Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I thoroughly enjoy hades and Persephone retelling and all things Greek mythology. That being said, I also read the first book of this before and was looking forward to this one. I’m so excited that it lived up to my hype. I do hate the miscommunication between them but I loved the book so much. I wish there was more Cerebus though, he’s my favorite.

Was this review helpful?

"I am the Queen of the Underworld, but I am also the Goddess of Spring, and I have lived too long being one without the other, existing as half of myself, ashamed of an entire part of me."

I really enjoyed this sequel! It definitely did not go in the direction I thought it would after the first book which in a way made the story more interesting to read. The character development was interesting and I loved getting to revisit these characters!

"How do we piece our souls back together when neither of us knows where to start?"

My one complaint would be I felt like the plot got lost in the story. Certain events were rushed through so we could focus more on the emotional effects of the events. It was hard to connect to the trauma the characters were experiencing when the trauma event itself wasn't a focus of the book. The story just really got bogged down by the character's miscommunication and the storyline getting buried under the weight of the character's emotional baggage.

"My brothers collect weapons and power. I collect knowledge. In the end, the weapons that always stood the test of time were between the pages of a book."

This isn't a profound and complicated story, but it isn't supposed to be. Did I have fun? Yes, and that's what counts. Thus, four stars.

Was this review helpful?

I dunno why but I'm not vibing with this book although I loved the first book. I will try later again, maybe I'll change my mind but I just not liking the plot amd the fact they are apart. Like let them be together and overcome their issues together.

Was this review helpful?

3.5⭐️ 3🌶️

I am a sucker for Hades and Persephone retellings and I loved the fresh take book one had so I couldn’t wait for book 2.

I love Hades so much. I loved that despite being the ruler of the underworld and a pretty important guy in the human world, he was still vulnerable when it came to insecurities with his relationship with Persephone. I never doubted his love and commitment to her. It broke my heart when he really needed some reassurance from Persephone about their relationship and she was not in the right headspace to have serious heart to heart with him.

I once again struggled a little with Persephone. I loved so much about her, like her ridiculous nickname for Cerberus, her friendship with Mellie, and her acceptance and compassion for everyone in the underworld. But I struggled with understanding why she was so resistant to talking to Hades and why she created distance between them for so long when it was quickly resolved when they finally did talk. I loved what a total baddie she became when the underworld was under attack but I also raged at how she chose handle things at the end of the book leading to a crazy cliffhanger.

This very much felt like book two in a trilogy and I am anxious for the next one to see how this is resolved.

Was this review helpful?

I was lucky enough to get a ARC of this book and knowing it was pert of a series i grabbed myself a copy of the first, and i was hooked.

I do love retelling stories with a bit of something extra and this definitely had the something extra.

I loved the characters of Hades and Persephone and the way they interacted with each other and how their love blossoms even with plenty of things stopping them and these books it seems always ends with a cliffhanger which frustrates me no end but I’m looking forward to the next instalment hopefully it will not be too long.

Thank you netgalley for a copy for an honest review

Was this review helpful?

Definitely should have read the first one before this, I didn't realize this was the second in the series before getting the ARC. I'm a sucker for a good spicy Greek mythology retelling especially hades and persephone, but this one wasn't my favorite. Maybe I would have liked it more if I had read the first one but the miscommunication in this got very aggravating. But the cliffhanger will leave people eager for the next book so I won't knock it too much.

Was this review helpful?

i did not read the sequel because the first one did not do it for me. however, i would be willing to revisit them in the future!

Was this review helpful?

MY First ARC REVIEW YESSSS! I love how kind of very faithful to Greek mythology how hades even though is ruler of the underworld is really just a regular dude. The main problem is that Persephone gets into trouble because of Persephone. Persephone never wants to communicate which causes problems and makes things feel awkward. Even though everything is on the line Persephone just wants to get dick downed so badly in the first book. That now she thinks Hades doesn't want her anymore lmao. At least in the first book there was smut which was it's redeeming quality. This one has NONE! and it flopped badly. 1.5 stars. Just my honest review. Persephone ruined the whole book for me. Miscommunication has it's place in romance books but not in the exchange for the whole book. This DRAGGED THROUGHT THE WHOLE BOOK! And the depressing energy doesn't for this type of story. just saying!

Was this review helpful?

This is book two in the series of a retelling of Hades x Persephone. I really enjoyed it and couldn’t put it down. I have read book one and two so far and can’t wait to read the third book when it comes out. Thank you to Alexis Rune, Jeanette Rose, Rose and Star Publishing and Netgalley for an opportunity to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

I wouldn't say I liked this book as much as I wanted the first one. I felt this one was more centered on the couple being apart then when they are actually together. Also, I just hated the plot arc of the entire book. I loved the original ending of the first book and would have been okay with just that as the ending.

Was this review helpful?

I was so excited for The Mistress & The Renowned after reading The Maiden & The Unseen, but this did not meet my expectations whatsoever. So bummed!

Was this review helpful?

Book 2 in the series begins with Persephone now trapped in the Underworld as its new Queen, with her King Hades mysteriously missing. This book absolutely did not go the way I expected, and I’m all here for it! The first book was extremely smutty, which I loved, but this book-which some smut is still there-takes a much more serious tone and deals heavily with trauma and past abuse. It focuses clearly on the relationship between Hades and Persephone along with the new threat to the Underworld.

The story deals heavily with a plot point that is hardly ever addressed in any real way in any of the stories I’ve read of Hades before, but that I always thought needed to be. Hades grew up while falling in a void, and then spent the first part of his adulthood in a prison realm out of time. Only to be spat back out and into a war they weren’t prepared for. The trauma of such a thing has to be insane! This unpacks a lot of his emotions regarding this, his repression of those memories, and the harm it’s caused him long term.

We also deal with Persephone’s trauma here, which is really two fold. There’s the newer trauma from an event in the book, and that has shaken her to her core. It’s not something she regrets, but to get what she wanted, she had to deal go through hell. It leaves her in a head space where she can’t deal with anyone else’s trauma, and that’s a problem for her relationship at present. Then, there’s the trauma of her mother, Demeter, and the years of abuse she put Persephone through. Which is much worse in this story than just being overly controlling as in others.

Mellie makes her appearances in this book, but doesn’t have a whole lot going on here beyond helping Persephone and trying to dodge Helios. We do get more of Zeus and Poseidon. This series makes a really cool change to the usual mythology and makes the three much closer. Brothers in truth. I love getting glimpses at their relationship. The three of them messing with each other is hilarious. It’s such a big change from the usual relationship I’ve seen of them, I definitely think it was a good choice here. Especially where these boys have so much trauma already. They don’t need to add to that!

In regards to the main relationships here, Persephone and Hades love each other. That is so very clear, but both are new to relationships and have a lot of trauma to deal with. This inevitably leads to issues as the two try to deal with their issues as individuals as well as a couple. Their journey from where we left them last book, after the curse was activated, is fantastic. Persephone’s anger over her choices being taken away is addressed and dealt with, while Hades tries to deal with his own fears and insecurities. I really enjoyed getting to see the ups and downs they have and how two people who love each other so deeply can have such trouble communicating that it threatens the relationship itself.

While a much heavier book than the first, there are plenty of moments of lightness and levity here. Persephone’s relationship with Cerberus, or Berry as she calls her marshmallow, is so freaking adorable. Seeing the three of them all as a family is too cute. Especially when he gets in the way of their alone time, and Persephone is stuck between disappointing her boy or sacrificing sexy time. Hades is able to hear his thoughts with their bond, and we’re left with the impression his need to be near her is to protect her. Which is both adorable and worrying.

There are a lot of really cute Hades moments here too. In reality, this is a man who grew up alone and isolated, without love. He became “the rich one” due to his need to have more, because he had so little. He knew he would have a fated queen one day, and we waited eagerly for her. Even as much as he hated the fates calling the shots for him, he wanted that love and companionship that he’d always been lacking. The depth they go into Hades’ psyche here is truly impressive! And due to this, his moments of vulnerability and his need to cling to Persephone is heartbreaking. But, we also get the slightly sillier and adorable version of Hades when he’s with Persephone and happy. And the two work through their issues to find a momentary reprieve.

But Demeter is far from letting things go. Abusers like her feel the need to control. And Persephone is currently out of hers. She will do absolutely anything to get that back. Her plan, once unraveled, is horrifying. The end of this book ends on a cliffhanger, one that punches you in the gut after all we’ve just been through with Hades and Persephone. My heart broke and shattered for them. Demeter is well aware the two won’t just give the other up, and finds a way around it. I seriously have to know how this goes from here, and I hate that I have to wait for the next book! I’ll be anxiously awaiting the next part in this series to calm the anxiety and dread this ending left me with (in a good way)!

Was this review helpful?

I loved this sequel. My favourite part was the relationship between Persephone and Cerberus. I liked the way the author explored the feelings of Persephone once she arrives in the Underworld and then after she reunites with Hades. The end I feel could have built up a little more. I enjoyed that we saw more of Hades past and more of the dynamic between him and his brothers.
I’m ready for the sequel and to find out what happens between Hades and Persephone

Was this review helpful?

Spoilers ahead for THE MAIDEN & THE UNSEEN.

After Hades claims Persephone as his queen, she is whisked off to the Underworld…and he goes missing. As Persephone adjusts to life as the Queen of the Dead, she also struggles with her conflicting emotions of anger at Hades for taking away her consent and worry that something is wrong. Meanwhile, Hades is trapped in a void, his abilities doing everything they can to keep him from becoming a broken shell. The two work to find their way back to each other while something even more sinister simmers underneath, biding its time.

The vibes of this story are vastly different from the vibes of the first. The first book was very much a romantasy where the two main characters had to find their way to each other and to falling in love. The focus of this story shifts to what happens after they do and the struggles of maintaining a relationship and battling other forces, both from within and without.

With less of a focus on the romance, there is the opportunity to explore darker themes with this story. From the question of consent to trauma and PTSD, Rose and Rune definitely veer onto a different path for this story. Which is not to say that there is no romance - Hades and Persephone are still trying to figure out their dynamic and it’s nice to see that even gods stumble sometimes.

Though this story did feel cohesive overall, it does also feel like there are multiple stories in one, as if each act of the book had its own three act story that played out. It isn’t something that I would say necessarily took away from the story, but it did feel a little jarring at times.

Once again, we are left with a cliffhanger at the end that leaves me ready and waiting for the next book to come out. I’m not sure if it’s different in the finished copy vs. the ARC, but there is an additional scene after the last chapter that jumps back to an earlier point in the book from a side character’s POV, which felt like a strange way to end the book.

Disclaimer: I received an advanced copy of this book from the publisher for free and have voluntarily written this review.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book! It continued with the story from Book 1, but it added more political drama and trauma within this. The authors have made it clear that the content warnings for this book include PTSD, Child Abuse (Historical), Emotional/Physical Torture, Sexual Content, and Fantasy Violence. Looking back at my review of book 1, I hoped that book 2 would have more world-building and could set the scene more. I am happy to report that we better understand the world of the gods and the different realms, but there is a heavy focus on the Underworld. The relationship between Hades and Persephone builds where they are learning to communicate and be an actual couple. The depiction of Cerebus in this book is the most adorable depiction that can happen. The ending of the book somewhat is of a cliffhanger and makes me wish Book 3 was already in my hands.

Was this review helpful?

The Maiden and the Unseen was a five star read of mine so I was beyond excited to continue the series. Much to my dismay, The Mistress and the Renouned was mostly filler and nothing of consequence happened until the last few chapters. I found that this book lacked the charm of the first book and the characters lost the depth they had.

I was excited for the drama between Hades and Persephone following the events of the previous book but all I got was two immortal gods acting like angsty teenagers. I did really enjoy the sweet romantic moments between the pair, but unfortunately there just wasn't enough plot to hold my interest.

This book ends on a cliffhanger and I am actually quite intrigued to find out what happens so I'd definitely be open to reading the next book.

Was this review helpful?