Cover Image: Unsettled Ground

Unsettled Ground

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I heard this week that Claire Fuller’s Unsettled Ground has been longlisted for the Women’s Prize for Fiction and I thought that this shows exceptional good taste and wisdom from the judges, as it really is a wonderful book.

Although this book has some very bleak moments for the main characters, there is always a beauty to the writing that lifts even the most hopeless of situations in Julius and Jeanie’s lives. I said last year when I read Hamnet that I was so jealous of Maggie O’Farrell’s beautiful use of words, and the same goes for Claire Fuller – sometimes the sparest sentence can evoke the most vivid pictures and I stand in awe of her skill.

At the heart of the book is a single lie, which has grown and multipled over the course of years to become a tangled web of pain and deceit, made by Julius and Jeanie’s mum, Dot. As we see her dying mometns it seems that she realises what she’s done, but it’s too late to save her children from what they have to face next.

As Dot’s lies begin to come out the twins must face the truth without Dot’s protection and with little ability to provide for themselves which, at the age of 51 is a huge culture shock – in some ways, they are living ‘out of time’ – they’ve no bank accounts, few modern conveniences and a stubborn refusal to accept help from anyone, so when their lives start to unravel it’;s an unstoppable force.

I though Julius and Jeanie were wonderful characters as, although they were quite childlike in some respects, there was potential there and by the times we leave them at the end of the book, we’re content to do so, knowing that they’re going to be ok. That’s another of Claire Fuller’s great strengths – making you really, truly care for her characters with all their faults and foibles.

The strongest thread running through the book is music, which is at the heart of the Seeder family. Even at the heart of their biggest disagreements, the music is able to bring them back together and give them comfort.

This is a powerful book, touching on the strength of family, and the weakness of individuals within that family. It’s sometimes a hard road to get there, but it’s ultimately an uplifting and rewarding read.

Was this review helpful?

I found 'Unsettled Ground' a read that was easy to get into and reopen and I enjoyed the characters of Jeanie and Julius, 51 year old twins who live with their mother. This book opens on the final day of their mother's life and is set over the days and years immediately following this, as they navigate how they want life to look and deal with many challenges that have been left for them. The themes were interesting: poverty, family secrets and dealing with long-term health conditions to name a few.

The book is a journey through uncovering family secrets and how people cope when their security is stripped away and what was familiar is turned on it's head. As a reader, it felt a little predictable in terms of what was uncovered, although there were other plot developments that were not as anticipated. I feel like Fuller writes people and interpersonal relationships well.

I just felt this book was a little predictable and I kept waiting for something different to happen. It felt realistic, but I did get a sense of being left a little wanting and waiting for something to happen.

Overall, I'm finding this book quite hard to review. On one hand, Claire Fuller has written well- great prose and characters who feel real. The difficulty I am having is that I have seen her writing strong stories (I loved 'Our Endless Numbered Days') and this feels a different kind of novel and without some of the qualities I enjoyed in that. If this was the first novel I read of Fuller's, she wouldn't be someone I would keep in mind to look out for. I am not sure if I would have enjoyed it more, not having her other work as a comparison. It is by no means a bad book, but it doesn't feel one that will stay with me and I just found I wanted more.

Thank you to Netgalley and Penguin: Fig Tree for the advance copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to the publishers and NetGalley for the ARe-copy in exchange for this honest review.

Unsettled Ground is about 51 year old twin brother and sister, Julius and Jeanie, who have lived their whole lives with their mother. At the beginning of the book their mother dies and we then follow how the twins' lives begin to unravel as do the secrets their mother left behind.

This is a captivating book with rich, compelling characterisation and a exquisitely constructed plotline that takes you on a somewhat uncomfortable journey, but rewards you with glimpses of breathtaking grace.

Examining themes of abject poverty, family ties, isolation and community Fuller weaves a heartbreaking tale that really doesn't spare you in its bleak spiral of one tragedy leading to another. But despite this overall the book tells a story not of despair, but hope. The stoicism of the characters is inspiring and their imperfect lives woven together in relationships built on acceptance and love portray an accurate sense of strong community.

I love the diversity of the themes addressed in Fuller's writing and her execution is always masterful, guaranteeing a good read from anything she writes.

Was this review helpful?

Powerful, sad, poignant, tragic, hopeful. This book really shows human nature at its best and worst. My heart constantly broke for Jeannie. The way she had to overcome every obstacle life threw at her and the way she and her brother were treated. This book looks at grief and poverty but also strength and resilience when life really doesn't give the twins a break.
This book will stay with me for a long time.
Claire Fullers writing is beautiful. It's my first book by this author but I will definitely be looking to read more.

Was this review helpful?

I first encountered Claire Fuller with Our Endless Numbered Days, and will someone please tell me why it's taken me until now to pick up another of her works?! Sometimes this is the problem with being a book magpie, always jumping from one new shiny distraction to another - I don't make the time to really immerse myself in any one author. I'm realising the error of my ways now. Along with Sarah Moss, Claire Fuller is a writer I really need to spend more time with.

This is the story of 51 year old twins Jeanie and Julius, who live with their mother Dot in a dilapidated smallholding. Jeanie, who was diagnosed with a heart condition at a young age, has lived most of her life within the boundaries of the family home, whilst Julius has remained loyal to the women after his father died. When Dot dies suddenly, the twin find the walls of their existence pulled down by outside forces and the secrets their mother kept come creeping out of the rubble. Their story if one of abject poverty, social isolation, and bonds being tested. What does it mean to be an outcast, even from your own history?

This book is bleak, but it is also incredibly powerful. My heart was with Jeanie as every punch life threw at her landed with sick precision, in awe of her as she drew on her scant resources to keep trudging forward. The helplessness and confusion she feels on discovering, time after time, that there is further to fall than rock bottom just broke my heart. But she is not the only fully realised character in this story - Fuller has a real talent for crafting whole people with her words, even if they're only on the pages for a short while.

Much like with Our Endless Numbered Days, this story built and built, the height of the drama and tension had me sitting bolt upright. That is what makes this book so powerful, there is a story that pulls you through so that you aren't simply left floundering in the bleakness. And there is humour here too, both in the shape of the characters but also from Jeanie's observations of them.

Not necessarily an easy read, but a very rewarding one.

Was this review helpful?

I make no secret of the fact that I’m a huge Claire Fuller fan, and Unsettled Ground gave me no reason at all to think otherwise - it’s a beautiful book.
The characters Jeanie and Julius are vulnerable people who just need someone to guide them when their mother dies, even though they are fiercely independent. This is a family that has always lived on the edge of their community - both their actual geographical location and socially. They live hand to mouth, and when Doris their mother dies, the twins have to go without food at times, when it transpires that Doris has left them with no money and debts. The cost of her funeral is the least of their problems (and they overcome that problem reasonably easily anyway).
There is a feeling that the twins are trapped by circumstance and by each other. Jeanie has never recovered from a childhood illness and is illiterate, and Julius is not only expected to look after her, but is trapped in their local area because he has severe travel sickness linked to their fathers terrible death. Their one comfort is their joint love of folk music (I wish I could have actually listened to these songs - I shall have to google them, and I hope they really exist!).
Claire Fullers use of language makes the everyday seem more lifelike in her books. I read most, if not all, of this with my heart in my mouth. How could I not? Jeanie and Julius are people who are shunned by society, taken advantage of and treated terribly. I feel I can’t leave this quite like this though: there are the good people, the ones that help.
I don’t want to spoil the story, so I’ll stop here, but what I will say is that this is another gorgeously written novel by Claire Fuller, and you should most definitely read it!
Many thanks to the publisher for providing me with an e-copy of this book through NetGalley to read and review.

Was this review helpful?

Not much happens in this book. But it's still a good read.

Two 52 year old twins live with their mother in an old and dilapidated cottage. Their father was killed in an accident and the local farmer blamed by the family for his death.

Then their mother dies suddenly and they are left alone. They end up thrown out of the cottage because of debt, and things go from bad to worse. Secrets are gradually uncovered, which throws light on the secret life that their mother lived.

A very readable book with a satisfying conclusion.

Was this review helpful?

This soulful read rips the plaster off a facade of contentment and emotional security to reveal a festering truth concealed too long.

Events corral fifty-one year old twins, Jeanie and Julius Seeder, into the clutches of uncertainty, leaving their familiar, safe little unit marooned and conflicted. As fast as they rid themselves of one problem another presents itself, making each new day a greater challenge than the last.

In environments where doubt and hostility bloom no one can predict who will wither or grow. When applied to the Seeders the potential outcome is especially affecting; as adult siblings who have never left home their ordeals are magnified tenfold. Particularly for Jeanie who endeavours, despite living with the shadow of a childhood heart condition and having to rely on others to read her letters as she is unable to do so herself.

Those on the outside of their humble, run-down cottage occasionally intervene to offer their ‘well-intentioned’ assistance, or to simply take advantage. But no one could have truly anticipated the ways an unexpected tragedy would alter the course of their lives, forever.

Unsettled Ground has its fair share of heart-wringing hardship and endearingly awkward moments. It’s also consolingly hopeful, in a kind of ‘it’s never too late’ way – although not as you may be expecting.

Was this review helpful?

Claire Fuller is an outstanding writer and that will never change. The set up of this novel was less intriguing than her other books but I did care about the characters. Maybe that's why I often found it a bleak and upsetting read, but of course that could be due to what's happening in real life right now. That doesn't change my view that this is another excellent novel from this author.

Was this review helpful?

There is something very familiar about Jeanie and Julius. So much so that I think most rural villages and towns in the UK have people a bit like them although they are a dying breed now. Often from farming stock. People who are happy with the old ways, living a bucolic existence and managing the smallholding they live on with their elderly mother. And then the mother dies and their world is turned upside-down. What many of the real- life people have that in this book Jeanie and Julius don’t is property. Their parents were tenant farmers so they have no legal claim to the land they farm or the decaying cottage they call home. There is talk of an agreement, formed after their fathers death, which they were told meant they should be able to live in the cottage rent free but like all verbal agreements, it isn’t worth the paper it’s written on. But in many ways, this is the old country way but it leaves them vulnerable to exploitation.

I was drawn into the story almost straight away and found it hard to put it down much of the time and read the second half of the book in one sitting. It did feel a little dark and depressing at times but the ending was satisfyingly bittersweet.

Music plays a large part in this book. Before the mother’s death, the three of them would spend their evenings playing music instead of watching tv or reading books so it had become a common bond between the siblings but also a source of grief. The piano which lived in the cottage for the whole of their lives becomes almost a symbol of the decay of their previous life as pianos are not easy pieces to move.

This is a book about grief and poverty and how close many of us could be to homelessness. It is also a book about resilience and how to carry on in the face of adversity. There is also a core theme that we don’t really know our family as well as we think, especially our parents but I don’t want to spoil some of the lovely twists at the end.

Scheduled for publication on the 18th March 21 and the link below will become active then.

Was this review helpful?

I thought there would be more to it. It’s a book that doesn’t give much at all. It’s just ok in every way. I don’t really know what else I can say about it really.

Was this review helpful?

*Many thanks to Claire Fuller, Penguin Genral UK, and NetGalley for arc in exchange for my honest review.*
A poignant story of 51-year-old twins, Jeanie and Julis who have to come to terms with the reality after their mother's death. Both have lived in a relative isolation with Dot for over thirty years in a delapidating cottage not far from Oxford since their father's sudden death. Jeanie has difficulty relating to people, Julius make a living doing odd jobs. The twins depend on each other, living in poverty and sharing the love for music. The day when their mother dies is the moment when they begin to uncover the truth behind some events that changed their lives.
A novel that kept me invested in and feel for both main characters.

Was this review helpful?

Claire Fuller has had a large number of plaudits, and reviews I've read of this book suggests 'Unsettled Ground' is going to be met with similar critical acclaim.

This is the story of Jeanie and Julius, 51 year old twins who at the beginning of the novel lose their mother Dot as a result of a stroke. Both of them have remained cloistered in a rented farmers cottage, but Dot's death leads them to have to interact with the world, and to deal with both their lack of finances and their mother's secrets.

Whilst I can understand the positive feedback this book has received, I have to admit I found it a bit of a chore to read. It might be because of lockdown, and the fact that there are enough sad/complex stories surrounding us, that we don't need it in our fiction. However, whilst the depiction of Dot's death at the beginning of the novel was brilliant and held great promise, the tone of this didn't remain and the characters and story didn't get under my skin, so it became more difficult to keep reading. I am sure though, that this book will do very well and will be enjoyed by many.

Was this review helpful?

Claire Fuller is one of our best writers and consistently produced thoughtful, gripping and taut novels which explore profound issues. This is no exception.

Was this review helpful?

I'm afraid I didn't care for this. I read it at totally the wrong time as there was a lot in the novel which upset me and there was just too much depressing thoughts from the novel for me. The writing is perfect though and the author is a definate go-to author for me. This book was a character driven plot and there was a lot of inward looking at families and family secrets which many will enjoy.

Was this review helpful?

Unsettled ground tells the story of Jeanie and Julius. 51 year old twins who have grown up with their mother after their father was murdered when they were 12. The story starts with their mother Dot dying. Jeanie and Julius have to learn to navigate the world without her. They quickly realise that their life wasn’t quite what they thought it was and Dot kept lots of things from them. They have to find a way to survive as best they can.
I loved this story and finished it in 2 days. Couldn’t put it down! The story unfolds in intriguing ways. I found myself rooting for Jeanie but also utterly frustrated by her.
I have enjoyed all Clare Fuller’s previous novels and this one didn’t disappoint

Was this review helpful?

Claire Fuller has written a novel that is both charming and sinister in equal measure.
When Dot dies her children, fifty one year old twins Jeanie and Julius, who still live at home, find that nothing is quite as it seems and soon find they are facing homelessness and poverty.
Jeanie can not read or write as she was kept off school for long periods of time and has always worked on the farm with her mother, and is ill equipped to face the modern world. The twins fragility and hopeless situation makes this a desperately sad novel at times but there is some respite thanks to the help they receive from neighbours and friends.
I thoroughly enjoyed this beautifully written eloquent novel.

Was this review helpful?

Stunning but bleak. Simply beautifully written with an essential perspective on poverty, family, and loneliness.

Was this review helpful?

@currentlyreading__
Book 5 of 2021

Thank you to @writerclairefuller, @netgalley and @PenguinUKBooks for the advance copy in exchange for my honest and unbiased opinions.

I read "Bitter Orange" a couple of years ago and loved Claire Fuller's evocative writing so was thrilled to get hold of an ARC of "Unsettled Ground". It was a great book with such an unusual premise of twins, Julius and Jeanie still living with their mother at the the age of 51. Their mother's death in the first few pages of the novel brings about the unravelling of their lives, where Julius and Jeanie struggle to survive emotionally and financially. Dot's secrets emerge slowly as Jeanie discovers the extent of her mother's deception. Jeanie was such a memorable character: very much protected from the world due to a heart condition, never having had a boyfriend nor being able to read or write, she truly has been hampered by her mother's influence:

‘Think of your heart like an egg. You know what happens if you drop an egg?'

Fuller writes beautifully evocative scenes and my favourites were of the garden with the hairy gooseberries and Jeanie digging for early potatoes. The garden is a sanctuary in a very uncertain world for Jeanie. A definite recommendation for this one.

Was this review helpful?

This isn't a premise that I am usually excited by. But I picked it up anyway because Claire Fuller is an incredible writer and I had high hopes of enjoying her words. I wasn't disappointed. Fuller has once again proved how beautifully she writes and how she pays attention to measured sentences and fine details in scenes.

The story follows fifty one year old twins Jeanie and Julius who live with their mother, Dot. Their rented cottage isolates them from the world, a world steeped in rural poverty. They grow veg in the garden and sell them and Julius does small jobs around the village to sustain them financially. But when Dot meets with a sudden death, their livelihood and arrangement is brought to a standstill.

I was thoroughly invested in the characters. I felt worried knowing there are two middle aged adults out there with nothing to their name except three pounds in a stocking. I was anxious, screaming in my head "how did this happen, what will they do?" Fuller approaches their trials with patience and compassion. The twins worry about a decent burial, Jeanie wonders how she can secure a job to help them both, they meet other people outside their isolated life — like Dot's friend Bridget , the person Julius has hooked up a few times with — and they are unsure how to accommodate them in their lives. The twins have their own limitations. Julius can't travel in a closed vehicle, Jeanie can't read. The book is sad but more than sadness, Fuller makes the reader go deep into the thoughts of Jeanie and Julius, making us worry whether they will manage the bare minimum. There are heartfelt scenes — like deciding whether a wake is needed, Jeanie using a public lavatory and wondering if her hair smells because she has no shampoo, the make-shift toilet arrangements. The book also evokes a familiar sense of earth and the domestic space, two aspects that are repeatedly revisited in the novel. I enjoyed this book

Was this review helpful?