Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I genuinely think a lot of people will love this book. The characters are good, and the story has a lot going for it, but it just wasn't for me.
I found my attention drifting so often, that it took me a few weeks, and several other books finished, between starting and finishing this book.
I can't put my finger on exactly why this was. Other than personally I didn't find the story that engaging.

Was this review helpful?

Love Theoretically by Ali Hazelwood is described as a STEMinist romcom and it certainly lives up to that billing.It hits on several tropes that readers of the romance genre may enjoy, including enemies to lovers and grumpy/sunshine pairing, Readers already familiar with this author will know to expect a certain level of spice and they will not be disappointed.
Elsie Hannaway is a theoretical physicist currently working as an adjunct professor but searching for a more secure position that would allow her more time to spend on research and developing her theories. In a perfect world that would mean she would also be able to give up her side gig of working as a companion for hire, the perfect fake girlfriend for any occasion. When a position opens up at MIT and one of the recruiting panel throws her support behind Elsie, it looks like things may be beginning to look up. The one dark cloud on the horizon is Jack Smith, the experimental physicist on the panel who not only has a candidate of his own in the race, but was responsible for ruining Elsie's mentor's career and creating a rift between the theoretical and experimental branches of physics that still hasn't been mended. It looks like things could not get any worse but when Elsie meets Jack as part of the interview process, they are both shocked to discover they have already met, as part of Elsie's other job, and that is just the start of an awkward but sizzling love story..
This was such a fun read, I loved the setting of academia and the rivals to lovers progression as the story unfolded. Elsie and Jack were great characters to spend time with, and by the end I felt they were really good for each other , and each had helped the other to grow, Elsie has type 1 diabetes and I loved how this was integrated into the story, making it clear that while this is something that definitely impacts on her life negatively from time to time, by and large she is in control and it was something that Jack just accepted as a matter of fact, and went out of his way to accommodate without making a big deal of it. There is a lot of wit and humour in the book, and that really added to my enjoyment of it as a reader.
I read and reviewed an ARC courtesy of NetGalley and the publisher, all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Love Theoretically
Ali Hazelwood
Publisher: Berkley (USA) (Penguin Random House) & Sphere (UK)
Release date: 13th June 2023

Anyone who reads romance will have heard of Ali Hazelwood. It’s my first time reading her, but I’m an instant Ali Addict.
In this novel, ten months ago, Elsie graduated with a Ph.D. in theoretical physics. Instead of ending with a well paid academic job, she’s in a poorly paid sciencey job * yes I made that word up * and running herself ragged between teaching classes whilst rationing insulin. As the pay isn’t much, she has a second job being a fake girlfriend through the Faux app.
Her current favourite client Greg Smith has hired her to accompany him to his grandmother’s birthday party. Dealing with his neurotic and strange family has its challenges, but his brother Jack? That’s a whole other story.
The Smith family are lots of fun. Millicent Smith – the rich grandmother whose birthday it is – is an absolute hoot. Her reaction to the gift of a “mud bath voucher” is hilarious and on point for her. Just like Elsie, I adore Grandma Smith. This collection of loveable eccentrics remind me a bit of the family in “While You Were Sleeping” with Sandra Bullock.
Hazelwood has a terrific turn of phrase, particularly with metaphor, similes, description, and dialogue.
The narrative voice – i.e. Elsie – is very strong and laced with sardonic humour. From her description of Millicent and Jack, to that of the hedgehog as “that malignant sentient pincushion,” it is simply delightful. We also have a large number of science metaphors, physics puns, cheese porn and emails from students whose metaphorical dog ate their homework.
The science? Well, as the girl who got F in physics I have no clue, however Hazelwood moved to the US to pursue a Ph.D. in neuroscience and is a processor with peer-reviewed articles behind her.
What was one hundred percent accurate about the science community though, was the nerdier aspects. I’m a SF Group committee member, and friends with a number of scientists, plus I’m a writer. You add that all up and I can spot a nerd or geek at fifty paces and the group social interactions are spot on.
As for the academia settings, and students, her epistolary excerpts of emails are groan-worthily accurate ... This one is nothing compared to some of them. I give you ...
“From: SandraShuberton@ gmail.com
Re: Thermodynamics Essay
Doctor Hannaway, ma’am, it’s been 23 hours, have you graded my essay yet?”
Amidst the humour there’s a lot of drama too.
Women in STEM and academia and the discrimination they face, family baggage, identity, gender, and sexuality.
For Elsie specifically, the emotions revolve around her low self esteem and her need to please everyone.
She has spent her life moulding her public personality to fit the needs of those around her. Not to mention her health issues which have fed into her need to be little trouble to anyone.
She is so adept at being a fake girlfriend, because her entire life is being whatever she thinks the other person wants to see, or who they want to be with.
Jack though, as well as Cece her roommate and Greg her fake boyfriend/friend are some of the few to really see, and like her as she is. Again I’m reminded of a classic rom com here; Bridget Jones.
Which brings me back to romance – and Jack. Ooh boy! He’s seriously lumbersexual, smart and growly. And big. And tall and oh so yummy.
Unfortunately he’s also her sworn enemy in the physics field and the man who potentially holds the key to her career.
As with all good romances, we have a number of popular tropes here; fake-dating and enemies to lovers for starters.
Add in the sizzling chemistry born of physics-fuelled hate and when their lips crash together – it’s one hell of a Hadron Collider!
There’s a grand gesture, self discovery and of course, the HEA.
You'd be stupid not to buy this book, or get it from a library. I mean ... It’s not rocket science.

Was this review helpful?

Every single Ali Hazelwood book I read, I fall more and more in love with her characters. I love the way she writes, I love the way she develops the plot, I myself am a scientist so I adore the way science is fed through the plot. There's nothing to me, better than a MC who is also a women in STEM. Literally, she never fails.

And this book. WOW. The dynamic between Elsie and Jack - talk about tension. Two rival physicists who work in different aspects of physics. The tension that built up in this book was to die for, I read this on the train, on the tube, when I was walking. I just couldn't put it down.

I also love how each book has a introduction to previously talked about characters, we get little insights into Olive and Adam in this book (BRILLIANT).

Thank you to NetGalley for the early copy in exchange for my opinions.

For more reviews, please check out my Instagram and TikTok at @blondesbooknook and my Twitter at @lausbooknook

Was this review helpful?

Ali Hazelwood is BACK and I mean that in the way that her writing doesn’t feel like a forced copy and paste of her other stories. This one has her personality and personal touch shining through and I’m so glad I held out and gave her another chance after the nonsense LotB and Loathe to Love you novellas.

I really enjoyed this story and the characters! It wasn’t too exaggerated for tropes, in the sense that grumpy wasn’t too grumpy and sunshine wasn’t too sunshine (does that even make sense??). The miscommunication trope is always ridiculous so the fall out always feels unnecessary. Especially in this book. But luckily it didn’t last way too long.

These characters felt flawed and real. The representation of diabetics was new and needed! I don’t think I’ve read a book yet with a diabetic MC and she was written extremely well. It didn’t feel like HELLO LOOK AT THIS NEW REPRESENTATION I HAVE that some books do where it feels forced and thrown in just for the audience. This felt natural.

I also loved how fluffy it was! Though I will admit as a woman in STEM myself, it has completely put me off pursuing academia 😳🥴 sounds horrendous.

I’m just really happy I enjoyed one of her books again

Was this review helpful?

I love all her books , but this one was just amazing and I couldn’t stop reading.
The romance was so perfect .
The fake dating , grumpy sunshine and put in that mix also academic rivalry. It was absolutely perfect read and it as had a bit of spice that made it all more enjoyable to read.

Was this review helpful?

This is a enemies-to-lovers (academic rivals)/grumpy x sunshine/STEM romcoms/HEA guaranteed.

There’s not a Ali Hazelwood book that I wouldn’t read and this really cemented that. The fmc is really relatable and I really enjoyed how the Mc was patient with her. I was really hyped when I saw Adam and olive was also featured in here.

Was this review helpful?

If there's anything an Ali Hazelwood book can't heal! Honestly, for me the books are always pure comfort. I am aware that females have to work twice as hard in male dominated industries, however the issues, setbacks and hostility faced by female STEM professionals is unknown to me so I do enjoy reading Hazelwood's writing for exploring these within the narrative in each book so far.  LT covers the threat and challenges that female STEM professionals face when senior cis white males act as mentors and how their influence is not always progressive. In the foreground, Jack and Elsie's journey and connection blossoms from being rivals in their respective disciplines to learning how they can bring out the best in each other. The supporting characters, in the form of Greg and Cece especially, are well written - everyone would want a best friend or sibling like that. This was an easy read for me that got me out of a reading slump. I am aware that the basic plot is (arguably) repeating itself in 'Aliverse' but still there are enough twists and turns and quirks that kept things fresh for me. I was hooked! Thank you @netgalley and @LittleBrownBookGroup for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the characters in this book. Elsie is such a relatable character for me as she’s always observing people to see how she can change herself to give them the version of herself that they want even if that’s not her true self. It was beautiful to see her change out of this and become her own self and care less about what other people wanted and started to do what she wanted. I also loved Jack. He was so sweet, gentle and patient with Elsie. I loved every second that they were together and how he really wanted to get to know the real her. The storyline was so interesting and I couldn’t help but be excited at what was going to happen. I also loved when we got to see a glimpse of Adam and Olive. Millicent is by far my favourite side character, I loved her so much.

Was this review helpful?

This book was amazing !!! One of my favourite reads of 2023 so far !! I've re-read the book already just incase I missed anything. Completed my first reading in one go it was just too good to put down !! An ode to 2000 RomComs humour and fun with a dash of science in an academic setting. Definitely recommending to everyone have already recommended it to three of my friends and pre ordered a paperback from Amazon.

I loved Elise and Jack, even before we were supposed to like Jack !

Was this review helpful?

It is fair to say I'm a huge Ali Hazelwood fan. I own all her books to-date and I loveeee them🤍

No Spoilers Summary:
Love, Theoretically features academic rivals Elsie Hannaway and Jack Smith, in an enemies-to-lovers (academic rivals), fake-dating (with a twist), "STEMinist" romcom.
Throughout the book Elsie goes on a bit of a journey of self-discovery and personal growth, while navigating challenges when her regular job and other job collide.
Although it follows the same sort of formula as Ali's other books, this one has enough differences to make it stand out from TLH and LOTB.

Things I loved in this book:
Diabetes rep
Character growth of the FMC
LGBTQIA+ rep (ACE character)
The communication! Jack was great at this and Elsie tried!
A guest appearance from a previous couple! 🤩
Witty banter
A fun, easy read (though a bit science-heavy in parts!)

Tbh I found some of the writing a *little* cringey at times, but it suited the book and the FMC's personality, so it worked in its own way.

Read this if you like:
enemies-to-lovers (academic rivals)
grumpy x sunshine
STEM romcoms
HEA
Spicy, open-door scenes

CW- gaslighting and controlling behaviour (not MMC, although the way MMC talks on occasion may be triggering to some people as he is very direct).

Publication date: 13th June 2023

Overall this is a 4 ⭐ read for me. It wasn't my favourite Ali Hazelwood book to-date, but I still enjoyed it and will read it again. And although I received an eARC of this book earlier this year, I am going to buy the paperback version, so I can keep my Ali Hazelwood collection intact! 🥰

Thanks to Netgalley/Little Brown Book Group for giving me a copy of this book in eARC format in exchange for an honest review.

#alihazelwood #lovetheoretically #stemromcom #netgalley

(links to be added when review posted on Instagram on publication date).

Was this review helpful?

This is my first book by Ali Hazelwood and honestly, I was impressed and I liked it. Now, I have to check other books as well. I liked the characters that were really well written and the background of the whole story that gave us context to their feelings and how they matured and grew up. Loved all the jokes and puns on physics too.

Was this review helpful?

Love, Theoretically by Ali Hazelwood is a great new edition to the nerdy corner of the world that is academic romance!

We are thrown into the deep end when introduced to the main character; Elsie, a broke, people pleasing physicist who has an unusual but thematically fitting side gig of being a 'fake girlfriend' to bring in extra money. Her romantic counterpart is Jack, a complex (and unfairly tall and attractive) problem that Elsie now can't seem to escape from!

I adored Elsie as the main character, as she had me giggling at all the relatable internalised dialogue that I'm sure many people pleasers will be familiar with. I also loved the representation of Elsie as a diabetic character because its not something I've come across in other literature despite it being such a prevalent condition many people live with. Jack was equally charming, with a complex personality, intelligence and charisma and I think he was the perfect love interest for Elsie.

Despite the romance being exciting and more than a little spicy, there is also a dynamic plot dealing with the intricacies of academic workplaces and the politics surrounding them. Whilst I'm not overly familiar with many advanced elements of physics, I found the discussion of theories very convincing and these dialogues made the characters and the surrounding world feel authentic and natural whilst still being understandable for those not in the field. By incorporating this scientific jargon, the characters felt realistic and had me far more invested in the world.

It's vary rare I pick up a book and get completely hooked from start to finish but this was one of them for me! The pacing was great and I struggled to put it down so it's definitely convinced me to pick up a lot more of Ali Hazelwoods previous works because I NEED more!

This would be a great read for anyone who is a sucker for a nerdy romance, enemies to lovers tropes or just generally wants a garenteed enjoyable read from start to finish! I'm very grateful to Ali Hazelwood and her publishers for the ARC in exchange for an honest review and NetGalley for making this all possible!
5/5

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this. It's one i could have read in one sitting, if I'd had the time! However, I feel like it's quite similar to Hazelwoods other books and I was a little disappointed by the similar storyline...
While Elsie seems the strong female in STEM, she struggles to say no. To her family, to her friends, to her advisor (who doesn't even use her correct name..) Until she meets Jack. Jack is an anomaly and on their first meetings Elsie isn't able to read him like she is others. However, as the story goes on this turns out to be what Elsie needs.
The chemistry was fab between the characters and Jack is exactly the kind of man you could fall for.
Like I said, I enjoyed the book and if it had been my first All Hazelwood I would have loved it!

Tw manipulation/controlling behaviour

Was this review helpful?

My second book by this author and in my opinion even better than the first which I loved. I read liked Elsie and Jack even at the beginning when Jack wasn’t supposed to be likeable. Great characters and a great storyline

Was this review helpful?

I'm definitely in the minority here, but this one fell flat for me. I really struggled to get into it and ended up putting it away half way through.

Was this review helpful?

I fell in love with Hazelwood’s writing in The Love Hypothesis, and this was just as sweet and spicy as I had hoped it would be.

Ali has such a great way of making you fall in love with her characters immediately, and you can’t help but binge read the entire story because you need to know what happens. I loved the dynamic between Jack and Elsie. Jack is so easy going and ridiculously charming, you can’t help falling for him right alongside Elsie. He is so different to the silent and broody types she has written in previous books, and it was refreshing to have that change.
I enjoyed how in depth into the STEM world we dove as well! A little heavier on that plot side of things and it was great.

I can’t wait for what is to come next from Ali!

Was this review helpful?

I think at this point I will read anything that Ali writes 😍 I adore the way Ali writes and her ability to suck you into the main character's life, and Love, Theoretically was no exception.

Elsie felt like such a real person and her and Jack's chemistry was undeniable. As their enemies to lovers relationship develops there's also many laugh out loud moments interspersed with resolute STEMinism. Other tropes covered are fake dating and he falls first. This book is quite science heavy and some of it went over my head, but I'm glad these details were included because it made everything seem more authentic. Also, I (kind of) work in STEM and my workplace got mentioned which felt surreal!

I will say that almost all side characters had very similar personalities (quirky, same sense of humour etc.) which seemed too coincidental, and some scenes towards the end felt more stretched out than they needed to be. But by the end of the book it left me with an overwhelmingly positive impression and the ending was perfect, so it's a five star read in my eyes despite these minor flaws.

Some quotes:

"STEM culture has been a boys' club for so long, I often feel like I can be allowed to play only if I follow the rules men made."

"I hate that I look at Jack Smith, with his good jaw and his good dimples and those good hands, and find him handsome. Maybe I just won't look."

"He looks like an oak tree on steroids with a six-foot-eight wingspan. Is he even human?"

"Academics are awkward, resentful nerds unable to interact with our colleagues without litres of ethanolic lubricant."

Was this review helpful?

Thankyou to Netgalley, the publisher and the author for allowing me to read this ARC.
I love Ali Hazelwood and was so excited to recieve this ARC.
This book was so sexy, clever and fun and i really loved it.
I was glued to my kindle and could not put this book down!
This had a great story line with well written characters.
Thankyou again!
5/5 stars

Was this review helpful?

If there is anyone who can write a great STEM romance, it’s Ali Hazelwood.

Out of all her books, I think this might be my favourite. I mean hello, she’s brought us an enemies to lovers book!!

This story revolves around Jack and Elsie who start out as enemies due to Elsie believing that Jack ruined her mentors career, dislikes theorists (her field is theoretical physics), is hiding something from his brother and sits between her and her dream job.

Elsie has a side gig (fake dating) to help her pay off her student loans and finds out that Jack is the brother of her best client, Greg. Jack, surprised to learn that she’s not his brothers girlfriend and instead works in a field he cannot stand, realises while obsessing about her, that he’s supporting someone else for the job Elsie wants.

Jack is cocky, charming, confident, knows what he wants and goes for it. Elsie is a people pleaser who has a lot of difficulty saying no but she’s driven and doing everything she can to make her dreams come true.

I love these two as a couple, and I really enjoyed this book. Oh and for the fans - we also got a tiny Olive and Adam cameo!!!

I recommend this to anyone who loves Ali’s books and anyone looking to get into Ali’s books. You won’t be disappointed.

Was this review helpful?