Skip to main content

Member Reviews

We beginning the story with high drama. Amy had just been killed and the leading lady Layla was found holding Amy's body. The police obviously arrest her but Layla is adamant that they have to find someone called Michael as he will have all the answers. But the police have no idea who this person is or even if they actually exist. Layla is running out of time to convince the police that they really need to find Michael and that she had no part in it, before time runs out not only for her, not only for her husband, but for lots of other people too.

I always like a story that is told over a duel narrative timeline. I think that it keeps you guessing and keeps you engaged in the storyline. Thankfully they make it very easy for you to keep up naming the different timelines then and now.

You know that Layla isn't telling the whole truth and it is up to you and obviously the police to piece things together to find out what really happened and how the events unfolded. But can you find the truth in the lies.

I have to say that I wasn't as connected with Layla as I could have been. Which meant that I found the book at times a little hard to relate to as sometimes I couldn't understand why she acted the way that she did.

But overall a well written book that was gripping and engaging.

Was this review helpful?

I dont quite know where to start with reviewing this! I found myself quite invested early on but mainly because I couldn't get a grasp on what was actually happening. Its told over 2 timeliness and jumps back and forth, laying out the story of the story of the murder but its also all very vague and you're never quite sure if it's the narrator being unreliable or if she's just spinning it a certain way or if this did actually happen....... there is absolutely no firm grasp on the reality of the events which I guess is the same as the police trying to investigate must feel.

It's well written and as I said, that sense of being off balance and unsure of what's what is predominant throughout. The characters are well written and convincing. The plot mainly moves on via the past timeline and the current timeline is the retelling so I did feel in some parts it was a but slow just going over the same things in thr interview room but I also found I couldn't put it down because I was so desperate for answers. It's really cleverly written to have such an effect on the reader. For those who are 100% logically minded, it may be a bit frustrating because it is delving into fate and free will and coincidence and probabilities and there's even talk of an angel initially..... so..... if you need that realism then this might not be the one but if you want a book that will have you guessing the entire way through and that does an amazing job of keeping so many possibilities open, this is perfect! I've literally never been so confused and yet invested in a story before

Was this review helpful?

I would like to thank Netgalley and Bloomsbury Publishing Plc for a review copy of All I Said Was True, a stand-alone thriller set in London.

Layla Mahoney is arrested for the murder of Amy Blahn when she was found holding the body. All Layla will say is to tell them to find Michael as he has all the answers, but they can’t find Michael and wonder if he exists.

I have not read this author before, so I was excited to try a new to me style and surprised by my reaction to the novel, which I don’t think I’ve experienced before. On the one hand I found the narrative immersive and spellbinding in parts, but I found myself resistant to picking it up again when I had to put it down. I can’t explain it and I found it strange.

The novel is told on alternating timelines, helpfully titled “Now” and Then”. Now starts with Layla in custody being interviewed, while then deals with the events leading up to her arrest. The intertwining of these two stories is cleverly done with each being compulsive reading, making the reader want more and desperate to see the endgame (which I found slightly flat after what has gone before.

So, the novel is told from Layla’s point of view and it is apparent from the first chapter when she’s deciding what to tell and how to present it, that she is keeping secrets and is inherently unreliable. This is borne out by her erratic behaviour and thought patterns in the then sections. By about half way through the novel I was sure that there was an element of gaslighting to her story, but by whom I couldn’t work out. And that’s the joy or torment, depending on the reader’s view, of the novel. There is no firm ground and everything is open to interpretation. This I thought was particularly well done as interpreted one way certain events show Layla with mental health issues, interpreted another it’s a series of clumsy accidents.

I must admit that I never got to grips with Layla and her mindset. By the end of the novel I had a better understanding of why she acted as she did in custody, but I couldn’t identify with the why of it. I think that she’s a bit obsessive.

All I Said Was True is a clever and compelling read, so I have no hesitation in recommending it.

Was this review helpful?

This is the third book I have read by author Imran Mahmood and I have to say I have really enjoyed all three. The author has worked on the criminal bar in London for over 20 years and together with his skills as a writer he produces legal thrillers that have more than a touch of realism.

Amy Blahn was murdered and her body discovered on a London office rooftop. Layla Mahoney held Amy as died in her arms. The police arrest Amy who offers little defence other than saying ‘It was Michael. Find Michael and you’ll find out everything you need to know.’
The problem the police face is that there is no evidence Michael ever existed and they face a race against the clock to find either Michael or charge Layla with Amy’s murder.
Layla is a lawyer so is fully aware of the predicament the police face and knows that they only have forty eight hours in which to charge her or let her go. Layla pleads with the police to find Michael but as the interviews progress more facts come to light that threaten to expose Layla.

This is a real page turner told in a past and present format featuring the police interrogations of Layla as well as the build up to the murder itself. Well written novel that had me already looking forward to the authors next novel.

I would like to thank both Netgalley and Bloomsbury Publishing for supplying a copy of the novel in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?