Cover Image: Four Christmases and a Secret

Four Christmases and a Secret

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Zara Stoneley couldn’t write a bad book if she tried and this hugely talented rom-com queen is back with a hilarious, heart-warming and irresistible Christmas romance that will make you roar with laughter this holiday season: Four Christmases and a Secret.

Daisy and Ollie Cartwright have known each other since they were in nappies. As their mums were best friends who loved nothing more than indulging in a spot of one-upmanship as they competed in a game of whose offspring is the best, Daisy and Ollie grew up together and were forced to attend Uncle T’s inaugural Christmas party at his bookshop (even though he was a family friend and not an actual relation). Every year, without fail, Daisy would find a comfy chair in a quiet corner and lose herself in one of the books her uncle was selling in his shop. The year she turned eighteen, Daisy had been curled up with a Jilly Cooper and was falling madly in love with Rupert Campbell Black when Ollie had found her and kissed her underneath the mistletoe! It was a Christmas kiss that lasted seconds, but one which Daisy hasn’t quite managed to put behind her many years later…

Things have certainly changed in the intervening years for Ollie and Daisy. While Ollie graduated with honours, has a fantastic job and an ever-changing array of gorgeous girlfriends on his arm, Daisy hadn’t been so successful. Although she had big dreams as a teenager about conquering the world and becoming a successful professional, reality has proven to be quite different. She is in a relationship with a selfish and unreliable guy who is not so much Prince Charming, but a rat of the highest order and has had a succession of dead-end jobs which have all ended in disaster. Back home to spend Christmas with the family, the last thing Daisy is in the mood for is Uncle T’s Christmas party – especially as she knows that Ollie Cartwright will be there looking as successful and gorgeous as ever. Only Daisy hasn’t seen Ollie for a very long time and she has forgotten just how handsome he really is!

Daisy is determined to prove to Ollie that she isn’t the immature and flighty girl everyone makes her out to be, but a Responsible Adult who is about to prove everybody wrong. There will certainly be no stealthy mistletoes kisses with handsome Ollie either – even if he looks like he’s just stepped out of one of her deepest and darkest romantic fantasies! Daisy wants to play it cool and not let her head be turned by Olly’s good looks, however, when Uncle T makes a shocking announcement that threatens to change her entire life forever, it looks like Daisy has got more than an inconvenient attraction to her childhood friend to worry about.

Will Daisy manage to prove everyone wrong and show them just what she is capable of? Will she and Olly pick up where they left off that time they kissed under the mistletoe? Or is Daisy condemned to a lifetime of disappointment and broken dreams?

Four Christmases and a Secret is an irrepressible, feel-good and uplifting romantic read that is vintage Zara Stoneley. Full of hilarious one-liners, witty repartee, laugh out loud moments, poignant romance and gripping emotional drama, Four Christmases and a Secret features a delightful heroine who gives Becky Bloomwood a run for her money, a clever and sexy hero who will make you swoon and plenty of mischief, mayhem and festive hi-jinks to keep you glued to the book’s pages.

Zara Stoneley has written yet another exceptional romantic romp that I couldn’t stop reading and Four Christmases and a Secret is guaranteed to be another sure-fire hit for this very gifted writer!

Was this review helpful?

Lovely festive read. It was a heart warming romance. It was a wonderful book to read. It was well written and flowed well.

Was this review helpful?

After reading ‘Bridesmaids’ a few month ago I just had to be involved in Zara’s latest festive read. I devoured this beautiful story in just a few days, couldn’t even wait get back to it on the busy commute to work.

This is a story that will definitely get you into the festive spirit and focuses on Daisy, who’s finding her way in life with her work and of course her love life. She finds herself going to her Uncle Terence’s annual Christmas Eve party at his bookshop (love the bookshop element) Christmas jumper and antlers at the ready. She bumps into the lovely Ollie Cartwright who she hasn’t seen for a while however has heard all about his successful life from her mother.

As the title suggests the story involves secrets and they were some very unexpected twists and turns. This is the main reason why I just didn’t want to put it down I just had to know what happens with Daisy and Ollie. Uncle Terence is a prominent unique character who made the story even more interesting. I loved his personality.

I am a huge fan of Zara’s writing. The narrative flows so freely you can’t help but turn the pages quite quickly. She writes in so much detail, I would have loved to have visited Uncle Terence’s bookshop! 😊 ‘Four Christmases and a Secret’ is a heartwarming story about family, second chances and love ❤️ I give this beautifully written story 5*/5*

Thank you to One More Chapter for an advanced copy of this book via Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?

Wrapped in a beautiful festive cover, this Christmas book was nicely sold with an interesting blurb and the great promise of a “Bridget Jones” and “Hallmark Channel” colour to it. So, my expectations were really high and, sadly, plummeted just as quickly. Typically, I have no issue with first-person narratives, however, Daisy, the lead female character sounded very immature, and in this context it’s difficult to focus on someone else. Lots of “hahas” were thrown around in the text and dialogues, and this writing style can be off-putting and it quickly started to annoy me, on top of the heroine’s personality. Her stream of thoughts felt a bit all over the place at times. Add to that other caricatural protagonists (like Daisy’s mother), and well, I ended up feeling as though this book was definitely not for me.

It wasn’t my cup of tea, but it might be someone else’s. Thank you for the galley, but this is my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Every year Daisy has to face insufferable Ollie and hear all about how brilliant he is. Whereas Daisy has no job, no man and no idea how to fix things.When I started reading I couldn't put it down.Zara Stoneley is magnifysent and amazing writer.I cannot wait to read more of there books.Keep up the great work.You should definitely read this book.Can't wait for the next book.

Was this review helpful?

Before I start the review I just want to say I'm not a fan of books written in first person. The story was good but the flow was like trying to keep up with a fast talking teenager. I don't feel like I got to know any of the characters, I think because of that fast flow. I know some people like first person narrative and if you do you would probably like this book. I just couldn't get into it the way it deserves.

Was this review helpful?

An ok book but didn’t really enjoy it.
It seemed a little under developed to me and superficial.
I liked the writing style but it just didn’t capture me

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this book!!

I adore Christmas books and look forward to the time when they come out each year, and having enjoyed the book from Zara so much last year, I have been eagerly awaiting her Christmas release for 2019 and it is a fabulous read and was well worth the wait!

The characters were great, so well developed and they worked really well together. The author has a superb writing style and she had again brought this story to life for me. I was hooked from the first page and I thought that the ending was great.

It is 5 stars from me for this one, it is a fabulous festive read that is full of fun – very highly recommended and I thoroughly enjoyed it!!

Was this review helpful?

This book is the perfect feel good holiday read. You know how the story is going to end up, but enjoy the ride! I enjoy these heartfelt books during the holidays and this one was extremely well written.

Was this review helpful?

Another enjoyable escape read from Zara Stoneley that will make you laugh even as it pulls at your heart strings.

Daisy and Ollie grew up together, and their mothers are best friends/ worst competition type enemies. Every aspect of their lives has been compared and held up to judgement. Sort of like the boy/girl next door expectation, would they be best friends or would they marry?
Until the year each went off to university and their lives took very different paths.

A decade (plus) passes before Ollie and Daisy are in the same room together again, at a traditional holiday party hosted by Uncle T. I loved Uncle T. He is flamboyant and interesting, larger than life, has many ex-wives and a huge secret.
I also fell in love with Stanley. There was a moment when he (or his situation) broke my heart, and made me snuggle someone special close to me, but all in all, the experience had value. (Not giving anything away.)

Daisy has a flatmate, Frankie with her own wild and crazy and complicated love life.
I could see an exciting novella or two from her story or viewpoint.
Perhaps after another author gathering, additional ideas will be triggered.

Life after Uni did not turn out as Daisy planned, even with her list making. Christmas also seems to be an especially disastrous time of year for her. After discovering Ollie again, life took even more strange twists for Daisy. All is taken in stride, along with some snide bantering dialogue. Frankie stands by her side, when she is not off snogging or looking for someone to snog.

Will life ever straighten out for Dairy? Can she and Ollie find their way to being friends again or will it always be a competition? What happens to Stanley? Who discovers Uncle T's major secret?
So much to love in this feel good book!

Was this review helpful?

Don't let the rather cutesy cover fool you - this isn't a sweet, cute romance, although it does have elements of both. This is a laugh-out-loud, tongue-in-cheek rom com, with an MC with a totally wicked and dry sense of humour, who calls a spade a spade. Her mum is especially funny, and Stanley the dog has his moments, too.

BTW, I wish i had an uncle like Terence - he sounds wonderful and a right laugh, and he provides most of the more poignant moments in the story.

All in all, a jolly funny read.

Was this review helpful?

The perfect Christmas book to kick off the holiday reading season. Precisely the right amount of Christmas cheer to start getting you in the spirit. this really is a book you could read anytime of the year, so you don’t feel crazy that you’re reading it in September. Zara Stoneley has written another fabulous book full of fantastic characters and the perfect blend of romance and humor. I smiled, I swooned, and at one point I laughed so hard tears were coming down my face.

Daisy has lost everything, her job, her boyfriend, and maybe even her dog. This was not the life that Daisy or her mother had planned for her, and it is made even worse when she is constantly compared to childhood friend Mr. perfect Oliver. Then Daisy finds a new job (not necessarily the job of her dreams but a job nonetheless) and finds herself sharing an apartment with Ollie. This was a fun will they? won’t they? story. Ollie and daisy are lifelong family friends with a complicated and competitive past. Even though they ”snogged” A couple times in the past, neither of them are willing to admit to any kind of attraction. Thank goodness uncle Terrence is around with his mistletoe magic. This book was just so much fun! I especially love the annual Christmas parties complete with ugly holiday sweaters. And best of all the parties took place in uncle Terrance’s bookshop. Terrence was a character that made any time of the year festive! Daisy end Ollie were great and I loved watching their relationship develop, although at times I was quite frustrated with the two of them! Daisy was a character that I’d love to be friends with, and girl I’d support you much more than you know who. I’d also love an invite to one of those Christmas parties! The secrets in the story were surprising and added an additional layer to all the mischief and magic. This is a story that will appeal to all romcom lovers, even if you are a book Scrooge and don’t enjoy Christmas Reads!

This book in three emojis: 📚 🐶 💌

*** Big thanks to the publisher for my copy of this book ***

Was this review helpful?

Although Christmas parties do feature in this story, it isn't really a festive romance as such. Daisy is the main character in the story and it is great to see how she grows and matures through the story which spans more than a decade. Uncle Terrence is an absolutely brilliant character - he isn't really her Uncle but he has always had that role in her life. He runs a bookstore and hosts a party every Christmas for family and friends there.

Daisy has mixed feelings about the party as Uncle Terrence always hosts amazing parties but she hates the competition between her Mum and that of her peer, Oliver Cartwright. The two women always seem to try to out do each other boasting about the achievements of their offspring. That was fine whilst they were in school but now Daisy feels she's a failure with no prospects whilst he's now a Doctor..... They haven't met for thirteen years and last time they were together they kissed under the mistletoe and it was dynamite! Now he's back, successful, a hunk and with a model girlfriend. They've gone from friends to rivals and now have a chance to be friends again but will fate intervene again?

This is a story of self discovery, learning to care for yourself and just be the best version of yourself you can. The journey involves betrayal, secrets, discoveries and love. There are plenty of surprises en route, especially in the form of letters revealing emotions and more from the past. It is a funny, moving and emotive read, a story of family, friendship, supporting each other and learning to love your own aspirations and achievements. This is a lovely heartwarming romance with some fantastic characters. I enjoyed reading it and have no hesitation in recommending it.

I requested and was gifted a copy of this book via NetGalley and this is my honest review after choosing to read it.

Was this review helpful?

Could you get any more Christmassy than this book?? The title is a bit of a giveaway as to what time of year it is set in, but its one big festive feast from the very first page! It can however be read at any time of year and certainly isn’t limited to being read over the festive period! Daisy’s story is set over four different Christmases, but the main premise of the story is that Daisy is dumped just before Christmas and the only thing she has in her life is her adopted dog, Stanley and the thought of the annual Christmas family party at her Uncle Terence’s bookshop. When Ollie, an old family friend who Daisy last saw 13 years before, turns up at this year’s party Daisy realises how much he has done with his life whereas she has achieved nothing! Over the course of 4 different Christmases, we get to see how life is turning out for both Daisy and Ollie….

The book, for me, began a little bit slow but as it moved on the pace picked up and I became really involved in the characters stories! I loved Daisy’s character and thought she was fabulous! I loved the relationship between her and Ollie over all the years, and I just adore storylines where the main characters are best friends first! Their bantering and ‘arguing’ was so funny and I could have read about them forever!! Of course, all the other characters were great in their own way and each added something special to the storyline. And, we couldn’t forget to mention Stanley the Dog! He’s definitely a dog you’re going to love, but believe me Stanley won’t be the only character to melt your heart in this book!!

This was a full on Christmas read, with enough mulled wine and mistletoe to make me think we were on the run up to the big day and not at the end of September! The book was filled with lots of warm-hearted romance, friendship and family and it bought tears to my eyes as well as a smile to my face on more than one occasion! I would definitely recommend this book if you feel the need to get into the festive spirit, and even if you don’t, you still need to read it anyway!!

Was this review helpful?

Really wonderful christmas story. Full of charm, romance, great characters, and magic settings this book will get you in the mood to put your christmas tree up early, it did me anyway. Lovely story, i would really recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

💕In two minds: but the good outweighed the bad🎄
3 and a half 🌟 stars

Ultimately, I did fall for kind-hearted Daisy, her best bud Stanley, and the quiet and elusive Ollie, Daisy's childhood frenemy turned handsome, successful physician. But it really took until the latter half of the story and I felt it took an awfully long time to get to the good stuff. The background characters were well-defined, including the bad eggs, and Daisy's character matured a lot. But, and a big but, this story had its weaknesses and I was tempted to put it down unfinished on occasion.

Too many times I got frustrated with this story. First, it's all told from just heroine Daisy's point of view. This is not my favorite style as the author keeps me from really getting to know the mindset of the other main characters, like Ollie. A few heartfelt letters written by Uncle Terence did not mitigate my feeling that I was missing out by not understanding the other characters' motivations or what's happening in their lives when Daisy's not directly involved. Second, there is just way too much rehashing of Daisy's flights of fancy and uncertainty. I had to stop and release my frustration several times -- just get on with the story!!

But I was in it for the romance and finally, achingly slowly, the good, romantic plot took flight. Plus, I really enjoyed and was moved by bookshop owner Uncle Terence's poignant love story. What a bonus, but it was saved for the latter stages of the book. Had I not persevered through the lengthy ramblings in Daisy's head I would have missed out.

I would have liked to rate this story higher, because in toto it's a nice, positive, sweetly romantic story with small-town values and some holiday cheer, but the constant rambling introspection just did not do it for me.

Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for providing a complimentary advance copy of the book; this is my voluntary and honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC of this book to read through NetGalley in exchange for a fair review. Four Christmases And A Secret by Zara Stoneley is a funny and charming Christmas themed book reminiscent of Bridget Jones Diary and all your favourite British Rom Com films. Daisy Dunkerly is 31 and feeling that her life can be summed up with the phrase Must Try Harder. Ambitious and competitive as a child everything seemed to go wrong when she was 18, did poorly on her exams and her dreams of becoming a vet drifted away. Her childhood friend and nemesis Oliver Cartwright on the other hand has become a successful doctor and world traveler with beautiful girlfriends things that are drilled into her head by her mother and his, good friends who fiercely compete in bragging rights of their offspring. I enjoyed reading this story of how Daisy finds her way back to herself and finds love along the way making it a perfect book to curl up with after a busy day and just escape all the frustrations. Mild Steam. Publishing Date September 24, 2019 #NetGalley #FourChristmasesAndASecret #ZaraStoneley #HarperCollinsPublishers #HarperImpulseandKillerReads #OneMoreChapter #Bookstagram
#BritishRomCom #BritishChickLit

Was this review helpful?

The early scenes of this novel, set in an atmospheric bookshop oozing with Christmas magic instantly drew me in. As a bibliophile I find it hard to resist novels where bookshops play a significant role and the addition of Christmas makes this book a winning combination. I knew I was in for a treat.
Daisy was a likeable character treading water while everyone else is succeeding in their dreams especially her childhood best friend, Ollie.  I had sympathy for her as she is dragged into the competitive battle between her Mum and Ollie’s mother. Adult Oliver is the hunk who leaps of the page making me swoon when he appears in the chapters. The chemistry between the two characters, other memorable characters like Uncle T and the antics of her smelly dog, Stanley made this an entertaining, enjoyable festive read about self-discovery and learning to fly.
It made me chuckle, cry and made me get in to the Christmas mood. What more do you need in a festive rom-com?

Was this review helpful?

Four Christmases And A Secret is my first Christmas novel of the year and, so far, my favourite book from this author. I loved the plot, the characters, and, of course, the author’s recognizable brilliant and clear writing style.

The heroine is Daisy, a thirty-something girl who was supposed to have it all figured it out, but somehow it went all wrong. Daisy loves animals and when she was at school she dreamt of becoming a veterinary. However, something happened and she failed her exams. Now she works in the marketing department of the local newspaper, she rescues dogs, she shares a flat with an exuberant woman, and, to her mother great displeasure, she is still single. On the other hand, her arci-nemesis Ollie is a successful doctor with a beautiful girlfriend and, Christmas after Christmas, Daisy has to hear all about his achievements.

When it comes to romantic comedies, Zara Stoneley is one of my favourite authors. She knows how to make me laugh and keep me glued to the pages with her beautiful and entertaining stories. She creates characters that are likable, funny, and authentic. In Four Christmases And A Secret, there is Daisy who is hilarious and relatable, there is Ollie who is dreamy, uncle Terence, who is full of good advice, and, of course, we can’t forget Stanley, the adorable dog and my favourite character.

I loved the setting and the atmosphere. Christmas is my favourite time of the year and in this novel you can feel it page after page. Also, Daisy spends her Christmases in uncle Terence’s beautiful bookshop and what is better than that?

I know it’s still September, but, if like me, you are already thinking about Christmas, this engaging and refreshing novel will get you in the right mood!

Was this review helpful?

I didn’t read the blurb before saying yes to this tour! I love love love Zara Stoneley books.

This one follows Daisy and Ollie’s relationship. From a brief snog under some mistletoe through relationships or lack of. The highlight of the year is Uncle T’s Christmas parties.

I loved all the main characters except Tim and Frankie. I don’t know why I disliked Frankie, but she grated on me a bit. It seems that was justified towards the end, but no secrets now, you can all find out for yourselves.

Daisy did it for me, in the beginning she came across as a woman that couldn’t make up her mind. She was in one sense, an in-betweener, she was inbetween everything. Deciding on a job she loved, no relationships just a best friend and a dog she was fostering. But one Christmas she decides to change everything. By the end of the book, she was a very strong independent woman that knew exactly what she wanted and she had no hesitations in going for what she wanted.

This was a beautifully written book, with humour, sadness and you can smell Christmas flowing out the book, holly, spices, cinnamon, just Christmas in general. I loved it! Bring on the next!

Was this review helpful?