I had a hunch I would dig this book. What I didn't know that I would absolutely love it! After struggling find her place, Maggie is running her friend's bookstore. The store is unique in that it only sells books that were published when the town's favorite author was alive. So, nothing new. When the store needs revenue. Maggie decides to start an underground book club where authors offer their spin on classics. She also starts selling new books on the side. And she unexpectedly finds this incredible community. But how can she keep this all going? She's determined to find a way, and that is so much of the story. Y'all, this was just a delight. I wanted more - I was so drawn into Maggie's world - her events, her relationships, everything - I want/need to know what's next because it was just that wonderful. Thanks to NetGalley for the look at this January 2024 release - one y'all definitely need to check out!

Rated - 3 / 5 ✨

When a book has Book Club in the title, I couldn’t not request it.

This was a really easy, light hearted read about a woman called Maggie, she’s unhappy with the path her life is on and is struggling to find her purpose. Her best friend Rochelle asks her if she can cover the book shop she works in whilst she’s on maternity leave, here is where the story really begins. There is mystery, fun, romance and adventure.

I liked Maggie, she was fun, but I found her frustrating at times, it was so obvious what she would be doing by the end of the story. Malcom the love interest was great, a quiet, serious, sweet book lover. I really enjoyed how they pulled each other out of their comfort zones.

However, I found their feelings for each other a little dull. There was no actual chemistry or spark shared in the story, there was the opportunity so many times, but it felt overlooked We didn’t actually get any really passion from either of them, I found it so frustrating.

The relationships with the towns people were really lovely, I loved getting to know them and seeing the whole town grow as the story progressed.

Overall, this was a lovely read, with some laughter and happiness.

Thanks NetGalley, One More Chapter and Shauna Robinson for the eARC.

Maggie is having a rough time so when her friend offers her the opportunity to run her bookstore while she goes on maternity leave, she decides to take her up on it. The problem is, the bookstore isn’t too profitable because it only sells books from a certain time period because the town historical society owns and runs most of the town puts restrictions on what can be done and sold in the town. After attending a booksellers event, she gets inspired to make the store more profitable for her friend by forming a back door book club and sells books that would otherwise be banned from the store and starts to host author events that have members of the town excited to come to now that they can buy something other than books from 1838. The connections she makes with the townspeople, and in particular her grumpy upstairs neighbor Vernor, are what really make the story.
This was an heartwarming and enjoyable story sprinkled in with bits of humor.
Thanks to One More Chapter and NetGalley for this eArc in exchange for my review.

So I feel silly… I didn’t realize that The Secret Book Club is actually the same book as The Banned Bookshop of Maggie Banks. There are just two different titles (one for the US and on for the UK). I have no idea why this book required a title change, but I am happy to report I read the book in February of 2023 and LOVED it. Anyone one who is a fan of books about books or romcoms should give it a go in whichever title you prefer!

What could be more perfect than a book taking place in a bookstore. I find it hard to believe one selling only classics would stay open very long.
I applaud Maggie’s desire to make more money. It’s rather resourceful on her part. I can’t say this was my favorite book but I’m sure some others will enjoy it

A slow, interesting book that made me think about the books that I read and enjoy. Would I be put off a book if I didn't like the author? There was a fantasy series that I really enjoyed, but in the author's notes at the end he didn't come across very well. The idea of a bookshop that only sold "old" literature doesn't seem to be a sound business decision and I'm totally with Maggie with her efforts to get around this. I'm probably much more staid than she is, but we need people like her to get us out of the rut. The focus is on the books, rather than the romance, but is the better for that. Definitely worth reading if you fancy something a bit different.
I received an advance copy of this book from the publisher through Netgalley, however this did not influence my review of the book.

The Secret Book Club by Shauna Robinson

Maggie moves to Bell River to take over her best friend Rochelle's book shop while she is on maternity leave. But this is not a usual bookshop - they only sell classic literature and the books written by the town's hero, author Edward Bell, by order of his grandson Ralph. Maggie settles into small town life, makes lots of friends, runs secret events and sells forbidden books, until she discovers a secret that will change everything.

I loved this book - the small town with quirky characters reminded me of Stars Hollow (Gilmore Girls), I loved the storyline and Maggie's journey, and I loved the mystery around Edward Bell and its resolution. Very VERY highly recommended.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC of this book.

[I wasn’t an aimless wanderer who gave in too easily to distraction. I was driven. I had purpose. It was just a purpose that didn’t fit the mold of what people expected. And there was nothing wrong with that, was there?]

Oh how I LOVED reading books about books, a secret book club, and how books are able to bring people together (grumpy neighbor included). Seeing Maggie finally able to find her place in this world after struggling to do so for a long time truly warms my heart.

Attention all Bookstagrammers: This book is 100% your jam. I am beyond confused as to why I have seen it NOWHERE. It has:

1. A protagonist who develops a love of reading
2. A super cute romance that isn’t even the main point of the book, but it’s there and adorable nonetheless
3. An elderly curmudgeon who is actually lovely
4. A really fantastic idea for a bookstore event that I would absolutely get out of my I’m-at-home pajamas and leave my house for
5. A female protagonist who I loved (and loved to root for)

The Banned Bookshop of Maggie Banks lighthearted and an absolute delight. It was the perfect book to balance my reading of Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow this past week.

Bell River is both a totally fabulous location for a book, but equally between the town, the Bell society, and all of the various rules in place by Ralph, I do sometimes wonder if I was almost reading about a cult.

Or at least the setting of a rather disturbing film, as there is something just so creepy about the hero worship of author Edward Bell.

He wrote his most famous book in the town, and as a result it thrives on tourism of people that are fans of the man, and thanks to the Bell Society, the bookshop in town that Maggie is looking after, it's only allowed to sell books that were around before Edward's death. So nothing recent, and predominately classics.

However Maggie who is doing a favour for a friend and looking after the shop for a few months, is a bit of a rule breaker, and well things start to get interesting. She's also just discovering an absolute love of books, and that is fabulous to see.

I absolutely loved the secret events Maggie set up, and if I was in town I would have happily gone to them, they sounded amazing.

However I never really gelled with the love interest in this story, I just couldn't really feel anything for him, and although I could see they were building a connection, it felt more platonic to me!

But other than that, I thoroughly enjoyed this book, I loved hating the obvious bad guy, and seeing Maggie develop as a character and find out what she may truly want from life is inspiring. .

And above all it is clear to me that with the two books I've now read, that Shauna Robinson really really loves books!

Thank you to One More Chapter and Netgalley for this copy which I have reviewed honestly and voluntarily.

The Secret Book Club is about Maggie who's been unemployed for 10 month, suddenly encounter a chance for a temporary job at a bookstore managed by her best friend. Except, what's weird is that the bookstore only allowed a classic literature and mostly just a book by Edward Bell (the famous author who used to work at their bookstore. Hence it become a main attraction of the tourist). Maggie then having a wild ideas which is to snuck in a books from different genre and create an illegal book club at the store,

The story was entertaining and fun as you can relate to the main character, Maggie and how you just want to read more than just a classic literature. Owning a bookstore is a fun job, interact with people that have the same interest as you is a huge enjoyment. The romance is not that bad either.

However, the way the conflict is handle are quite abrupt considering the problem Maggie caused is big, irresponsible and childish. While I admire her courage and wanting to do more for people she love, she needs to think more of the consequences. Not only that, her action cause a damage to the town's images. Her character is relatable but at some part it's quite annoying.

I love her chemistry with Malcolm though. both of them are adorable. Their discussion about the books they've read is just so cute (I want to have that too not gonna lie). Overall this is an enjoyable read but the ending is quite rushed.

HarperCollins UK, One More Chapter, One More Chapter and NetGalley provided an eARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. Opinions expressed here are solely my own.

Pros:
- The premise
- The diverse small town setting
- Malcolm, the MMC
- All of the supporting characters

Cons:
- Maggie, the FMC
- Not enough spice

I am a sucker for diverse small town rom-coms and enemies to lovers stories. This was a very cute story - so cute that I kept reading even though Maggie, the FMC, was extremely annoying.

DNF'd at 10%. I just found this really boring and dull - I'm sure if you want something with relatively low stakes this will appeal to you, but I just couldn't bring myself to keep reading it.

This was a sweet story about Maggie, who moves to the small town of Bell River to cover for her friend Rochelle’s maternity leave in Rochelle’s bookstore. The whole town revolves around a famous writer - Edward Bell and many of the businesses are owned by Ralph Bell. Things have been done a certain way to put Edward Bell on a pedestal and Ralph doesn’t seem willing to change. I loved how Maggie quickly made herself at home in Bell River and got herself an army of friends, including the grumpy man who lives upstairs from the bookstore, Vernon. Maggie wants to make some changes, but has to do them secretly so Ralph doesn’t find out. Maggie was a loveable character and there was a sweet romance. When Maggie finds out some surprising information she does all she can to make things better for the residents. A fun read involving a small town, books, book events and friends helping friends.

Is it just me? When I see a book with the word book in the title I have to read it! This is a story about Maggie Banks and a town called Bell River where everything pays homage to author Edward Bell. His grandson Ralph more or less owns the town including a share in the bookstore run by Maggie best friend Rochelle. Maggie has come to help run the bookshop whilst her friend has a baby, but there are rules, lots of rules and Maggie soon manages to fall foul. A nice light and easy read with some great characters and a one sitting read for me.

Briefly, the best selling books in the bookshop are those written by Edward Bell. When these are removed from the shop to the museum by the Edward Bell society, Maggie is worried that the loss of income would affect Rochelle, so she hatches a plan. She starts simply just by selling a few modern books ‘under the counter’ but soon this isn’t enough for her and she starts to plan other events.

I could really imagine this small town in America, where one person runs the whole town, and nobody wants to do anything to upset him as they may lose their jobs/home. Maggie was a bit of a flighty character, hopping from job to job, never know what she wanted to do, but she was also very caring. She just wanted to help her friend and the townsfolk. She wasn’t, however, backward in coming forward in her relationship with Malcom! This was quite a quirky read, and one to be taken with a pinch of salt, but it’s also very enjoyable like being wrapped in a big warm blanket of bookish love.

DNF at 20% - this was not my cup of tea at all. Heroine is the most immature 28-year-old I have read about in a long time. The comparison the MMC makes of her to Lydia Bennet is completely accurate and likely why I don’t like the FMC. I didn’t like Lydia either. Good heart, with the brain of a teenager. She hopefully improves as time goes on, but between her comments about “musty old classics” and having zero interest in respecting her job (which was handed to her on a silver platter by her friend), I have no reason to continue reading.

And side note - I don’t like classics much either, but yikes, the tone felt icky.

Robinson's writing made it an easy read, with a good idea for the story, but I expected a little more for the execution.

The book started a little slow for me and in the first 10-15% or so all I felt was frustrated. By Ralph, Malcolm, this whole bizarre town, and with nothing good really happening to our poor FMC. But the writing was good, so I carried on, and managed to get into it soon after.

The romance in the book... I'm not sure I can get behind that. It's supposed to be a sort of enemies to lovers, but our FMC was just unapologetically into the love interest. No difficulty to admit it to herself and no bumps along the road with them. It was almost just too easy and I felt no chemistry between them. Or maybe the romance is supposed to be an afterthought and my expectations were too high.

With that being said, I loved the topics this book touched on outside of the romance. Especially about people's relationship with reading, how everyone can have such a unique experience. I loved seeing people discover reading as something fun -although again, our FMC got into reading and became.a bookworm almost a little too fast for me.

It was interesting reading the story where the solution for Maggie's "what do I do with my life" issue was so obvious (kick Ralph out somehow, join Rochelle in the bookstore, organise events, and build a community) -but made impossible due to financial constraints, which made it feel so real. Unlike the way Rochelle coddled her even after their standoff at night with Ralph and how easily Malcolm got over everything that happened.

And Ralph's reaction when Maggie found him on her way to the meeting with the journalist? Now that was the most unrealistic part. I get that characters often get redemption arcs, but not like that.

The book felt like a bit of a rollercoaster that way: I was frustrated with it, then got into it and liked it, then I was skimming and rolling my eyes again. Maggie's internal monologues got quite repetitive and annoying, and with the lack of good romance and the unrealistic-feeling scenes and reactions, I found myself just wanting to get through it.

I love books about books and people's love for them, but this wasn't it for me.

Maggie has been looking for her dream job, and every time she feels more passionate about everything but her work. She feels adrift, lost as if she cannot stick to one place. When her best friend asks for help in her bookstore in the little town of Bell River, Maggie seizes the opportunity to escape her parents. This book truly has everything for a cute rom-com:
🏡a quaint town with an eccentric community and random festivals
🤐a secret romance book club
👿a grumpy main male character and an even grumpier neighbor
🔥a book revolution

It's a story about finding your place, family, and community. It explores Maggie's perception of a fulfilled life versus her society / family expectations for her career, when and how she should land her dream job and achieve her dream life. Honestly, it was a great read, and I love books about books or bookstores; it's just so heartwarming 🥰

Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for my review 🫶

“The secret book club” follows Maggie as she moves to a small town to take over her best friend book store while she’s on pregnancy leave. She’s still unsure what to do with her life and is hoping working there will help her figure it out. However in this town and at the book store only classics are allowed to be sold. Maggie with the participation of all the other towns people found a book club to fight against all this. And while creating reading events and a blossoming of a new relationship, Maggie will have to figure out how to make the rest of the town see that books can’t be banned based on genre or publication date.

I was very drawn to this book based on the plot, it was very endearing seeing Maggie go from being lost to finally finding her place and dream. The cast of secondary characters were great, too. I was not 100% sold on the romance. I didn’t feel like it was necessary and it kind of ruined the ending for me.

Also the conflict at the end wasn’t really handled just brushed to the side, the “villain” of this story just changing his mind at the end wasn’t really how I envisioned this to end, considering how obsessed he was.

Thank you to NetGalley and One More chapter for allowing me to read this book.

“The Secret Book Club” - Shauna Robinson

⭐⭐⭐⭐

Summary: Maggie Banks is unemployed, back living in her parent’s house and feels like she is aimless, so when she gets the opportunity to go and work in her best friend’s bookstore for a few months, she takes it. However, when Maggie arrives in Bell River, and reaches Cobblestone Books, she realises the place appears to be a shrine for an author called Edward Bell, and the bookstore only sells books which were published before a certain date. After some time and mishaps, Maggie decides to run a secret book club, and accidentally stumbles upon a secret.

💭Thoughts:
I received this ARC from NetGalley and One More Chapter; thank you!

This is very different from what I usually read, but I did enjoy it. I felt a connection with Maggie, as someone who has been struggling to find a purpose within the workforce, and feeling like I have no clue what I am doing. Maggie is constantly feeling like a failure in life, and so when everything goes wrong in the shop, this adds pressure for her to try and salvage any profits for the bookshop. Malcolm, the love interest, was sweet, and I enjoyed how he slowly came out of his shell.

This was a quick read; but, it was more because I couldn’t put it down. I wanted to know what Maggie was going to do next, and how she was going to pull off her secret events, and her book club. The book showed how great it can be in a book loving community, which I enjoyed reading, and how being able to read different voices and genres can really open someone up to enjoy reading again.

This was a fun and fluffy read.

I wish the author luck for when it gets published (18th January 2024), and thanks again to NetGalley and One More Chapter!