers think is Yorkshire as he first meets Lucian Darnay

Part 3
This jumps in time to weave together the other two parts/strands of the story.

For me Part 1 was slow in its pace and didn't draw me in enough. If I hadn't been reviewing it I probably would have given up at this point. Part 2 then recaptured my interest. and picked up momentum. Part 3 had a "Dorian Gray" type atmosphere especially with the debauched and cruelly manipulative father.

Overall though I feel slightly disappointed that this book did not live up to the "hype" and I doubt whether it will be asked for a few years down the line.
In fairness though other readers have loved it and I would love to be proved wrong.

Was this review helpful?

This is the hardest review I have ever had to write because I just don't know what to make of it.

This is a story that is split into three parts: Part 1 is seen through the eyes of Emmett - he has been unwell for some time but we don't know with what. What we do know is that he is being sent to be a 'binder' working with an old lady at her cottage. We learn that 'binding' is something to do with books but what the 'binding' is and why everyone is so afraid of it remains unclear at this point. This section is also hellishly slow, I felt like I lived every single day with them!

Part 2 is again focusing on Emmett but this time it is before his illness and we find out what happened to him and how he ended up ill and working for the 'binder'. A much faster pace in this section sweeps you along. Beautifully written, the descriptions are beautiful.

Part 3 focuses on Lucian Darney, his relationship with his family and he has come to know Emmett and how their lives are entangled.

During Part 1 I almost gave up - I was about 20% in and I was struggling but something just kept drawing me back and drawing me back until I had to finish it. Part 2 was so much better, the writing seemed cleaner and the story flowed much better and it made the first part make sense too. Part 3 was almost as good as Part 2 but I hated the sudden, very abrupt ending that kind of just left the characters...hanging.

I can't say much more without ruining it for others who want to read it - what I can say is that if you do pick it up give it a chance, stick around until Part 2 as that really helps to pull the story together and the things from Part 1 make a lot more sense.

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the advance copy in exchange for an honest review,

Was this review helpful?

Part fantasy and part historical drama The Binding is a real revelation. It is Collins’ first book for an adult audience. A twisting dark gothic tale it centres around Emmett Farmer. In the first part he is recovering from a mysterious illness and on reduced duties on the farm where he lives with his parents and sister Alta. A letter arrives out of the blue and suddenly Emmett is packed off to be an apprentice Binder.

His new employer Seradith is an old woman living alone in the middle of nowhere. With her reputation for being a witch Emmett is a little afraid of what life with her will be like. Instead she is concerned about his welfare and sets him up with some tools and leather and he begins to learn about the craft of book binding. But Seradith takes all of her customers down to the dank basement. The room that is always under lock and key. The place that Emmett cannot go. As Seradith’s health starts to fail she imparts a little more information to him about the work of the Binder. How they take away people’s memories and seal them into a personal book. The books are secured in a vault and the willing Bindee has no recollection of the stories they have shared.

Some readers may find this book a challenging read with references to abuse and sexual violence, gay relationships and the persecution of gay men in society. While the violence and sexual scenes aren’t graphic they are very evocative and even sensual which may offend a reader expecting a novel about a book binder!

The Binding is a glorious mix of Victorian morality, an ill fated love affair and the fantastic ghoulish concept of the Binder who can steal your thoughts away. Once you immerse yourself in its dark and devilish conceit you won’t be able to tear yourself away from Emmett’s story.

Supplied by Net Galley and The Borough Press in exchange for an honest review.

UK Publication date: Jan 10 2019. 448 pages.

Was this review helpful?

I don’t like to give low ratings for books, but I just did not enjoy this novel and, unusually for me, could not finish it. I can see that many people really like it, and that opinion on the book is polarised quite sharply.
I liked the mysterious concept of the book and I was really looking forward to reading it. A boy with a mysterious illness is apprenticed to a bookbinder, at a time when folks are afraid to have books. His illness comes and goes, but seems to be connected to his fate as the next bookbinder. Much is unknown and the true nature of the books created by the old lady is slowly revealed.
For me, the characters seemed unevenly drawn, with inconsistent behaviour and I wasn’t keen on the writing style, which felt a little simplistic. Then, as the plot developed, it just did not draw me into it enough to make up for the aspects of the book that I didn’t like.
I have just finished an absolutely cracking book and I think that for me the contrast of my disinterest while reading this was just too stark.
Sorry, just not for me, but I am glad so many others have enjoyed it.
Many thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for a copy of the book in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Very disappointed with this one. What could have been a great story, especially seen the amazing premise that could have been the start of an intriguing moral and ethical debate, turned out to be only a love story. The prose itself is gorgeous and the love story itself is alright. But I feel as I've been cheated out of a great moral story.

Was this review helpful?