Cover Image: Open Water

Open Water

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Open Water by Caleb Azumah Nelson is a stunning debut. Powerful, poignant and full of love. It's a breath-taking and evocative look at what it means to be intimate, to feel and be judged because of your skin colour and gender rather than for who you are as a person.

Was this review helpful?

Open Water by Caleb Azumah Nelson is possibly the most beautiful book I have ever read. It's like a work of art, a creative masterpiece. It reads almost like music and I was completely absorbed in it from start to finish.

Open Water is an intimate love story. You can feel the connection between the couple even as they first meet, and this builds throughout the book. It's a celebration of Black beauty and Black love and it is just gorgeous to read.

It is also a book about identity. Learning who you are, learning how to love yourself before you can fully give yourself to another. It highlights the struggle Black men face living in London. Being unseen, unheard. Seen as a Black body rather than a person. Always meeting the description, being stopped, being questioned. Wondering if today will be the day they don't make it home. Trying to not let that fear overcome them. Trying to find space to breathe. Trying to find a place, a person, somewhere to feel at home.

It's got heart and soul. Its unique second person narrative flows really well, at times it feels like poetry. It's atmospheric, you can feel London, feel the heat and the cold, hear the bass. The minute I finished it, with tears in my eyes, I immediately wanted to read it again. It's been a struggle to even begin to describe how I felt about this book but there is a fantastic trailer on @viking page so check that out because it is simply perfect for this book!

Was this review helpful?

Open Water is a deeply felt novel of love, heartbreak, inner self, and what it's like to be Black in the UK at this time.

Nelson writes with such lyricism and honesty. You can't help feel with the narrator the wide range of emotions that they go through. Told in second person, you are attached in a way that another narrative perspective would have distanced the reader. It was a bold choice and it pays off dividends. Throughout the book, there are very self-aware references to other Black artists which I found had the effect of creating this lovely community. A way of lifting up other voices and creating touchstones of experiences.

Open Water is a novel that will sit with you for a long time.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin UK, Viking for kindly providing me with a digital copy of this book for review.
Well, I honestly don’t know where to start! Firstly I think it needs to be said that this is an impressive and ambitious undertaking for a debut novel, and what this author manages to pack into a fairly small amount of pages, it quite staggering really.
I found this novel very timely in light of the 2020 BLM protests last summer. It’s main story line is the evolvement of a romantic relationship between our main male character and a female dancer who starts out as his friend’s girlfriend. However, running alongside that storyline are themes of systemic racism, police harassment, social inequality, and personal growth. All of that makes it a pretty heavy and challenging read, despite its short length.
I found the writing style quite difficult as well if I’m honest. It was written in second person, which you would expect would make you feel more connected to the character, but I found it quite claustrophobic, jarring and distracting. The sentences used were also sharp and short and it times it felt like I as the reader was under fire- I did not feel I could just relax into the story. I wonder if this was intentional from the author as he explores the experience of being a black man, and the dangers and fears faced by just stepping out onto the street daily, and always feeling like you’re having to dodge a bullet or attack.
So while I can’t exactly say I enjoyed this book, it has certainly given me much to think about and I think this is an important new voice in literature and I’m sure there’s much more to come from him.

Was this review helpful?

An astounding debut, that explores intimacy and what it means to expose your vulnerabilities to another.

The two central characters are introduced at a party and the attraction is instant. The introduction though is by a close friend to one and boyfriend to the other. To pursue the relationship would break all sorts of moral codes but to deny the electricity that fizzles between them is not possible. They settle for the only relationship they can take and nurture an intense friendship that slowly evolves. This is everything I had hoped for, and never really felt, whilst reading Normal People.

The two central characters have much common ground; both artists, a shared love of music & culture, both attended predominantly white fee-paying schools, as one of only a handful of black children. Throughout the book, there are numerous cultural references to books, art, music, even philosophy, which serves to create a truly immersive read. This is further amplified by second person narrative, never getting to know the names of the two central characters, which means you can only think of the characters as "her" and "me". That said, I did feel a little upset not to know the names of people I cared so much for.

Vulnerability and the fear of entering "open water" is explored throughout the book both in the sense of exposing your vulnerabilities to another within a relationship and struggling as a young black man in Britain today. Although short, this was a really remarkable book told with such tender, poetic language, where every line felt considered. I hope Caleb Azumah Nelson writes many more books - I will be keenly watching for anything he writes in the future.

Thank you to NetGalley and VikingBooks for a copy of #openwater for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful love story, gorgeously written. I tried savouring this book to enjoy it longer, but kept finding myself completely hooked and unable to put it down. It’s one of those books that stays with you, and I find myself thinking about it frequently - it’ll stay on my bookshelf forever. Thank you.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book. Written in the second person, it is so beautifully crafted that at times it reads like poetry (I’m pretty sure I “shushed” anyone who tried to speak to me while I was reading it). It is a celebration of black artists, from Zadie Smith to Kendrick Lamar, and some passages in the book reminded me of the hazy, dreamlike cinematography in films such as If Beale Street Could Talk and Moonlight. No words are wasted.

Open Water is also an exploration of race, vulnerability and masculinity. The narrator’s everyday is interrupted by acts of racism against him, and those around him. What does it mean when someone decides you are a threat because of the colour of your skin? When they can’t see past their own prejudices? How does that constant state of fear and the trepidation to walk outside your own front door affect you and those that you love and who love you back?

Tender and beautiful, I feel lucky that it’s the author’s debut novel as it means that we have so much of his future work to look forward to.

My thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the advance review copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This is an amazing debut novel about what it means to be young, Black and British in today's society. He is a photographer, she is a dancer, and they fall in and out of love.

The poetic writing explores racism, police intimidation, masculinity and 'not being seen.' Open Water is written in the second person which some readers find off putting. I would champion it in this case as it fits with the view of 'It's one thing to be looked at and another to be seen.'

In essence, this is a love story but not a conventional one. It is a relationship which yearns for calmness but is often set adrift in the open water of the title and by the vagaries of society. This could be one of the books of 2021 and for such a short book, that is really saying something.

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin: Hamish Hamilton for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Two people meet in a bar, introduced by a mutual friend. Male and female, there is an instant connection, which is made slightly awkward by the fact that this mutual friend is in fact, her new boyfriend. Whoops.

Best friends, colleagues, something close to lovers, they keep connected across London and university education in dance and photography.

This is told from his point of view, in the overwhelming majority. We don’t know and are never told their names, although we learn his family’s names and their characters in short, sharp bursts.

The recurring, slow build analogy of a relationship being open water, about allowing yourself to be vulnerable enough to hang on to someone else when you can’t tread your own water, permeates the book and the narrative in an all consuming way. I loved that, the way the narrator talks about his life and how hard it is to deal with all of the emotions and thoughts and pressures he deals with. He talks of plays he sees, films he watches and music he listens to, all of them evoking an emotional response that he somehow can’t put into words to the person he loves most of all.

This isn’t about a repressed Black man – he is open about crying in numerous places, alone and with others – he represents, for me at least, as a middle aged white woman, the tightrope balance between expressing your emotions and love and remaining ‘strong’ for your family.

As well as love, of forging that strong relationship beyond the bonds of family, he talks of the fear, the rage of being stopped by the police purely because he is a Black man on the streets of London and looks out of place, or matches the vague description of something, or because they can. Exploring the places your family came from while feeling and being British, holding all of those in your head simultaneously AND dealing with the actions of those who make you feel like this is not your home, even though you were born here – that’s tough. Nelson is on fire in these sections, and perhaps as a 26 year old British -Ghanaian, he’s drawing on his own experiences by writing a narrator who is also a young British Ghanaian – it certainly feels authentic.

“Open Water” is what I would call a blistering debut – it felt like kin with Sally Rooney’s Normal People in that it revolves around a young couple (not) being together, but also takes in questions of class and principles and how ‘you’ you need to be.

Thanks to Netgalley and Penguin – Viking for the DRC, as always! This book is available for pre-order, released on 4th February 2021.

Was this review helpful?

Beautiful story, delves deep into love, race, ambition. An insight into how two people are perceived by society and how this affects their life journey.

Was this review helpful?

I really couldn't get into this book. The characters were not at all likeable and the story itself didn't click with me at all.

Was this review helpful?

Open Water is beautifully written and I think very important. I felt sad when it ended, mostly as a result of the intensity of the writing and the grief that is portrayed within the novel.

Was this review helpful?

This book is a wonderfully poetic yet tragic love story. At first, I found the fact that it was written in the second person quite jarring, but once you lean into it, the words take you away. The intimacy is amplified by the use of the second person narrative style, and the emotion alongside the exploration of masculinity and race is something that was so captivating and eye opening.

I think this is one of those books that everyone should read.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to @netgalley and the publisher @penguinukbooks @vikingbooksuk for the arc of this book released next month. "It is one thing to be looked at and another to be seen" Some books you just know within a few pages, you're going to love, and this is one of those books. It's also one of those books where my words feel inadequate and you're just going to have to read it for yourselves to see how blooming brilliant it is.

Open Water is a celebration of friendship and love between two unnamed young black characters. They both live in London, he's a photographer and she's a dancer, who also studies in Dublin. We go through the seasons as their relationship changes, with London being the perfect backdrop.

It is effortlessly cool and exciting. Intimate without being overtly sexual. I got lost in the sumptuous poetic prose and its beautiful ebb and flow. This is simply, a dazzling debut. I fell in love with this book. @caleb_anelson is a refreshing new voice and I'm very excited to see what's next.

Was this review helpful?

Hard to review this book as I found it difficult to get into the writing style and don’t know much about the music mentioned
Having said that it was interesting to read about the two characters’ feelings and is very descriptive regarding how depressing it feels to be black and never to feel safe or free

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book, which is surprising because I first started off thinking I wouldn’t like it. The reason for this is because it’s written in the 2nd person, but I quickly got over that because the writing is exquisite. This book reminds me of why I love reading books and that is because of words strung together so beautifully alongside examinations of the human condition. Particularly in the case, how fraught it can be to love someone. Every single time I put this book down I couldn’t wait to dive back into it, it had this pull on me and every time I picked it backed up it was like walking into a hug.
This is a short narrative that follows two unnamed black protagonists, one a dancer, one a photographer. The story follows their relationship as it turns from a friendship to a romantic relationship, and the troubles that come with embarking on a new romantic relationship. Although told in the 2nd person, we mainly focus on the guy and his struggle of opening up in this new relationship, and you get the feeling he constantly has terror swimming around in his head. This terror is a combination of being in a Black body and living in London, police brutality, mental health issues and the general trauma of life that fuse together to weigh him down. The story is somewhat heart-breaking to witness because you realise it’s not a lack of love in this relationship, instead, it’s a communication issue, our male protagonist is grappling with his masculinity and what society has taught him about himself and the result is he doesn’t know how to express his feelings. This is particularly heartbreaking when those feelings are those of fear, vulnerability and insecurity.

The writing in this is just masterfully crafted, such great care has been taken to craft each sentence and as a result, this is a work of art. There are so many beautiful lines you can quote from this. That said, I think the poetic like prose is what may put other people off the book, whilst I think there is so much substance to this book, I think most people may be deterred by the lyrical writing and therefore think it lacks substance. I absolutely loved it and so it’s not a problem for me, but at times I did feel like a lot and so, that’s why it’s not a full 5 stars for me.

This was an emotional and powerful story, yet it also feels tender because of how it shows that these larger societal issues (racism, microaggression etc) trickle down and affect the individual’s ability to explore love, enjoy relationships and express feelings. I can’t believe this is a debut, I will definitely be purchasing this at some point and cannot wait to re-read it!

I have also reviewed this book on my YouTube channel here: https://bit.ly/2Y5fBCX the review starts at 13:04 and I'm happy for this to be shared if needed to promote the title.

Was this review helpful?

Open Water follows two young people as they fall in love - from the beginning of the journey to the rocky, potential end of it. Told in second person, we follow from the male perspective as he explains what it's like to find your perfect match, to be Black and British, to be British and Ghanaian, to love the soul of a person while being scared for your own.

"You know to love is to be a whole, partial, a joint, a fracture, a heart, a bone. It is to bleed and heal. It is to be in the world, honest. It is to place someone next to your beating heart, in the absolute darkness of your inner, and trust they will hold you close. To love is to trust, to trust is to have faith. How else are you meant to love?"

This book is utter poetry, and I loved every second of it. It kept stunning me over, and over again with gorgeous descriptions of that perfect, thrilling feeling of falling in love with someone - the heady feeling of becoming obsessed about what makes a person who they are, of wanting to open your mouth and drink every bit of them up so you can understand their soul and they yours.

The love in this book is pure, and powerful, and not completely perfect. Perfect in its imperfections but what I loved the most was this precious glimpse into the mind and life of a young Black man, struggling with his pride in who he was, and where he came from but also the fear for his life every time he walked out the door.

I think I have read books from BIPOC characters or authors mostly focused on the female perspective which I love, but I really felt it special to see the character's joys and fears spilled out on the pages in this one. His utter rage at what he is made to feel like, how he is treated. He is a gentle, creative soul yet because of the colour of his skin, is often made to feel like a criminal because of the authorities. And if it's not the police he's afraid of, he also has to be way of knife crime and gang crime in London, issues which also disproportionately affect young Black men.

The character's struggle to be vulnerable; to not show his fears to the girl who loves him most is so hard to read, and the fight to understand between the two of them as well is tough. The silent battle to have someone know what you are going through without having to say it and lay all your vulnerabilities on the table. To not be the "strong, Black man" society assumes you to be.

"You don't know why you're crying. Sometimes, love aches. You're not sad but bowled over."

The only reason why I didn't give this the full 5 stars as I felt at times the character would wander off with his thoughts, and my own mind would stray a bit - not fully committed to the page. But the beauty of this book struck me again, and again and I can't recommend it enough!

Was this review helpful?

The synopsis of this book sounded really promising and the kind of story I enjoy reading with many interesting and topical themes. Unfortunately the book did not work for me, however I am conscious of the fact that the reasons why are mainly due to my preferences as a reader rather than a reflection on the book.

Open Water follows two young adults, the male character is a photographer and the female character is a dancer. They meet when a friend of the male character starts dating the female character and slowly a friendship and romance develops between the two protagonists. The story is told from the perspective of the male character using second-person narration. This was my first issue with the book as I do not like second-person narration. I understand that for some it is a way of placing the reader in the shoes of the protagonist but, combined with the way both lead characters remain nameless, I found this narration really distancing and I didn't feel like I got to know either of them.

I also wasn't very keen on the style of writing. There were some lines that were very beautiful and touched on something profound, but to me it read like a summary of a full novel rather than giving me the description and detail I was craving to bring the story to life.

Having said this, the book brought in many important themes such as race, fear, masculinity, identity, privilege and love which were handled really well and woven seamlessly into the plot. In this sense there is a lot that can be taken from this book but it was the style of storytelling that let the book down for me.

Thank you to Netgalley and Penguin UK for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book - I haven't read something that engages your senses so readily and easily in a very long time. A really beautifully written and heartfelt debut.

Was this review helpful?

'The two of you, like headphone wires tangling, caught up in this something. A happy accident. A messy miracle.'

In OPEN WATER, two young people meet at a pub in South East London. Both are Black British, both won scholarships to private schools where they struggled to belong, both are now artists - he a photographer, she a dancer - trying to make their mark in a city that by turns celebrates and rejects them. Tentatively, tenderly, they fall in love. But two people who seem destined to be together can still be torn apart by fear and violence.

I don't know how people can write like this - this soulful, aching prose. Wow. Nelson renders his images in intense poetic detail, using language to form evocative vignettes which mirror the author's talent for photography. The novel's references to music, theatre, film and London itself (especially South London) made me double-take a few times while reading to make sure I didn't have my own diary in my hands. The authenticity here is unparalleled and I don't think I'll ever get over seeing my London on the page. This feels like a particular summer I had in my twenties - all heat and motives and vibes.

The novel explores the vulnerability not only of daring to fall in love but also of life as a Black man in Britain. Here, the protagonist's interactions with grief and the police contextualise the idea of what it can mean to love a Black man. A tender depiction of Black masculinity and mental health, it's a vivid portrayal of how we carry our experiences with us, how they mark and reshape our futures.

OPEN WATER is written in the 2nd person, which I found unsettling at first, to occupy the space of the "you" in a story that is so intimate and personal. Beyond the author encouraging the reader to empathise with his protagonist, it feels as though he's talking and writing back to himself and the deliberate repetition throughout is a confrontation of one's own memories - the act of remembering lives vividly through the narrative structure of the novel.

This is a love song.

Was this review helpful?