When I originally heard All of Us Villains pitched as a dark magical Hunger Games I was immediately intrigued and knew it had the potential to become a new favourite book. While it didn’t quite reach favourite territory, I thoroughly enjoyed my time reading All of Us Villains and recommend it to anyone looking for some villainy, a cool modern magic system and disaster teenagers just trying to survive.

The magic system of this book has interested me since I first heard of it. This book takes place in the modern world imbued with magic. Spells are bought and sold in department stores and kept inside jewellery until they’re cast. I just think this is such a cool concept and I loved learning more about the magic system and lore of this world as the story progressed. In particular, I loved the exploration of family and tradition and the beginning of breaking the cycle through our competitors.

All of Us Villains has four POV characters and I enjoyed reading from them all, though I definitely had my favourites. Each character had a distinct voice and motivations and I loved getting to know them. The characters are all morally grey and all struggle with their own villainy which was really fun to explore. The war between duty to family and this role they’ve been raised to fulfil and their own morals and desires was really well executed and I could sympathise with all of them. There was also an enemies / rivals to lovers romance which I adored; it brought new dimension to this struggle between duty and free choice and upped the stakes for the characters.

This book kept me hooked right from the beginning and didn’t let me go. All of the characters, the competition and the intrigue were so enthralling that all I wanted to do was find out what happens next. Not knowing who the characters could trust and knowing that they each had the capacity to turn on each other at any moment had me on the edge of my seat.

I highly recommend All of Us Villains, especially if you love explorations of morally grey characters, cool magic systems and a bit of a thriller element in your fantasy. I can’t wait to see what happens next!

I dnf'd this book because I just wasn't enjoying it and wasn't really invested in any of the characters so I didn't really feel for them.

Many thanks to the publisher & author for letting me review this!

This was sold as a morally grey hunger games, and definitely fit the idea. The storytelling was vibrant and the worldbuilding interesting. However, I didn’t connect much to the characters. But the action was perfect so I’ll definitely be reading more in the series!

I ADORED this book. The suspense, the world building, the characters, everything was just so beautifully done and left me on the edge of my seat as I had no idea what was coming or when it was going to develop. The only critique I had was that the villains didn't actually seem as villainous as I was hoping- I was genuinely expecting a lot more evil and underhand tactics instead of a bunch of teenagers who want to change their fate, however, I still thoroughly enjoyed every page and loved how atmospheric and easy to follow everything was. I can't wait for the next installment!

In the city of Ilvernath there is a tournament every generation during the Blood Moon. Tied to a curse, this tournament has been happening between 7 families of the city, for the prize to control a spring of coveted high magick. Each family sends a young champion and to win they must kill each other. The tournament was not known to the rest of the world until now...

A narrative full of villainy (pun intended), a whiff of the macabre and sarcasm, with a sense of foreboding that turns to outright danger, all wrapped up in melancholy. Elaborate and to the point descriptions embellish a captivating mythology. Undoubtedly the authors' imagination is a thing of wonder as they build this intriguing world.

Presenting multiple POVs where each has its own distinct voice and you get not just a taste but the whole meal of what the character is going through. Showing the worst in people but also the best. You feel for them even when they are being ruthless and that makes it nearly impossible to decide who to root for.

There is a lot more going on than just the tournament, more depth to the story and I like all the twists and turns. Despite the intricacy it is so comfortable to read. It is gasp-worthy and well-paced. Though there are decisions that are made by the protagonists that seem to not make sense or are out of character and the rules of the magic system are sometimes confusing and inconsistent.

Exemplifying the don't judge a book by its cover phrase, or in this case someone by their reputation. You encounter glimmers of hope plus delicious darkness in this story that keeps surprising you.

Bravery against odds is the main ingredient of this intriguing beginning to a new series.

I was sold on this book as soon as I read the description and it did not disappoint. The first half felt slow to set up the tournament and then I realised this is a series and flew through the rest of the book.

I loved the history we got of the main characters and the love they have for their friends and siblings was the bright spot in some truly awful families.

I am beyond excited for what will come in the next book because the cliffhangers for each character were brilliant.

This book was SO good.

I love a good villain, so it would have been weird for me to not love this book. Especially Alistair. This book could have been entirely Alistair's point of view and I would still have loved it (he's SUCH a good character), but the multiple perspectives in this novel work so beautifully together. I loved getting to see how different moments in the book affected different characters as greatly as they did and how it affected them going forward.

This book was a surprisingly easy read and I am DESPERATE for answers after that ending. And I just want more Alistair Lowe to be honest.

For many years, every twenty years the Blood Veil descends and the seven powerful magical families of Ilvernath each offer a Champion to take part in a battle to the death to decide which of the families will control the supply of High Magick for the next two decades. It is a curse that all of the families are tied to, and some of the competitors taking part are eager for the chance to prove themselves in combat, while others merely hope to survive. But this year something is different - the curse is no longer a secret, as a book has been published telling the world about the contest, and all eyes are on the seven participants. It has become political, more of a media circus, with more outside interest and into this much more complex arena the seven champions must compete.

Fans of the Hunger Games and the Maze Runner series will enjoy this book, which is suitable for young adults (although at the older end of the scale given the bloody violence and bad language throughout the book) but has plenty to keep older readers gripped too. The characters are distinct and memorable, each of them with their own complicated reasons for behaving the way that they do, and I am really looking forwards to reading the second book of this (two part?) series. I really enjoyed it.

With thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for a copy of this book in return for an honest review.

First of all, I don’t know how to properly express my feelings for this book because it blew me away. I kept putting off reading this for some reason and I really wish I hadn’t because I was addicted to this story and the characters!

‘Monsters couldn’t harm you if you were a monster, too.’

Set in Ilvernath, All of Us Villains is told from the perspective of four teenagers, each chosen to represent their family in the tournament. Every generation, at the Blood Moon, one child from the seven magick families of Ilvernath competes in the tournament to decide which family has control over the remaining high magick in the world. These children have to fight to the death, but some of them know each other, and some used to be friends, so tension is high. Up until the year before, the only people that knew about this tournament were the seven families, but the release of a tell-all book gives the whole world an insight into the goings-on of Ilvernath.

‘Day and night, Ilvernath would remain a haunting crimson until all but one of the champions were dead.’

Alistair, Isabel, Gavin and Briony are our protagonists and they each have their own issues to deal with outside of the tournament. Pushy families is a major issue in this novel. The authors have written an incredibly immersive story with detailed characters and you will just easily get sucked into the story and the action. We find out each families champion as the characters do and we get to see their reaction to the champions.

‘In a choice between staying here or going home, I’d still choose here. With you.’

Once the tournament begins, alliances are formed, almost bordering on friendship. But all champions know that when the time comes, it will all come down to one victor. Not all of these characters want to compete in the tournament, and one even believes there might be a way to end the cycle and the spell of the tournament. There are many twists, turns and betrayals in this book and you don’t quite know who to trust. Whilst the book is called All of Us Villains, these characters are almost pawns to their family’s history. Some characters have their morally grey moments, but at the end of the day, they are just teens trying to survive.

‘Slaying me was supposed to be your ultimate act of victory. But I’m not your monster. Or your trophy.’

One thing to be aware of is the major cliffhanger at the end of this book. I am in desperate need of the sequel, although it won’t be out for another year! All of Us Villains totally impressed me and I think it is sneaking into my top 10 of 2021 last minute. I didn’t want to be specific with the characters in this review as I think it’s something that should be experienced! Absolutely adored this book!

Evil Magic? Check
Tournament of Death? Check
Amazing Character Development? Check
Morally Grey Characters? Check

All Of Us Villains is a dark fantasy following seven champions as they compete in a deadly tournament called the blood veil, that takes place once in every generation, to give their family total control of the most powerful magic there is.

I have taken a star off because I felt like the plot didn't pick up the pace until half way through the book but overall this was a fab read.

Rating: 3.5/5

Firstly, the magic system was original and pretty well developed. However, the world wasn't.

Things pertaining to the tournament were really well done, and the dark atmosphere was well crafted. Beyond that, Ilvernath could've used some development.

We don't know the time period in which the story is set, which makes imagining the town a little tricky. There were these Knockturn Alley-at-night vibes prevalent throughout, but then time and again, the mentions of cameras, paparazzi, and a few other instances of technology being used were like a slap in the face. This made the world less immersive.

Almost all of the characters were well developed, but it wasn't easy to connect with and to care for a lot of them. I think Alistair is the only one I genuinely adore.

The pacing of the book was really weird. I like it when things are given some time to develop. This itch of mine was satisfied in the first half of the book. We follow our characters through the fortnight leading up to the tournament for 50% of the book.

However, the tournament arc itself, which spanned around at least a month and a half (most probably), was dealt with in the next 50%. We simply jumped over weeks. The authors simply told us that a week had passed. We did not see most of their interactions, and we did not witness their bonds actually forming, which made the friendships lose their authenticity. There was just one couple that I was rooting for.

And there is not even a lot of action during the tournament. Most of it is just talking. Where The Hunger Games was gruesome and bloody, All Of Us Villains is a children's story in comparison.

The book is marketed as Hunger Games with villains. But there are probably only one or two morally grey characters. I expected some more cruelty and darkness. Some more villainy.

The ending was a hit for me, though. I did not see the last segment of the book coming at all.

For me, this was not a mediocre book, but not exceptional either.

Even though the book had some issues, the entertainment factor is really high.

We could have had a diverse cast of characters and a little more villainy and bloodbath. If you have characters that you claim are villains, I definitely am disappointed when most of them are actually goody-two-shoes who are here against their will.

I am really looking forward to how the story proceeds, though, and I am looking forward to picking up the sequel when it comes out next year.

I have just sat pressing next page on the kindle several times while my brain caught up & realised there was no next page! Now I NEED the next book. I'm not normally a fan of a cliffhanger but actually it worked really well here & has definitely left me wanting more.

I did struggle at the beginning to get in to the story, I like that it flipped between characters but there was a lot of build up to the action at the start because there were quite a few characters to get to know. Once the tournament started I was hooked & couldn't decide who I was rooting for as the characters all have something going for them. This is where the different perspectives really worked as you could see the outward impression they were giving off versus what was actually going on in their heads.

As I said before, I want more.

The world of All of Us Villains is very similar to ours: they have modern technology and all the discoveries and inventions we do but they also have magic. Spells can be bought by anyone and used to ease daily tasks. Simple magick cannot do much and high magick is believed to have been used up, until an anonymous source publishes the story of the seven families of Ilvernath, who sacrifice one of their own every generation to try and gain control of the high magick that remains. I absolutely loved the concept of this Hunger Games-esque trial happening in a world with gossip columns, journalists, tourists, and the effects of the media. It’s such a refreshing twist to a story like this and I don’t think I ever stopped being surprised by the mention of magic and an airplane in the same sentence. I also loved the way the government gets involved in this centuries old curse, which is definitely not something I’ve seen done before.

The story begins a few weeks before the tournament is set to begin and we get to see the perspectives of four of the seven champions as their prepare for the Blood Veil to drop and the three-month long contest to begin, knowing only one of them will come out alive. Alistair Lowe is the champion for the current rulers of Ilvernath, and everyone expects him to win as most of his predecessors have done before him. He was raised by his family to be the monster in night, the villain and not the hero, and he is determined to win so he can get away from it all and be reunited with his brother, the only bright thing in his world. I loved Alistair, and would have happily read the entire book from his point of view – though I know it wouldn’t have worked for the type of story being told.

Unfortunately, I can’t really remember the names of any of the other champions, because their chapters all felt quite similar – each trying to use their new fame to gain the advantage, and having family drama. It took quite a while to build up to the tournament, and when it did finally happen I again found it all to be a bit repetitive and I admit to skimming certain chapters – I guessed a few of the twists and intentions of the characters so I just wanted to get to the reveals. I will admit there was one final twist I didn’t entirely anticipate which did have me interested, and I really enjoyed the idea of change that the book deals with. However, I also didn’t realise that this book was the first in a series, and so where I was expecting some sort of resolution the ending came as a bit of a shock, and left me feeling a bit disappointed.

Overall, I still really appreciate the concept and the convoluted character relationships that form throughout the narrative, but I didn’t quite feel like the book was saying anything much and it just seemed a little bland. I have seen a lot of people praise the book, and I’m sure many will enjoy it, so I do still think it’s worth picking up by anyone who is piqued by the blurb, but it just wasn’t a standout read for me.

The mix of The Hunger Games, a bit of Harry Potter (especially Twizard Tournament), and kind of teenagers and families feuds in one book. Sound great? Yeah, but not for someone who hates The Hunger Games, unhealthy competitions, and vibes "kill or be killed".

I read it, finished it, but I felt tired and overwhelmed by the plot, characters, and their problems. I expected to find some adults in here, not the young adults who are going into life. Their insecure, sometimes, and complicated feelings to cope with, was hard to go through.

Was this book good? Ok, it is nice written - if we talk about the style, it is totally fine. But the idea, the characters, the events - I felt like I've already known all of that. Not really surprising, predictable, rather boring. I expected so much more.

https://lynns-books.com/2021/12/06/all-of-us-villains-all-of-us-villains-1-by-amanda-foody-and-lynn-herman/
My Five Word TL:DR Review : Took its time, but then…
4 of 5 stars

All of Us Villains turned into a book that I really enjoyed. It did take me a little while to become invested but slowly but surely it worked it’s magic.

For me, and yes, I can see where all the Hunger Games comparisons come into play, this is a strange meshing of a few concepts that actually succeeds in standing on it’s own two feet. Similar to Hunger Games this book contains a tournament to the death, similar to Red Rising the participants form allegiances and teams but, uniquely, rather than the contenders rushing for supplies and weapons they instead fight over magical landmarks and relics.

This is a book set in a world of magic – think low and high magic. Most people can perform low magic which is pretty basic and non threatening. High magic, conversely is much sought after and for centuries seven ruling magical families have fought tooth and claw for the privilege of wielding it. The tournament is a curse, once it starts seven champions will fight to the death, the last person standing will gain the right for their family to wield high magic for the next twenty years. It’s almost like throwing seven students straight out of Hogwarts into the mix and see how they fare chucking unforgivable curses at each other.

The setting is a remote place called Ilvernath. For centuries the tournament has remained hidden from the rest of the civilised world, until an anonymous author wrote about the tournament and turned the place into a media circus. Most people are shocked by the brutality of the contest, although little can be done to divert the course of the curse, and there are certain government agencies who are definitely interested in what takes place in this small village every twenty years. You may ask why every twenty years – it’s certainly a long time to wield such power after all, I think that aspect is more about logistics, after all you have to wait for each of the seven families to have had sufficient heirs to be able to choose a viable contender.

There are a number or povs to get on board with but I think the authors do a really great job of bringing each character to life with their own personalities and traits.

Central to the plot is Alistair Lowe (whose family wins the tournament two out of every three times). The Lowes are disliked intensely. They have created a dark and menacing aura around themselves and raised their champions ruthlessly to think of themselves as the monsters of the story.

Isobel Macaslan was surprisingly named champion for her family over a year before the contest was due to start. This was an unexpected development that occurred at the same time as the release of the anonymous book leading many to point the accusatory finger in the Macaslan direction. Isobel, however, has risen to the challenge well, Beautiful and accomplished in terms of magical ability she uses the media attention to her advantage.

Briony Thorburn used to be best friends with Isobel but the two no longer speak – I don’t suppose entering a tournament to the death engenders such friendly connections (difficult to curse to death your bff after all).

I won’t highlight the other contenders. Suffice to say that some of them are more favoured than others and these different expectations drive the story here as each strives to even the odds.

In terms of criticisms. I think the story takes a little time to establish itself so be patient. There is a feeling of depth to the place and the history behind the contest, plus all the vying for position which takes a little while to set in place. I think I was a bit keen to get to the tournament to be honest but you can’t rush these things. Also, the title, ‘All of Us Villains’ – for me, I think All of Us Victims might be more appropriate. I mean, at the end of the day everyone treats the champions as though they’re blood thirsty maniacs but each of them knows they are entering a contest to the death – there is no two ways around it. Fight, or be killed. If it was me – I’d be failing all the magical lessons just to ensure I wasn’t champion – imagine growing up knowing that come your late teens you could enter a contest that there is no walking away from. So, villains or victims?

Anyway, all in all, slowish start notwithstanding, I enjoyed this. It’s a great concept and given the ending I think it has the capacity to develop in very interesting ways and I look forward to reading more.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks. The above is my own opinion.

My rating 4 of 5 stars

Like many people, the idea of this book - The Hunger Games with magic - REALLY excited me. Especially as it was also advertised as having strong LGBT representation.

First of all I found the setting/time of the book quite confusing. It seemed like a magical medieval type setting but then would mention cars and school lockers other modern things. I know there's magic but it just seemed strange that the champions wouldn't use any kind of modern tools and techniques in the tournament. It was just a bit confusing.

The style of the book is multiple point of view characters which is a style I personally really enjoy. It allows the reader to really get into the minds of the characters and understand what makes them tick. Of course with this being a book about all the PoV characters trying to kill each other, this meant that nobody was safe! There is a real risk of the reader getting close to a character and starting to love them just to have them brutally ripped away from them! That's my kind of book.

Now, although the book is about a murder tournament, it doesn't actually start until about halfway through the book and then when it does begin there are exciting moments but overall is just kind of a bit limp...

Most of the characters talk a good talk about killing the others and being "villains" and "monsters" and then as soon as it is time to put the money where their mouth is, they're kittens. All bark and no bite.

I was expecting some strong LGBT+ elements but there was pretty much nothing. One hinting sentence and that was it. The "love story" was your standard YA opposites attract boy meets girl yawnfest.

There are positives however! The writing style is smooth and easy to follow so it was an easy read. The idea of the plot is great and the magic system is really interesting - especially the system used by Gavin Grieve in the latter half of the book. It is very much a young adult book and I think many young adults will love this and it may well be a great competitor in the genre.

Thank you very much to Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with an eARC in exchange for an honest review

I am attempting to write this little review while things are fresh in my mind, but I am struggling because I am replaying the last two or 3 chapters because, the end...
I- How coul- Wait, what? Well, s- !
These are all things I have said out loud while reading just the last 4 or 5% of a book I have very much enjoyed and would like more of, please.

I hate spoilers, I never look for, or read, reviews myself (just give me a blurb!!), so I will keep this brief so you can wonder into Ilvernath blind, just like I did, but I will say that its wonderfully written, with a rich, well thought out, history and lore that truly gives the depth needed to solidify the characters thoughts, feelings, and actions, making the time I spent with our 4 (main) characters fantastic.
I love them all, even the ones you think maybe you shouldn't, and you feel for them. Their desperation, their fear, their need and desire, and their villainy.

I am hoping book 2 will be out within the year, and while you wait, read this one, maybe read it again to convince yourself you just didn't see that coming because, how? What does it mean? And, why?

A solid 5-star read, All Of Us Villains is available now - go forth, treat yourself, and your villainous friends and family!

When I saw the description of this book, I knew I had to read it. I absolutely adored The Hunger Games and so when I heard this book was like a high-fantasy version, I was already sold.

When I started reading, I wasn’t too sure if it would be for me. There were a lot of different characters to follow and I struggled a little bit in keeping at track at first. However, when I got into it, I found it such a fantastic YA fantasy story! It had purpose, a great cast of characters, and real direction. I already can’t wait to read the sequel!

I love a good villain as they are always the best characters and so was so excited to get to read this book!

The characters were so well written, the story grabs you and doesn't let you go until the end and then you will scream.

I am a big fan of Amanda Foody, so it’s no surprise I enjoyed this book. No book is perfect, unfortunately, and I do have a few comments. Let’s jump in!

Characters – 7/10
We follow four points of view in this book, which in my opinion is a bit excessive. I enjoyed two out of the four, mainly Allistair and Isobel’s POVs. They can both step on me. I really enjoyed them as characters and I was really invested in their dynamic. Their character development was chef’s kiss.

Unfortunately, I didn’t enjoy Briory and Gavin’s POVs as much. Gavin kind of annoyed me and Briory really has a hero complex. However, I wish we could have stuck with Allistair and Isobel. Their POVs just grabbed me from the beginning and I need more of their stories.

Atmosphere – 8/10
Foody and Hermann didn’t pull any punches with this one. Sometimes with YA fantasy, the authors are all talk and no bite. They claim their stories are dark, but really they’re not. Not All of Us Villains. I was really surprised at some of the events that transpired, and it made the book’s atmosphere and characters even better. After all, they’re supposed to be villains.

The atmosphere was dark and broody. “The Hunger Games but with magic” is an apt description. The authors really nailed the tone. I also found the worldbuilding to be very refreshing. The book is set in a modern world with magic and I just love that mashup.

Writing – 8/10
It’s no surprise that I liked the writing. Foody’s first book, Ace of Shades, really pulled me in and I fell in love with her style immediately. I was drawn into the story and at some point, I couldn’t put it down. This book has a great premise and setup, I need the second one asap.

Plot – 7/10
The plot has a lot of moving parts but it was fairly easy to follow. However, I did find myself wishing that it had taken a different turn here and there, but let’s chalk that up to how amazing the character and worldbuilding is.

Intrigue – 9/10
The magic system in this book is awesome. I love the way it fits into the world and how the world is built around it. Hard magic systems are always my favourite, especially when characters break the rules of those hard systems. Additionally, I also loved the theme of stories and fairytales. The way Allistair told his stories just made me fall more in love with him.

Logic – 8/10
The title of the book definitely applies to all of our characters. Additionally, they all have shades of grey and I love to see it. I want them to get mad and get revenge. I can’t wait for them to spiral further out of control in the next book.

Enjoyment – 8/10
In conclusion, this was a fun book. If you’re looking for an urban fantasy-ish read with magic and murder, this is the book for you.