This is definitely surreal, as advertised. If... is a collection of fanciful artwork that invites readers to imagine outlandish possibilities. Each picture is preceded by a simple "if" statement. The reader is then left to look at the picture and elaborate on the imaginative possibilities.

Some of the pictures are just a little too weird (If toes were teeth... kind of grossed me out), but many really do make the reader think. This could be a great book in a classroom setting if used as a catalyst for creative writing projects. The illustrations--subject matter aside--are all well done.

I think I probably would recommend this one, especially to creative readers who are looking for jumping-off points for their own stories.

Ever wondered what's inside a child's mind? It's this book. A child thinks of flying cats, of mountains as dogs, and the moon as a square. It's a wonderful journey into imagination and the possibilities of the human mind. Based solely on that, it does it's purpose admirably. However, some things were just out of place. Some were creepy, I mean toes instead of teeth? However, many inspired me into thinking about more things like this, which is what this book was trying to do. The anniversary edition includes two more stories. I'm looking forward for more books like this one.

*Disclaimer: I received this book for free from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

This is an adorable picture book that explores the idea of imagination in a short and snappy way, accompanied by beautiful illustrations.

My only issue with this book is that it is difficult to ascertain the age group that this is aimed at. The illustration style appeals to me as an adult but I'm not sure that it would appeal to most children, particularly those who are younger.

Overall I enjoyed this book and I think I would buy a copy for my son in the future, but I don't think it will be for everyone.

3 out of 5 stars!