Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Ooof.

Was super excited to read this book after reading babbel.

Ms. Kuang, did not come to disappoint.
A story surrounding someone who is essentially a culture culture, and profits from exploiting someone else’s heritage.

Both Athen and June were terrible. Definitely had a weird symbiotic-ish relationship. Athena definitely got an ego boost.
A good read to get out of a reading slump

Was this review helpful?

For weeks after reading Yellowface, the only thing I was able to verbalize to my book-loving friends was - MIND. BLOWN. I needed to sit in my feelings and digest many different aspects of this story. This was a deceivingly quick but deeply uncomfortable and multilayered read that left me thinking - is there any writing style/genre exploration Kuang won't dare try (and incidentally completely CRUSH)? Additionally my first impression was a certainty that yes, without a doubt this book will be popular and successful but beyond that it will polarizing and most definitely talked about.

When she witnesses her super successful writer friend Athena Liu die, Juniper Song's first instinct is to grab her unpublished manuscript about unacknowledged roles of Chinese laborers in WW1. What follows is Juniper's journey of trying to hide her secret while navigating newfound literary success which comes at a cost.

Though the story is full of unlikable characters and deeply uncomfortable topics, on occasion I still found myself (quite involuntarily and pretty sure as a result of a skilful literary manipulation) rooting for Juniper not to get caught. Gasp. One of my favorite things about R.F. Kuang's writing is that she doesn't dumb things down for her reader. She just leaves you to ponder seemingly endless number of complex topics. Not just about identity, race and representations but who decides what is appropriate, in literary world, in (social) media and in life in general. These intricacies really resonated with me because it's quite similar in the world of social justice - not only are we constantly attempting to challenge and change the existing system but there is also an internal system of "rating" and judgment of what and how you are supposed to be.

This story will make many readers uncomfortable but explorations of racism and systems rooted in inequality and propped up by white supremacy are MEANT to be uncomfortable. In words of R.F Kuang "If reading it feels a bit like watching a train crash in slow motion, then I’ll have done my job." If you want a read that will take you for a loop, make your head spin and leave you thinking about it for a long, long time, then this is a book for you. I thought it was beautifully written, well thought out and truly impactful. Another one for the ALL TIME FAVORITE READS shelf.

Just a note for those who are fans of Babel and The Poppy War trilogy - this book is a completely different beast, so keep that in mind when diving in.

Immensely grateful to NetGalley and HarperCollins UK/The Borough Press for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

This was SUPER fun to read and must have been extremely fun to write. Deliciously bitchy while also really smart. I like how the book is complex and nuanced - Athena is not a flawless character. Overall, this would be a great book for book club discussion - it's easily readable in a day.

Thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I cannot adequately say how much I enjoyed this book, which deals with the ups and downs of friendship as much as being a frenemy and the repercussions of doing what you want. Athena Liu is a literary wunderkind, her work celebrated and critiqued the world over, but her friend June Hayward is not so much on the literary periphery as banished to the back of the bookshop. No one wants to read what June has to say and she’s achieved modest success (very modest). When Athena dies in an accident, and June is there, she makes a split second decision… and steals her friend’s unpublished manuscript. It’s not long before June’s new book – now written as Juniper Song – is making headlines and she is a star. But not everyone is convinced of June/Juniper’s greatness, or talent, let’s be honest. When success is stolen, is it really that sweet? You’ll be surprised by the novel’s twists but it’s a great read and one that’ll stay with me this year.

Was this review helpful?

An insightful delve into the world of publishing, which is always interesting to any bibliophile. Absolutely loved it and raced through it. Brilliantly written with excellent character build and development. A must read!

Was this review helpful?

I did not know what to expect from Yellowface but I was not expecting to love it quite so much.

The book follows June, who after her ‘friends’ death, steals her latest manuscript passing it off as her own. The continuing story spirals out of control.

The story takes a look at the very dark aspects that can sometimes crop up on social media. It also gives a great look at the publishing industry which is really enlightening.
But also delves into mental health and loneliness.

Honestly there is just so much to love about this book.

Was this review helpful?

June and Athena were both Yale students and both dreamed of becoming writers, though only one of them really succeeded.
June is quite jealous of Athena, but they have kept in kept touch and during one of their catch ups, they go back to Athena’s flat, and June witnessed her death.
This spirals in June stealing the manuscript Athena was working on, and publishing it as her own. What would the Chinese community make of it, since June doesn’t have any Chinese heritage? At some point, June even believes she is victim of reverse racism.
What a brilliant read, this is satire at its best touching so many topics: from racism to cultural appropriation, diversity in the publishing industry.

Was this review helpful?

Yellowface follows June Hayward, a struggling author, from the moment before and after she steals the work by her fellow author, and behated friend, Athena Liu. You follow June as she struggles emotionally and morally with her choice, how she tries to internally argue that it isn’t theft but rather a way of bringing Athena’s work into the world — bettering it as it hadn’t been finished before Athena suddenly died.

It’s an interesting exploration of human nature, how we try and rationalise obviously bad behaviour and decisions, and how easy it can be to continue with a lie when there is a safety net all around the colour of your skin. June does not, at any point, outwardly say that she stole it but there are moments where even the publisher must have doubts and instead of questioning her, or outright removing themselves from her, they aid her by having her seem ambiguously Asian. Yellowface also explores the publishing industry, how ruthless it can be and how certain aspects of it absolutely disregards what is morally correct as long as there is a monetary benefit — I don’t know much, or anything really, about the publishing industry but I imagine it’s pretty accurate.

I think, as a white person, that this book was an interesting example of how white people can have a tendency to see marginalised people as a threat when they have even an ounce more visibility than a white person. There are continuous comments by June Hayward, and other white characters, on how marginalised people have it easier and that it’s hard to be white in the industry as “you are just like everyone else”. You don’t stand out. You aren’t interesting. But, and Kuang makes a point of this, marginalised people are just seen as their ethnicity and not as a person and that’s pointed out several times in the book. It’s a very on point commentary, as I’ve definitely been witness to this rhetoric from fellow white people throughout my life and I know some people feel that Kuang is very on the nose with a lot of these comments. I don’t really think so, I think it’s just pretty accurate.

Of course Yellowface is also, at times, an exaggeration. The characters seem like caricatures at times and they are very very expressive in their behaviour which seems almost comical. But sometimes to get your point across, that’s just the way to go. I thought it was a fun aspect of the book and it made for an intriguing book — you’re stuck to the book, turning each page, waiting to see if June Hayward will be exposed or if she’ll get away with it all.

I’m blabbering on, but I REALLY did enjoy Yellowface and I thought it was an interesting book. It’s nearly midnight as I write this review and I’m half asleep here, but you gotta get your thoughts on paper when you’ve got them lmao so yeah, Yellowface is a great read. The only thing I didn’t particularly like was the ending. It happened too fast, it was too abrupt and that’s a shame. But otherwise, I enjoyed every moment I spent with the book.

This was the first book I read by Kuang, but it is definitely not the last one. I already have Babel sitting on my shelf, so I’m interested in seeing how her writing is in that versus this one as I know this one is a lot more “accessible” in its prose.

Was this review helpful?

Such an intriguing read – the ethics of whether The Last Front, the fictional book that protagonist June Hayward/ Juniper Song publishes, is truly her work given that she stole the first draft from a deceased college mate, are so grey they might as well just be black. And yet I could not stop reading how June tries to convince herself that her actions and subsequent consequences that then snowball are justifiable. R.F. Kuong expertly weaves June’s paranoia that she will be discovered with the modern juggernaut of social media and “cancel culture”, which all feels incredibly current and of the moment. Not being a published author, I don’t know how realistic the depiction of the publishing industry and associated processes are, but what did ring especially true for me was June’s addiction to the spotlight and accolades. Not an especially sympathetic or likeable character, there are some seriously questionable ethics around cultural appropriation and also her theft of ideas. This really reminded me of Beautiful Creature, with June living a life not really hers and unearned. I had the same feeling of discomfort at the plot and June’s dependence on people’s approval here but just engrossed as I wanted to find out how she could possibly get herself out of the giant sinkhole with minimal destruction. The book left me hungry for more R.F. Kuong with her smart and assured writing style and even more convinced that life as a writer is not for me…

Was this review helpful?

I love books about the inner workings of publishing, as I think most people who are involved with publishing do, and this idea is *perfect*: it's about the plagiarism scandals that have rocked the book community for years, crossed with the conversation about racism in publishing, cultural appropriation, and who can authentically write stories rooted in specific identities and cultures. It's a tough read - the protagonist is consistently awful, very openly racist both specifically and generally, and you're certainly not rooting for her but I definitely wanted to find out how it was going to end.

Was this review helpful?

I’m a little torn about my feelings towards the book. Had it come from a new writer, I would have thought it was really interesting and a bold story to put out there. However, as the book was written by R F Kuang, I’m a little disappointed. I thought the book would be more. Having read Babel where I had to take moments to just sit with what she’d written, I expected this to be another literary genius. There’s nothing wrong with the story but it just feels lacklustre compared to her other work. I also don’t care for pop culture references. The ending was the most frustrating. I checked twice to make sure that was all there was. It was unsatisfying. Thanks NetGalley for the advance copy.

Was this review helpful?

R. F. Kuang has some it again. Like with her previous books, I could not put this one down. I’m convinced Kuang can write a book in any genre and it will be a hit. A necessary book which reflects on the publishing industry

Was this review helpful?

There aren't enough words to describe how much I enjoyed this book!

Like all of Rebecca F Kuang's books, it's insightful, eye-opening and a must-read.

The book follows two friends who are writers, June Hayward is a lecturer and struggling with getting their work published, Athena Lieu of the most successful writers of the time. They meet for drinks and whilst it's clear that there is jealously from the success of her friend, June finds she can't end her friendship with Athena. Then suddenly, Athena dies and June runs off with the manuscript of Athena's new book. June publishes it as her own under the ambiguous name Juniper Song.

The book highlights the toxicity of the publishing industry, cancel culture, toxic relationships, white privilege and racism. All of which have been incredibly well-written.

I don't want to say any more, as it's such a powerful and impactful read that you really need to experience it for yourself!

Was this review helpful?

Rounding up to a 3.5

Firstly, thank you to HarperCollins for a digital ARC in exchange for an honest review. I have not read R.F. Kuang's previous work because the genre's were not in my typical interests, but Yellowface's blurb really pulled me in. I immediately requested an ARC after seeing it. I wasn't let down reading Yellowface, but I wasn't wowed either. Kuang is a great writer. She uses simple prose in this book and I really loved that. I also think she did a great job giving a P.O.V. of someone she wasn't. To me it felt very realistic. But as a Black reader I'm realizing that this type of story, white people stealing, hurting, bullying people of colour, just doesn't work as a thriller to me. Due to my real life experiences, it's just overly predictable and nothing came as a shock to me. I also think I would have enjoyed it more if it was comedy instead of a thriller, because I think comedy would have been a great medium to get the same message across. Overall I wouldn't recommend this but I wouldn't tell anyone not to read it either.

Was this review helpful?

An interesting read the characters were okay I didn't love them and the story was intriguing, even though I found it really hard to get into.

Was this review helpful?

I really wasn't sure what to expect from the short synopsis on this book but that also made me incredibly curious and so I had to read it to find out and I'm very glad I did as I really enjoyed this story.

This was a good read that explores a lot of themes and informed me about some of the worlds history that I'd never heard of before. It was good to learn something new and to follow June dealing with Athena's death and everything that happened after that. Yes, there are things she probably shouldn't have done but could we all say we wouldn't have done the same in the same situation?

It was fascinating getting a glimpse of what authors go through in getting published and then what can face them afterwards also. I am very grateful that so many do as I have had many hours of enjoyment reading thanks to them.

Was this review helpful?

Great thought provoking book. Enjoyed it from start to finish. Would definitely read more from this author.

Was this review helpful?

Yellowface by Rebecca F Kuang is a novel about an author (June) who, after her friends (Athena) death, decides to steal her unpublished manuscript and gets it published as her own. As soon as the book is published there are people who do not believe that June wrote the book butdid in fact steal it, but June is determined to not lose her newfound success after the failure of her initial attempt to get a novel published.

Whilst I dont condone what she did, part of me feels a little sorry for June as she seems to have low self esteem and noone she can really turn to. Aside from Athena she does not have any friends, while she is somewhat dislikeable, this makes me feel sad for her as I know how awful lonliness can be. I think part of the reason she decides to become an author and in turn to steal Athenas book is if she can't get love aand affection from the people in her life then she can get it from publishers, fans etc.

This book also confirms how toxic and completely awful social media can be and how so many people are willing to say the most disgusting things to people they have never even met.

I will definitely be recommending this book.

Thank you to Netgalley and Harper Collins for an ARC in exchange for an unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

I really loved the book so much. It tells so much about the literature world, about our world. How lonely and hard it is. It gives insight into racism without being too hard on the reader. And it makes you laugh about all the madness.
Thank you for this book. I am looking forward selling it.

Was this review helpful?

Hmm... I was mighty uncomfortable while I read this book, the intended dislike ability of the characters was an achievement, we ticked that box. This story was very cut throat and dog eat dog.

Whilst it was an uncomfortable read, I can see this is something that may occur in publishing, there are people who will do anything to get what they want, that's life. I didn't get all the jokes, so the humour was a little lost on me, and I felt at times I was being pushed into what the author wanted me to think or feel as if her voice was willing it, but is that just good writing?

I wasn't a fan of Babel, but I read this with a gripping uncomfortable feeling and I thought it was well written.

Was this review helpful?