Skip to main content

Member Reviews

The Girl with the Whispering Shadow is the second book in this series by D.E. Night. I enjoyed the first book a lot and couldn't wait to read through this one.

Ivy Lovely discovers she is the fulfillment of the Moonsday promise, and within no time at all, she is taken away to a secret town reserved only for those with magical blood. We pick up exactly where she left off in the first book as she's in search of the Kindred Stone. As with the first book, I loved the way the author depicted this magical world. It was similar to Hogwarts in some ways, but in other ways it was so unique. The descriptions of everything from the characters, the plants, the town and everything in between was done very well - I felt as if I was experiencing everything myself.

Ivy is the perfect main character and wonderful in so many ways, she is the definition of what you want in a heroine. It was a book that I managed to read through quickly and I wasn't able to put it down after getting into the first few chapters. I really enjoyed this book.

I give this book 4 out of 5 stars for it's originality and captivating storyline.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an e-book to review!

I was hooked on the first book and the second one pulled me in even more. I loved the new character additions and I really thought they helped to further the plot. Ivy is still a great protagonist and I enjoy seeing her friendships and relationships grow. Evil was still lurking in this book and I need to read book three. the plot, details, magic system and setting are all enjoyable and I really think the series is developed so well. It was a quick read and I still can't believe I'm only reading this trilogy now. I also would love more of Fyn's perspective and I hope even though he was older and graduated he'll be a present character in the third installment. Rebecca is also important and I love how far her and Ivy have come and will continue to grow. Great series so far and I'm glad book two didn't hit the dreaded sequel slump.

Was this review helpful?

I am writing on behalf of my daughter, who is 11 years old. She has an IG account (@paige.s.reading), and thanks to Stories Untold Press, she received a free e-book in exchange for an honest review.

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ , she loved it and wants to keep reading the whole series.

Plot: Ivy Lovely is an orphan living in Castle Plum as a Scauldron dragon maid. One day she is kicked out of the castle with her Scauldron. They wind up in the Halls of Ivy, a magic school. Ivy is curious about an empty journal that she found at the school, but she is forbidden to read it. Will she find out the truth behind the journal?

Feelings: I was curious and Anxious at the end of the book because I am afraid that Ivy might get in trouble, and I want to know what happens next! It is written with magic and mystery; that’s what kept me reading the book. It also reminds me of Harry Potter.

Fun Facts: This is my second book on kindle (on my Ipad). I enjoyed reading an ebook for a change. It also has an electronic bookmark.

Recommendations: I highly recommend this book if you like fantasy or magical worlds or Harry potter.

Was this review helpful?

I’m really glad I decided to pick up the second book since the first book was just so-so for me!

Once I stopped comparing it to another fantasy/magical/wizardry book, I enjoyed it much more! As with the first one, I enjoyed the world building (I’m need to fantasy, so the middle grade style is PERFECT) for me! While the book did seem to drag at times, I enjoyed it so much more than the first book! I will definitely be finishing the trilogy!

Was this review helpful?

The second book lives up to my hopes. It tides over in many ways the first book.
Ivy is the last heir to the throne and the only one with royal blood. That explains why the Dark Queen wants to destroy Ivy.
I do not want to write more about the content. Because I am afraid that I mistakenly spoiler something.
The world-building and magic are as awesome as in the first book. I extremely enjoyed all of it. In this book we visit more places in the world, we meet old and new characters in the book. D. E. Nicht improves the old ones and I adore all of them.
I recommend this series to all who like HP, Keeper of Lost Cities, or who are a fan of middle grade/ fantasy.
Thank you to Stories Untold for provided me the copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and D.E Night for this free copy in exchange for an honest review.

Only hours after Ivy Lovely discovers that she is the fulfilment of the Moonsday promise, she is whisked away from her beloved school to Belzebuthe, a secret town for only those with magical blood.

Ivy sets out on a mission to uncover the second facet of the Kindred Stone while eluding the Dark Queen’s wrath. But even when she’s supposed to be safe, something is shadowing Ivy. She will need all her natural-born magic and more as she battles to find the rest of the Kindred Stone and return to the Halls of Ivy.



After reading the first book, I thought this was a good series but nothing special. Second books in a series tend to be worse than the first, however, this one is the complete opposite. I really enjoyed this book and the magical world is written in a way which is so vivid to imagine.

The characters are loveable - in the first book, I wanted more development of them individually and in their friendship, and this book does exactly that. Not only are they developed but expanded and a found family is formed. The relationship between Ivy and Fyn is adorable and I hope he sticks around in book three, after graduating.

There are books that are so good that when you finish them, you end up in a slump. Then there are those which make you realise why you fell in love with reading, and are excited to read more, no matter what genre or type of book. And this is one of those gems.

I can’t wait to read book three!

Was this review helpful?

The Girl with the Whispering Shadow
(The Crowns of Croswald #2)
by D.E. Night

I received a complimentary copy and am voluntarily leaving a review.

A magical story beginning basically where the first one left us with the experiences of the Masquerade Ball still a vivid recollection in everyone’s mind, which is only to be expected. Who could forget that?
A mysterious girl who can’t claim rest from sleep, a wet ball gown from a ball she can’t recall attending... has the Dark Queen managed to penetrate the unseen protection of Belzebuthe? Would life ever be the same in Croswald?

Ivy Lovely is again the centre of attention in this second book by D.E. Night. With the fear that the Halls of Ivy will no longer be safe, what alternatives remain available to her? This is the second book in The Crowns of Croswald series, that stands out and shines all by itself. It continues the story perfectly but is also possible to read as a standalone without the confusion that ordinarily follows jumping in at a book two. I would recommend reading the first book nevertheless, as there is considerable detail to discover concerning Ivy’s background and it is again an exceptional read in general. We return to face the characters that charmed us in Book One, Humboldt the Scaldron, for example, plus we meet fresh ones along the way.
The author depicts beautiful imagery, evoking scenes that would fit perfectly on screen, in a movie or series. The descriptions are eloquently written, making it so obvious to envision each place or situation as the adventure unfolds. D. E Night has a fabulous narrative that enthralled me from book one; I was far from disappointed, fixed even further on the personalities and the world that surrounds them.

The Girl with the Whispering Shadow is full of vivid characters and detailed events that delight from start to finish. With an intense storyline that captures you from the beginning, mystery and intrigue, the ominous threat of the Dark Queen continuing to torment, a possible budding romance... all squashed between the pages and bound together with potions and spells.
Thank you to D.E.Night and NetGalley for allowing me to discover this amazing world.
I am a huge fan and can’t wait for more!

I rate The Girl with the Whispering Shadow 5 out of 5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

I'll star by saying that I liked this book a lot more than the first, but that's expected since we already know our characters and setting . The story develops at a good pace and the action was entertaining. The characters developed naturally and the magic aspects keep growing. I liked the inclusion of new friends for Ivy and the expanding of the world of Croswald. We get the resolution to one mystery but we get more to keep us hooked. I'm looking forward to read the third one and know how this ends!

Was this review helpful?

After reading the first book in this series earlier this year, when I was given the opportunity to read the sequel, I couldn’t pass it up. The first book reminded me a lot of Harry Potter, in a good way, and the sequel built upon that but also felt very unique.

The Girl with the Whispering Shadow picks up from where the first book ends, so this review will have spoilers for the first book. After the events of the end of year ball, Ivy has been told not to return to the Halls of Ivy next year, and Winsome has sent her on a hunt for the other parts of the Kindred Stone. Her journey takes her to the Town, which only residents know the true name of. There she is reunited with Fyn and meets lots of new people and friends, and discovers a new game called Quogo.

‘Every book in here is a fantasy, and they consider fantasies to be just the same as lies.’

I really love the friendship in these books and I always forget that the characters are older than I think. The author tells an addictive story of magic and friendship and I couldn’t stop reading. Fyn and Ivy have such a good relationship and I really enjoyed reading more about them in this book. Also, Rebecca and the new characters introduced were interesting and provided moments of tension at points. This is such a fun read and I loved it even more than the first book! Despite being children’s fiction, this book and this series are definitely for all ages.

Throughout the course of this book, Ivy is constantly learning about herself and magic and growing into a great character, whilst the threat of the Dark Queen is constantly looming. If you love Harry Potter and books about magic schools with magical creatures and games, then this one is definitely for you!

Was this review helpful?

Rating: ★ ★ ★ ★.5

The Girl with the Whispering Shadow is the second installment in The Crowns of Crosswald series.

I love the way Ivy’s personality developed from a shy, clumsy girl to a determined and matured one. Though she had doubted herself a couple of times, her persistence and willingness to become better made me admire her. I love how the author conjured the secret town, Belzebuthe. Though some of the events were predictable, the concepts in this book were unique and magical. The idea of Quogo and Invisitaurs were is fantastic, but my most favorite one is where one could make a wish upon a moondust star and be able to grant someone’s wish by fishing a star as well.

Moreover, I became ecstatic that when I got to know more about Fyn Greeley’s background story and personal life which made me ship him and Ivy even more. I also like how Fyn had Ivy’s back every time she went on a dangerous adventure, solidifying themselves as partners in crime. Ivy and Rebecca’s inseparable friendship, as always, makes me smile. I am glad that Ivy has Rebecca and Fyn in her life. Though there is not much information about the new characters, I still enjoyed their presence in the book, especially with Gliste and his outgoing personality.

Overall, I enjoyed this light and fun book. The plot, characters, dialogues, setting, vivid imagery, and concepts are very whimsical. The twist towards the ending about star solo is nicely done. I hope I will be able to read the third book because I am hooked onto this series.

Was this review helpful?

'The Girl with the Whispering Shadow': 4 ⭐

(Unpaid review: thank you to @denight, @netgalley and @storiesuntold for allowing me to read this eArc).

I've read the first book of this series last year. It was thrilling, yet soft and sweet. This one, however, was intense and mysterious, just how we like it!
The protagonist was stronger and more determined, which made me love the book even more! I absolutely love everything about this world and more people should read this series, as it is the perfect match between Harry Potter and Percy Jackson!

Was this review helpful?

*Disclaimer: I was kindly gifted an electronic copy of this book by Stories Untold via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Enter a world full of magic and mystery in the second book of The Crowns of Croswald series by D.E. Night. The Girl with the Whispering Shadow starts where Ivy Lovely leaves the Halls of Ivy to go to a mysterious town called Belzebuthe, this is the only place where she is hidden away from the Dark Queen. No one can find this town unless they know the name.
School has come to an end and Ivy has to find the second missing segment of the Kindred Stone in order to defeat the Dark Queen and her time is running out. Ivy is supposed to be safe in Belzebuthe but unexplainable things are happening which can just mean the Dark Queen is behind it. In the streets there are whispers of the Dark Queen and fear is seeping into the residents after a break-in in the Quill Keep.

Apart from her mission to find the missing piece of the Kindred Stone, Ivy makes new friends while staying with Fyn and his mother, even celebrating his birthday and spending time together fishing for stars on the roof. Wait until you get to this part, it gives new meaning to ‘wish upon a star’.
I enjoyed the part where Fyn takes Ivy to her first Quogo match. Quogo is a duel between quills and their previous owners and the magic that takes place is exhilarating.

The town of Belzebuthe is quite intriguing with all of the different shops and their unique names. One being Quinton’s Brews & Hodgepodge where Ivy gets a part-time job when summer is over and Fyn is back at the Halls of Ivy.
After getting a letter from the Selector inviting Ivy back to school, the Selector is shocked when she sees Ivy in the halls. After explaining she never sent the letter, anxiety starts to creep in. If the Selector never sent that letter, who did? Is the Dark Queen luring Ivy into a trap?

To be honest, I liked the first book more. The second book is enjoyable and the characters are fun and magical, but the first book had my attention from the beginning. In the second book, Ivy embraces her magic and her identity and there are interesting scenes involving the Dark Queen.
The world-building is wonderful and all of the details makes it come to life and the reader is whisked away to a world with duelling quills, spells, magical stones, missing creatures and fishing for stars.

Was this review helpful?

The plot in this book was very adventurous and full, which is how I think a fantasy book should be like. I really enjoyed learning more about Ivy, Belezebuthe and the Crowns of Croswald world in general. This wasn’t too heavy on the fantasy world and still kept the aspects of day-to-day life, which I really like. The writing was amazing as well and the characters were unique. I totally recommend this book series for fantasy and YA readers, you won’t regret reading it.

Was this review helpful?

I think I loved this one more than the first. I think that is because there was more action in it. But regardless I am loving this series a lot and cant wait to get a hold of the 3rd book. I also wonder when the 4th book will be released. But before I go I have to say Ivy, Fyn, Rebecca and Professor Night (D. E. N.) are my favorites and that I really dislike the Dark Queen alot. I also want to get the books in physical form cause I believe I will want to reread them in the future. Also look out for my June Wrap up coming to my channel very soon.

Was this review helpful?

I'm still a bit lost but I can honestly say I like this better than the first book! One of the things that I love about his book is that there's young love but not the explicit kind that is so common, nowadays. Readers who like discovering new magical worlds will enjoying this book series!

Was this review helpful?

The Crowns of Crosswold is a series that any YA Fantasy reader can get lost in. The second book doesn't disappoint.

Was this review helpful?

After Ivy's first year at her new magical school, she stays for the summer with friends in The Town - really named Belzebuthe but hidden by magic from the Dark Queen so people can practice magic freely. She's told that it's not safe for her to return to school after the Dark Queen's attack on last year's ball, but it doesn't seem that she's any safer in The Town.

Another quick and quirky middle-grade fantasy - it was great to get a more expansive look at the world of Ivy & Croswald - we see the world outside of school, meet more magical creatures, and see more of life, careers, and hobbies.

My main hangup with this second book is that there seem to be more and more very obvious parallels to the Harry Potter world - a secret student club, a possessed student, visiting memories with a teacher, invisible creatures, and a secret room of long-lost and forgotten items.

Thank you to Stories Untold Press and the author for the chance to read this book in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Thankyou to netgalley and the publisher for allowing me a copy of this book. I enjoyed the first book and i hoped this would live up to my expectations and i have to say i enjoyed it more than the first installment, The world building is amazing and i loved the character development, The atmosphere was great and it was an emotional rollercoaster. such a magical world.

Was this review helpful?

This is the second installment in the series and it was just as good as the first.

D. E. Night has expanded the world as we saw it in book 1 and the magical systems as well. We start where the last book left off. Ivy Lovely is leaving school and has returned to The Town that now one remembers with a secret name. We get a host of new characters as she lives there during the summer. She returns to school and is immediately swept up into danger again as the Dark Queen tries to gain access to Ivy’s royal stone. With the help of her new friends, Ivy again defeats the Dark Queen’s plans to keep the world safe for a little longer.

One of my favorite parts of this book was the Quogo matches (some of which are illegal of course!). The magical students doing tournament style duels was fantastic. I will say that at late teenage years, these students do seem to act younger than they are and I wish they would have grown a little more as their ages in the book did.

Overall, an absolutely fabulous return to a magical world! 100% would recommend this book for those who love middle grade/YA fantasies and lovers of Harry Potter.

Was this review helpful?

I really liked the world and characters introduced in the first book, so I was looking forward to reading the second one. I will say this one was a bit harder to keep my attention compared to the first. I felt like the plot was not as interesting, and at the same time, it was a bit confusing.

This sequel focuses on Ivy's journey through her banishment from The Halls of Ivy, her inevitable return to the school, and her continued quest to overpower the Dark Queen and save their world.

There were even more Harry Potter influences in the second one than the first and I felt some of it was a bit too much than just an influence. There are still unique aspects of the story, characters, and worlds, but I can compare almost everything to a part of HP, with the thestral-like creatures, a possessed student, secret magic club, and so on. I hoped for a bit more from this book, but I am still interested in reading the third.

Thank you to the publisher for gifting me a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?