Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Wallace Price is a lawyer that likes structure. He wears fancy suits, lives in a huge glass apartment, and has no time for anyone. He doesn't love, doesn't get involved, and is terribly lonely. Then, he dies.

A quirky reaper named Mei picks him up and brings him to Charon's Crossing. A Tea Shop in the middle of the forest maned by Hugo Freeman, also known as the ferryman. Wallace is tethered to this way house and is supposed to come to terms with who he was before crossing to what comes after.

The triumph of Under Whispering Door is in its characters. T.J. Klune does a wonderful job of filling a book that could sound morbid with wondrous light. The found family element is superb. Hugo is such a pure soul, you want to sit down and have tea with him. Mei is fierce and loyal. Nelson (Hugo's ghost grandad) and Apollo (Hugo's ghost dog) bring comic relief.

However, I wished there was more to the ultimate message of the book. Don't get me wrong. This book is funny and emotional, by the end of it I was so glad I was able to read this story. But, it's also a bit cliche. It's almost a collage of greek mythology, Neil Gaiman, The Good Place, and many many other references. There's a lot going on, but it's also skin deep.

I loved seeing Wallace grow, but we get little insight into his life before coming to the tea shop, aside from the uptight lawyer caricature. There's another secondary character that is revealed to have had such a profound life filled with details, and I wondered why the same wasn't done for Wallace. I know that the important thing really was about what happened after his death, but sometimes more context can bring even more emotion to a plot, and I think it would have been the case here.

Under the Whispering Door is a magically wonderful book, that will make you laugh, ponder, cry, and appreciate the tiny moments of joy in life. It's not perfect, it's not original, but it's a good time nonetheless.

Was this review helpful?

At his own funeral, Wallace realizes that he's dead. He gets escorted to a tea shop by a reaper, Mei. There he meets Hugo, the tea shop owner who gives him room and time to be ready to move on to the afterlife. But as Wallace never really lived, it's going to take him some time.

Most people are going to start reading this and comparing it to the Cerulean Sea. This is a mistake. The author might be the same, but this book deals with accepting death. As Cerulean Sea deals with children and, therefore, a hopeful future, this deals with accepting that your hopeful future is over. If it sounds painful, that's because it is, but it's a good pain.

Klune is excellent when writing characters and settings. The people are lovely. They have an infinite amount of patience when dealing with people with grief. The location is cozy and warm.

Review based on an advanced reader copy provided through Netgalley for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book is slightly different from what I’m used to reading. But it was a really well written book. I loved the overall point and theme of the story. It’s very interesting to see the main character go from a snobby jerk to someone who has to accept death or even what it means to be alive, This novel brought a new perspective to me. To appreciate what I have now when I’m alive. The love story without the novel seemed a little weird to me. I couldn’t really understand what had happened but nonetheless it was a decent book. I do believe it was drawn out a lot and could of been cut down a few pages. A lot of it seemed repetitive in a way but that was only at certain parts overall it kept me in tuned and interested in the book and that’s all that matters.

Was this review helpful?

ARC provided by NetGalley in exchange for honest review

Under the Whispering Door manages to deliver a thought-provoking story about the complexity of grief and death in a way that made me laugh as much as I cried. Once again TJ Klune created a story that had me hooked from the very first page. The characters felt so real and I loved reading both their banter and their deep conversations. I would love to be able to sit down and have a cup of tea with Hugo. Wallace’s character growth throughout the story was incredible to watch and I was rooting for him every step of the way. Everything from the setting to the characters radiated warmth and made me reflect on life.

This story was such a joy to read and I never wanted to put it down. The vibe is similar to The House in the Cerulean Sea yet it leans more towards thought-provoking than heartwarming. Though, of course, both books include elements that are thought-provoking and heartwarming. I was incredibly impressed by some of the discussions that the characters had and their ability to make me think about the topics of death, grief, and what comes next.

I don't know how much I can say about this book other than the fact that I loved it. If you are at all interested in this book I would suggest you jump in knowing as little about the story as possible. Allow every moment of this book to come as a pleasant surprise. I would say, as a note to the publisher, I felt like the plot description gave away a bit too much of the story. As someone who has stopped reading most book descriptions for fear of being spoiled, I was frustrated that this description mentioned events that happen quite late in the story.

I loved this book and I would recommend it to everyone. You will not be disappointed!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley and the publishing house for a chance to read an ARC of this book!
This is a wondrously queer, exquisitely written book! The gorgeously illustrated cover says it all! T. J. Klune is a master of words and wit even when addressing heavier topics. The prose matched with the characterization and the setting which draws the reader in from the very first page. This was an emotional and fantastical read that I couldn’t put down!

Was this review helpful?

This was breathtaking.

I’ve seen Klune’s work all over the internet, with nothing but rave reviews for his previous novel. I haven’t gotten around to reading it yet, but after seeing advanced copies available for his latest one, I had to go for it. Thank you so much to NetGalley for the EARC in exchange for an honest review!

The story follows Wallace, a man who dies. He is taken by his Reaper, Mei, to a tea shop in which he is given time to come to terms with his death and find his way onto the next phase - through the whispering door. (I got major ‘The Good Place’ vibes when reading this, which from my view is high praise indeed.) There are a mixture of interesting, complex and memorable characters featured, such as Nelson, Apollo and Hugo - but also the minor characters such as Nancy, Desdemona and the Manager made a significant impact despite only fleeting appearances.

I loved that this book somehow managed to be funny, cute, quaint, and comforting, but also heartbreaking. I got warm fuzzy feelings whilst reading, but also got my heart shattered. It’s the first time in a long time I’ve had to put a book down and have a cry. And I’m not talking about a single tear down my cheek; it was a full-on ugly cry. This is also the first book I’ve ever read with a trigger warning disclaimer at the start, which was really touching and very much appreciated.

Honestly, I can see why TJ Klune has received so much acclaim now, and I am now well and truly on that hype train. This is easily one of the best novels I’ve read all year. I can’t wait to buy a physical copy.

Was this review helpful?

This is a really pleasant, feel-good story about a dead man and what happens to him once he dies. Doesn't sound like something that should be so mellow, but somehow Klune manages it. The writing is vivid and calming even with the difficult topics of death, divorce, suicide, etc. There are a few fun turns in the story but overall, I think people will find the end satisfying. If you enjoyed [book:The House in the Cerulean Sea|45047384], you'll definitely like this one too.

Thanks to the publisher for providing an ARC through Net Galley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Under the Whispering Door follows Wallace as he experiences what happens after he dies unexpectedly at work. At his funeral, he meets a reaper who takes him to Hugo, the ferryman. Wallace finds himself living for the first time in a while, but struggles with the fact he's dead.

This was one of those books where I am constantly tearing up throughout. The experiences each of the characters went through really make them stand out and you can't help but to feel for them. Obviously, this book deals with very tough subjects including death, murder, and suicide. It also made me think a lot about how life should be lived. Wallace was such a human character. He was a pretty crappy person in life but in death he really came into his own. I will never get over sweet gentle Hugo, I just want more of him. For me, this was a 4.5/5. It was so close to a 5 but I did find the beginning a little hard to get into.

If you like the idea of living to your fullest once your dead, tea in countless flavors, or want to fall in love with at least four new characters, then this is the one for you.

I received a digital copy of this book free from NetGalley and Macmillan-Tor/Forge in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Ohhhh my heart. This book. This book.

Ok so let me say, I requested this one after reading The House in the Cerulean Sea and loving it so much, and so at the start of this one I was a bit sceptical and compared the two a lot. It felt a little similar in formula and some of the characters and I thought it was going to be very predictable. Which, let's be honest, it was. However - it sucked me in good after about a third. And then I was totally 100% in.

This is the story of Wallace. A Lawyer, and his death, and what comes next.

There are parts that crushed me. Like literally broke my heart into a million pieces and made me question why we are here on earth and how short a time it is that we get, and it made me start a small existential crisis - so keep that in mind if you are not in a good place (or if you are turning 46 while reading it). And particularly if you are grieving the loss of a loved one. If you are raw, don't go there yet.

BUT, then it also made me sooooo happy and my heart felt so full in other parts. Happy and sad tears were rife whilst reading this one. I adored all of the characters and just the way it is written - my goodness, he sure can write an amazing story. And there are parts that I think would be incredibly healing for people who are grieving (if read at the right time).

All that being said. I also feel awful even just reading or reviewing this one after the Authors comments about his inspiration for Cerulean Sea. I struggled with this fact the whole time. Can we separate Authors from their books? Or Artists from their work? I don't know. That's a whole separate conversation. All I can say is, even though I tried not to, I really did love this book. I am not a fan of the Author.

Was this review helpful?

Under The Whispering Door was a heartwarming, thought-provoking read, and I really enjoyed it! As with TJ Klune's other works that I've read, the character development and "connection" messages are really welcome and very empathetic. This work involving feelings of grief and handling life after death seems like a really thoughtful work, really processing through feelings on those subjects, and I found it relatable. I loved the humor and poignancy of House in the Cerulean Sea, and this is in that vein of life-affirming feel-good but also crying moments. After the year that was 2020, and the ongoing chaos that is 2021, this was a very welcome read and I enjoyed it thoroughly. I thought the diverse representation where it was present in this work was handled with sensitivity from this author. Thank you to NetGalley and Tor for this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

This is a delightful, funny and poignant look at death, what may happen afterwards, the memories and regrets we hold and how it is never too late to change or find love, even as a ghost.

Wallace Price is a callous, driven business man with no time for the trivial things in life. He dies suddenly from a heart-attack and finds himself witnessing his own funeral where he meets a young woman who says she is a newly trained Reaper and her first lone assignment is to help him cross to the other side (or through the Whispering Door) and on to the next step. She takes him to a tea shop where he meets Hugo and a range of very quirky and cleverly written characters both human and ghost. Parts of this are laugh out loud funny and some you almost need tissues for and you leave the last page with a powerful urge to appreciate everything in your life while you have it and take nothing for granted.

Like The House in Cerulean Sea this is easily a YA crossover.
A totally exceptional and perfect read in every way. Just loved it.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely adored The House in the Cerulean Sea last year and it was easily one of my top favorite reads of 2020. I was so excited when I read the synopsis of Under the Whispering Door - and, oh my goodness, the cover is wonderful.

T.J. Klune crafts his characters with such care, emotion, and vulnerability. I grew to love Wallace (though, admittedly, not as much as Linus in Cerulean Sea) and his growth as a character is a sweet thing to watch. The tea shop and the tea garden are an amazing little place -- how I'd love to visit one afternoon! Once again, Klune is a master at creating a setting worthy of dreaming about.

And, Klune's humor is once again right on point. However, this book deals with some heavier grief and regret and emotion than those who loved Cerulean Sea might be prepared for. I still think it's worth a read, but do be warned.

We meet Wallace as a curmudgeonly lawyer. Very quickly, we are transported to Wallace's sparsely attended funeral. And he is incensed. Luckily, his very own Reaper is there to collect him and take him on a journey. Wallace and his Reaper flash back to a couple times in his life (which I think could have been expanded a bit). This immediately reminded me of Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol and I think it was a clever twist on a classic story idea. Eventually, the Reaper and Wallace arrive at Charon's Crossing and we enter a tea shop like none other and meet some very wonderful characters. For a bit, I didn't think all the loose ends were going to tie up, but Klune brings everything together in the end.

I'm not typically of a fan of the Fantasy genre, but I consider this book to be a "fantasy-light" (I also considered Cerulean Sea this) and I quite enjoyed the believable fantasy world Klune creates.

Under the Whispering Door does not beat The House in the Cerulean Sea, for me, but if you enjoyed Cerulean Sea and Klune's writing, you'll likely enjoy Whispering Door.

My sincere appreciation to NetGalley, Macmillan-Tor Forge, and T.J. Klune for an advanced reader copy. Such a fun experience and this book will definitely be going on my library shelves in September.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a heartwarming story about life, love, death, second chances and forgiveness. Wallace, a grouchy perfectionist lawyers dies and awakes finding himself at his funeral. There are only a handful of people present, one of those being Mei his assigned reaper. She is to take him to
Hugo the ferryman. Wallace then has to decide what to do with his after life and time at the tea house. He finds himself questioning many things about his previous life, mostly how he was. He learns to make friends, find love and offer himself forgiveness all while helping others as he decides how to proceed to the whispering door. There were so many laugh out loud moments, moments of tears and huge smiles while reading this lovely book.
Thank you Netgalley and publishing house for the opportunity to read and review an early copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Wallace has always been a great lawyer. Friend, husband, person? Not so much. Suddenly he is no longer in his office though, but attending a funeral. His own funeral? When a reaper shows up to help him move on, Wallace is nowhere near ready. He hasn’t lived enough of his life. Will Hugo and his cast of characters be able to cure this curmudgeons soul?

My goodness, T.J. Klune, you have my whole entire heart. I really thought that no book would ever be able to come close to The House In The Cerulean Sea, but I have been proven wrong. This book was once again, so different from anything I have read before. Much like Cerulean Sea it is also a big ol’ warm hug that will break you and then put you right back together. I loved every character, and felt like I was sitting right there in the Tea house with them all. This book will make you laugh, cry, and then fill your cup with warmth and happiness. I’m sorry to tell you this Klune, but I’m going to need you to stop sleeping, eating, bathing, and just write because I need more Warm Hug books in my life! RUN, don’t walk to preorder this one folks!

Was this review helpful?

Having heard of TJ Klune's previous work, but not having read it, I thought I would check out the latest upcoming release since I know many people really enjoyed Under the Cerulean Sea. However, what I was not ready for was the absolute enchanting nature of this author's writing.
I have never enjoyed a book so thoroughly with no previous knowledge of it before.
This book made me cry. And when I say cry, I mean sob. The beautiful character development that Klune creates is unlike anything I have experienced before. It's unconventional because this book takes a look at death like we have not seen since Christopher Moore's "A Dirty Job". The writing is reminiscent of Moore in that it takes a view of supernatural phenomena like death and the afterlife through a new lens and makes death more approachable and understandable.
The story follows Wallace, who dies, and who we very quickly realise did not live a very fulfilling or kind life. His path through the book takes him to meet Mei, Hugo, Nelson, and Apollo at a waystation between death and the afterlife.
I'm not normally one for allegorical books, but this was a special book. I felt myself drawn to reading it and honestly plowed through it much faster than normal, despite reading other books at the same time.
I wholeheartedly recommend this wonderful read to anyone - whether you believe in something after this life or not - as a way to look at how to live your life to it's best.

This ebook was provided by NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Having read more than one book by TJ. Klune I buckled myself up for what I was about to read when I settled in to read this book. And like the others this book did not leave me disappointed at all. It was a beautiful emotional gutpunch dealing with love, death and moving on in a fantastically romantic way I was not expecting. Highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

TJ Klune must be blessed by a fairy godmother for be being able to make my day with everything he writes. Before this work, I fell in love with its work Horatio and The Extraordinary. He has owned the skill of combining comedy, charming characters, and plot to make readers feel overwhelmingly content when the book ends. And as much as I give him praise for his writing skills and the ability to make me chuckle out loud. This book was not my favorite of his but it still holds Klune's typical charm.

Wallace is a character that is constantly overworking, bitter, and overall a jerk. I loved the character development in him. But, what I really adore what seeing his interaction with all our other characters. Which many of them are extremely humorous to me.

Plot-wise this isn't the strongest. The god-like power and dimension that manages death and the afterlife can be confusing at times. I will also admit that the big climax came a little out of nowhere for me and the ending was a little disappointing. The main morals of this story are that you only live one life and embracing death since it's a step of life. And for me, the ending didn't follow up with the morals presented.

As I said, this book isn't my favorite of Klune but I would be lying if I said that I did not cry, laugh or smile during my reading. The plot might have disappointed me but nothing can be Klune charm. And since he clearly has not lost it yet, this book will get a high rating and I will still be picking up the next thing he writes. Read this book if you have been bewitched by his prior novels and want the same vibe. But it won't be your favorite.

P.S Charon is my dream hangout spot so if anyone can point me to a similar location I will forever be in your debt. Also, I'm sorry if this review seems contradicting.

Thank you, NetGalley, Macmillan-Tor/Forge, and TJ Klune for giving me this arc.

Was this review helpful?

There is so much to love about TJ Klune’s Under the Whispering Door that I almost don’t know where to begin. I feel like I’ll never be able to put into words how much this book touched me. The story is exceptional, as are the characters, themes, and messages. It’s a story that leaves a lasting impression and made me a fan of the author for life. It’s profound and touching, emotional and moving. At times, it’s laugh-out-loud funny, and other times it’s unbelievably sad – in short, it is an outstanding read that made me feel all the feels.

Filled with loss and love, grief and happiness, and so much more, this book left me in a puddle of tears but also completely content and happy. I love books that evoke such strong and varied emotions. Months ago, one of my book blogging friends talked about the power of Klune’s writing, and I must wholeheartedly agree with her.

Wallace is not a very good person. He is selfish and so focused on his career that he thinks of nothing else. Upon his death, Wallace’s spirit is taken to a remote tea shop which serves as a resting place before a person moves on. His character is so unlikeable at the start of the story, and the way he acts and treats people is unappealing. At the tea shop, Wallace meets Hugo, the ferryman who will guide him, and an eclectic cast of characters who help Wallace find his way. However, Wallace isn’t ready to move on, and as he stays at the teahouse must face his past, his reality, and what lies ahead.

Wallace grows and changes so much throughout the story. In death, he learns what is most important in life, and it is both heartwarming and heartbreaking. Other characters in the story are equally interesting, and I found myself as invested in their stories as I was in Wallace’s. Every single character, good, bad, and in-between, is compelling and stole my heart. And I love how all of their stories and experiences contribute to Wallace’s growth and understanding of the important things in life.

The found family is one of my favorite parts of this story. I love each character in Wallace’s new life and how each contributes to their family unit. They have distinct personalities and skills, and each helps Wallace in their own way learn what is most important in life and beyond. Hugo is so kind, supportive, hopeful, and understanding, and I love his quiet strength. His dog Apollo is so sweet and funny, and Hugo’s grandfather is hysterical. I love all of his silly antics and his loving way of taking people under his wing. Mei, Wallace’s reaper, is quirky, affectionate, and so funny. Even Wallace found his way into my heart, especially once he found his. Individually, these characters are well-layered, interesting, and unique. Together, they are an exceptional unit with a strong and unwavering connection.

The story examines how people cope with death, how people grieve and heal, and how people prepare for the unknown. Death is unavoidable, but everyone deals with it differently, which this book highlights perfectly. The story also explores so many deep and universal questions that I think all readers can relate to. What is our purpose? Why are we here? What comes after death? What does it mean to be a good person? Simple yet profound concepts that many people face at one point or another in their lives become thought-provoking plot points throughout the book. I love how Klune weaves these tough topics into the story with skill and honesty, creating a well-rounded, deftly layered, and unique narrative.

I adored Under the Whispering Door! It’s is everything I never knew I always needed, beautifully written, poignant, and more than I ever expected. A powerful contemporary fantasy, intricate and nuanced, it made me laugh and cry, sometimes at the same time, and it has so many wonderful layers. It’s a novel about love, loss, finding oneself, and faith. Thank you so much to NetGalley, Tor Books, and TJ Klune for an advanced copy of this brilliant book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

It is not often a book leaves such an impact on me as this book has done. I'm not sure any words I can put together will do it justice, but I will try. This story felt, to me, like a great big hug or an excellent cup of tea. It brought me sad tears and happy tears and overall captures the whimsey and magic that I love most from T. J. Klune. This heartwarming story of found family, redemption, and joy means so much and if you enjoyed The House in the Cerulean Sea you will most definitely enjoy this book. Klune has a way with character that makes me want to leap into the pages and never leave. I cannot recommend this book enough, I give it a perfect five stars.

Was this review helpful?

I never thought I'd say this, but Under the Whispering Door somehow beat The House in the Cerulean Sea as my favorite Klune book! I think particularly the reason for my heightened enjoyment/ closeness to this story is because at the time of reading this, I had a family member go into hospice. I know hospice and death are two different things, but they are closely tied to the end of one's life in different ways. Wallace's journey helped me to come to terms with this impending familial death, and I'll be in debt to it for giving me that clarity. It gave me comfort honestly in a dark period/ headspace, so I have this deeper, more fulfilling connection. Klune is truly marvelous at weaving together tough stories of the human condition/ experiences. He finds a way to reveal the truth in an otherwise extremely complicated situation. I cannot wait for more books from him.

Was this review helpful?