Cover Image: Oh to Be a Gentleman

Oh to Be a Gentleman

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

This title was archived before I had a chance to download it to be read so unfortunately I was not able to read it and give feedback.

Was this review helpful?

The writing style of this book was very odd. Oddly telling, oddly stilted, oddly in need of a good developmental editor, too. The constant head-hopping proved difficult to follow, making this a very surface, telling, and unfortunately, rather boring read. It gave me no real reason to read on - no plot, no interesting characterization, weird and stilted dialogue always pre-empted by a dialogue tag. Really needed a good editor to go through it before publication

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately, I couldn't push myself to finish this book and ended up stopping around 15%. The writing wasn't my style, the characters were insufferable, and I couldn't get behind the story or plot.

Was this review helpful?

I had a really hard time enjoying this book. I was put off in the first few pages with the characters' introductions. The writing was overly descriptive and the conversation was odd. People are introducing themselves and sharing too much irrelevant information. The book follows eight people from different backgrounds and different ages as they discuss the concept of being a "gentleman." Every person is there for a different reason and has a different life experience, which we learn more about in each chapter. Overall it was hard to read and I did not really enjoy it. The biggest thing for me was honestly the writing, I did not like it so it made it harder to follow and get into.

Was this review helpful?

I’m becoming a fan of this author book. This was good. Really enjoyed this story. I will read more. Go read This now

Was this review helpful?

This is an interesting little novel that follows eight people on a cruise together. I liked the idea a lot, though the execution didn't quite work for me. I couldn't really connect to any of the characters, maybe there were too many, and that prevented me from connecting to the story as a whole. That being said, the writing was good and the premise a clever idea.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks you Netgally for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Not exactly one of my favorites for April. Its was on an ok read.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley, author Clive Morton, and The Book Guild for giving me a free arc of this book in exchange for an honest review! All thoughts and opinions are my own.
3.5 stars
The books follows eight passengers on cruise ship from Gibraltar and heading off to Barcelona, Rome, Pisa and Florence. Each came on this cruise for a different reason, but all have a common thread that has tied them together and that is the ideas on relationships. Some have gone through divorce, others have lost the communication with their partner, and others are searching for their perfect match in meaning less nights of passion. Who will be able to return to port with a new outlook on relationships and who will bring more to the port than what they left with?
This was a very quick read. The author did a great job creating characters with diverse personalities as well as interesting backgrounds. I enjoyed the different experiences these character brought to their travels. Ralph was my least favorite of all the characters! He was so self absorbed and really learned nothing from the cruise nor the people that challenged him to change. I thought Liz was such a sincere character and I hoped for the best for the next chapter in her life. Overall, I really enjoyed this novella and hope to read more books by this author!

Was this review helpful?

A Mediterranean cruise brings together 8 people from very different backgrounds together. All lone traveller, they are seated together at dinner. This short story focus’s on each of the characters in turn as we discover what led to them being aboard the ship.

I have been loving books set on cruise ships and boats recently so when I saw the setting of this story I requested it immediately. It was the kind of book that I wouldn’t say was bad but it didn’t wow me. It felt like I didn’t take much from my time reading it. We follow 8 different passengers as they embarked on the cruise. Some of them were very pleasant , real ‘gentleman’ whereas others were not so likeable. One of them in particular was pretty appealing in fact. I enjoyed following the characters as they explore the locations of the cruise because that’s what I really enjoy abut cruise stories. However, this wasn’t the main focus of the story so there wasn’t a huge amount of this or seeing them doing activities on the ship. I must admit I didn’t actually realise this was a short story until I started reading it and I think that was the main problem. We only get one short chapter with each character so some of them felt quite flat and one dimensional. You didn’t really have the time to get to know and connect with them. There was most definitely no room for character development. I enjoyed my time reading it and there wasn’t anything I really disliked but it felt flat. I think I would have enjoyed this story so much more if it was full length and offered the opportunity for lots of character development.

Thank you to Netgalley and the Publisher The Book Guild for providing me with a copy of this book or review.

Was this review helpful?

I was really intrigued by the concept of this book, and it was probably these same high hopes that ended this book for me so quickly and so painfully. I was put off by the characters, and the writing, and the overall message as well, and by the end I was just wishing for this book to be over and done with - but even reaching this mindset did not help make the ending of this book better.
Maybe it's just me who has a very different idea of what it means to be a gentleman in this world, but I could not agree any less with Clive Morton on that one. That was probably what irked me the most about this book: how, if you want to be a so-called gentleman in the 21st centruy, you will need to change so many innate things about you. How being a nerd, for example, is unaccaptable and something to be changed. When, at least my opinon, being a gentlman is about how you treat others - it has nothing to do with how you choose to present yourself.
Other than that, the writing also really annoyed me. Every piece of coversation sounded unnatural, and the characters were incredibly clichéd with the most basic sob stories as context for their actions.
Or in other words, here's my way bitchier Goodreads review: "a bunch of rich people sitting around on a cruise whining about their failed marriages, musing about the place of gentlemen in the scary modern world and psychoanalizing each other's sob stories - but make it sound like it's a speaking exercise in a language school for like intermediate english or something
(Shoutout to NetGalley for the ARC, though, and please don't hate me.)"

Was this review helpful?

I had a really hard time enjoying this book. I was put off in the first few pages with the characters' introductions. The writing was overly descriptive and the conversation was odd. People are introducing themselves and sharing too much irrelevant information. The book follows eight people from different backgrounds and different ages as they discuss the concept of being a "gentleman." Every person is there for a different reason and has a different life experience, which we learn more about in each chapter. Overall it was hard to read and I did not really enjoy it. The biggest thing for me was honestly the writing, I did not like it so it made it harder to follow and get into. Thank you for the opportunity to review!

Review Posted March 22:
https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/26213123-brittany-e

Was this review helpful?

This short story gave a concise, yet deep, dive into analyzing basic human behavior when presented with loss, whether death or relationships. A ship of 8 wildly different personalities cruises along the Mediterranean to find themselves, and learn more about the real meaning of life. Fun, easy, and eye opening to see how they learn to open to each other and learn from their past relationships on how to move forward into a fulfilling life,

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book, it is the story of eight completely different personalities coming together on a Mediterranean cruise, all trying to discover themselves, or escape their everyday lives. Each chapter is dedicated to an individual, to learn their reason for being on the cruise, what they think about the person they are interacting with and describing the trip they are taking, thoughts and feelings. Every person is unique, and the ages range from 30s to 70, with varying situations in regard to childhood, education, marriage, children.

The interactions are great and very descriptive. The underlining reason for the book, 'What is a Gentleman', is it an outdated concept? How is it now perceived by women in today's modern world? creates great discussion points.

Was this review helpful?