Wow - where to start!

When I put my "I believe" cap on, I really enjoy this book. Maybe it's my age, maybe it's my inability to be social, maybe it's something else... I find some of these scenes extremely hard to believe. But that's okay. I enjoyed it anyway. Despite the formulaic style of this writing I did like the ending and the path to the ending.

The writing was fun and entertaining. Learning about the characters was a great ride. I loved the different personalities and could really see how they all came together to make a great "union". I couldn't put this book down once I got started and I told my bookselling friends all about it.

I am so sorry. I read this long ago, before my divorce trauma, so I do not remember it. I do not have access to the book any longer and really do not remember anything about

Thoroughly enjoyed this read.
Some say smut, I say an easy exciting raunchy read .
It’s never going to be a literary great but I would recommend to my more open and adventurous friends

There isn't much to say about this book that hasn't already been said. It's a short read that focuses more on the smut and insta-lust than the plot. For some that may be a deal breaker, while for other readers, it could be exactly what they're looking for.

There are only a couple true issues with the book, one being the author actually develops some plot in the beginning that could have been expanded on upon. This would have made the erotic scenes hit harder. The other issue is that it is a short read but seems almost too long for pure smut. In an era of bite size erotic reads, this novella feels like it should either be longer or shorter.

However, if you're looking for a short reverse harem sparked by insta-lust and carried by smut involving three brother

The book is hot, there’s no denying that. If you want sexy scenes then yes! However the instalove is very quick. I wish there had been more build up and resistance in them falling for her and plot built around this. Still a good read

The book starts off strong, with an interesting plot which lays the groundwork for great character development, and the writing is atmospheric, capturing the mystery and charm of Edinburgh. The issue is how they fall for her INSTANTLY. And to top it off, 70% of the book is just confusingly written smut. And unfortunately, I was unable to look past the whole brothers thing.

Quick, easy, and smutty book! This book got hot and heavy quickly! The story was very detailed with smut. There wasn't a lot of character build-up or plot. For a quick easy read, it keeps your attention. I do wish there were more character and plot details. More to the storyline besides three brothers wanting the same girl would have been nice too.
Thank you, NetGalley, for allowing me to read this book and give my honest review. Thank you, Lily Manning, for writing this book.

A good quick and dirty martini of a read! There is a little plot, but it quickly boots through to the next spicy scene. If you're in it for the spice, this is a great read, but it feels a little lacking in the rest of the story.

Definitely a good one for those who enjoy a Scottish hunk or three! All three very different characters were a good mix for the MFC. But there felt like a lot of repetition of thoughts considering it wasn't a long story. Would have wish for more plot.

Thank you to @NetGalley and Innes Field LLC for my ebook!

"Making Her Theirs" by Lily Manning is a tale set against the captivating backdrop of Edinburgh, where the main character, Georgia, finds herself attracted by the Knox brothers upon stepping into a lively bar. Spicy and cheesy romance read.

Huge thanks to Innes Field LLC & Netgalley for the ARC!!! I love Reverse Harem. This book was 5+ SPICY! I read this book in less than 1 day 🫣. Knox, Finn and Lachlan are every girls dream. I believe the character development was fine for how short the book was. Knox is possesive, Finn is fun and Lachlan is sweet & kind. The way these men folded for Georgia, the FMC, was EVERYTHING! 😍 The ending was exactly what I wanted it to be as a reader who is all about the happy ending! The author left me wanting more with the sneak peak into the next book! If you are into quick reads, Reverse Harem, & 🌶️… then this book will have you 🔥!! Loved this read.

Quick read. Light on the plot and character development. And lots of cheese and smut.

Not for me, but maybe enjoyable to others.

Good book with several well done parts. However there were some slow parts as well. Nothing to bad but definitelyslower.

"Making Her Theirs" by Lily Manning is a tale set against the captivating backdrop of Edinburgh, where the main character, Georgia, finds herself entranced by the Knox brothers upon stepping into a lively bar. Each brother embodies a unique allure: Knox is the epitome of intensity and possessiveness, offering a sense of dominance and protection. Finn, with his effortless charm and laughter, brings lightness and adventure, making every encounter unforgettable. Lachlan, the strong and silent type, communicates a deep understanding and connection without words, his presence alone compelling.

The story unfolds as Georgia navigates the complexities and intensities of forming a unique bond with each brother, exploring themes of desire, consent, and mutual respect. The Knox brothers, each dealing with their own vulnerabilities and strengths, find in Georgia a kindred spirit, someone who matches their intensity and fulfills their longing for connection.

It's a narrative that promises an exploration of love's boundless possibilities, set within the enchanting streets of Scotland's capital. The novel is explicit in its portrayal of the characters' relationships and is designed for readers who appreciate a story where romance and desire take the forefront, challenging conventional boundaries of love and partnership.

While the novel excels in delivering steamy encounters and explores the dynamics with the Knox brothers and Georgia, I do wish for deeper character development and a more substantial storyline beyond the erotic aspects.

Not my cup of tea. No storyline. If you are looking for a book that is 90% smut, this is it.
Maybe it's just me, but the amount of times the brothers just "forgot" they are sleeping with the same girl, at the same time, just doesnt do anything for me but creep me out. And I would like to know what type pf shower fits 4 grown people???

This was interesting.....read like an adult film rather than a novella. So bizarre and honestly unbelievable on all accounts but I still read it.

A very sexy fantasy, but pretty much just that. Three beautiful, perfect men, all brothers, fall head over heels for the same girl. She’s not like other girls, she drinks whisky and likes anal sex and is always horny for these boys. Sexy, funny, and a quick read, but ultimately full of typos and wildly unrealistic dialogue and an ending too tied up in a bow too fast. Fun though!

It's a sweet story, mostly porn with a little bit of plot. Has a HEA ending which was super sweet. The writing was a little cheesy and over the top at times. But it was a nice quick day read that had just the right amount of spice.

If you are looking for plot, this isn't for you. If you are looking for the smut aspect of adult romance, then you've come to the right place. Manning excels in writing the open door scenes and it was a wild ride to read!

Imagine stepping into a bar in Edinburgh and you cross paths with three breathtaking men, but did you know they were all brothers?

Each brother is magnificent in their own way. Knox is possessive and burly. Finn is charming and lovely. Lachlan is a tortured soul who finally found hope in a southern Texas girl Georgia.

Each man falls for her in their own way they need and the each have their own sensual scenes with her. Individually, with two brothers and sometimes all three. Spicy level is high on this book! I would’ve loved more storyline in this book but overall it is very erotic.

📚 Thank you NetGalley for the eARC in exchange for an honest review!

— reverse harem
— why choose
— insta lust/love
— lots of 🌶

If you want some good, quick smut then this is the story for you. This spice in this was actually pretty good, but it was hard for me to stay tuned into the story line. The beginning was actually going along pretty good, it was around 15-20% in when I started struggling to stay tuned in unfortunately.

I felt I was getting almost too much interaction between the characters and sex versus getting plot/character development. I did appreciate the boys and their backstory; again, I just wish there was more to add onto from that — it felt counter productive for them to have abandonment issues but to be instantly attracted to this random girl by first sight.