Cover Image: The Case of the Disgusting School Dinners

The Case of the Disgusting School Dinners

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

A wonderful book for children. Super funny and with a lot of heart. I loved Mina and think a lot of young readers will find a favourite character in her.

Was this review helpful?

A laugh out loud detective story about a schoolgirl detective’s secret mission to find out why her school is serving the grossest and unhealthiest school meals EVER!

Packed with comical B&W illustrations of scenes, case files and secret character profiles for readers to follow along and help crack the case.

Written in a witty tone that offers readers of all ages a giggle, the Mina Mistry Investigates series is perfect for fans of Planet Omar and Anisha Accidental Detective.

Was this review helpful?

Mina Mistry is a great character. Smart, witty, detail-oriented. Loved the personal files mixed in with a story/background. Mina's personality really shines. You get to know her life and the people in it through her eyes.

Was this review helpful?

At the beginning of this book, I started to get excited about Mina and her family. The multi-racial family was showcased beautifully by showcasing Mina's Indian heritage and her grandmother cooking Indian food. However, from this point on, I was disappointed with three main aspects of the book. The first was the way Mina thought about her best friend. She treated her friend Holly pretty horribly, always implying that Holly was not intelligent and very shallow. The second was the inconsistency in some of the storylines. One of the characters Postman Pete was only supposed to have one arm but was shown in illustrations with two arms with no explanation. Also, there were not enough breadcrumbs throughout the novel to showcase how Mina figured out the mystery who was the culprit. She seemed to arrive at the solution without much sleuthing. Lastly, there were some sentences throughout the book that had missing words or were phrased poorly. While I had these three major problems with the book, I do think there is a lot of hope for future installments in the series. Mina seems like a proactive, intelligent young girl and with a few fixes, I could see myself recommending this series to young students.

Was this review helpful?

The book was written nicely, gave an amazing message, and may help many kids in the United Kingdom with eating healthy and with recipe ideas FOR that purpose!

I feel there were some interesting points in the book, and the mystery was very unique! As a middle grade novel, I think this book served its purpose well, and may be entertaining to many.

Angie Lake's writing was somewhat spotty, some points were written well, and some points could be hard to understand requiring a few double-takes.

This first entry in the Mina Mistry series is a solid novel!

2.5 stars!

Was this review helpful?

This book was funny and my children enjoyed listening to it. We enjoyed the multicultural references and the storyline. It was an easy to read and and a lighthearted book. I found the writing of the best friend quite derogatory and wouldn’t like that to become an acceptable way of viewing friends for positive relationships. I suppose this could be a teaching point to discuss in school. I also found the weight shaming of the teacher in the book unnecessary to the story line and quite disappointing in a children’s book. I think lots of children would enjoy the book and the adventures of the character but I would like to see a refreshing book that didn’t need to resort to ‘Walliams-esque’ ridicule of the overweight or less able.

Was this review helpful?

Children’s literature is most definitely an effective means of communicating a significant message, attracting kids and their suddenly (and similarly) curious parents. The straightforward aim of this story is to encourage youngsters to choose healthy snacks over fatty and sugary ones (or at least maintain a balanced diet). Sometimes that is not possible and this is where all readers should pay attention to a better hidden purpose, slipped in carefully among the pages. Adults may occasionally prove to be contradictory, pointing out one thing and doing the opposite, thus influencing children to head on a wrong direction. Some will detect the mistakes, but will take longer to alert others. A grown-up’s mind is an interesting matter, as it holds plenty of clashing intentions. But a kid’s brain is even more exciting to observe and Mina Mistry is here to prove it.

The little girl has a special way with words. She experiments with them, replacing her real family name, Snotbridge, with a secret undercover one, Mistry, alluding to Mystery – eventually I began to see her as a Mistress of Mystery. Her mind is quick to spot the truth and reveal it, but she still chooses her words carefully, avoiding unnecessary discussions and getting straight to the point. What is great about her is that she never scares or gives you the impression she may be misjudging someone. She is aware of both flaws and helpful attributes, and knows when to ask for assistance. Her solitary retreats enlarge her perspective and she will find someone to confide in (you as the reader). Admittedly, she is jotting down her log entries (not to be confused with plain diary entries), with formal references to her current location and status. However, you soon feel as if she often looks away from her notebook and her plush (and best friend), Mr Panda, and gives you frequent side glances. She will either have a “can-you-believe-this-is-happening” moment or slide in an obvious and amusing remark, something which you have been dying to say even in your real-life situations, but have somehow thought it would be irrelevant.

I think it is clever how a simple topic like school dinners (or, as the American edition has nicely adapted, school lunches) provides an elaborate plot, a serious investigation surrounding an issue meant to be addressed once and for all. It may be an indirect hint to how taking the first step towards action is often harder than the task itself. Once involved into something, we all go with the flow and link cues and clues. After attending a talk about nutritious eating, Mina does not ignore how the school cafeteria keeps pumping in unhealthy treats. Case files pile up, presumptions are made, clear evidence is discovered. There is not one second where the readers may get bored. And before they realize it, they are motivated to change bits and pieces in their lives.

Was this review helpful?

Hello everyone, this is a fresh and easy to read book series. The age I would recommend for this book is 7+. This book is for preteens. I would say this book is for people that think school sometimes can be boring and they can flip around that situation with their ingenious imagination.

What we like the most:

*Engaging illustrations that show you Mina’s personality
*Hilarious way to describe common and simple scenes of school life
*It is easy to read, even if you have English as a second language. Double point!!
*Draws the attention to healthy life style at lunch time

Was this review helpful?