Skip to main content

Member Reviews

An extraordinary book where we get right inside the head of nurse Julia Power as she single-handedly cares for the woman on this Dublin maternity ward who also have Spanish flu. Every action, every decision, every feeling is described during 2 intense days. The doctor on call is not only a woman, not usual in 1918, but on the side of the rebels. She and the volunteer ward assistant, Bridie, change Julia’s life forever in unexpected ways. Life-affirming, tragic, wonderful, it’s all of this, and stayed with me for a long time.

Was this review helpful?

Set in a maternity ward during a flu epidemic Julia, a nurse, and Bridie, who was brought up in care, work together to try to save the lives of mothers and babies in their care.
Reading this during the current pandemic could make it difficult for some readers and I would suggest anyone with a pregnancy in the family waits till after the birth as parts can be traumatic.
Having said that I got very involved in the two ladies’ lives as well as Tim Julia’s brother suffering from shell shock.

Was this review helpful?

I was really looking forward to reading this having read ‘Room’, which I had mixed thoughts about. However, I really enjoyed this, if that’s an appropriate thing to say. There is some familiarity about it as not only is it set of a specific period of time but takes place territory during the 1918 Flu pandemic (of which we now know more given our own present pandemic). It follows Nurse Julia Power who is in charge of a three-bed maternity ward. Donoghue is at her best when she is confined to a tiny space and I really felt the intensity of the relationships between the patients and staff and life and death. I'd recommend this for any Donoghue fans but especially for those new to her.

Thank you to Pan Macmillan and NetGalley for the ARC

Was this review helpful?

An incredibly prescient novel which is set over three days in Dublin during the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic. Reading this during lockdown, this stunning piece of writing held a unique resonance for me as Emma Donoghue has captured the zeitgeist a century later. I am a huge fan of Emma Donoghue's writing and as with all her novels, this is meticulously researched, beautifully evocative and compelling reading. Thank you Netgalley for the advance review copy.

Was this review helpful?

“I felt I was adrift in a leaking boat with these strangers, waiting out a storm.”

This is a fantastic, powerfully empathetic novel, a moving story of coming together through trial, helping and loving each other despite hardship, and holding strong in the face of complete desperation.

It’s 1918 and an influenza pandemic is running rife across an already war-weary Ireland. Julia Power is a midwife in a hospital utterly overrun in the crisis. The staff numbers are dwindling as doctors and nurses themselves succumb to the dreadful illness, while the patient numbers soar, leaving those staff remaining stretched dreadfully. Julia finds herself on her own in charge of the maternity fever ward, with nothing but a fresh volunteer without an ounce of knowledge or experience, in Bridie Sweeney. Julia and Bridie battle together with death, ‘the bone man’, and try to save their patients as best they can with occasional help from the rebel Doctor Lynn. This felt like a hectic race of a read; while the characters raced and battled to save lives I felt completely along with the journey and couldn’t put it down. I loved the character of Bridie, the young woman without any training whatsoever but reams of energy and optimism despite the hellish, desperate circumstances of the improvised fever maternity ward, and a terribly deprived background. What a girl to have on your side in a crisis! The struggle felt almost impossible, as if there was little to be done to ‘influence the stars’ but the characters tried their utmost anyway, and loved for what moments they could. I’m a little bit heartbroken by this book after finishing it, it was that good! And given current circumstances, I think this book has a lot to say and learn from.

Thank you to the publisher, Pan Macmillan, and #Netgalley for the arc to review.

#bookstagram #ThePulloftheStars #EmmaDonoghue #arc #picador #booksofinstagram #bookreview #booklove #historicalfiction #literaryfiction

Was this review helpful?

This was my second Donoghue and I enjoyed it as well. This book takes place in Dublin during Spanish flu. It's a bit slow going until the end, but nevertheless very well written and emotional.

I enjoyed my time, and if you're interested in the blurb, it's a good one.

Thanks a lot to NG and the publisher for this copy.

Was this review helpful?

Such a great book, loved it, devoured in one sitting. The accuracy and details were frighteningly good. Reading whilst in a current pandemic gave further affection to this book. The strange advice given by the Irish government back then made me laugh, off to eat an onion and drink some whisky!

Was this review helpful?

Looking at the title alone you might not think that this is “a book for our times”. But in this latest Donoghue historical novel we are taken to Dublin in October 1918 – and the midst of the “Great Flu Epidemic” – the mythical “Bone Man” is therefore collecting thousands of people. To offset the disastrous scale of the impact at the time Donoghue is presenting us with just four days through the eyes of a (youngish) nurse Julia Power who works in maternity services.
In the introduction Julia is travelling to work by bicycle and bus from the home she shares with her brother – who is still suffering injuries both mental and physical from his time on the Western Front. He has a small pension but even with their joint incomes money is tight and life is sparse at the best of times. But in addition to that, the speed and severity of the pandemic is starting to have a major impact on basic ways of life, with increasing shortages, of food, utilities, transport and people for many essential roles. This is adding to the difficulties and distress that more and more families were facing with the loss of loved ones.
The hospital is swamped with the ill and dying, but “ordinary” medical requirements have not stopped. Nobody really knows what the impact the disease will have on flu victims or their unborn babies. Julia will be told that she will have to run a small “overflow” ward with just three beds. Apart from a nun who “mans” the nightshift, she is required to do this alone, that is until a young, untrained volunteer, Bridie, from the religious “home” nearby, appears to help. Doctors are in short supply and often inexperienced. Donoghue will introduce a woman Doctor Lynne. But she is based on real life – someone involved in the 1916 rising, until with concern over security issues rising, she will be re-arrested in the hospital and cease to provide critical medical support.
Just as the current Coronavirus has directed a not particularly flattering spotlight on the failures of our social systems – so Donoghue will use this novel to do the same on the medical and social practices and attitudes in 1918 Dublin. Even before the flu pandemic it would not have been pleasant to watch or indeed to be subject to at times of vulnerability. Expect detailed depictions of the risks and realities of maternity practices in the time before antibiotics when large numbers of mothers and babies died. Add the realities of the flu – in the midst of a pandemic with overrun services - and the uneasiness increases. She will explore the realities of trying to treat people with this deadly disease – a disease that could kill rapidly, but one that was both little understood and had little effective treatment other than trying to bolster the resistance of those ill with food, drink and failing medical supplies.
Behind that of course, then as now, people continued their lives as usual as far as possible – often developing a new resilience for the good of others, or to their own agenda. Donoghue has not forgotten that the First World War had also laid down layers of distressed and damaged people already trying to cope with that too. Life is not single layered. In addition nursing was often peopled with nuns and other religious working to their own agendas. Groups who ran powerful institutions but held a strong broader social sway and influence. Many readers will have already heard of the harshness and iniquities of many of these places that were supposed to be refuges for the vulnerable. Through Bridie in particular deeper the truths of the matter – both physical and in ethos – and the reality of those places will be explored. For one short night Julia and Bridie will find comfort in the quiet presence of the other – even in this extremely challenging place and time – but that cannot last.
It should be said that this is not a novel for those lacking a strong stomach, because Donoghue does not pull any punches. Albeit (a minor criticism) it might be that she has a slightly benevolent view of a hospital of this time in crisis and is not harsh enough. But she is a consummate writer and her ability to present history in a way that is both visceral and relevant is unmatched. With her fluent writing style that draws the reader along, and into her places, this is another very fine novel.

Was this review helpful?

Remarkable coincidence that this novel, set during the time of the Spanish flu pandemic, should come out when the world is in the middle of another brutal pandemic, Covid-19, making Emma Donoghue’s depiction of a virus-infested world all-the-more resonant. This novel is not for the faint-hearted with its vivid depiction of a maternity ward, described as an ‘antichamber of hell’, and lest we forget the (at times) macabre experience of childbirth, Donoghue’s mellifluous prose hones in unabashedly, reminding us of the cruelty of a society where a woman’s love for her husband is judged by how many children she bares for him. I found this gothic-style vignette of chauvinistic and intolerant early 20th Century Dublin engrossing and incredibly moving at times, and believe it is a novel that will linger in my mind for some time to come.

Was this review helpful?

The Pull of the Stars by Emma Donoghue is set in Dublin during the Spanisg Flu pandemic. It focuses on burse Julia serving on a maternity over the course of 3 days. I was very excited to receive this early copy as I have enjoyed previous books by Donoghue however I really did not enjoy this book. I found it very slow moving for the majority of the story until the final few chapters where it was crammed with content. I found the last incidents of the book unbelievable and overall I'd find it hard to recommend this book.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for this ARC

Was this review helpful?

This was an absolute rollercoaster of a book. Set in 1918 in an Irish hospital, Julia is a nurse thrown in at the deep end running a tiny ward for pregnant women during the influenza pandemic. It is gripping and visceral, with in depth details of labour and death. She struggles to do her best, aided by a volunteer from the local convent. It touches on the horrors of medical care before widespread antibiotics and vaccinations, the difficulties women faced becoming doctors and being trusted to know what is best for their bodies, in every sense. The book mentions the widespread domestic abuse and institutional abuse of the time, and the lack of power and agency most women had in their lives. It sounds depressing, but there are glimpses of hope, reminding me of Room. I literally could not put this book down, and reading it during a pandemic just added even more layers.

Was this review helpful?

The Pull of the Stars takes place during 1918, the time of the Spanish Flu and World War one. I found it quite a difficult read, history is not my favourite genre but I always enjoy Emma Donahues writing. It's topical right now with our current situation. If you're into history them you'll enjoy this book.

Was this review helpful?

The reviews really helped me prepare for reading this book! I was emotionally invested throughout and exhausted by the end...

Brilliantly absorbs you into a time that I knew nothing about previously.

Also, very prescient what with the current COVID-19 situation. I automatically drew similarities between the Spanish Flu pandemic and the current situation.

Read this when you can give it your full attention.

Thank you for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

A very strong 4.5!

The setting is bleak, a hospital in 1918 Dublin during the Spanish influenza and World War I, there’s also the shadow of the Irish fight for independence and tensions between Catholics and Protestants looming large. Donoghue paints a detailed and believable picture of this time and it was interesting to see the parallels between 1918 and today. It’s a rather timely novel.

We follow the sole nurse working on a maternity/fever (pregnant women with the Spanish flu) ward over 3 days. Those three days are incredibly eventful as life comes and goes from the ward. Heart wrenching moments are followed directly by moments of success and joy, while you could guess at the direction of the story you never quite know how exactly it’s going to unfold.

The novel is largely female driven with a number of expectant mothers, an untrained volunteer assisting the nurse and the inclusion of a real historical character in Dr Kathleen Lynn. They represent several different areas of society. These are all complex characters who have been beaten down time and time again by a situation out of their control but somehow they keep on going, trying to do what they think is best for others.

This book requires you invest a lot, at times almost too much, but for me that’s what made this reading experience.

Was this review helpful?

This book hit home on so many levels. It is set at the time of a pandemic in the early 20th century which obviously echoes the situation we are in today. being pregnant as well this book gave an indication of what I'll expect to go through in a few weeks. it was a beautiful fantastic and excellent read.

Was this review helpful?

When she set her latest novel in the middle of the 'Spanish flu' outbreak at the end of World War I, Emma Donoghue couldn't possibly have imagined it would be so relevant and timely when published in summer 2020. No doubt this unexpected coincidence will add to its appeal as books dealing with plagues have become popular as people turn to literature to make sense of current events. But it would be a shame to simply dismiss any success as lucky timing - this is a really excellent novel regardless of when a reader comes to it.

It is set over just three days in 1918 Dublin. The point of view character is Julia Power, a midwife about to turn 30, and struggling in an understaffed hospital full of flu patients. She finds herself in charge of a small ward of women who are both pregnant and suffering from the virus, with only a young girl to assist her who has never worked in a hospital before. Meanwhile, the lady doctor (a rarity in those days) who has been drafted in turns out to be wanted by the police for her role in the Easter uprising.

It's natural to look for the parallels with the Covid-19 lockdown, and there are certainly some. But most of the action is centred on the ward itself, rather than the experiences of ordinary civilians. Its depictions of events on the wards - sometimes mundane, sometimes dramatic - are completely convincing and it is extremely compelling. I read it very fast, even delaying watching the next episode of my favourite TV show to keep reading. The characters are likeable, beautifully drawn and realistic. The depictions of birth, death and medical procedures are vivid without being gratuitous and make for gripping reading.

Plot wise, the medical dramas of the patients alone are enough to keep you absorbed, but there's plenty more to it than that. In fact, the plot took an unexpected turn that I hadn't seen coming. A reading group could find a good session's worth of discussion topics here - hierarchical societies, Irish independence, women's rights, health inequalities, whether violence is justified to use in any cause, etc. etc,. Don't think this is some sort of worthy tome though - it's really not. These topics are touched on but 'shown' not 'told'. It is really just a fantastic, readable, absorbing story. Fiction at its best.

The parts about the impact of flu - and childbirth - on women already weakened by poverty now seem shockingly prescient. The tragedy is that more than 100 years after the book is set, those inequalities still exist. Both the Covid-19 pandemic and the Black Lives Matter protests have thrown stark light on how your chances of surviving a severe viral illness, or childbirth, depend very much on your life circumstances. Some elements of the story you can think 'thank goodness it's not like that now' but all too much of it you feel ashamed to realise we haven't moved on that much at all.

This is sure to be one of the best books I read this year, and one of Donoghue's best. Highly recommended to all readers.

Was this review helpful?

A prescient novel, written before the current Covid 19 outbreak, The Pull of the Stars has startling parallels between the Spanish Flu in 1918 and our life today. Set in a maternity hospital in Dublin and spanning only three days, this novel gallops along and sweeps you into a time and place where life was precarious and revolution was in the air. I can’t recommend this novel highly enough -Emma Donough is an impressive author.

Was this review helpful?

In the opening scene of Emma Donoghue's eerily prescient new novel, set in early twentieth-century Dublin during a flu pandemic, a man hawks up phlegm on the floor of a tram carrying commuters to work.
'Ye might as well have sprayed us with bullets!' moans one of the passengers. And here we are again. I wonder whether if this were set in a future dystopia rather than the past, it would have been even stronger, but of course Donoghue had no idea about the pandemic at the time of writing and, as the novel shows, the past has its own echoes and eerie similarities to today (including a culture of victim-blaming, which particularly boils the heroine's blood when she sees posters blaming the sick for their own deaths).

Because of its similarity to COVID-19, some of the details in The Pull of the Stars have the immediacy of Room - which was inspired by contemporary news stories as well as the author's experience of motherhood.
However, this is also the more historical, romantic Emma Donoghue of Slammerkin, Hood, The Wonder and most recently Akin - taking on questions of family, love and passion between women (nice to see some of that back)! while continuing to be fascinated by the collision between science and religion, medical practicality and the unseen workings of the Universe (the 'stars' of the title, which reference mortality as well as romance).

To some extent this duality is mirrored in the book, with the first two thirds an earthbound look at the dullness as well as the drama of giving birth during a flu pandemic. The three women the heroine Julia is entrusted with all have difficult labours, and sometimes the depictions are eye-watering - when a porter tells Julia that women don't pay the 'blood tax' of war, she asks him to look at her ward. However, the last third is heightened, dramatic, feverish - appropriately so - as Julia struggles to hold onto the love she's only just found.

Definitely vintage Donoghue, 'Room' may have been a one-off in the chords it struck around the world, but in a writer this good, there's no need to complain about a return to form.

Was this review helpful?

Emma Donoghue is fabulous writer. I have read a lot of her work and she never fails to impress me.
Set over just three days in 1918 in Dublin #ThePullOfTheStars is a beautiful book. Very different to her most famous book Room, but just as impactful and moving. The research must have been extensive, as her knowledge of the Spanish flu, midwifery, and the political and social situation in Ireland at the time is faultless. It all adds to the story without overwhelming the main themes of loyalty, loss, friendship and hope. I highly recommend this beautiful book. It would be a really good choice for book clubs and for those studying history at school or college. I absolutely loved it.
Thank you to the publisher, the author and #NetGalley for the opportunity to read this special book.

Was this review helpful?

1918. Ireland amid the Spanish Flu pandemic.
Nurse Julia works in an understaffed maternity ward where expectant mothers are fighting the flu.
Her life gets intertwined with Bridie Sweeney, a young volunteer, and Dr. Lynn, who is considered a rebel and wanted by the police.
Together they bring new lives into the world, but also lose some to the virus.

I requested this book blindly because I loved The Room.
What I hadn't realised though, is that this book was not of the same genre, and therefore initially, I struggled to get into it.
However, the story imperceptibly sucked me in, and I really enjoyed it.
I loved ''seeing'' the past, comparing the government's advice regarding the virus to what we're told to do now. It was good to see how the hospitals operated, some of the remedies they used to use made me cringe.
The downside was that the chapters - or more accurately, sections - were so long ( there were 4 of them in the whole book ) that there was no good place to stop. Also, there was no dialogue as such, the story was told through Julia's eyes, which I found confusing at times.
I didn't know what to expect from the ending, but I found it satisfying.
Overall, although it wasn't my go-to genre, I enjoyed this book.
There are some graphic scenes in there, so you might want to avoid this book if you're a bit squeamish, but otherwise, I think it's a book worth checking out.

Was this review helpful?