Skip to main content

Member Reviews

A brand new matt Cain book? Just what I needed for a chilly winter evening.

I'd read that this was a bit like David Nicholls' One Day, and I was a bit apprehensive as I never fully got into that book. I felt it was all a bit slow. And I was worried that this would be similar. But I needn't have worried. I mean yes, for me, no explosive action happens in it, but that doesn't mean it's boring. It's a slow burn, giving you time to really develop a fondness for these characters and their journeys, and it's perfectly executed.

People think this is just a piece of entertaining fiction - which it is - and nothing of consequence. But it's more important than that. It breaks my heart to know that this isn't just fiction, people have to go through this day after day, just because of who they love. This kind of thing should be relegated to fiction, to fantasy worlds.

I completely recognise that as a heterosexual woman, I have never been put in a position where my sexuality or the gender of my partner has been put under scrutiny. But it's books like these, that contain openly gay characters, but in the same way that mainstream books market openly straight characters...I think it's a lot more important than "just" a piece of entertainment.

It's set over two time periods, the early 2000s whilst the two protagonists are at University and the years following graduation, and 2022. We get to see the two men grow up individually and together. It makes them so likeable and so detailed that it's hard not to root for them. It also allows us to see the change in LGBTQ+ attitudes over those two decades.

Like the work of the aforementioned David Nicholls or Nicholas Sparks, Matt is not apologetic about the romance and the light and likes and loves and positivity in his books. But he balances that with very human feelings and situations, especially around LGBTQ+ elemenst.

It felt so real, like I wanted these people to be in my world. They're not always likeable. They're immature and they can be nasty and angry and obliviously cruel, but that's what makes them - and I know I keep repeating myself - but real. No-one is 100% a good guy in life, we are all sometimes the villain, and that's what Matt has achieved here. Danny and Guy are both the hero and the villain in their respective stories, and it's just about balancing that.

Not to be dismissive or anything as he's obviously worked really hard on it, but for me, the plot is inconsequential. He is such a master at creating well-developed, flawed, likeable, and very real characters, that I would just gladly read a study of people by him for 400+ pages.

It was really moving. I wasn't expecting it to be so. But it really is just so beautiful that I found myself welling up on more than one occasion. There's just so much heart in it. I won't give too much away as I think the effect comes from experiencing it yourself, btu there are passages in it - particularly towards the end - that just, I felt in my heart and my soul. There's this nostalgia, but it's not always a positive one, and it is so strong. I predict a bestseller come January.

It is a truly heartwarming, cosy, intense, strong, sad, happy, fun, entertaining, beautiful, important, comforting hug of a book.

Was this review helpful?

Knowing Manchester well, I enjoyed it as the setting to this book. I liked the dual timelines and how eventually it all became one.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first novel I've read by the author and I'll definitely be seeking out his back catalogue after this.
It's set in 2002 and 2022 and the years in between, when Danny and Guy meet during Freshers week at Manchester University. The novel chronicles their friendship during the intervening years culminating in a weekend in 2022 at Manchester Pride.
I absolutely loved One Love, I was drawn into the characters, particularly Danny, from the start and the Manchester setting was very nostalgic as I was a student there the decade before the novel is set. The author excellently portrays what it's like to be an outsider because of both sexuality and class and chronicles changing attitudes to sexuality over the first two decades of the twenty first century. For me it was also a portrayal of huge changes in Manchester that have taken place during this century and the author really brought the city alive.
Most of all this is Danny's story, it's often emotional and is told with such love and affection that I felt bereft when I finished the novel.
Highly recommended.
Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this digital ARC.
4.5 stars

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed both Albert Entwistle and Becoming Ted so I was excited to read this, it’s very different and pushes the boundaries but it’s a very strong and thought provoking read. This is one of those books you’ve really got to read to the end to fully appreciate and although the first half was good I found the way I looked at Danny’s story in the second half changed and this is when it really took off for me. There’s some fantastic points raised in this about changing attitudes both in general around LGBTQ movement and society, and the characters in this too as they look back over the years and consider what’s made them who they are today and they make for a very solid read.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Headline for approving my request to read an arc of this book

One Love is the story of Guy and Danny who have been friends since they met at university twenty years ago. The pair bonded quickly over their shared sexuality and the need to be around someone else who could understand them after being unable to for all of their life previously. Twenty years later the two meet up to go and experience Manchester Pride all over again and this time try and find the courage to tell the other how they have really felt all of those years.

Was this review helpful?