Skip to main content

Member Reviews

The ARC of this book was provided to me by the publisher via Netgalley in return for an honest review.

This book! This book guys I have no words for quite how much I loved it. It has all of my favourite things from queer rep to found family to witchcraft it feels like it was tailored with me in mind. This has just the right balance between the action packed plot and the cute romance which develops over the course of the book, with neither of them overpowering the other!

I cannot wait to get my hands of a finished physical copy of this in October and force it on everyone I know.

Was this review helpful?

This was the cutest thing I've read in a really long time. I loved all the characters and the diversity of them! There's a hard of hearing MC, a non-binary MC, and LGBTQ+ romance in it.

Thank you netgalley for letting me read this ahead of time and giving my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A young witch and a werewolf rediscover each other and their love for each other enables them to combat a common enemy.

I enjoyed reading this. The artwork is bright and blends in nicely with the supporting text. The story combines magic, adventure and love in a hopeful way and the main characters have a challenge before them which they respond to together.

The characters in the story are diverse which is refreshing and actually enhances the storytelling. Tam is a werewolf and Nova a witch and they were childhood friends. When Tam left their home town Nova tried to find them but she couldn't and she has missed her friend.

When Nova finds a white werewolf in the nearby forest she realises it is Tam, and all the feelings she once had return. Tam has never felt at home since leaving their hometown and they are grateful for the welcome given by Nova and her grandmothers, but there is darkness afoot and a demon on the loose. Nova, Tam and the grandmothers must work together to defeat this danger and the people behind it.

This is a lovely story, beautifully told with lovely artwork.

Copy provided via Netgalley in exchange for an unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

I don't read graphic novels often, but I'm so glad I gave this one a chance!
Firstly, the art style of this is insanely cute and gave me a whole lot of warm, fuzzy feelings. I was in awe of the obvious talent shown throughout the whole story. There was also so much diverse character design and each character looked like someone you could imagine passing in the street. You can tell that lots of readers will be able to find something of themselves in this comic.
The plot is another thing that gave me fuzzy feelings. For my personal taste, it had a perfect balance of romance, family life, and action. I adored the relationships that the characters had with each other. The romance was lovely to read and the relationships with family and friends were heartwarming and humorous.
Also, can I just say that the forest spirit animals in this book stole my heart. The amount of adorableness is unreal. I want them all as pets.
In all honesty, I genuinely cannot think of anything that I disliked about Mooncakes, so I'll definitely be wanting to get my hands on a physical copy when I can.

Was this review helpful?

Mooncakes is a cute and witchy graphic novel that follows main characters, Nova and Tam, as they work together to defeat evil in their hometown. It touches on a lot of themes of the hardships of growing up, actually finding home, and tough family dynamics.

The illustrations are gorgeous, the colors are vibrant and really evokes feelings of fall. They're whimsical and there are a few pages that I would love to hang up on my walls as posters. I can't wait to see the final physical product in October!

I found some of the dialogue quite juvenile, however, and there were a lot of aspects to the story that I felt were underdeveloped. The characters really liked to just not talk about things that they found were tough to talk about and that kept me from learning almost any backstory about who they really were. I would definitely like to see more stories within this world, though, as it was a very captivating story.

Was this review helpful?

This was so sweet! I loved the art style so much, I loved the main characters so much. It was beautiful and it was queer and I loved it with my entire heart, please pick this up when it comes out!

Was this review helpful?

I have seen this book around in the book blogging community, and I am also looking for more comics to read, so I decided to check it out for myself. This graphic novel is a cute ya book about magic, witches and werewolves, but it also had some great representation in it. Tam is a non-binary character who is Chinese-American and Nova is hard of hearing and also Chinese-American. Also Nova lives with her two grandmothers so that was cool to see. Everything is not made to be a big deal and normalizes everything so that made it so great to read about. There is one line where Tam corrects someone about using "they" pronouns and then that is the end of the conversation, so I loved that!

The romance in this one is pretty cute too. It's kind of a second chance...I would argue, but also a friends to lovers romance, and that is one I really enjoy. I also loved Nova's nanas who so knew what was going on and were totally there for it. I love those women!

The plot of this one deals a lot with magic, as Nova and her nanas are witches. I loved the world in this one where witches are doing witch jobs and it is a completely normal thing. Tam is a werewolf and there is something funny going on with them, but Nova and her family want to help them to figure it out. We find out who the big bad is in this one and it's so devastating to Tam. I really felt for them!

I liked that this one is a complete story, so it's not a graphic novel that I will have to try to remember about to read the rest of the story. I think there definitely could be another one about Tam and Nova's next adventures but I did like that this was a complete and digestible story in one sitting.

I really loved the color palette in the artwork on this one. It just gave it this soft and calming feel when I was reading each panel. I don't know if that's the right way to describe it, but that's how it made me feel.

If you are looking for a fun ya graphic novel about witches, magic and a little bit of first love, I definitely recommend this one.

*I received an eARC copy of this book via Netgalley and the publisher Lion Forge. I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley for an advanced reader copy of Mooncakes in exchange for an honest review.

I absolutely loved this graphic novel. This had everything I love:witchcraft, werewolves, romance, and tense family relationships. The story was great, characters were interesting, and I loved the art style!

Was this review helpful?

That was SO good and so awesome. The artwork in this is absolutely phenomenal.
I love the magic, the werewolves, the friendships, and the fact that this is so fantastical.
I loved the story line, too, it was captivating, compelling, and had me hooked from the first page.
I can't wait to get a physical copy of this to see what the finished artwork is like.
This is easily one of my favourite graphic novels of all time.

5/5 stars

Was this review helpful?

I just loved it. The sweet characters, the lovely relationships they have with each other and the magic make this a really good story.

Was this review helpful?

Such a cute story!!!!! And so important with F/NB relationship rep!!!!!!!! So much unconditional love in the relationships in this beautiful book.This would be perfect to read in autumn, the colors and story are just so perfect. :)

Review to come on my blog closer to publication.

Was this review helpful?

I'd have say, this graphic novel, gave me all the feels. From witchcraft to villians to a protagonist who is quite brave. I love the obvious connection between Nova and Tam. I'd recommend this to any one who loves a little magic and love in their life.

Was this review helpful?

This graphic novel was so sweet! That’s the best way to describe it; the art style, the characters, the story were all super sweet! We follow childhood best friends Tam and Nova as they reunite to rid their town of a demon. Tam is a non-binary werewolf and Nova is a hard-of-hearing queer (unlabelled) witch....and they maybe fall in love?! This is my first time reading about a HoH character in a young adult novel, and while I’m not able to personally comment on the accuracy, it appeared respectful. I will definitely recommend this graphic novel for anyone looking for a quick and easy read with important themes and diverse characters and stories, and I’ll definitely check out more from this author in the future!

For fans of Nimona, Lumberjanes and The Backstagers.

Was this review helpful?

This was SUCH a cute book! I've never read a book with a nonbinary, nonhuman character. I thought it was written well and was cohesive with the story. This book has a lot of good rep in it, and I adored the witchy, magical aspects of the story. I will definitely get a final copy when this is published!

Was this review helpful?

*I was given a copy of this via Net Galley for my honest review*

4.5 Stars

Oh. My. Goodness. This was the most adorable thing I have ever read! I absolutely adored the characters, the story, the rep...it was done so masterfully. My favorite characters, the grandmas, reminded me of my other favorite characters, the aunts from Practical Magic. They were so sweet and so progressive in trusting their granddaughter to make her own decisions and grow into the person she was meant to be with her love.

The only gripe that I have is that, even though it was incredibly progressive in using fluid pronouns, a girl/girl love, and hearing impairment, it sometimes felt really contrived, like the author was trying to convince you that this was OK. I love have the rep so prominent in the forefront of the story, but a mention was all I needed to be on board.

Other than that, I think this was a fantastic story and I cannot wait to see the finished copy because I NEED to see that final scene in color! I would highly recommend this to anyway who wanted a light-hearted Halloween read to breeze through in one sitting.

Was this review helpful?

Mooncakes was the cutest thing I’ve read in ages! And the artwork was fabulous. I loved Nova, Tam, and the Nanas. It was a fun, action packed read and I have a feeling I’ll pick it back up around Halloween because it's absolutely perfect for fall!

Was this review helpful?

This was such a sweet story with great diversity and representation from family dynamics, to disabilities to sexual & gender orientation. The story was cute, spooky and everything in between. My only wish was that we could be given more backstory into Tam and Nova relationship as children, I think it would have added a depth to the narrative. I loved the art style and coloring and can't wait to see the full graphic novel when it comes out.

Was this review helpful?

This was so sweet and I really enjoyed it. It was diverse, cute and a fun read. I highly recommend checking it out when it comes out in October.

Was this review helpful?

I've been trying to read more graphic novels for work, so I can know what themes are present in certain series, what different authors usually focus on, etc. And I've been astonished by the last few I've picked up just for the amount of diversity in these stories! There have been deaf characters, queer characters, racially diverse characters, and so much so that I can't remember the last straight white character that was a main protagonist in one of these graphic novels.

This book delighted me. The hints of magic and love between the families makes my heart warm. I was dancing on my toes when I learned that one of the characters was transgender and that it wasn't the only part of their plot!

The plot had a nice arc, leaving it open ended for more adventures, but with closure for the characters so that you're not left at a cliffhanger.

I loved this so much.

Was this review helpful?

Stunning art, magic, and heartwarming romance. What else could a girl ask for?

Many authors have explored the idea of a romance between a witch and a werewolf, but Suzanne Walker and Wendy Xu bring something to the table that I haven't read before. They bring this romance to the LGBTQIA+ community by introducing readers to a nonbinary werewolf, Tam, and a witch, Nova, who Suzanne describes as queer. They are childhood friends that are separated and find each other again due to some complicated circumstances, which allows for them to really connect with each other romantically.

Along side the romance, is also a story line filled with betrayal and self discovery. The surprises along the way and the occasional suspense made me want to read as fast as I could to see what was going to happen next.

I can not get over how much diversity exists in this graphic novel, in a good way. Beyond the LGBTQIA+ aspect, the level of diversity is even more expansive. Nova has a hearing impairment that requires hearing aids and Tam is Chinese American. The family structures that are represented are also very diverse. Nova lives with her two grandmothers and Tam reveals that their parents are no longer together.

In a world that seems to be crying out for greater representation of marginalized groups, this graphic novel delivers just that. I would recommend this graphic novel to lovers of magic, fantasy, romance, or are just craving something different.

Was this review helpful?