Secrets in a Small Town

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date: 09 Jun 2019

Member Reviews

I am a big fan of a story with an ice queen so was looking forward to this book. I did enjoy the interactions between the two which made the story entertaining. I did however feel the transition from hatred to romance and love was too quick which made it hard to feel how believable the romance was. In saying that I did like the two together just would have liked the transition to have been done a little better and believable. 

The mystery I thought was good, I had a small idea of who I thought it was but was never 100% as I thought the storyline kept me guessing. 

Overall a really good read which I did enjoy and would recommend it as a light mystery read.
Was this review helpful?
Here is the run down of the book...Micki is Chief of Police is a small town that Savannah is TM ( is that kinda like a mayor?). They clash like the titans of old in a big way. Savannah has the personality or demeanor of the typical Ice Queen whereas Micki is pretty laid back and chill. Something stirs up the small town that effects Savannah and in comes Micki to try and save the day. The book starts off great. I really liked it and it made me smile. The initial interactions between Savannah and Micki were really great as well as you could feel the dislike/soon to be attraction between them. My problem comes from how quickly things take a 180 turn. I also felt things just seemed unfinished as I read. I'm all for instalove but this wasn't it and I felt the thawing of the Ice Queen was more like throwing an ice cube in a bonfire.

I am bit torn on how to rate this book. First of all this is a debut novel and for a debut it is well written and easy to read with likable main characters. However, the book just seemed to move to fast in the relationship between Micki and Savannah, the mystery or crime in the book dragged a bit for me, and felt like other things were just not fully hashed out to the point that it was not worth mentioning at all. That seems like a lot of bad compared to the good but really the read was nice. It's not a 3 star by any means but not a 4 star either. I guess, for her debut, I would rate this about a 3.60 star. And I look forward to reading the next book Nicole Stiling releases.

***Got an ARC from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review *** (Thank you)
Was this review helpful?
Secrets in a Small Town by Nicole Stiling had everything to win me over (and it did!). Reminiscent of an SQ fanfic, this book combines three of my favourite things. An ice queen, the enemies-to-lovers and the ‘forced to live together’ tropes and it’s a suspense/thriller.

Savannah Castillo manages the small town that is Winter Valley. She has everything under control until she starts getting creepy messages and gifts from a secret admirer (read stalker). Refusing to get the Chief Police, Micki Blake, involved because of their mutual dislike for one another, Savannah soon realised that she’ll need Micki’s help to ensure her six-year-old Eliana’s safety when things escalate, and the stalker starts targeting her home.

As well as being well written, this book is funny. There’s an underlying humour that I personally really enjoy, and I found myself chuckling quite a bit throughout the book. The banter between the two main characters is great and there’s definitely great chemistry between them.

I usually like my romances to be slow-burn, but Savannah and Micki realize quite early on that they are attracted to each other and they just sort of go with it without the usual ‘they get together, they break up, and they get back together drama’. It was nice.

For me, this is more of a 4.5 star read, but because I was so emotionally invested in the characters, I’m rounding it up to 5 stars. I’m really surprised that this is Stiling’s debut novel, and I will definitely check out anything else the author will publish. I definitely recommend it :)

Thank you to Bold Strokes Books and NetGalley for providing me with a free copy of this title in exchange for an honest review.
Was this review helpful?
I read this book in one sitting, it was a very nice and enjoyable read, part romance, part mystery. The mystery part was actually quite scary at times but not overwhelmingly so. The romance was an enemies to lovers one, and I liked how the characters themselves were surprised by it, how fast and how easily it happened. 

I’m always amazed at the quality of some debut novels, and while this one is not perfect, it makes me look forward to the author’s next one. 

I received an ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
Was this review helpful?
Savannah Castillo, Town Manager and Micki Blake, Chief of Police of small town Winter Valley are polar opposites and butt heads whenever they cross paths.  When Savannah finds herself being stalked, Micki moves in with Savannah and becomes her live in bodyguard. Micki makes it her mission to find Savannah's stalker and as the case evolves their attraction to each other intensifies.
Initially, I found the interactions between Savannah and Micki somewhat immature as they seemed to go out of their way to purposely antagonise each other. I guess this was the premise to show their love/hate relationship but I just found it a bit annoying.  Having said that, the more I read, the more I liked the story and how well it was written. You were kept guessing til the end who the stalker was so this was nice little mystery romance. A very good first book from Nicole Stiling, she's definitely someone to watch out for.
Was this review helpful?
I wasn’t prepared to like this book but by the end of chapter 2 I was shocked and could not put the book down. This book centers around the main character Micki who is the chief of police in a small town. She rents a room from Rebecca,  Who works at the small elementary school in town and also does childcare for Elaina, the six-year-old daughter of the town manager name Savannah.  Micki and Savannah have an antagonistic relationship   Micki knows Savannah  thinks that she is inept and Micki  views Savannah as cold and demanding needing to be in control person. While  Micki  has an easy-going attitude Savannah is all about order and control.  When Savannah begins to get strange gifts delivered to her office her office assistant Chloe talks to Micki about it because Savannah will not bring the issue up to the police department, especially with Micki in charge however Micki decides that she will informally watches Savannah’s house to see if she can find anything amiss. When Savannah realizes she is parked outside of her house she goes out punches Micki  in the face and the man’s that she leave immediately.  Micki’s mission is to protect both Savannah and Elaina from any danger, how is this going to work when Savannah wants nothing to do with   Will Savannah  eventually realize that she does need police protection and if so how was that going to work?

Stiling  does such a beautiful job developing the characters of Savannah  and Micki that you realize you don’t want harm to come to either of them and there’s always the hope that Micki might be able to melt the ice queen that is Savannah. This is a wonderful read and I highly recommend this book .
Was this review helpful?
This was a great little romance/mystery that I plowed through quickly. I loved the dynamic between the two leads, Micki and Savannah. Of course, I'm a sucker for the uptight, sarcastic, prickly woman who keeps everyone at arm's length until THE ONE comes into the picture. 

The mystery part of the book was believable and sufficiently creepy. I waffled throughout on who the stalker was, so I think that was well done. I was on pins and needles waiting for the resolution.

I enjoyed the suspense, but I loooooooved the romance between the two woman. I was actually giddy in anticipation of the first kiss. The way it came was a surprise, but it ended up being quite satisfying. I closed the book with a happy sigh. Would definitely recommend.
Was this review helpful?
I wanted to like this book so much! The beginning grabbed me and I laughed a lot through the first several chapters so I thought I was in luck. I got over the fact that this  very, very likely was a Once Upon a Time fan fic - which I normally don't care for much unless the writing is really well done - and decided to just roll with it. After all, Micki and Savannah had great chemistry and banter and there was a cute kid and fun secondary characters. All the makings of a fun read. 

And then the police work started. 

I've been told many times - a few while reading this book and chatting about it with a friend - that I'm just too hard on f/f romance novels. And I probably am. But in my defense, if a main plot arc of a romance is solving a case and the main character solving it is a police officer - even in a rom/com - the police work should make sense and be somewhat believable. I didn't think that happened here.

I did like the author's voice and her humor so I would certainly try her next book. This one had too many rough edges for me to get into properly. 

Thanks to Bold Strokes Books and NetGalley for the chance to read an author I'd not heard of before!
Was this review helpful?
This book is a lesbian Lifetime movie. Kinda predictable who the stalker was. The characters went from hate to love from 0 to 60 seconds and the stalker thing was kind of far fetched how he managed all without being found out till the end.
Was this review helpful?
Secrets in a Small Town is a very good and enjoyable story set the typical American small town of the title. Savannah Castillo is a big fish who has voluntarily settled in her small pond to better raise her daughter. Mackenzie Blake - Micki - is the Deputy Chief of the same small town.
Personalities grind and sparks fly, but long-suffering Micki gets the bad end of the deal until suddenly, she doesn't.
Quickly the sparks of conflict become the fires of passion.
This is a great book, a nice mix of light thriller and romance, that I enjoyed reading a lot. Maybe those sparks become fires a bit too quickly but nevertheless a worthy 4 stars.
Was this review helpful?
I really enjoyed this debut book! 

Savannah Castillo has a lot on her plate as manager for an extremely tiny town. It is her way or the highway when it comes to town issues and she's constantly butting heads with the town's Deputy Chief Mackenzie Blake when it comes to their ideas about the town. But when Savannah begins to receive strange packages in the mail, she fears for both her safety and the safety of her daughter. She soon she realizes she's come to the point where she has to put aside her differences and let Mackenzie know about it so she can do her job. Mackenzie moves in with Savannah and her daughter. She is confident her previous PI experience will help her find out who is behind this mess, even with the town's limited resources. But as the two women grow closer and the lines begin to blur, Mackenzie fears she is only putting Savannah in more danger. 

I really liked both characters, they were a perfect mix of strength and vulnerability. You connect with both women from the beginning, and the story only adds to the readers connection to them and their connection to each other as it moves along. Their relationship moves quickly, but it's a natural pacing for who these characters are, and for their connection and history prior to the beginning of this story.  Even while differences remain, the two women complement each other and balance each other out. This was a very mature romance, very organic. 

The book as a whole and the mystery moves at a fast pace as well, but the author doesn't leave anything out. Every supporting character has a purpose, you're always engaged int his vibrant story. 

I'm looking forward to what comes next from this author! 

I received an ARC via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Was this review helpful?
3.5 Stars rounded up to 4 stars for this debut novel by Nicole Stiling.

Savannah Castillo, a town manager, is an ice queen extraordinaire who likes to be in control of everything and everyone around her. Her one soft spot is for her 7 year old daughter, Eliana. The Deputy Chief of Police, Mackenzie (Micki) Blake regularly clashes with Savannah as her requests for her office renovation to be finished and updates to the police equipment and cars are repeatedly denied by Savannah. (Question: why isn’t Micki the “Chief of Police” instead of Deputy since there is no one above her position?)

Savanna begins to receive anonymous love letters and gifts from an admirer that quickly escalates to stalker. When the stalker starts leaving messages inside of Savanna’s house, Micki moves in to protect Savanna and Eliana. Savanna and Micki’s relationship goes from adversaries to lovers very quickly. My preference is slow burn romances but I didn’t mind this fast burn (hot) romance.

One quibble I had is I felt there are standard police procedures that Micki could have done that would have aided in identifying the stalker quicker. I had in my mind who the stalker was, but alas I was wrong. A good mystery keeps you guessing.

I was wondering if this story was originally a Once Upon a Time (OUAT) fan fiction or inspired by OUAT. OUAT was a TV show with ice queen Regina, who was a mayor of a small town with a young son and Emma was the Chief of Police. They too regularly clash and resemble Savanna and Micki. No matter. I enjoy fanfic so I’m thrilled when a fanfic author becomes a successful published author.

This is an enjoyable debut novel and I’m looking forward to Stiling’s next book.

An ARC of this book was given to me by NetGalley for an honest review.
Was this review helpful?
Nicole Stiling’s debut novel Secrets in a Small Town is a dynamic romance meets mystery that keeps you on your toes yet smiling page to page. No worries with this one, you won’t be scared to turn out the lights but you will be enchanted and thoroughly entertained. 

Savannah Castillo is the town manager of a sleepy little community of fewer than 1,500 people. She picked this small town specifically because it was an ideal place to raise her daughter, Eliana. Savannah is 100% an ice queen. She lets no one, other than her little one, close to her. This control fanatic is disturbed by the sudden onslaught of mysterious gifts. They arrive at her office and home at all given times with no sender to be found. The gifts start increasing in frequency as well as becoming more and more threating. Savannah thinks she can handle this on her own until her assistant goes over her head and involves the one person Savannah wants to avoid more than anyone, the chief of police, Micki Blake.

Micki loves working in Winter Valley. She was worried when she left the hustle and bustle of the city she would be bored. Come to find out she likes the slow pace of small-town life. The only thorn in her side is that the town manager seems to loathe her for reasons she can’t quite grasp. Micki takes Savannah’s attitude in stride and throws it right back at her needling the uptight town manager whenever she gets the chance. You really can’t rule this lighthearted good-natured police chief. When Micki’s friend and Savannah’s executive assistant, Chloe, brings the gift situation to Micki’s attention, the chief is bound and determined to help her abrasive nemesis. 

Nicole Stiling can write a damn good book that is for sure. My mind is still boggled a bit that this is a debut novel. It really has a good flow, the plot is dynamic and the dialogue reads very natural. From the very first page, I was drawn to the story and the main characters. As caustic as Savannah was at times I still liked her and Micki is just a main you are immediately drawn to. There were enough twists and turns in who the stalker might be that I was guessing to the end. I will definitely be reading what Nicole Stiling has to offer next.
Was this review helpful?
Savannah Castillo is the town manager of a very very small town. She has a reputation of being an ice queen and she is ok with it. When she starts receiving unwanted gifts she is reluctant to ask for help from the town's Deputy Chief Mackenzie Blake until she can't ignored her stalker situation much longer without putting her and her daughter's life at risk. Savannah is not Mackenzie's favourite person but she is on a mission to find the person who is putting in danger the life of people in this quiet town where everyone knows each other. 

I really liked this book. It moved at a great pace, the characters were well described and well developed. I really liked both main characters and they had great chemistry. This was not a slow burn book but I was ok with it. It worked for this characters.

The mystery wasn't the strongest part of the book but it was still a fun well written book.

ARC provided from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Was this review helpful?
Great debut! This is a fast paced thriller with an enemies - to - friends style romance. When stern town manager Savannah Castillo finds out that she may have a stalker, she's reluctant to enlist Deputy Chief Mackenzie Blake's help. They're polar opposites and clash over everything except Savannah's daughter, who they both adore. When the stalker becomes more threatening, Mackenzie suggests that she becomes a temporary live-in bodyguard. Sparks end up flying as Mackenzie realizes how much she comes to enjoy Savannah's prickly smiles, and Savannah struggling to re-assert her sense of control. With the stalker circling ever closer, will the pair find out who they are?

I thoroughly enjoyed the characterizations here, especially with Savannah; you can see her need to control her environment, and how ruthless she is in making sure it happens, but not at the expense of the town she runs. It is fun to see a female politician like that, a total ice queen, but uber competent. There are a lot of layers to Savannah, like her wishing to be more spontaneous for her daughter, who has a completely different personality, but struggles with her innate introverted nature. Mackenzie is the type that leaves everything out there, except her deepest fears, which are touched on, but not until later in the book. I feel like Mackenzie is the most consistent character of our two leads, but that doesn't make her a lesser character. 

The stalking case is creepy, and does lend an air of mystery, leaving you to guess which of the suspects might they be. Savannah's reactions to the stalker's escalations were spot on. And it felt realistic; many stalkers find ways to invade the spaces of their victims in order to try to control them. Pairing that with Savannah's relentless need for control and Mackenzie's insistence to just be there and help just made everything more tense. I loved it. 

If there's any complaint, its that I wish it was maybe twenty or thirty pages longer, to allow the characters a little more time together and to develop. I think the author did a great job in not allowing the characters to be 'changed' or 'fixed' by finding each other. Savannah especially; she's mean and prickly, but has a huge heart that is very generous, and that doesn't need to change at all. We just get to see that side of her with her daughter and Micki.
Was this review helpful?
MacKenzie (Micki) Blake likes her job as Deputy Chief  very much. When she started her career she worked in slightly larger communities but there's something about working in a small town like Winter Valley that just seems to suit her. She leads a staff of three including herself and she would love to have a extra set of hands to at least help with all the paperwork. But that seems unlikely to happen anytime soon. 
     Winter Valley Town Manager  Savannah Castillo runs a tight ship and didn’t have any money in the budget to help Micki with her problem but then again even if she did she probably would find a reason to refuse the request. She loves what she does and really only seems to have room in her life for her young daughter Eliana.  Getting along with others isn’t very high on her list so when she starts receiving the attention from an stalker she surely doesn’t want help, especially from Micki.
    Ms Stiling does a good job of setting  up this story. Well paced with a nice little mystery she makes this book quite a enjoyable story. I look forward to reading more from this author. A very nice read.
ARC via NetGalley
Was this review helpful?
It’s hard to imagine this is a debut novel! I enjoyed this one a lot even though it had some minor glitches! But overall i definitely recommend it for anyone who wants to be entertained! 
For starters, both MCs were very interesting. I loved the banter between them and at certain points it was actually funny. There was very good chemistry between them, although I found the insta love a bit too much. But because the book is so smooth, I actually didn’t mind it in the overall storyline.
The mystery/stalker part was done nicely as well. Turns out my guess was wrong, so for that, an extra point goes to the author :)
Supporting characters were also quite interesting especially the daughter and the Chief’s roommate.. 
My rating is 3.75 rounded up to 4. I really did enjoy this one. 
Copy provided from netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
Was this review helpful?
Secrets in a Small Town by Nicole Stiling is a well-written story about two women who are thrown together because of a stalker. Savannah Castillo, the town manager of Winter Valley is a perfect ice queen character. She must always be in control of everything and everyone around her. The only person she is close to is her seven year old daughter Eliana. When Savannah begins to receive anonymous gifts and messages that gradually become more ominous and threatening, she is forced to ask for help from the one person in town that she really detests. Deputy Chief Mackenzie (Micki) Blake agrees to help Savannah even though the two can barely stand being in the same room together. The two are completely different and mix like oil and water, but they must learn to put that aside and work together to find the stalker before someone is hurt or worse.

This is a very enjoyable read. The characters are well-developed and the dynamics between the two are perfectly written. The pacing of the story is good and kept me interested from the first page to the last. While the reader is given lots of clues to who the stalker might be, the author kept me guessing almost until the last, and even threw in some twists that threw me off the scent for a while. I also loved the humor the author displays throughout the tale. She had my interest from the first sentence and had me chuckling by the second page. Humor helped to keep this book from being a totally scary and nail-biting tale, and made it something you could read and enjoy without having to keep all the lights on in the house.

I really enjoyed this book. I believe this is a debut novel for Ms. Stirling, and she did an excellent job. I will be looking for more from this author.
Was this review helpful?
A gentle, simple, reasonably enjoyable read.

The snark between the characters was enjoyable and funnily enough, one of the best parts of the book. The characters honestly didn't seem perfect for eachother so the very quick transition of their relationship was a bit of a stretch for me.
Was this review helpful?
This was an excellent debut from this new author. Secrets in a Small Town was engaging from the start and continued that way until the end. 

The two lead characters, Micki and Savannah, are at odds from the get-go. What seems like a small thing that Savannah blows out of proportion inserts a wedge between the two heads of the town, and develops into an antagonistic relationship. They interact because they have to, but Savannah will go out of her way to avoid Micki at all costs.

Happy go lucky Micki doesn't actively avoid Savannah, but if she has the chance to needle her, she'll take it. I loved the character of Micki in this book. She was funny and sweet and her ability to see through Savannah's bitchiness was really endearing.

The mystery was interesting and plausible. I thought I'd had the suspect pegged but from the halfway point, but oops, I was wrong. I loved the way the whole thing played out.

I do wish the novel was a bit longer, with more scenes between the two mains. But I thoroughly enjoyed this one and wouldn't hesitate to recommend it to anyone who enjoys romance, mystery, or a good combination of the two.

Thanks to Netgalley and BSB for providing me with an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
Was this review helpful?