Finishing this book has left me feeling haunted, checking over my shoulder and feeling like someone's watching me. The way Gish was able to write such a compelling novel, and interlace horror into the story is admirable. I rarely, if ever, get scared reading books, but the unreliable narrator combined with the incredible writing, left me feeling truly haunted. The characters were so lively and well written and felt so real that I found myself torn between who to align myself with and who to believe. I thought the ending was superb, a brilliant way to end such an unsettling novel. The plot moved a little slow, but I think that was necessary, in order to fully experience the experience. I also love how questions are left unanswered, and the reader struggles to separate fact from fiction. Superb.

4 stars

I can’t remember the term for this format (diary, text, email, etc), but it is one of my favorite ways to read a book, if done well.
Gish did a very good job writing in this format. Kept me interested and turning the pages. I read it in one sitting.

The dread, creepy atmosphere, & characters will stay with me for a while.

I really hope to see more of similar style from this author.

“Wisdom. War.
We are beyond such things.
We are teeth and skin, spit and hair, bones and blood.”

I was absolutely torn on this review, on one hand, I stayed up till the wee hours devouring the story….

On the other, I really wasn’t a fan of the main character Ada. She ground my gears, she was stubborn, lacked communication skills, was so desperate for love she literally changed herself, and just became completely unrecognizable from who she was at the start of the story. However, knowing her family history and traumas, the repression of women at the time (1901 is when the tale transpires), I can also see how the transformation could’ve occurred after all the pressure and loneliness broke her.

The creature itself was a mystery; eerie and ominous, transcending the known order of things. However, I didn’t like that in its approach of Ada, it was so forceful. Even though Norah said she could choose, the actions of the creature and it’s fervour implied that she really had no choice; it drove Ada to ruin her life. She went from being horrified to enamoured which was puzzling to me.

I loved that readers receive this mysterious transcript of events through Ada’s journal. It made me feel even more scared as I read in the night, and I could picture the narrator hovering in the light of a lone candle, the darkness pressing in around her as she scribbled down the creepy and astounding events.

So I chose to give 4 Stars as the author did create a very unique, queer tale of creeping dread and it has haunted my mind since I finished it.

Thank you to the author, NetGalley, and ECW press.

I loved this novel. Slow burn, creepy folk lore..Reminded me a lot of the great author Andrew Michael Hurley. Perfect time of year to read this gem.

At first this book starts off a little slow and I found the diary format a bit boring. However, the last half of the book had me completely enthralled.

Gish definitely takes typical historical female fiction and turns it on its head with horror and LGBTQ+ characters. The descriptions at times made me physically cringe which I love in a horror story.

I am still thinking about the meaning behind all this. What is the Grey Dog? Is it a manifestation of female rage? Of nature seeking revenge for it's creators (aka women)? I absolutely loved it and loved the ending. I will be reviewing this on my Tik Tok for the end of month wrap up! (@reading.michaela.kay)