Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Wow, what a read! I feel slightly traumatised after completing the book but worth it for the pleasure of reading Kristin's latest publication.

A time in history that I did not know a lot about; yes, I'd enjoyed the TV show MASH but this has so opened my eyes as to what sacrifices were made and indeed how awfully the Women were treated. Yeah, the country needs you as nurses, doctors but that where it stopped, ashamedly! To treat the vets as only male and not even acknowledge the role that women vets played was deplorable. But then it was a man's world, chauvinistic and it shows some parallels in treatment of women in the series Mad Men!

Thank goodness things have changed for the better, however, the story that Kristin has brought to life brought me to tears, anger and consolation that Frankie found some degree of happiness but importantly, fulfilment. She and her close friends are great characters!

Is there a film in the works for this one?

Congratulations on a great book, a 5 star read and I look forward to your next book Kristin.

Was this review helpful?

‘The Women’ is my first novel to read by Kristin Hannah , I can honestly say I was not disappointed, and this book is the first of many books to read by her. This book was extraordinary, it was a woman’s experience, our FMC Frankie, that worked as a nurse during the Vietnam War. This novel is heart wrenching, impactful, moving, fantastic and something everyone should read ❤️📖

Being someone who loves historical fiction and therefore reads a lot of historical fiction, I have actually never read a book that took place during Vietnam War (I have watched movies that took place in the Vietnam War, a personal fav is ‘Good Morning Vietnam’, another topic for discussion) which is actually quite shocking to me, and I wonder is it because authors are hesitant to set their books about such a controversial war?

I learned so much from this book and found myself pulling out encyclopaedias and google to learn more. Kristin Hannah was well researched when writing this book and I love that she was. In the acknowledgements she says that she wanted to write a novel about Vietnam back in the ‘90s but she didn’t think she was up to the task at that time because it is a big topic and there’s so many layers to it.

‘The Women’ while it did focus on the experience of women in the Vietnam War, it also went into details about how women bravely stepped into harm’s way but were constantly dismissed for ever being there. But they were there. The book also largely discusses friendships that were created through the most difficult of experiences and the courage to fight for yourself, in my words women being there for women and the value, strength, and resilience of women. I adored the main character Frankie and I felt for her so much, she was just a women who chose to help those in need and suffered the consequences of doing so.

Even though it was about 500 pages, I didn’t want this book to end, and I couldn’t put it down 🥰 I cannot wait to read more of Kristin Hannah’s books. The only negative thing I can say about this book is that I can’t read it for the first time again 😭

Was this review helpful?

Loved this! An excellent and gripping read ,loved the main character Frankie, a well rounded and interesting character. The Vietnam war was a brilliant setting.a good romance thrown in also!

Was this review helpful?

I DNFed this early, just too long descriptions and I couldn’t get into the story. Will try to come back to this at a later date.

Was this review helpful?

An enjoyable and emotional read. I enjoyed it. The characters are well developed and the story flows with ease. A recommended read.

Was this review helpful?

This is a heartbreaking book that tells an incredibly important and largely forgotten story - that of women who served in the Vietnam War. It is well written though a bit repetitive at times, as we follow Frankie from her conservative, wealthy, and sheltered upbringing to her decision to enlist as a nurse in the Army during the Vietnam War and through her deployment and return home, where she struggles to reintegrate into the society she grew up in. She clearly has PTSD, which wasn't recognized at the time, and doesn't receive much support except from her two best friends, other nurses she met while in Vietnam. This is one of those historical fiction books that you wish was just pure fiction, because the fact that this episode in history really happened is too upsetting to believe.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to NetGalley and the Publisher for giving me the opportunity to read and review this book.

This was an easy 5 stars for me! The amount of research this book must have taken - is incredible. Such a beautiful and heart wrenching story woven in to how life must have felt during the Vietnam war. This book shed so much on a topic I previously knew very little about. So from a historical point it taught me a lot. The highs and lows of FMC Frankie was a total journey! One that I can’t help keep thinking about! Honestly, the book has so many layers. Kristen Hannah does it again! Highly recommend!!!

Was this review helpful?

The only second Kristin Hannah book I’ve ever read, and it certainly didn’t disappoint.
Gripping from the beginning, harsh and so descriptive.

Following her brother's death in Vietnam Frankie volunteers to be a nurse in that war & the story follows her harrowing experiences there, together with the bonds of friendships.

Very educational read

Thank you for the ARC copy

Was this review helpful?

I adored this book. It tells the story of Frankie (Frances) who after training to be a nurse volunteers in Vietnam - the first half of book tells of her experiences as a rooky to a veteran. The second half addresses how she copes when she comes back to the US. It was really fascinating to read about experiences of Vietnam especially from the point of view of women which is much less talked.

Was this review helpful?

An absolutely stunning novel about the women who served in the Vietnam War and were forgotten. Not many books can make me cry but this one is one of them. Following the life of Frankie McGrath who followed her brother into the war ad a nurse. It is horrifying yet moving at the same time and just prooves how useless War is.. Beautifully written as are all Kristen Hannahs books it certainly gies to the top of my list for one of my best books this year.

Was this review helpful?

Kristin Hannah shares a brilliant insight into the Vietnam war from a nurses perspective. 20 year old Frankie comes from a Navy family, and after her brother flies out to Vietnam she decides to join as a nurse hoping to serve her country, but ultimately she wants to make her family proud.

This book tackles so many topics that I want to talk about but probably won’t be able to fit in this post so I’ll do my best to condense!

The first half of the book is action packed, introducing a very young, naive Frankie to the realities of war. Some of the scenes are so heartbreaking and hard to read, with civilians often being targeted and coming to the hospital for treatment. I couldn’t help but think of some of the horrific images we’re seeing come out of present day wars and wonder why this is still going on.

The second half looks at Frankie’s return from ‘Nam where she is treated, not like a hero, but with disgust and made to feel ashamed of her service. The world she returns to is very different and she comes back a different person due to the experiences she’s endured. You can see the change in her perspective and her frustration that others don’t feel the same.

She is suffering from PTSD, although it is only in the early stages of being a recognised condition at this time. The second half of the book is definitely a mixture of emotions, where we see Frankie battling with her rollercoaster emotions, showing that recovery is definitely not linear.

“in love she’d been too cautious for years, and then too impetuous. In retrospect, it all felt haphazard.”

I love this quote when she’s looking back at her twenties. It sums up this period so well, I felt life was haphazard, never mind someone who’s living with the backdrop of war and suffering from not yet diagnosed PTSD.

This is an amazing coming of age book, with incredibly strong relationships and learnings and I would highly recommend!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Was this review helpful?

Kristin Hannah is one of my favourite authors! I've cried buckets on reading The Nightingale, felt immersed in Alaska in the Great Alone, The Four Winds had me shuddering but ..but..but...The Women didn't live up to the expectations which one comes to build from a face. The premise is excellent and so promising but somewhere in between, I lost the plot....Nam war is a sensitive and volatile topic and this book had so much potential, I only wish the author hadn't meandered from it.

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely loved this. It is everything Kristin Hannah does best: incredible sense of place and historical period, heroine you root for, great love story. Have recommended to many many people.

Was this review helpful?

Such a riveting account of the Vietnam war told through a brilliant piece of historical fiction. I thoroughly enjoyed it and would recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

I didn’t know very much about the Vietnam war, and nothing about the women who were there. I couldn’t stop reading this book, and like how it described both Frankie’s experiences of war, and the lasting trauma and difficulties with readjustment to civilian life. It had me feeling a lot of emotions throughout, and I would fully recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

Kristin Hannah has a knack for writing historical fiction about wartime. I last read The Nightingale and had devoured it in one sitting. The Women kept me just as engaged and I stayed up late to finish it.

We get to witness the impacts of the Vietnam War on Frankie McGrath. Raised in a sheltered bubble, she's ready to make her mark on the world by volunteering as an army nurse - with a faint picture of what it entails and all the hopes and dreams of making a difference. Kristin Hannah spears no expense describing the horrors Frankie is thrown into - you either sink or swim while there, and she manages to adapt to the change with the help of two fast friends - Ethel and Barb. While a harsh reality with clearly depicted trauma and unflinching accounts of atrocities that took place, our author's softened this by threading in some romance to this part of the story, and building on the relationships between the three women - Frankie, Ethel and Barb.

While there are quite a few different romance leads in this novel (most of who had their pitfalls), I found the bond with the three friends to be a balm for the rest of the novel. We see Frankie struggle with PTSD on her return from war - her spiraling outlook and at times apathy, anxiety and depression compounded by the shame she feels from the hate the public throws on veterans and soldiers for participating in the war, along with her frustration that no one believes women are in Vietnam.

We get to see a few ups on Frankie's journey towards accepting her new reality, though often times cruelly snatched away, and above all we see the support needed from her friends and family around her to help pull her through. While the middle portion of the book was tough to read, there was some light at the end of the tunnel and I appreciated how Kristin Hannah brought Frankie's arc to a close for this novel. We're left envisioning what might be next for her, and the future looks hopeful, if not altogether a completely happy ending.

Thank you Pan Macmillan and Netgalley for providing me a copy for review!

Was this review helpful?

Although I have read only one Kristin Hannah book in the past, because of her popularity and hype associated with her new books, there was a certain expectation when I started reading this. Unfortunately the book failed to meet that expectation, but I enjoyed listening to the first part of the book. Like most of her other books, the premise is based on actual historical events. In 'The Women', the Vietnam war and the participation of women in the war and the treatment of Vietnam veterans once they returned to America are addressed.

Frances McGrath comes from a family with a long history of decorated war veterans and her dad has photo frames of their family men who fought in various wars -the wall of heroes, in his study. The book is in two parts, the first part being Frankie's experience in Vietnam as an Army nurse and witnessing suffering and death first hand, trying to save soldiers whenever she can and when she cannot just staying next to them and holding their hands in their last moments. She also falls in love in Vietnam only to have her heart broken. She makes life-long friendships and creates memories as well as nightmares that will haunt her the remainder of her life. I really enjoyed reading Part 1 of the book and few events described in the book were so emotional that it brought tear to my eyes.

Part 2 of the book concentrates on Frankie's life after her return from the war. She struggles to fit into a society that expects her to forget Vietnam and just continue living her past life. She cannot talk about her war experiences, in fact her parents are too ashamed to admit that Frankie had been to Vietnam. There is no hero's welcome for Frankie. This part of the book dragged and they were so many chapters that did not do anything to move the story forward. It was appalling to read how so many refused to even accept that women were present in Vietnam. Women's contributions in the war were largely forgotten or ignored. This was an epic story that I enjoyed reading in bits and parts.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for an advanced copy of the book.

Was this review helpful?

I discovered Kristin Hannah with this book and it was really a great discovery.

The book tells the story of Frankie, who enrols to go to Vietnam as a nurse during the Vietnam war. She comes from a well to do family and naively thinks that this will make her dad proud and she will have her place on the hero wall at home. Her time in Vietnam is very rough and she witnesses first hand what a horrible conflict it is. But also she makes solid friendships with other women who are there, like her. Then, she returns to the US and it is harder than she had thought. She suffers terrible post traumatic stress and she finds that society is not admiring the heroes of the Vietnam war, but rather the opposite. She also realises that people think there were no women in Vietnam, they were invisible. She sets out to rebuild herself and to contribute to the voices of the courageous women that were in Vietnam.

I really enjoyed reading this book. It is a rough read at times but it is also bringing to life this episode of history through the eyes of our different characters, whether Frankie, her friends, the troops in Vietnam, and others in society like her parents or her employers who did not realise what people returning from Vietnam had gone through and were still going through the rejoin society. The characters are interesting and beautifully written into the story.

It is a well researched book which brings to light the role and situation of women who were in Vietnam. I found the authors' notes interesting and I learned a lot about the context around the book on Kristin Hannah's website. This book is a tribute to all these women whose testimonies found their way into this story and to those who worked tirelessly to give them a voice and a visibility, for example at the Vietnam Women memorial founded by Diane Carlson Evans. It was a very moving insight into a complex moment in history and what it meant for the many whose life were shattered by it.

Was this review helpful?

Well this was definitely an enjoyable and emotional read. It educated me on things that I’d never even considered about the war before and will help bring awareness to all of the women were in Vietnam. Would definitely recommend.

Thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for an advanced digital copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley for my review copy of this book.
Been a very long time since a book has moved me so much to bring on tears as well as laughter. This book was one of them.
With unpredictable plot, great characterisation and moving events, this book has been well researched and written with such taste and thought, you would think that the author was there.
Superb.

Was this review helpful?