Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Will also be posting an Instagram post when I get my physical copy of the book! (Bookishsoph_)

Where do I begin? When I got accepted to read this before it was published I was so excited! So thank you so much for giving me this opportunity.

Reading Ali Hazelwoods writing is one of the most comforting and amazing reading experiences I’ve ever had! When I read the love hypothesis way back in 2021 I became obsessed. And love theoretically does not disappoint.

This book follows the story of Elsie and Jack who are honestly great! The tropes in this book are grumpy sunshine, which Ali Hazelwood writes so well! Elsie is a people pleaser through and through and will/can be anything you want her to be. Jack is a strong minded academic who cannot seem to stomach Elsie. The romance in this book is so good, feels so real and raw. The miscommunication trope is one I normally cannot stand but I think in this book it was done really well! Elsie and jacks friendship and relationship blossoms right in front of us as we get to see them have “honesty” which is just such a cute concept and I loved it so so much! (If you know you know)

I cannot wait to have the physical book in my hands!! Everyone needs to preorder this asap🤍

Was this review helpful?

Oh god, where do I start?!

I don’t know how Ali Hazelwood does it, but EVERY book she writes is one that I hold close to my heart.
The plot was amazing! The romance was perfect and the amount of spice was just enough to make it exciting!
It took me a little while longer to read this book than ones on my normal TBR but I think that’s because Ali allowed the reader to really get to know the characters and developed layers to each one which meant that I came away from every chapter reflecting and thinking about how their life experiences shaped them and their actions throughout Love Theoretically.

I was slightly worried towards the beginning that it was a bit slow but once I got past the first two chapters I was hooked!

What makes this book different from others I’ve read? It’s allowed science and romance to go together and even for people who don’t necessarily like STEM or romance, it had the perfect balance that basically anyone could read!

Thanks Ali for another gem in the book world, can’t wait to get my hands on the physical copy!

Was this review helpful?

Love Theoretically
Release date June 13th post about the review will come 2nd June on Instagram
5 stars
Thank you for the arc @netgalley and little brown
Where do I start with this book except, I feel seen in this book so much so I cried twice full on tears but not because of the romance because of the rep. As someone who has the same condition as Elsie I am so happy to finally read from a woman’s perspective about this condition. The rep is 1000% accurate and as someone who knows what is like the constant need to know such things is something I can relate to. I won’t say what it is as its not in the blurb but finally I felt seen. I do think this book needs to be shouted out about the rep because for so long I have been wanting to read about a woman who has what I has and not a man- the other times it has always been the man who has had it so thank you Ali for finally giving me what I have been craving.
I loved Jack he was adorable even if moody I knew the moment we met him that his looks was because he liked Elsie and the steaminess in this book is something that is unmatched in her other two books, I wonder if this was because I connect more to the character and was rooting for them a little more. It was so relatable what Elsie was going through and how she was coping with things I kept nodding my head and saying things like been there.
Am I excited for more from Ali Hazelwood? yes- would I take more from Elsie and Jack? Absolutely and I cannot wait until I am able to talk to more people about this book because I feel without a doubt it is the best one and as soon as I cried I knew the book was going to be five stars because what else could I give it?

Was this review helpful?

Like the majority of bookstagram, I fell in love with Ali Hazelwood through The Love Hypothesis. Romance set to a background of STEM whilst smashing stereotypes and being some-what educational yet not confusing is a tough task, but Hazelwood manages it perfectly.

Love Theoretically has loveable yet flawed characters who develop throughout the story. The tropes (fake-boyfriend's brother, enemies-to-lovers, academic rivals ...and more) are all top tier and the book makes for a nice, easy read. The spice was there, but not to the point of it overriding the underlying narrative. For me, this book is very similar to TLH, but I'm always down to fall in love with new characters!

Thank you NetGalley for providing me with an E-book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Right so let’s talk about it.

This is not the worst piece of writing Ali Hazelwood has ever written. Trust me, she’s written A LOT worse. However, this is probably the most disappointing. What started off as a very interesting premise with actually interesting characters ended up falling into the usual “big man small virginal woman” narrative that she loves so much. And I can’t for the life of me understand why.

Elsie is a character that needs to learn to stand up for herself, advocate for herself. And Hazelwood delves into her family background to help us understand where it all came from. But she does nothing with it. There is no “development” for her character until the 92% mark (not joking).

The love interest is less a romantic partner and more so a life coach/therapist (the mc should just go to therapy bc she’s got a lot going on).

The aroace rep was fine as was the diabetes rep. She touched on the realities of not being able to access affordable healthcare and what that means as a chronically ill person.

Quick bullet points of what didn’t work for me:

* massive miscommunication
* two adults that are obviously attracted to each other but act like petty children
* reylo references (barf)
* a bunch of white people in academia
* they use this type of technology which is constantly referred to as the iTwat which was jarring . i need everyone involved to be serious.


it’s probably a 2.5 but i’ll round it up to be nice

Was this review helpful?

I was thrilled to have been able to read and review an ARC copy of Love, Theoretically, one of my most anticipated romance reads of 2023. Thankfully, it lived up to the hype I had built for this too - thank you to NetGalley and Little Brown Books for allowing me the opportunity to do so!

Hazelwood is known for her fantastic STEM/academia-inspired romcoms with strong female protagonists and broody, attractive love interests. Love, Theoretically is no different so Ali Hazelwood fans are bound to enjoy this.

Elsie is a theoretical physicist and an adjunct professor desperately hoping to stop teaching and start being herself. Used to adapting her personality to meet the needs of whoever she is talking to, Elsie has become a master at people pleasing and not being herself. When the opportunity arises for her to land tenure and stop struggling to pay rent, Elsie is determined to prove herself. However, there is one particular brooding person that seems to be in the way of her achieving her dreams.

This book felt like more of a slow burn than Love on the Brain and The Love Hypothesis and personally, I preferred this. There seemed to be more STEM background and I could feel myself being dragged into STEM politics and rooting for Elsie's success. Ali Hazelwood's books are always so easy to be drawn into with sizzling chemistry and quick wit.

If you love easy romcom reads and the enemies-to-lovers trope, you will not want to miss Love, Theoretically!

Was this review helpful?

Ali Hazelwood does it again, third one I've read of hers that's 4 stars! This one was closer to 4.5 to be honest as I would say out of the three it's the best one. I threw through this within 2 evenings and loved every minute of it. Yes she has once again written about a rather large male character with a smaller female one but she does it well! Both characters have complicated pasts and even presents during this story and it was nice to see some diabetes rep in this one too and if you like any of this authors work I recommend picking this one up!

Was this review helpful?

Elsie is a people pleaser and young physics lecturer interviewing for a dream theoretical physics job at MIT. During the interview she bumps into Jack, the brother of a man she’s been fake dating and the lie could escape… Enemies to lovers trope done brilliantly. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to netgalley for the opportunity to review this book.
I really enjoyed reading this book. The story of Elsie, the people pleaser, is something that resonates with me quite a lot. We all have this idea that we need to change ourselves to fit in sometimes, she just does it more often. Along comes Jack who calls her out on everything and a clear romance starts blossoming very early on.
The book was the perfect mix between romance and insecurity, along with an academic twist to make it slightly different to the usual meet cute books.
I would have liked more at the end, a bit more about them as a couple but other than that the book is a definite yes from me.

Was this review helpful?

I am a big fan of Ali Hazelwood’s other works, and this was no different. As usual I fell in love with this story and its characters. I loved the focus on communication and honesty between Jack and Elsie, I think it’s a much fresher approach than the typical miscommunication trope that is often relied upon to cause tension. I also love that Ali often uses ace/aro characters, I love that we are finally getting to see little glimpses of this representation. My only criticism is that I felt the ending was a little abrupt, I wish we’d gotten a little more of a glimpse into Jack and Elsie’s future.

Was this review helpful?

I was very excited to read an Arc of Love, Theoretically. I really enjoyed Ali Hazelwood's previous books and this latest story had the same witty dialogue and loveable, slightly awkward characters. I always enjoy the wit and creativity that goes into Hazelwood's writing, and Elsie was great fun to read, particularly in her interactions with her friend, though she did have a habit of getting flustered a lot though given her experience talking to men in various different social situations through her fake dating job I didn't quite understand her naivety, Of all Ali's male main characters I had a little more trouble warming to Jack, I didn't quite enjoy the patronising undertone of their relationship, whereby he seemed to be constantly undermining her words from a vey early stage, despite not really knowing her at all in the beginning. As an example, the first sex scene in his apartment felt like Jack was pushing her into a situation that she was uncomfortable with, and then ignoring her words when she told him she wanted them to sleet together like she wasn't smart enough to know her own mind or make her own choices, I really wanted Elsie to use her words to put him in his place and point out the hypocrisy of his actions, and though she did a little, it wasn't quite enough, and didn't get through to him at all. For that reason it wasn't my favourite of her stories, but having said all of that I still enjoyed it and would definitely recommend to friends who I know also enjoy comedic romances.

In future books:
In future stories it would be great to see the female main character in a position of authority rather than the man again, and to explore the dynamics that would come from that.
It would also be great for the ending to be drawn out a little more; so far Ali's books tend to finish almost immediately after the tension/conflict has found some sort of resolution, whether that is accepting a job, or making up after a fight, and it would be great to be able to see more of what comes after those decisions are made.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for this advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.

I am a big fan of cheesy easy going romcoms and have enjoyed all of Ali Hazelwoods previous books and this one did not let me down either.

This book focuses on physicist Elsie as she tries to land her dream job at MIT. However one of the interview panel is her sworn academic enemy and the brother of her fake boyfriend. All of which makes for lots of fun romcom tropes and drama!

As with other Ali Hazelwoods books I love to see the women in STEM representation and academic setting. This book follows the same formula as her previous books and the result is a fun, entertaining romcom with interesting characters and some witty banter.

Was this review helpful?

Yesssssss. When I saw this was available to request, I didn’t even hesitate. I thoroughly enjoy Hazelwood’s work. It’s fun, it’s entertaining, it’s amusing, and so easy to read and some good smut through it, too.

<I>Love Theoretically</I> delivers in spades. I had so much fun reading this. I enjoyed the characters, had a few good, laugh out loud moments, and thought the situations came together well. No, there weren’t any major twists or anything like that, but that’s not what these books are about.

Well worth it, and I cannot wait for more from Hazelwood, she’s a great romcom writer, and I really like that her books have characters that are in science, makes it a bit different from the regular tropes.

Was this review helpful?

This is the second of Ali Hazelwood's novels that I have read, and I enjoyed it just as much as The Love Hypothesis. Was it predictable? Yes. Did I love it anyway? Yes. Easy, entertaining romance with great characters and an interesting academic setting.

Was this review helpful?

Love theoretically was yet another completely enjoyable read by Ali Hazelwood. If you enjoy slow burn romances this is the ONE. I almost thought I was going crazy halfway through. But when the time finally came I loved Elsie and Jack together, they had real chemistry and Hazelwood truly managed to convey that.

This is also definitely the most academically political book she’s written thus far, with a lot more stem politics talk in the beginning although this dies down toward the end as the romance becomes more apparent. Love on the Brain will forever be my favourite from Ali, however this is a strong contender to Love Hypothesis in my opinion! It really feels like the author has taken on the critique of readers and put it into her writing. I also found Elsie truly relatable, I loved her as a protagonist despite the occasional over-explanation of why she was SO small in comparison to Jack (I think we all have to accept that this is part of every book now).

The ending for me could’ve done with a little more, it was short and sweet but I wish we’d had a little epilogue or something at the end to fully show & flesh out Elsie’s development! Other than that it was a super enjoyable read and i’ll be picking up anything else Ali Hazelwood writes as per usual🤍

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely yes yes yes! Ali can do no wrong! I absolutely adored this one. I cannot write about it too much or I'll end up giving spoilers. But YES you need to read!

Was this review helpful?

I have all the feels and I bloody love it. Ali Hazelwood is just so damn good. I adored this Elsie was so adorable in her little messed up self and Jack was a sweetheart. Loved all the characters and the plot was just perfection. Fabulous. And could quite possibly be my fave.

Was this review helpful?

When Love Theoretically became available for request on NetGalley, my Twitter feed was awash with excitement. Naturally, I joined the masses.

Between me and you - I purposely requested no other books so I could sit comfortably at the desired 80% mark awaiting approval.

Elsie is fed up of earning very little, rationing her insulin and dealing with paper extension requests from her students - she's being championed for a position with MIT but her two worlds are about to collide. Whilst working on the side as a Date-For-Hire, in walks Jack, the brother of one of her Fake Boyfriends.

Elsie has to navigate the interview process under the tutelage of her mentor whilst also managing to keep up the charade of the fake relationship.

Focussing much more on the politics of academia; if your main challenge with Hazelwoods books have been the science element - this is going to be right up your street.

Yes, Love Theoretically does follow the tried and tested formula for this series of incredible STEMinist books but don't let that discourage you. This is great addition and we even get a visit from Adam and Olive from The Love Hypothesis to tie the books in together.

Was this review helpful?

I seem to be unable to dislike anything Ali Hazelwood writes. I was a bit sceptical about Love, Theoretically at first - the premise of immensely talented female researcher falling for grumpy/misunderstood scientific archenemy is starting to get a bit old. Nevertheless, the chemistry between the characters is unreal and Ali manages to write in a way that is laugh-out-loud funny (and occasionally incredibly steamy), so I was little surprised when I finished this book in less than 24 hours. I also appreciate the realistic portrayal of academia - as a fellow PhD graduate in science (albeit significantly less brilliant or successful than our hero Elsie) I recognised and sympathised with many of the struggles our characters experienced. Overall, yet another solid science romcom by Ali Hazelwood that I would definitely recommend!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley UK and the publisher for providing me with an e-arc in exchange for a review.

This book surprised me! I enjoyed it more than I expected to, given my experience of the Love Hypothesis, which fell a little flat for me…

But Love, Theoretically was funny, full of banter and chemistry between the main characters. I enjoyed the side characters of this book a lot too - Millicent most of all, she cracked me up. The pacing overall did feel a little too quick, their relationship changed lanes very, very quickly. But overall I enjoyed it. One aspect I admired was the representation of Elsie’s diabetes - I thought it was a meaningful part of her character without becoming the only thing the author/characters focused on, which is a glance not everyone pulls off!

Review will be posted to goodreads and storygraph 1st week of june

Was this review helpful?