Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Becky we are told is a modern retelling of the book William Thackerey’s ‘Vanity Fair’.
Becky is a book that follows the life of a young girl, from her not so good upbringing to her struggle to get to the top in newspaper editing and letting nothing and anyone stand in her way. It follows her rises and falls of her life and the lies that are told and the damage done by them.
This book is a different genre to what I usually read and I did enjoy it. The book was fast paced but did jump around with the timelines quite a lot that was sometimes confusing. I haven’t read the original “Vanity Fair” so don’t know how alike or different it is. It had an engaging story but I didn’t like Becky even though I think I should have done through her childhood but knowing what kind of a woman she was it fell flat. A proper rags to riches tale.
I would like to thank Netgalley and Pan Macmillan, Picador for this ARC I received in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Wickedly clever and waspishly funny, I loved this character - it was mean, riotously fast paced, and joyfully constructed. Excellent.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately I felt very meh about this book. None of the characters were engaging, even the ones you were meant to dislike. The story didn’t really go anywhere and it certainly wasn’t one scandal to the next. Just not for me I’m afraid.

Was this review helpful?

“Becky is a story I’ve carried inside me for a long time … From the moment she hurls her dictionary out of the carriage window as she leaves Miss Pinkerton’s Academy for Young Ladies, I fell in love with William Thackeray’s Becky Sharp. An eighteen-year-old orphan with no friends in the world and even fewer prospects.”

My thanks to Pan Macmillan Picador for an eARC via NetGalley of ‘Becky’ by Sarah May.

In her Author’s Note quoted above, Sarah May talks about her love for William Thackerey’s ‘Vanity Fair’ and her decision to write this modern retelling. She kept Thackeray’s names and timeframe but transported the setting from the Regency period to 1990s London. She also removed Thackerey’s male narrative voice, allowing Becky to tell her own story.

In addition, she places the ambitious Becky in the world of tabloid journalism. She will stop at nothing to reach the top of the career ladder at the Mercury newspaper. As a result Becky finds herself involved with the biggest stories and scandals of the decade, and she has something to do with every one of them. Landing scoop after scoop, Becky ruthlessly carves out a place for herself.

Those familiar with the original novel are aware that Becky’s story is a tale of rags to riches, and riches to rags. It was often described as a ‘novel without a hero’. With celebrities and the royals constantly in the news and the rollercoaster of social media and cancel culture, the message of ‘Becky’ and its classic antecedent, ‘Vanity Fair’ remains relevant.

Overall, I found ‘Becky’ an engaging tale. While I didn’t feel that it was as powerful as its inspiration, I did appreciate seeing Becky Sharp in a 1990s setting as well as Sarah May scathing portrayal of the practices of tabloid journalism.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fast paced and enjoyable read that was different from my usual book pick. I loved the change of genre and this was a gripping and entertaining read.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for a copy of the novel in exchange for an honest review

Was this review helpful?

This book started out well for me and I was really enjoying it but the the way the story jumps about without any warning became annoying, you really need to keep on track with it as it can be so disjointed. I also found myself totally disliking everyone, not a character in the story is likeable, I liked Becky to begin with and her background story led to sympathy but as it went on I just couldn’t sympathise with her at all. I haven’t read Vanity Fair so can’t comment on similarities but this was just an ok read for me in the end. Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the early copy.

Was this review helpful?

Having enjoyed the original, I thought Becky would be an amusing read, bringing Thackeray up to date. Sadly, the reality wasn’t as appealing as expected, and I struggled to read it.

Apologies, but not a book I would recommend.

Was this review helpful?

I expected this book to be a high octane tale of an ambitious woman making her way in the world of journalism. However, I found it very disjointed. The reader is hurled from one paragraph to the next, first in the present, then back in Becky's childhood. Her upbringing was pretty dire, although we only see things from her perspective, and the author rather glosses over her career in any detail - occasionally we jump years. It is really just a pastiche of events in her life,centring around her childhood, a missing child she uses to jump start her career and her relationships.

Overall I enjoyed the story, and once I settled down to be bounced around time lines it makes for a good story, but the reader has to be prepared to work at staying on track. Some sections work better than others.

Thank you to NetGalley and Pan Macmillan, Picador for allowing me access to the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Becky by Sarah May is a debut novel by the author and it is set in the mid nineties tabloid era London.Becky wants it all and wants the success as editor of one of the major newspapers of the times. Where the newspaper people mix with the new millionaires, the wheeler dealers, royalty and the politicians of the day.
Then it all comes to an end for Becky with the phone hacking scandal. Reminiscent of Rebecca Brook and those sordid media trials.
An interesting, funny, sad and sometimes humorous storyline reminiscent of times hopefully long gone by.
Highly recommended

Was this review helpful?

100% enjoyable from beginning to end. A masterful update of a classic. Didn't expect to like this as usually find retellings of classics in a modern setting rather dull. This one is anything but, a rip-roaring read from beginning to end.

Was this review helpful?

In this modern telling of 'vanity fair" we meet Becky, a young woman hellbent on succeeding to be the top journalist at a newspaper in London in the 90s. The story alluded to many landmark events in the 90s such as Princess Diana's affairs, her ultimate car crash and death and the phone hacking scandal that caused the implosion of a major news group. Becky was such a complex character and while at times she appeared quite ruthless and unlikeable, the author did a great job of providing a rich backstory that made the reader understand her faults. I loved this book and would definitely recommend!

Was this review helpful?

I loved Vanity Fair, on my reading list at uni I was pretty intimidated by it, but what I discovered was a witty satire teeming energy thanks to the anti heroine, Becky Sharp.
And so I was drawn to Becky by Sarah May. And at first I loved it, the way it pulls on the threads of modern society, and I enjoyed Becky’s unapologetic rise through the social ranks.
I became more uncomfortable when the lines of fiction became blurred and it moved from being a retelling of Vanity Fair to taking whole chunks of an actual persons reality. To me, it seemed obvious that Becky is modelled on Rebekah Brooks, the CEO of I think it was News International, who was heavily implicated in the phone hacking scandal. But that a child abduction mirroring Milly Dowler’s was also used as a central plot device left me with more than a bit of a bad taste that I struggled to get past.

Was this review helpful?

This was a discovery for me u known world of jounalism. Really xould not belive how entertaing it was. I would never could guess or immagine. So thank you Pan Macmillan and netgalley for this opportunity

Was this review helpful?

Rebecca Sharp is determined to slough off her background and be a success. She re-invents herself as a public schoolgirl and manages to gain a foothold in the tabloid press. With a nose for good journalism and a ruthless streak Becky rises high but at a huge personal cost.
This book purports to be a re-telling of the Thackeray novel 'Vanity Fair' with an updated setting and there are many parallels. However it also draws heavily on the story of Rebekah Wade, an infamous tabloid editor and friend to the movers and shakers of the late 1990s. Lots of real-life stories are altered slightly and aspects of the original novel are lost but what emerges is a really entertaining read.

Was this review helpful?

Becky Sharp will do anything to escape her past. From mingling with celebrities and royalty, Becky will stop at nothing to reach the top of the newspaper ladder at The Mercury. She’s ruthless, getting all the best scoops and she is part of every scandalous story that emerges. But Becky has more in common with these people than she thinks. She has spent her life building herself up to be the top of her game. But in a moment, everything can come tumbling down…

I haven’t read Vanity Fair but all of the main characters in Becky are based on those in Thackeray’s novel. Rachel has transported them into the world of media and journalism. An interesting concept and something that had me hooked from the first chapter. Growing up in the 90s, I remember all too well the sensationalism and media obsession with Princess Diana and certain celebrities which Sarah alludes to this in her novel. The phone-tapping scandal rocked the world of the celebrities, politicians and royalty, and Sarah manages to capture perfectly in this story.

Becky as a protagonist is one tough cookie. She has gone through so much but refuses to let it define her. She’s savage when it comes to getting the biggest scoop and her dogged determination to get where she wants leaves a wake of relationships and friendships behind her. Her childhood really has a huge impact on her and I liked how Sarah jumps from the present day to the past to give the readers and insight into what made Becky what she is. At times it is a depressing story filled with some very poignant moments but Sarah successfully depicts Becky’s insatiable hunger to escape from her past and mould herself into a figure of authority in the world of media and journalism. Although she is not a likeable character for many reasons, Sarah ensures that Becky’s reasoning behind every decision she makes is there for us to see.

A gripping narrative full of lies, betrayals, secrets and devastating consequences. Becky is out now. 4 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Thanks to NetGalley and Pan Macmillan for the arc.

Was this review helpful?

Becky is a contemporary re-telling of Vanity Fair set in the recent past world of media journalism. Becky's story arc is a rags to riches and back to rags again tale. The author retains Vanity Fair's character names and even calls Becky's lawyer William Thackery. However for me that's where the similarity ends.

I remember liking some of the characters in Vanity Fair but couldn't connect with any of the characters in Sarah May's version. Everyone is extremely unlikeable and I couldn't root for anyone.

Sarah May uses real events of the 1990s through to 2010 in her plot. While I thought this was both interesting and nostalgic it took away any intrigue for me. Becky's character shares a lot with media executive, Rebekah Brooks, including the phone hacking scandal.

The most frustrating part of the writing for me was the way the plot jumped around from present back to past. There was no warning this had happened and I found this jarring and disorientating. The story also jumps several years forwards without any sort of resolution with current events.

So I thank Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with a copy to read and review, but this isn't a title I would recommend.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC.

I don't think I've ever read Vanity Fair so I don't have any frame of reference for how closely this story matches the original, but I thought it was a great read in its own right. Becky is a strong, identifiable character and although she isn't fully likeable, you can follow why she makes every decision. I thought the decision to set the story in the 90s at the height of tabloid power worked really well and allowed May to comment on a multitude of topics from media ethics to class and social mobility. The narrative gripped me and there were times I genuinely couldn't put it down! 4.5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

Another take on Vanity Fair. I found the content a bit dark and depressing, definitely not for the faint hearted. A bad start in life, a ruthless determination to change her life path and a don't care what she has to do to get what she wants. At times I felt sorry for her but at some points I loathed her.

Was this review helpful?

The heroine is the 90s versione of Becky Sharp and she share more than one traits with the Vanity Fair heroine.
It's a bitter sweet story: you laugh, you feel nostalgic and you realize who inspired this book.
The author is a talented storyteller and did an excellent job in writing this story.
It''s complex to explain but it made me think about some story of XVIII which features the rise and fall of a characters and there's always a moral lesson.
This could have been one of those books.
Highly recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher for this arc, all opinions are mine

Was this review helpful?

I found the style of writing in this book abit hard to take too, The characters were not very likeable and I found by the end I just felt dissatisfied.

Was this review helpful?