Skip to main content

Member Reviews

AMAZING!! This book was above and beyond anything I was expecting. It was funny, heartfelt and extremely entertaining. I loved all the characters in the book and found the story to be highly enjoyable. TJ Klune has a remarkable way of writing which makes me feel like I"m watching a movie instead of reading a book. This is one of those rare books where I'm sad I won't be able to read it for the first time ever again. I would highly recommend this book!

Thank you NetGalley and Macmillan-Tor/Forge for allowing me to read this story in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Just call me the the Grinch because I swear my heart grew a size with every chapter. This is honestly one of the most wholesome books I have read in a very long time.

It reminded me a lot of ‘A Monster Calls,’ as this is also a whimsical story that so gently and lovingly explores grief and how to cope with loss. But in the same vein as ‘The Midnight Library’ and ‘The Five People You Meet in Heaven,’ this also insightfully shows what it means to live a good life, who to live it for, and how it is never too late to make it mean something.

This is my first book by TJK, but it will not be my last. Only a special author can create a story that radiates so much heart and warmth.

Was this review helpful?

TJ Klune writes the most charming books. This one had me laughing and crying, sometimes simultaneously. I adored it and recommend it to everyone I meet.

Was this review helpful?

Wallace was hard working. Wallace was precise. Wallace was correct. Worst of all, Wallace was an attorney. Being dead did not fit into his schedule.

Instead of finishing up his tidy work at the practice one Saturday afternoon, Wallace finds himself in a little tea shop in the woods where a cheeky woman who calls herself a reaper, a calm and empathetic young man, a very enthusiastic dog and a tenacious old ghost dwell. Together, they struggle to understand death and loss and what it means to have time.

Like most books by TJ Klune, this one is not terribly exciting, but it's somehow incredibly compelling all the same. The characters are carefully woven from threads of diverse backgrounds, unique history, unexpected health and mental health conditions and believable opinions. Add in the twist of what it might be like to die and find the way to the hereafter along with a touch of hipster culture and a dash of adorable gay romance, and you get a book that's difficult to put down. There are definitely some thought-provoking scenes and a few places that are bound to make anyone cry, but overall, this is a cozy reflection on what makes a person human and what it means to really live. It's certainly one of the first things I'd turn to on a rainy Saturday afternoon, but it's not something I'll be able to stop thinking about anytime soon.

Was this review helpful?

Wallace wasn’t expecting to die. He still had so much work to do at the office. Lo and behold, that wasn’t a priority for anyone but Wallace. When he comes to, at his funeral, he’s flabbergasted to realize that no one in his life liked him. When he is brought to Hugo, a ferryman, Wallace must figure out if he’s ready to go to the afterlife as he is or if he can change for the better.
Under the Whispering Door by T.J. Klune is poignant, moving and absorbing. Klune is a master at characterization. He managed to make you hate Wallace immediately only to completely fall in love with him a short while later. Every character is so well rounded and delightful, even the cranky ones. Wallace and Hugo were so surprised by the relationship they were forming, it made me root for them. I loved this book so much.

Was this review helpful?

This book was amazing! It is a wonderfully entertaining and heartwarming story with a delightful alternative take on reaper mythology and a beautiful exploration of the stages of grief and the age old question of the meaning of life. There were time when this story was hilariously funny, beautifully heartwarming and gut wrenchingly tragic. Like House on the Cerulean Sea, this book sat with me for hours after I finished reading it. It was simply beautiful.

Was this review helpful?

Just as with “The House in the Cerulean Sea,” Kline takes the reader on a gentle excursion through, what in other hands would be a horror story, a story of growth and awakening. His beautiful prose makes me yearn to travel to the tea shop in the mountains to discover my tea, and join in joy that can be found there. Thank you Mr. Klune for sharing this story with us! I am looking forward to more from you!

Was this review helpful?

Well, T. J. Klune does it again and fills me with squishy, warm and fuzzy feelings. I don’t know how he manages to create such adorable characters, original storyline that combines reality and fantasy; he knows how to lift your spirit.
Having recently read The House On the Cerulean Sea, I had to read this as soon as possible. It was worth my 3-day readathon, I lived on basic needs only just to find time to finish this. It’s impossible to put it down once you start it, the story flows beautifully with Klune’s lovable protagonists, fun, whip-smart dialogs. Only this time he creates a bittersweet purgatory and make you question your own mortality and how you spent your limited time. Death is a difficult concept to write about and he creates a fantastic story with death in the center with such level of imagination that makes you wish it were real.
Wallace Price is a successful lawyer with little personal life until he dies and in his death, he discovers life and what is meant to be alive. Imagine the irony here. As he adapts himself to the fact that he’s actually ghost, his reaper (a paid worker of The Manager?!) takes him to a teashop at the end of the line, where all souls gather before they ascend. He has to complete his adjustment and prepare for his afterlife at this in-between shop, where Hugo, the owner and ferryman, help them with their transition. As days pass by, Wallace tries his best to accept the circumstance while falling desperately in love with Hugo and his new dead-life in the teashop.
If you enjoy fantasy fiction and loved the House On The Cerulean Sea, you must definitely read this new fast-paced novel of Klune. The ending fell a little short of my expectations, but I loved it anyway. It’s never possible to make everyone happy especially if you’re creating a universe so vast that drives reader’s imagination to the roof. Definitely recommended!

Was this review helpful?

Reflections: do you ever wonder how someone so miserable can live with himself?

Wallace is an obnoxious character whom you love to despise. How can anyone live to be SO mean? As it turns out, Wallace doesn’t live that way, and he dies.
Grab a cup of your favorite tea. Pause to wonder where the tea leaves came from, then read on about Wallace.
Elizabeth Kubler-Ross and her five stages of grief are mentioned. Wallace says “I can’t grieve for myself.” He is told, “Of course you can......Everyone is a little bit sad all the time.” You won’t be sad reading this book.
Thanks to Netgalley and Tor Books for introducing me to author TJ Klune.

I also recommend you look for The Ferryman Institute by Colin Gigl https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/1766185287

Was this review helpful?

I debated for a good while about whether to give T.J. Klune's Under the Whispering Door three stars or four. The first two-thirds of the book dragged (at least for me), and if I'd stopped there, I would certainly have given it three stars. But the last third picks up the pace, giving readers "all the feels" and leaving them surrounded by tear-soaked tissues (the good kind). Even with my doubts, I couldn't NOT care about the characters by the end of the book.

I think my biggest complaint about the book is the glacial pace at which the key romance it's built around proceeds.

Semi-Spoiler Alert: I'm not going to reveal any special moments in the plot that aren't included in summaries and promos for this book, but if you're worried about weighting your reading experience before it begins, you might want to stop here.

So, my biggest complaint: the glacially paced romance. We have one character who's gay, knows he is gay, and is comfortable with his sexuality. We have another character who's bi, knows he's bi, and is less comfortable with his sexuality than the first character, but finding himself attracted to a man isn't a surprise and doesn't really affect his reflections on his own life any more than attraction to a woman would. It's like they're signalling "internalized homophobia!" when, in fact, that isn't actually an issue.

As I said above, the last third will have you weeping a copious mix of tears, happy and sad. My advice, let yourself move quickly through the first two-thirds. You'll get the gist of things. Then settle into "savor mode" when you hit the final third.

I received a free electronic review copy of this title from the publisher via NetGalley; the opinions are my own.

[I will also be posting this review on Edelweiss and LibraryThing.]

Was this review helpful?

This was my most anticipated read for the year and it has absolutely met all of my expectations. Almost immediately, our main character, Wallace, has died and is picked up at his own funeral where he is uselessly heckling the mourners for not doing a good enough job mourning him. I was hooked from there. There is a combination of reapers and ferrymen who help the recently deceased prepare for what comes next. There is a tea shop called Charon's Crossing, run by ferryman Hugo who provides a place for both the living and the dead to come and exist without the distraction for whatever time they need.

The big question that came with this book was whether or not you think you can change once you've died. Wallace isn't supposed to be able to change for the better. He's just supposed to find a place to accept his circumstances and move on. I love his journey and the realization of what a jerk he was in life and the struggle of what he can do with that knowledge now that he's dead.

As Hugo the ferryman says several times, everyone in this book contains multitudes. It is at times funny and at other times devastating. I was honestly unsure of what the outcome would be, and I was prepared for whatever ending T.J. Klune decided to give this book because I felt that it would be chosen with care and I loved every moment of it.

Was this review helpful?

I requested this title without even reading the synopsis - not generally a good idea - because it's the author of House in the Cerulean Sea. When I actually stopped to read the summary, I got a little worried. It didn't seem like my kind of book. Thankfully, I was wrong.
Wallace Price is dead. And also an asshole. Our brief meeting with him before his death makes that very clear.
But upon dying, he is led to away by a Reaper named Mei, and sheltered in the house of a Ferryman, Hugo. Their job is to help him cope with his death until he is ready to cross over into whatever is next.
During his stay, Wallace starts to realize awful his living self was, and he starts to mellow out. Growing fond of his keepers, he starts to ignore the temporary aspect of his stay with them.
Eventually he is given a deadline to move on, and makes some drastic decisions in his last days.

I feel like the official summary, and even my own above, really don't do the book justice. Though Wallace's development is slow (it takes like 40% of the book) so much more is going on that the summary lets on.
It took a little while for me to be invested in this book, but I definitely recommend it. Klune walks a delicate line with this story, switching back and forth between characters contemplating death and moments of loveable slapstick comedy. It was somehow masterfully done.
Absolutely read this book.
~I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review.~

Was this review helpful?

Full of heart, hope, grief, humor, delicious character development and perfectly steeped tea, Under the Whispering Door is one-of-a kind. I laughed, I cried, I stayed up far too late. You don't want to miss this.

Was this review helpful?

In Under the Whispering Door, one of two books coming from TJ Klune in the next few months, we learn that it’s never too late to make your life the way you wanted it to be. Even after you’re dead.

How do I write a review of a book for which I have no words? To quote one of my favorite YA books, We Contain Multitudes, this one utterly undid me.

Wallace was a successful lawyer. He should be a success; he thought about nothing but working harder and doing better, even at the expense of those around him, including his employees. No one would ever say he was nice or friendly or compassionate or even considerate, and he didn’t care.

The next thing he knows, he’s watching his funeral. And then a reaper comes to collect him for his journey onward. Wallace is angry about being dead. He demands that things be fixed because his firm has work to do.

The reaper takes him to meet Hugo, the compassionate, handsome owner of a peculiar little tea shop. He’s also a ferryman, assigned to help Wallace get ready to cross over to his final destination. He’s seen anger like Wallace’s before and isn’t fazed, but he's determined to help Wallace reach his own understanding of the situation at hand.

But as Wallace starts accepting his death, he starts seeing his life for what it was, where he went wrong. More than that, he starts to realize the beauty of vulnerability, the power that comes from surrounding yourself with love and kindness and companionship. Is it too late?

Klune’s The House in the Cerulean Sea was my favorite book of last year and this very well may be my favorite of 2021. Moving, quirky, thought-provoking, and beautiful, it’s a book about living—even when you’re dead.

NetGalley and Tor Books provided me with a complimentary advance copy of the book in exchange for an unbiased review. Thanks for making it available!!

Under the Whispering Door publishes 9/21.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Tor Books for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

~4.5 stars. This book manages to make you laugh out loud, be whimsical, make you cry, and make you think about things on a pretty deep level and ties all those things together seamlessly. The characters had their flaws but you still rooted for them and still cared about them. I'm excited to pick up other works by T.J. Klune!

Was this review helpful?

*I recieved an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review*

Another heartwarming and magical tale from T.J. Klune! Klune has a way of writing stories with simple messages and dressing them up with magical realisim and lovable characters. Much like The House in the Cerulean Sea, we are given a protagonist who goes through profound change when he meets the colorful cast of side characters. Is it a formula? Yeah, but it works!

I will say the protagonist's character arc isn't as fully realized as it could have been (the changes felt somewhat abrupt as opposed to gradual overtime) and that's really my only nitpick.

Overall I thoroughly enjoyed this book and I think fans of T.J. Klune and The House in the Cerulean Sea will be please with this one!

Was this review helpful?

I always end up long TJ Klune’s books! I got this one from Netgalley and I had a difficult time reading it at first but eventually I got really into it. This is a beautiful story about death and what comes after. I love that Wallace gets a chance to be who he was meant to be! I think there’s a lot of good meaning to be found in this book, but excited to get it when it comes out!

Was this review helpful?

Goodness, I cried. Not like a small cry but sobbing, heart wrenching, half a box of tissues, wake up in the morning with a headache cry.

In life, Wallace is an asshole. But by chapter 2, he’s dead. His reaper, the fiercely loyal Mei, leads him to Charon’s Cross Tea Shop, where his ferryman, Hugo, awaits. Hugo’s job, in addition to running the Tea Shop, is to help the recently dead cross over. There’s Nelson, Hugo’s grandad, and Apollo, Nelson’s support dog, both also dead. These characters are all humans (and ghosts) whom I loved getting to know and would share a cup of tea with any day. Klune did an expert job of fully fleshing out these supporting characters with complex back stories of their own, right down to the mother loving dog.

But they’re not the most important part! It’s Wallace, the aforementioned asshole. This book is the story of whether his after death journey can make up for a truly terrible in life journey. And it’s gorgeous.

I like that it made me think about how we’re all cogs in a wheel, which would be depressing if we weren’t each able to make such an impact as a cog, if only we try. Take that wheel! *shakes fist* Oh! And did I mention it’s queer? Wonderfully, fabulously, delightfully queer!!!

T.J. Klune has a way of writing that feels so raw and authentic. I haven’t figured out yet if his books are for kids or adults, but I loved this one even more than the Cerulean Sea. It made me deeply homesick, and that’s a compliment.

I’ve had readers ask me for tearjerkers, and now I know this can safely be added to the list. 😭🥰

Thank you NetGalley, so much for this ARC in return for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

DNF 25%. I don’t like giving up on books, but I could not drag myself through another chapter. Disappointing. The beginning of Under the Whispering Door is drawn out. It is pages and pages of Wallace complaining and refusing to listen to anyone. It is the same conversation on repeat. I can’t imagine where the romance would begin as Hugo has little character and no chemistry with Wallace. I have read other reviews saying the novel picks up after about 50% of the book. If you have the patience, the concept is interesting if it ever gets off the ground. Good luck.

Was this review helpful?

Under the Whispering Door is the second novel I read by TJ Klune. The best way I can describe to you the feeling I have when reading this book and The House in the Cerulean Sea is to imagine putting on your coziest clothes and snuggling down under your softest blanket with a cup of your favorite warm beverage while a cool breeze drifts through your open window, setting the stage for reading a magical, heartwarming story.

Under the Whispering door the serious topics of death and grief, but it is balanced with love and joy. I recommend it highly.

I am a library paraprofessional and received an advance copy from #NetGalley. Opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?