Skip to main content

Member Reviews

A sweet romance between two boys, a coming out , a coming of age story. It took the struggles of all young people to be themselves amidst pressure to conform and intensified it by making them public figures, member of a very popular boyband and being gay. It also explored other issues of drug use, adult manipulations. the characters were very likeable. My main problem was that it got bogged down at points with all the info about being in a popular band and those parts felt like too much/ not interesting after awhile. took from the main feels of the book

Was this review helpful?

This was everything I was looking for in a book. Boy Band Romance at its finest! I loved following the boys and watching them grow. 5 stars!

Was this review helpful?

I don’t think it would’ve been possible for a queer boy-band romance to be written any better. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and can’t wait to read it again. The story had me hooked right from the first line and kept me captivated the entire time. I also thought that Sophie and Cale did an excellent job at co-writing this book. I honestly couldn’t tell at all that it was written by two people instead of one. It was seamless all the way through and overall I thought the writing was really well done.
I absolutely loved Ruben and Zach’s romance and would honestly love reading about them more in the future if that’s ever a possibility. I loved seeing how their relationship changed throughout the book from band-mates/best friends to something more. I loved seeing the moments they had together with the other members of the band, especially at the beginning, that were lighthearted and fun with lots of laughs. Yet I also loved the more intimate moments Ruben and Zach got just with each other both when they were still just friends, to confused feelings, to more. It was an interesting evolvement that was far from perfect, but that’s just the way life is and I liked seeing the honesty in that. It truly was a slow-burn romance but honestly I thought it worked really well. It can be a scary thing coming to terms with knowing you’re in love with your best friend, and it can be even harder if you haven’t fully come to terms with your sexuality yet. I thought seeing Zach struggle with repressing his sexuality in the beginning was valuable to read about as I think it something a lot of queer people can go through.
I really loved that this book was written from a behind the scenes of the music industry perspective. I find books more enjoyable when they are more realistic and honest about things we only usually get to see from the outside. The music industry isn’t all fun and games and this book proved just that. might be a bit strange to say but i liked seeing the music industry being shown as not perfect because that’s the real truth to it. It made it easy to sympathize with all four of the boys in the band as you could tell their job wasn’t the easiest. Because the harder side of been in a band was a main point of the book it definitely made it a bit of a heavier read, but I found that I really didn’t mind that this time. Often I have a harder time reading contemporary romances that are on the heavier side but the way this one was written still made it easy and enjoyable to read. It was also really interesting to read about all of the different family dynamics each of the four band members had. No two family dynamics were the same and it was interesting to read about what the parents thought about their children being in a band, especially when that band is travelling halfway across the world for a tour.
I was surprised by all of the topics that were covered throughout the book. Like I mentioned before it was a heavier read at times, not that I thought it was a bad thing whatsoever. These topics included drug and alcohol use, eating disorders, being overly controlled by a management team, and unhealthy family relationships. Ruben was being pressured by management to stay closeted and had been for multiple years. Angel (one of the other members) dealt with a lot of mental health issues throughout the book that definitely shook me at points. Despite the heavier topic I thought the book had a wonderful and happy ending. I was really happy with the outcome of the story.
Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

It was so good. So cute. If you’ve ever liked a boyband fan fiction or liked RWRB, you’ll enjoy this book.

Relationships, love, figuring out your sexuality, and band shenanigans.


TWings: homophobia, racial stereotypes, forced closeting, eating disorders, and drug abuse

Was this review helpful?

I LOVED THIS BOOK. It made me get all the feels!
I had been dying to read this and when NetGalley gave me a copy, I was beyond happy.
This book reminded me of One Direction, and for that, I had to read it. It was everything I had wanted: romance, emotions, growing up and finding yourself. This might have been my favourite book of the year!!

Was this review helpful?

This love story was a refreshing change of a m|m love story. It wasn't cheesy and the characters were well rounded, and by the end of it I wanted them to pop out of the page.

Was this review helpful?

so good and kind of refreshing! there are not many books about boy bands these days so this was definitely SO good! the found family between all the members and the hilarious moments gosh my heart!

Was this review helpful?

A very fun read that I'm still thinking about a long time later! This is going to be huge! A must read for fans of boybands, and fans of prevailing love!

Was this review helpful?

This book was LOVELY and exactly what I needed this week. Going in, I had the expectation that it would be a light and fluffy romance - and yes, the romance is lovely, and there is definitely some fluff (not a bad thing!) But this is not a romance book as such, in that the romance isn't the main plot of the story and there are a lot of other things going on - including some heavy themes in the form of homophobia, toxic family relationships, emotional abuse and others.

Reuben and Zach are both well-rounded, lovable characters, and I loved their friendship with Angel and Jon (the other two members of the band). As a bisexual woman who only really identified the number of crushes I'd had on girls over the years once I was an adult, I really related to Zach's journey in particular. At the beginning, the book took me back to my teenage fandom years, then the creeping sense of just how wrong things are in the boys' world is well done, and by the end I was looking back in a whole new light. I definitely feel like I understand a little better why so many "teen" bands have members leave, or break up altogether, now!

Was this review helpful?

Super adorable, If This Gets Out is sweet without being saccharine and just a fun, smart read about two (famous) boys realizing their feelings for each other. There's definitely demand for this book, especially among fans of the former One Direction as well as a fair number of Kpop fans--and I expect my teen readers (and adult!) will be clamoring to read this!

Was this review helpful?

This book has been on my "To Read Upon Its Release" TBR list after reading a summary and seeing a cover photo via Instagram, and so the moment I saw this galley available on NetGalley, I jumped at the chance to request an early copy because everything about this story intrigued me so much. Besides, as a massive boy band fan, I was super excited about this concept and a behind-the-scenes look at what that recording and touring lifestyle is really like.

Here, 18-year-olds Ruben Montez and Zach Knight are two of the four members of the hit boy band, Saturday, which is one of the biggest acts in America. Onstage, the four boys are teen heartbreakers, and offstage they are just four normal best friends. However, cracks are starting to form under the pressures of fame. Ruben even confides in Zach that he's feeling smothered by their management's pressure to stay in the closet. During a whirlwind European trip, while dealing with a busy schedule and minimal supervision, Ruben and Zach rely on each other more and more as their close friendship soon evolves into romance. Though the guys decide they are ready to tell their fans and live freely, they realize that their management will never support the plan. They question how to hold on tight to what they have when the entire world seemingly wants to come between them.

I would describe this book as "Red, White & Royal Blue" meets One Direction, which means it's pretty darn close to perfect for my interests. Co-authors Sophie Gonzales and Cale Dietrich, who are masters of their craft, have created such a compelling narrative that's chock full of engaging language that draws me in from the very first page. Told in dual point-of-view, readers have the chance to get inside the mindsets of both leading men, who are equally vulnerable and authentic. Plus, Zach+Ruben as a couple are 1000% precious and adorable, and I ship them. Facts are facts. It's a fun read that takes place BTS of their European tour. I'd categorize this book more as New Adult than a true-form Young Adult because there's a tad bit of *spicy* content here, which I was totally on board with. It's a quick read, and both the characters and the book are so darn cute. This novel is completely, wholeheartedly, precious and squeal-worthy. It was so difficult to put down this book because I just needed to know what would happen next.

Was this review helpful?

This book may be deemed as a fun boy-band romance, but it is so much more than that.

If This Gets Out covers the precarious lifestyle that comes with being part of the music industry - especially while being queer like the main two characters. I was truly engrossed in reading the experiences the band was forced through and undoubtedly rooted for them. It was incredibly eye-opening to view the industry from the producer's angle rather than from the consumer's (like myself). I also enjoyed the depiction of their fans and the exploration of social media and the impacts it can create.

I feel like this book is notably character-driven. And, I wholeheartedly ADORED the characters. Each one of the main four resonated with me in some way. Their group dynamics were hilarious, and I genuinely enjoyed reading many of the scenes. This book also covers the personal struggles the characters were battling and how the overlap of their jobs affects them. The romance between the two mains, of course, is a significant part of the book. I couldn't help but occasionally feel giddy and warm inside seeing Zach and Ruben's relationship grow, and they had so many adorable moments.

In spite of everything I personally appreciated, I ended up rating it a three-star for several reasons. The main one being that I largely rate books based on my own personal enjoyment. The pacing unfortunately felt too slow for me, and I honestly felt like I was slogging through the whole thing. I also didn't end up enjoying the romance as much I had anticipated and felt mostly indifferent about it the entire time. There were also too many mundane points in which I felt underwhelmed and bored reading through. Most of the book felt like merely jumping from one interview or meet-and-greet to the next. Like several reviewers have mentioned, I feel like I would have liked this more if I was a fan of a modern-day boy band. I mean, the only boy band I seriously like is The Beatles, but I seriously doubt that counts in this context. :p

All in all, I believe If This Gets Out is not only an important read but a relevant one too. However, I felt largely conflicted about it and ended up not enjoying it as much I had liked to.

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy of If This Gets Out through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

If This Gets Put by Sophie Gonzalez and Cale Dietrich follows a very popular boy band and their struggles on the road and with a relationship amongst the group. Rueben and Zach, two friends and band members, find themselves struggling to deal with management and public image when their simple friendship starts to turn into something more. As this is happening we see the struggles of the rest of the band members, Angel and Jon, and just how little freedom these boys have within their band.

I knew I wanted to read this book when I saw the description, growing up I always had a thing for boy bands and this gave me a fun look at what could have been going on inside each of those real life bands. When you are a fan in the outside, you don’t think about the potential struggles on the inside and this book did a good job at showing what could very well have been happening. This was a really well written YA romance and I love the characters and their stories. I would definitely recommend this book to any boy band fan or anyone looking for a good YA romance read.

Was this review helpful?

Sophie Gonzales has been one of my fave authors for long. I was so stoked about reading a other book - my expectations were met and OH BOI THIS BOOK, Just all the feels, all the smiles and all the cries. The perfect coming of age and finding yourself book — incouding every damn emotion you can feel while rooting for the MCs, Ruben is my abs fave!

Was this review helpful?

Queer boy band romance?!! I'm in!

While I was born in the 80's, I grew up in the 90's/early 2000's, so I was definitely right in the beginning of the boy band craze. 'NSync>BSB. Not sorry. ANYWAYS, this is the story of Saturday, a very famous boy band consisting of four members. The chapters go back and forth between two of them which are the two characters who have a romance with each other.

The story focuses on Ruben and Zach, who both struggle within their band and not being allowed to express themselves they way they want to since they management is so strict about every little thing they do.

Things I loved:

This is a great queer story for young people. It involves standing up for yourself and being honest with yourself and the world about who you are.

I liked the relationships the bandmates had with each other.

There are distinct personalities within the band and they all support each other.

The dynamics between the two main characters and the relationships they had with their mothers.

Queer love. It needs to be celebrated more, especially involving young people.

Overcoming the obstacles involving drug use and the band's super controlling management.


Things I did not love:

It was incredibly predictable.

The writing style is very amateur.

I wished there had been a bit more humor/connection to today's teenagers.

Overall, I am glad I read this book. I do think it will be good for many young people, both queer and not. I can see it being especially popular with the creative and artistic type of people who are music lovers. I look forward to more queer novels from Sophie Gonzales and Cale Dietrich.

Thank you to Net Galley, Sophie Gonzales, Cale Dietrich and Wednesday Books for the ARC ebook in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Synopsis in two Sentences:
An extremely popular boy band that is taking the world by storm. Two members fall in love but are forced by the music label to hide their relationship and who they are for fear of ruining the image of the band.

My Thoughts:
This is written by dual authors Sophie Gonzales and Cale Detrich who are both known for queer representation in their books. This one does not disappoint. It beautifully illustrates the struggle someone may have with their sexual identity and coming out. The story also addresses the pressure many young artists deal with being thrust into the spotlight at such a young age.

This story reminded me of teen years and my obsession with boy bands. I couldn't help but think of my teenage room covered in Backstreet Boys posters and me rocking out to their music. While I never attended a concert I definitely would have been one of those screaming fans if I did.

I really enjoyed the alternate points of views between two of the main characters as each author took a character. I am not usually a big fan of co-authors because it can be difficult to pull off but Sophie Gonzales and Cale Dietrich created a masterpiece. I highly recommend this one.

Was this review helpful?

I'm such a fan of Sophie Gonzales, but I hadn't read anything by Cale Dietrich before. This author duo is the perfect amount of heartfelt and sweet and I can't wait to see what they write in the future. I went into this book expecting a fun rom-com about the music industry and secret relationships but the story ended up being lot more serious, addressing themes like drug abuse and exploitation of young musicians.

I adored Ruben and Zach (and Angel!!) throughout the entire book. Their relationship felt so real and Angel was the perfect amount of comic relief. I loved his dialogue, his relationship to Ruben and Zach, and this strong portrayal of male friendship. While I expected the book to be most about Zach and Ruben's relationship and coming to terms with their sexualities, the content had much more to do with the confines the music industry places on young performers to live up to impossible standards.

This book was such a delight and definitely delivers on the heartwarming, rom-com pitch.

Was this review helpful?

E-ARC received as part of street team
oh gosh!! where do i even start with this book,, it’s a wild ride to read in the most enjoyable way possible. it’s one of the most refreshing and original books i’ve read all year with such a realistic focus on relationships and working yourself out. i can’t recommend everyone to read this enough when it comes out in December!!

Was this review helpful?

Full Review Here: http://www.millennialbeautysisters.com/if-this-gets-out-book-review/

I LOVED these characters. They were all so human and beautiful and just going THROUGH IT. I really enjoyed how the authors were able to take something so far out there (for most of us at least...pop star dreams shall remain only that for me...but alas) and make it super relatable.

I also thoroughly enjoyed all the representation. So much going on here with mental health, self identity, sexuality, addiction, religion, ethnicity, this book really had it all and I loved it. Gah. I almost can't wait for December for more people to be buzzing about this one.

Lots of laugh out loud funny moments but some really tearful introspective moments too. I actually literally laughed until I cried and then cried until I could laugh again. Love the alternating points of view and thought it all worked well for telling the story as a whole. Zach and Ruben process the world so differently and it was amazing to be seeing the story through their different perspectives. Would 10/10 read another book / continuation from Angel and Jon's POV's as well.

Definitely one of my favorite YA romances of the year so much stands out about this one. Truly can't wait to see this one burning up Bookstagram and BookTok later this year!

Was this review helpful?

This is a fast paced novel that I would encourage high school students to read that are looking for a LGBTQ+ romance novel. The characters were relatable, despite being successful rockstars and musicians. The sub plot of another band mate struggling with addiction was important for high schools students to learn to address. The character’s showed how difficult dealing with feeling burned out is, which is relatable for busy high school students. Suitable for ages 16+.

Was this review helpful?