Cover Image: The Vanishing Trial

The Vanishing Trial

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

A book of this kind could easily become a snooze for anyone not specifically interested in the judicial systems workings. However, Katzberg did a great job providing engaging and interesting ways to provide this look behind the curtain so to speak of the trial system. A book worthy of a read, even for those that aren't desiring to hod a law degree or stand before a judge.

Was this review helpful?

Amazing insight into the author's experience and I thoroughly enjoyed this book Good balance of fact and description that kept me really engaged..
I have an interest in legal drama and sometimes the fiction is too unrealistic but this was a solid read

Was this review helpful?

I haven't finished reading Katzberg's debut 'The Vanishing Trial' yet, but I'm writing this review anyway because I'm really not sure what exactly to make of this book. To be clear, it's not a badly written book at all, but at the same time, I'm not sure (yet) if the book that Katzberg has written really deserves to be called 'The Vanishing Trial' because, beyond the initial introduction, I've yet to come across any real analysis about the 'vanishing' trial and why its vanishing and what this means in practice. Mostly, what I've read of this book is mostly about Katzberg's experiences as a lawyer, both with the district attorney's office and as a private defender specializing in white collar criminal trials. I'm 60% through the book and the mentions of the vanishing trial are few and far between.

On another note, I can't really understand Katzberg's choices in regards to details of particular cases; he includes lots of details about the residing judges, his fellow lawyers, the charges laid and the behind-the-scenes processes of the courts, but simultaneously, the information he includes seems almost surface level? In one particular chapter, we are regaled with the context, procedures and outcomes of 3 separate trials. We learn the names of the respective judges and the lawyers, their dispositions, where the lawyers and their clients ate at lunch, the performance of the defendants and their lawyers in the courtroom. There seems to be a never ending list of names and charges to remember, but once the anecdote has been told (in detail) we move straight onto the next anecdote. 3 times in one chapter! All I felt at the end of the chapter was overwhelmed with information that didn't really seem to matter in the grand scheme of the "vanishing trial" and the sense of anxiety you feel before a high school test.

I'm not sure if I'll finish this book, or even if I will find something in it to really enjoy, but I still feel like there's definitely an audience for this book, perhaps law students or someone who has more of an interest in hearing about a very skilled lawyer's career and has a desire to learn about the minutiae of his experiences.

Was this review helpful?

A courtroom memoir filled with humorous anecdotes and a warning about our current trial system.

This book was not exactly what I expected based on the title - it's more a memoir about the author's experiences as a trial lawyer than an explanation of why trials are less common and why we should care. Katzberg does make some references to plea bargains/mandatory minimums driving lower trial rates, but the focus is on his career.

If you like courtroom dramas and want a behind-the-scenes look, there's a lot to like about this book. Katzberg writes well and profiles some of the most successful and infamous trial lawyers, including the times when his path crossed with theirs. He shows the reader what separates a good lawyer from a great one, and a great lawyer from a superstar.

3.5 stars rounded up to 4 - this book delivers on its promises, but I personally would have liked more in-depth analysis of the "vanishing trial" phenomenon.

Thank you to Mascot Books for providing an ARC on NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Solid Examination More Memoir Than Treatise. I was actually going to 4* this one until I went back and re-read the description, which did in fact hint at this being more memoir than treatise - which was my only real reason for docking the star. I had thought, reading it well after actually picking it up, that I was getting more treatise with just a smattering of memoir.

That noted, Katzberg does a remarkable job of showing the problems he notes as only an insider can, and sets the stage for further exploration - perhaps, as he so often notes, from someone more scholarly inclined - of the exact issues, their exact causes and histories, and maybe some examination of potential solutions, even including Katzberg's own. Ultimately more Failure Is Not An Option (Gene Kranz's remarkable memoir of his time as a Flight Director during the Apollo era) than Rise Of the Warrior Cop (Radley Balko's complete record of policing in America and in particular its militarization of the last 50 years or so), this is truly a spectacular effort, well written with concise points, solid anecdotes, and an appropriate smattering of humor. Very much recommended.

Was this review helpful?

I conducted an interview about this book with Mr. Katzberg for the podcast The Modern Law Library. I genuinely enjoyed reading it, and I think it is a good mix of anecdotes from a long career, tips for aspiring trial lawyers, and a clarion call to protect the right to a jury trial. It's written in an approachable style, so although I do think that lawyers or other legal professionals will enjoy it, you do not have to have a law degree to understand and appreciate it.

Was this review helpful?

A fascinating ride through the intricacies of the judicial system, without ever appearing that intricate. Katzberg's tales of past trials, his thoughts on the system and the overall feel is the book, all are as entertaining as they are informative. Recommended to any even casual student of law.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book! The author explores how trials by jury are becoming less commonplace in our judiciary system and the effects this is having on our criminal justice system.

Katzberg really explores all sides of the issue and from the perspective of both citizens as well as legal counsel. There are clearly many flaws with the jury system, but using it less frequently results in more power being held in the hands of judges discretion, which can also be problematic. This was something I didn't even realize was happening and I think it's an overlooked aspect of criminal justice reform that needs more attention brought to it.

Was this review helpful?

It should be read by all those who care about preserving the Founders’ vision of the American jury as a need part of the system. It's a good read, almost reads like a novel.

Was this review helpful?