Cover Image: What the River Knows

What the River Knows

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

This one was a lot of fun and the setting was great. There was just something about it that didn't hit for me. I feel like the plot was super predictable and everything was just a little too easy. I did love Whit! He was great!
I will absolutely read the sequel because I am intrigued as to what will happen next, but it just didn't fully live up to my expectations.

Was this review helpful?

As someone who loves historical fiction and fantasy, this book brings both of these genres together and I loved it! I’m a massive lover of Ancient Egypt so this book was so fun to read! Would definitely recommend to readers who also enjoy these genres and topics.
Thank you to Net Galley & the publisher for this arc

Was this review helpful?

I need to admit that I was expecting more from this book. It starts perfectly with a smart and stubborn heroine bound to solve the mystery of her parents’ death. I loved the first few chapters, where Inez travels to Egypt and joins the expedition despite everyone’s resistance. There were adventures, secrets, and some romance, as I expected from a book compared to The Mummy movies, but the pace slowed down around the middle and did not pick up until the dramatic ending. Also, the plot focused on romance, with the characters dwelling on the same problem until it felt repetitive. The world-building was also lacking, as there were some beautiful descriptions of Egypt, but the magic system was never explained properly.
What the River Knows is the first book in a duology, and I might still pick up the second book to find out how this story ends.

Was this review helpful?

DNF at 63%

Not for me, too teenager. Ok it was sweet to follow the story and try to know about the murder of the heroin's parents but I wasn't able to get into the story or get attached to the main character.
Not for me but at least I would have tried.

Was this review helpful?

Well, I jumped into this title seeing all the hype. Lemme start with the good part. This is a historical fiction with fantasy elements set in Egypt. The author subtly hints at what the western civilization has done to Egypt and how it should have had been treasured. I loved the historical aspects , but magic system could have had been better described. The female main character is a headstrong girl, Inez , but often portrayed naive. There is a romance subplot which kind of destroyed her arc for me. I don't understand why women are portrayed dumb when it comes to love, even if she's great in other areas. Whit, the main lead does have some mystery around him and I would love to know where it leads to, but I wouldn't have wanted my heroine to fall for this guy. The prose is good, ignites an interest in the reader . I hope the second part would explore more of the fantasy and Egyptian treasures.
Tw: blood/ death
Worth a 3.7/5

Was this review helpful?

A fantastic book by Isabel Ibañez and a great addition to one of my favourite genres: Historical Fantasy. The comp to The Mummy couldn't be better suited, this is an adventurous ride through Egypt with memorable characters and beautiful prose.

Was this review helpful?

I have seen this said in previous reviews but I would have to agree this gave me Brenda Fraser, The Mummy vibes. I was obsessed with the film so I definitely felt nostalgic reading this! I enjoyed the action and the magical realism side of things! Very enjoyable!

Was this review helpful?

A great adventure story that reminded me of a cross between a young Indiana Jones and The Jungle Cruise. A strong wilful female MC and although she is 19, the story reads much younger and would be a great novel for younger teens, especially if they have an interest in magic, archaeology, Egypt and Cleopatra. The writing was very accessible and the pace was fast and gripping. There are some opportunities in there to gently introduce referencing and rabbit holes to teen readers, which is a wonderful part of reading when it comes to more complex stuff. Be warned, it is a bit of an abrupt ending but it is part of a dualology. So one for the young teens in your life. Also the cover is gorgeous.

Was this review helpful?

I knew a bit about 19th century history, Ancient Egypt and archaeology but I got to find out more while reading this book. Add to this mix, magic, mystery and intrigue and this became a quite enjoyable read. Looking forward to the conclusion of this duology.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for providing an e-ARC in exchange for an honest review.

This book actually has so much potential, which is why I had such high expectations for it.

There were secrets, betrayals, enchantments, and adventures in this. I liked certain sections and didn't like others. Both the world-building and the characters are undeveloped. The magic system clearly requires more explanation, why is this not of greater concern to everyone? One character dies needlessly, and since we don't really know them well, it feels flat. The main character is irritating, and the romance feels rushed. In my view, there aren't enough obstacles in the adventure, which makes it look too easy. It's an okay read, I guess.

Was this review helpful?

If you enjoyed Divine Rivals you’ll probably enjoy this Egyptian inspired romantasy. Comparisons to the mummy are a bit of a stretch but I can see how the relationship between Edie and Rick O’Connell inspired the one in this.

There were parts of this book I really enjoyed, however I found the main character to be a little irritating in her naivety. Even when she is presented with the facts of a situation it seems as though she doesn’t understand the facts until she stumbles upon the answer alone a few chapters later (I can’t go into which part I mean without spoilers).

I’ll probably read the sequel but at the same time I’m not rushing to.

Ratings:
Romance: ❤️❤️❤️
Fantasy: 🐉🐉🐉
Plot: ✨✨✨✨
Main character: 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️
Love interest: 🥂🥂🥂🥂

Was this review helpful?

As a kid I was obsessed with ancient Egypt so it was a pleasure finding about that dives into that, that combines a little fantasy and witty romance.
I loved the main character, Inez, she’s not your usually silly little heroine: she has a plan and she pursues it till the end. Her relationship with With was also to die for and full of sarcasm, I can’t wait to see where it’ll lead.
I was a bit shocked by the ending, a part of it was unexpected, so you can say I’m excited to read the sequel. Sadly it will be just a duology!

Was this review helpful?

Mystery in the Egyptian desert, tombs, treasure, and romance, what more could I ask for?

I ended up really liking this one, as I hoped I would since I bought a shiny special edition from Goldsboro books, wanting to feel the kind of immersion in the romance that still holds sway over Egyptian archaeology, as only a hard copy can provide. The special edition has a Victorian-style gilded cover so it felt like travelling with an antique Baedeker or Thomas Cook travel book and I'm glad I waited before reading and reviewing this book.

I had already started reading the e-arc and the beginning felt quite slow, perhaps due to the digital form when I was excited about the physical copy, and maybe due to the quicker more typical YA books I had been reading prior to picking this one up, but once I got into it, I was glad the author took the time to set the scene, the politics, and the characters in play, in much the same as a murder mystery might.

I didn't absolutely love the story in its entirety though, and here's why:
1. Whit, sorry, but I'm over the aloof, smug, patronising, lolling against walls with ankles crossed at every opportunity, male love interest, just stand up straight and stop being an ass! I didn't get what Inez saw in him, and while he was redeemed a bit by the author by starting to be nicer to her, I was over him by that point, and wished someone else had turned up, other than pretty much the first man Inez saw (aside from the one that mugged her of course).

2. I'm not sure the comparison to The Mummy or Death on the Nile stands up other than sharing a setting, broadly speaking, same country, earlier time. I did keep picturing it a little more in the 20s than the book's actualy placing in the late 19th century, perhaps because of those two comparisons in the marketing, so I was picturing Mummy/Poirot-esque hotels and costumes, even if that wasn't true to the time. But it didn't have the tongue-in-cheek comedy of The Mummy, which didn't take itself too seriously, or the complexity or darkness of Death on the Nile, the murder mystery element felt like a secondary theme, or undercurrent, rather than the main focus. The focus went more to the predictable romance, and the mystery of the artifacts and Inez's uncle's work and motivations.

3. I kind of liked the magic, though it meant that some of the discoveries were made through magic rather than through any detection or work on the main characters' part, I would have preferred clues and research to be at the forefront, and for Inez to show her smarts and that she could hold her own in the company of Egyptologists rather than her being used for her 'as luck would have it' ability. I'm still not entirely sure who has these abilities or why, or why some people don't, though I might have missed a key bit of information somewhere along the line.

Despite that though, I did really like it, I liked the way the book introduced the evils of colonialism, especially on the impact on a nation's material culture and identity, fiction like this is a good way to start and continue those conversations, and Inez and her family are an interesting way to explore that being neither European nor Egyptian, nor are her family, or Inez herself, entirely without fault, or complete outsiders to the debate, which was also interesting. The lure of treasure and objects, mystery and knowledge, affected Inez too.

The ending was brilliant, I didn't see it coming, as much as I recognised the signs along the way, the pre-ending twist, I did see coming, but not the finale, phew! I will definitely have to read the next one, I hope Goldsboro bring out a matching sequel!

Was this review helpful?

This is all my teenage archaeology dreams within the pages of a book.
A beautiful and vibrant world with sprinklings of magic, heaps of adventure and well thought out likeable characters.
I cant wait for the next one!

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars

I think there is always an issue when a book is marketed as ‘for fans of…’ in that it creates an idea and expectation of the book that you hold as a standard. In the case of What The River Knows, you are told this is like The Mummy meets Death on the Nile – so you’re expecting humour, endearing characters romance, adventure along with suspenseful mystery – unfortunately the comparisons end at the fact this novel is based in Egypt.

It's very possible I could have enjoyed this book more had I not gone into it with such high expectations and was allowed to make my own judgements, it is still an enjoyable book, however The Mummy it is not.

To go into it further, we have the main character Inez who lives with her aunt and cousins in Buenos Aires as her parents are excavating in Egypt with her uncle, following treasures and no matter how hard she tries, they don’t let her join them. Then one day she gets a letter saying her parents are missing, presumed dead – and she takes it upon herself to travel to her Uncle in Cairo to try and find out what happened to her parents. Upon arrival she’s met by Whit, British and mysterious with a deadly edge and working for his uncle, and immediately he tries to get her to leave, upon the orders of her uncle. Why do they not want her in Cairo? What are they worried she will find? Where are her parents and what were they looking for when they disappeared? Inez and, along the way, a reluctant Whit work together to try find out the truth.

I’ll start off with what I liked – Egypt. Egypt is the heart of this book, I feel like it was the story the author wanted to tell and I enjoyed it, you can ‘see’ the Nile, the history in the artefacts, the colours and the smells. There are also some good adventure moments and Inez can be a strong character at times, although I preferred Isadora who is painfully underwritten but a stronger, more empowering character.

This is an enjoyable read at face value, however I must review this as I’ve received a copy from NetGalley and in exchange I must be more critical and honest – if you were just reading this book without a critical eye, like I said, you’ll probably enjoy it.

However, that said, there are issues with this book and it’s probably easier if I list them:

Whit – our faux Rick O’Connell. He’s British, he’s impeccably dressed, he doesn’t stop flirting, he’s closed off but gives you crumbs of the troubled boy behind the shield, he’s dangerous and can be cruel but he’ll save you from crocodiles and he’s terribly beautiful. Whit is just an annoying character, quite a cliché creation and very unlikeable. For example, from the start of this book he’s terrible condescending and rude to Inez when she arrives in Egypt and he wants he to travel back home. Think the scene in The Mummy when Rick wants Evelyn to stay in the hotel so carries her over his shoulder and locks her in the room – that but without charm. He tells Inez repeatedly she can’t call him by his first name as it’s too informal, and then calls her by hers all the time. He’s hot and cold and honestly I have no idea why Inez likes him – besides the fact his hair, eyes blah blah blah
Then there’s Inez – our spirited Evelyn – she wants to chase knowledge and adventure, she wants to be more than the role of a wife, proper and elegant, as expected of her. She would be a strong character but she’s inconsistent – she acts like she knows she deserves more then moons over a boy who is terrible to her, she is reckless and spontaneous and for a character meant to be intelligent – makes some incredibly stupid decisions. For example, Whit makes it very clear that his allegiance is with Inez’s uncle and won’t lie to him – so when Inez is exploring somewhere, somewhere that someone else has already warned her to keep secret, she tells Whit what she knows, she uncovers things with him present – and then she acts surprised that he’ll tell her uncle. She also falls for some very obvious things that I can’t go into.
The romance – see above. It’s just not necessary and it’s deader and dustier than any of the treasures they’re trying to dig up.
The world building – there’s a magic system in this book that makes no sense and it’s not really developed either. Some artifacts hold magic, Inez gets glimpses of Cleopatra, a sandal can produce light like a torch, a scarf can shrink objects etc – but why? Why does no one particularly care about this when surely these items should be the treasures everyone is hunting after?
This book relies on miscommunication and it’s enraging – no one tells Inez anything and then they get annoyed that she gets the wrong idea and doesn’t understand things and gets herself in situations trying to find out the information for herself. So much of the plot could’ve been resolved with a simple conversation.
Unnecessary character death – just why???????
The ending …
Certain complaints, like the magic system, I accept may be resolved in the next book, I’ll admit I thought this was a one off when I started reading and then the ending made it very clear it wasn’t!

Like I’ve said, this isn’t a bad read, I just didn’t enjoy it as much as I thought I would, when you go in with a high expectation you mark down, not up. Essentially the characters need some work in depth and likeability and we need more word building to understand the magic – but I hope this changes with the next book.

Thank you NetGalley for the copy in exchange for an honest review

Was this review helpful?

I had high expectations to this, as I adore anything to do with ancient Egypt and archaeology. Sadly, this fell really flat, and was just too silly. Had to DNF at 25%.
My biggest problem was Whit - he's just obnoxious, no charm at all and I eventually couldn't make myself pick up the book cause he's in it.
The magic system felt very wishy washy as well, and I don't think the story would've changed much without it.
Did enjoy the setting and the discussions of colonialism and the dark side of Egyptology though!

Was this review helpful?

Ahhh finally a book about Egypt! I loved Egyptian mythology and history and am always on a lookout for a fantasy book inspired by it. The setting, the characters, the mystery, they were all expertly done and I couldn't get enough. Inez is an endearing, if slightly naive, MC, and my heart really did break for her in this book. I cannot wait to read the sequel!

Was this review helpful?

This is fantastic opener to a series and I cannot wait to see where it goes next.

I'm a sucker for an ancient historical setting but had never delved too deep into Egyptian mythology so was excited to read this!

Inez's world is torn apart when her parents are mysteriously killed whilst researching in egypt. She seeks to find answers about their deaths by travelling to egypt her self and is faced with secrets, legends and more questions than answers.

Inez is a strong and charming protagonist who I found likeable, convincing and entertaining. I loved the additon of morally grey but smart Whit and the chemistry between him and Inez as the plot progressed.

There is such a cliffhanger and I cannot wait for the next novel!

Was this review helpful?

𝐖𝐡𝐚𝐭 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐑𝐢𝐯𝐞𝐫 𝐊𝐧𝐨𝐰𝐬 | 𝐑𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰

It feels like it's been a hot minute since I enjoyed a book quite as much as I did this one!

Basically this book has everything - historical fantasy, slow burn romance, magic, mystery, brooding love interest, a strong willed and funny female mc, betrayals, family secrets, ancient Egyptian artifacts and archaeology… I could go on.

19 year old Inez has lived a comfortable life with her aunt in Buenos Aires but what she really wanted was her parents who were always away globetrotting for work, leaving her behind. When she receives a letter to say her parents have gone missing, presumed dead, Inez steals away to find out what really happened to them, disguising herself as a member of her uncle’s archaeological expedition and boarding a boat bound for the heart of the Valley of the Kings.

I loved Inez as a main character- she was so fearless and charismatic, the chemistry between her and Whit, the uncle's PA of sorts, was just spot on perfect and I couldn't put the book down.

Eagerly anticipating the next book in the series after a bombshell of an epilogue!

Thanks to @netgalley for the opportunity to read this ahead of its release, but What The River Knows is out now!

Was this review helpful?

Inez Olivera has everything she could ever want, but with one exception… her parents. Living with her aunt and cousins in Buenos Aires, she longs to join her parents on their adventures. When she receives a letter informing her of the death of her parents in mysterious circumstances, Inez is determined to uncover the truth. She arrives in Cairo with only her sketch pad and an ancient ring sent to her by her father. When the ring unleashes ancient magic, Inez finds herself on a treacherous path with danger at every turn.

Described as The Mummy meets Indiana Jones, this Young Adult book is already a hit since its release in November. I was so excited to read this but for me, it fell short. I loved the world building and the detailed descriptions of 19th century Egypt (the archaeology, the bustling streets of Cairo and the colourful characters) are beautifully written. The relationship between her and the handsome ill-humoured Whit just didn’t sit right with me. They’ve been described as the new Rick and Evie from The Mummy which I disagree with. There’s plenty of banter between the two protagonists but there was a real lack of chemistry and I think that this may be due to the fact that the author is aiming this story towards a younger young adult audience maybe? It just didn’t seem authentic.

I was all for the adventure, the supernatural and mystery elements of the story but there were definite gaps in the plot and the ending was infuriating! There will be a sequel but I think some of the plot holes needed to be addressed in this book.

Thanks to NetGalley and Hodder and Stoughton for the arc. Where The River Knows is out now.

Was this review helpful?