Cover Image: Mooncakes

Mooncakes

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

This was so precious and everything i wanted in a graphic novel!

The overall tone was atmospheric and made me beyond excited for the upcoming fall months in New England. The subject matter was also right up my alley and the magic system was very similar to that of the Harry Potter series which I really enjoyed. Oh and the romance was ADORABLE.

I can't wait to get my hands on a final copy in October to see the finalized artwork! Also crossing my fingers that we'll get a sequel in the future since it finished on an open-ended note.

Was this review helpful?

Mooncakes is a simple, magical tale that can entrance anyone looking for a short, whimsical story. The art style wasn't too complex, but it stood as cute. The plot wasn't very deep, but deep enough for a complete graphic novel, though I do wish that the story was a bit more complex, bringing more to the plot. However, as far as completion goes, I'd say this story does its job. The characters, in my opinion, could've been more rounded out, but I get the feeling that the book was going for flatter characters so that those characters would have room to grow and fill out in terms of relationships and personal growth.
In the end, Mooncakes is a tale that I could enjoy with a nice pumpkin spice latte in the cool of October.

Was this review helpful?

This is a beautifully illustrated queer fantastical graphic novel. The representation in this graphic novel is fantastic with a queer disabled main character and the other main character identifies as non-binary. The supernatural story is weaved in wonderfully with the exploration of the relationships and development of the characters. This was outside of my normal comfort zone but I truly enjoyed it and can't wait to re-read it again when the final product is released.

Was this review helpful?

AAAARTHHGJBITNDIVBDHGGGHHHHH

This was so pure and sweet and I just want to curl up an die while being surrounded by this amazing (and very much queer) story.

THE REPRESENTATION
I repeat: THE REPRESENTATION
I feel so proud, almost like a mother watching her child take their first steps. This is everything I’ve always wanted and so much more. I will never be over how much I love this

Was this review helpful?

This was a really cute, enjoyable read! I loved the witchcraft and the importance of family. Tam and Nova were really cute. The only problem I had was that I felt like the dialogue was jumpy in certain scenes and everything was wrapped up too quickly. It was kind of awkward to read and felt forced. However, the illustrations were really cute and I still think it's an enjoyable read!

Was this review helpful?

A cute graphic novel about a werewolf and a witch set in a sleepy New England town. Personally, I was more invested in the characters than the plot but I enjoyed it nevertheless. Nova and Tam's relationship was sweet- I'm hoping for a sequel because I'd love to see these characters more as well as Tatyana because she was pretty great. Overall, a fun read with neat illustrations, magical charms, and autumn vibes that gave me cravings for pumpkin spice lattes in the middle of summer!

*Thank you to NetGalley and Lion Forge Publishers for providing a free ARC

Was this review helpful?

ARC provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

This is absolutely adorable. The art style is incredible and definitely pulled me in. Mooncakes had me smiling from start to finish.

This to me was such a pure and sweet story that can't help but pull you in. I really hope this is the start of a series and we get to see the relationship between Tam and Nova develop further throughout each one. This very much feels like the start of something amazing! I would honestly recommend this to anyone that is interested in the synopsis, you won't be disappointed.

Was this review helpful?

Mooncakes is the story of a witch and a werewolf, Nova and Tam. Tam has been gone for years but when they come back, they find Nova pretty fast and confide in her. They're being hunted fro their wolf magic. Nova and her grandmas take Tam under their wings.

I really liked this. The story was interesting and pretty well paced, the characters had depth and so did their relationships. I just felt like something was missing. I guess it could have been a bit longer and add some suspense both in the main plot but also in the relationship plots... I don't know. I would love a sequel though, I would love to see these characters more.

Was this review helpful?

What a beautiful little story!

I had different expectations when first going into it. I expected the usual kind of heavy action and plot that goes into similar premised books such as this -- and Mooncakes didn't have that. While that is the reason it took me a little bit into the book, once I understood the tone and what I could expect, I was happily surprised.

Mooncakes is less of a thrilling book to read and more of a soft and cozy story that romanticizes the slice of life kind of thing (with some supernatural elements thrown in for good measure!)

It was a sweet, romantic read with LGBT+ leads, a supportive family for Nova (our protagonist), and an art style this is cute and a little whimsical.

The only drawback that I had from this, was the climax of the main plot. It felt a little gimmicky and shallow, but not enough that it look away from the story.

I definitely recommend this if you're looking for something cozy and sweet!

Was this review helpful?

Nova is a teenage witch working with her grandmas at their bookshop. Tam, her child-hood best friend (and maybe a little more than that), come back to their old town, needing help against dark forces that are pursuing them. I KNOW : this is the graphic novel you didn't know you needed. And you will probably fall in love with it as I did.
You cannot not love this graphic novel. First of all, let's talk about the obvious : the art. Wendy Xu's art is all I love : from the sweet, soft lines to the gorgious color palette, the comic boards are immensly aesthetically pleasing and just beautiful. Overwhelming, but in a good way. I wanna use them as wallpaper for my room.
The storyline and drawings carry a cute, witchy ambiance that I love. We have magic, witchcraft, and a spark of romance, all surrounded by books. I mean, that's all i ever asked for.
Of course, the strengh of the book is its characters. It can be hard to develop complex characters when the authours also want to develop an action-packed storyline. Well, Suzanne Walker and Wendy Xu did it. The grandmas are simply iconic, Nova is absolutly sweet and inspiring, Tam is touching and Tatyana is hilarious. I want to be best friend with all of them and participate in their adventures.
The storylines itself is not outstanding but still is good enough and satisfying. There are some plot twits that really had me SHOOK - even though one seemed pretty obvious.
The only thing I could hold against the novel is the pacing. It was maybe a little too quick. Although that can be just me, wanting the story to last longer.

(Rating : 4.5/5)

Was this review helpful?

YAAAAS! I was so excited to read this! Two Asian-American protagonists, both queer, one is non-binary and the other has a hearing disability, one is a witch, the other a werewolf - I AM HERE FOR IT! If all of that is not enough to make you fall in love with this story, what about a beautiful coloring and artwork? Or lesbian grandmothers? Magical forest creatures? Tons of magic?

Mooncakes was a really entertaining and lovely story to read. I had heard of Wendy Xu's fiction work (small self-promo in one of the scenes was great!) but hadn't had a chance to pick it up so far. I'll definitely look it up now and look forward to both authors future works.

Was this review helpful?

This was an amazing graphic novel that had a lot of magic and diverse characters. I loved the artwork, the story, and heart behind it. The main character, Nova, is a witch living with her grandmothers. One night, Tam, her long lost love, comes back into her life. Tam is a werewolf and have encountered a demon in the woods. Together, Nova and Tam try to defeat the demon while making up for lost time together. I fell in love with both of the characters and loved how well rounded and fleshed out they were. I highly recommend this for anyone fans fantasy graphic novels.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars.

My gosh, this is the purest most wholesome thing I have read in a very long time. Every character is fantastic — from kindhearted Nova to resilient Tam to the badass and supportive nanas — and the plot is engaging if slightly predictable. I adored the rep, the art, the soft interpersonal relationships; all the diversity and magic was so wonderfully matter-of-fact, which I loved. Seriously, every little detail of this is delightful.

Was this review helpful?

Adorable characters and a great graphic novel! I really enjoyed the humor and the magic. The story was very well developed to be so short and has me excited about more! Magically fabulous!

Was this review helpful?

I really liked this story. It was very sweet and Nova & Tam were adorable. I really like them both and thought their relationship was so cute. I really loved the magic in this book.The illustrations were gorgeous and everything from the villain to the story was interesting. It reminded me a lot of the show Sabrina the Teenage Witch.. It is the perfect book to read this fall!

Was this review helpful?

I normally don't review graphic novels on here, but I had an ARC of Mooncakes and it's so cute.  This will be pretty short though.



There is a lot to love in this graphic novel.  The artwork and colors were nice and kind of cute.  Nova uses a hearing aide and lives with her two grandmas.  They run a book store and they're all witches.  Her parents died, but they have visited as ghosts.



Tam is a wolf and is nonbinary.  They recently came back to town after being away for awhile.  Tam and Nova were best friends and know each other's secrets.  A demon horse shows up and everyone needs to work together to try to banish it.  



There are cute little creatures and a friend to romance relationship that was adorable.  Tatyana is Nova's best friend and I really liked her, too.



I gave this 5 stars.  Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for my copy for review.

Was this review helpful?

In my quest to read 75 graphic novels in 2019, I picked up Mooncakes by Suzanne Walker and Wendy Xu. It's queer, it's got magic, and I was pretty sold right away. I read an ARC from NetGalley that didn't have all the pages colored, but I still enjoyed it!

Nova's a witch and she lives with her two witch grandmas who run a witch bookstore and it's a whole thing. Great, right. Then, Nova's former best friend, Tam, comes back to town and they (non-binary) are also a werewolf. You follow? Tam's back in town dealing with a demon possession and it'll take Nova, Tam, two grandmas and a lot of magic to handle the issue, ultimately save a life, and take down a cult. There's a quickly-picked-up romance between Nova and Tam, some magical creatures, parents who are out of this world, and some great nature illustrations. I highly recommend it!

Was this review helpful?

Mooncakes follows Nova, a witch, and Tam, a non-binary werewolf. They are childhood friends who are reunited early in the story, and have to solve a dark mystery in the woods near town. The illustrations were charming and the world was adorable, but the worldbuilding is scant and a lot of the more whimsical parts (a magical bookstore, a gated forest filled with friendly animal spirits, ghost parents) were skimmed over. The story might have been strengthened by more time exploring how magic works and letting the reader spend a few more pages in some of the more magical elements of this world. The protagonists are delightful and easy to get attached to - though some of the insta-love scenes were cringeworthy - but the villains are caricatures at best and their motivations (and the conflict as a whole) are poorly explained. Overall, Mooncakes is a fun, short read with great representation, but could be improved by more time spent in the world to flesh out the magical elements and the conflict.

Was this review helpful?

Very cute graphic novel about a nonbinary werewolf and a queer witch who's hard-of-hearing! Both of them are chinese-american and not so sure about their place in life.

I loved the foreword and I appreciate that the authors took the time to write it! It's a wonderful introduction to the story and I recommend not to skip it!

The art style was lovely, and while there were several frames I adored, there were others that seemed a bit skewed to me. As I read an ARC, some changes might still be done for the final copy.

One highlight of the book was definitely Nova's family! Her grandmothers were wonderful, and her cousin Terry was a fun addition.

The story was simple but effective and lovingly told, and I enjoyed myself reading it.

Content warnings include: body horror, kidnapping, cultist rituals.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this graphic novel. It was inclusive without being pushy. It was creative and heartwarming. It was a good read about friendship and how important it is.

Was this review helpful?