Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Slow Dance is a slow burn romance of the “will they, won’t they” variety. Cary and Shiloh have had an intense relationship since high school when they were very close friends, extremely comfortable in other’s company, then an absence of contact for many years when they missed each other intensely. Their eventual reunion at a friend’s wedding would surely be their chance to begin again.
The timeline flips back and forth between then and now with “now” driving the plot whilst the flashbacks filled out the backstory. Wasted time due to missed opportunities and missed signals perfectly captures the bold assumptions of youth – that there will be other people, there will be other chances so there’s no need to hold on to this one.
The pacing is slow at the start and it took me a while to connect with the characters and become invested in the outcome but it was well worth reading to the end.
Thanks to NetGalley and the Publisher for the ARC

Was this review helpful?

This is the story of Shiloh and Cary, best friends back in high school who reconnect at their other friends wedding 15 years after not seeing each other. There's a lot of history between these two and issues to work out, it's at times sweet, frustrating, hopeful and possibly the least sexy sex scene I've ever read but overall a cute read and I'm glad Rainbow Rowell is back writing non fake fanfic stories!

Was this review helpful?

Wow wow wow, I loved this so much!
How your person you're meant to be with is right under your nose. Even if things seem hard. If it's the right person then they are worth fighting for

Was this review helpful?

Aching with romance this is a beautiful love story with a quirky and swoon worthy couple who you can’t help but wish to be together. Some of the old references dated the book somewhat and made it feel like a dusted-off re-release instead of something fresh and exciting but I still enjoyed.

Was this review helpful?

I have absolutely loved all of Rainbow Rowell's other novels, but this just didn't do it for me at all. I had no sense that Shiloh and Cary were in love as teenagers, the pacing felt slow and Shiloh's inability to let people in just didn't feel properly characterised to me. I ended up not really caring about either of the main characters, and felt bogged down in the book.

Was this review helpful?

Beautifully pitched with protagonists that make you want to give them a good talking to. Quite claustrophobic in the intensity of the relationship over the now and before sections. These shifts in time helped to provide a breather from the now story. Great supporting characters of all ages.
Enjoyable read.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to review this title.

Was this review helpful?

2* disappointing

Slow Dance wasn't for me, I found it slow and depressing and had no empathy with the main characters. Shiloh was unpleasant as a teenager, as an adult she oozed negativity. Cary was inadequately described resulting in his lack of depth and little personality – pity, because he had potential.

An author’s aim is to grab the attention of their reader, preferable during the first chapter, I managed 10% before reluctantly deleting.

eARC generously supplied by Penguin Random House and NetGalley, this review is my personal, unbiased opinion

Was this review helpful?

When I saw this book it sounded like something I was really in the mood for so as soon as I got the book, I read it.

The story is filled with the ups and downs of Cary and Shiloh’s friendship. Everyone thought the relationship they’d had in school was more than it was but it had only ever been friendship.

The story flips between timelines so you are pulled into the friendship from the very beginning and all that went with it. It’s a really sweet story and it was just what I wanted in a book.

A book that was easy to get into, easy to read and hard to put down. My first book by this author but certainly not the last.

Was this review helpful?

I wasn't prepared for how much this book would move me, reading it in as close to one sitting as possible. Cary and Shiloh should be together, they should have always been together - everyone thought they were together as teenagers. But life, and particularly Shiloh's low self-esteem, didn't allow it to happen. Now older, and somewhat wiser, can they finally get it together? A beautiful love story that felt more real than most, with characters who were complicated shades of grey rather than clear-cut black & white.

Was this review helpful?

I feel bad that I didn't enjoy this book, but I just could not get along with the main characters.
A disjointed start to the story, with the timeline constantly jumping around meant that I struggled to pick the book up even at the beginning, which never bodes well for the rest of the book.

I never really found anything to like about our two main characters. They were just so unlikeable that it killed any relatability that they may have had. Especially Shiloh, who in both past and present seems to hate and find fault with everything and everyone and it was never endearing.

It was utterly frustrating to read about these two because they're morons and they needed to get their shit together. I could not believe that Shiloh is such a shitty character that it would take her 15 years to attempt to give Cary a go and let him in.

Character motivation was never very strong, I'm not sure why these people's stories got told. I guess it was just a second chance at love romance trope, but it was only their own stupidity and stubbornness (mostly Shiloh's) that they never got together when they were teenagers.

When I felt like the book should be heading towards a solution to the problems that the characters were throwing up in their pursuit of getting back together, I was only halfway through the book. It was such slow going. The pacing was awful and there's no real plot to keep the reader's interest, just two fucked up characters having minor drama and conflicted feelings about each other whilst not seeing each other for months and years at a time.

I feel like I've been trapped with these characters for far too long. What sort of adult human still resolves their pent up emotions by biting and poking and hair pulling another human being? Shiloh is awful. Cary was too much of a pushover of a character, willing to put up with any shit she throws at him.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley UK and the publisher for providing me with an e-ARC in exhange for a review.

4⭐

I loved this book. It has the anxiety of being young and flirting the line between friendship and something more, pining and heartbreak and pure nostalgia. Cary and Shiloh's relationship was not without its issues at ANY point of the story... but you really rooted for them to work through it and just BE. The flashbacks were really well done, placed perfectly to add to your understanding of the characters and their relationship. All the side characters were compelling too. Lived up to my hopes for this book for sure.

Was this review helpful?

A slow romance brimming with melancholy and lost chances, Slow Dance didn't ready like a typical romance to me. It spends a lot of the novel building up this complex relationship between Shiloh and Cary, with the story bouncing between a wedding of one of their mutual friends and their past. We see the missed opportunities, the paths chosen that have led them to this moment and how things could have been. It's an emotional, very believable read and the sadness oozes off the page at times - especially from Shiloh. However I did find the pacing a bit all over the place. The first third is very slow, spent building up these characters, their history and backstory, yet there's not much movement in the 'present'. As such I really struggled to get through, however as their relationship picked up and feelings become more apparent I started to really enjoy this. It feels like a breath of fresh air at times, as the two take a metaphorical dance around each other regarding their deeper emotions.

Highly recommend if you like emotional romances.

Was this review helpful?

NetGalley thanks for an amazing book by Rainbow Rowell free review incoming.
Well what can I say Rainbow catches your breathe again with deep bonds in relationships. She grasps your very life experiences by the heart and soul.

I can’t think of anyone who wouldn’t love to see an old 🔥 flame when your down and slightly out of sorts see you again for everything you used to be . Back when everything was easy and you didn’t have adult responsibilities.

The character banter is too from the loves interest is so sweet I might need some dentistry.

Thanks again I would recommend this book to anyone who hasn’t read Rainbow Rowell other books no fantasy just real life stuff x

Was this review helpful?

The way I am absolutely obsessed with Shiloh and Cary. Not only is it a gorgeous love story, but it also deals with some very sensitive topics which are handled so carefully and sensitively. This is going to be one of my top reads for this year!

Was this review helpful?

There was so much I loved about this, I want to dive deeper into Shiloh and Cary's world and find out more about them. My only issue is it took me a while to love them, there were points near the start where it was nearly a DNF and I'd have been gutted if I'd left it then. It took a while for me to love them, as it took a while for them to find each other and I'm so pleased all round! I was already a fan of Rainbow Rowell's writing and she does not disappoint.

Was this review helpful?

Slow Dance is another Rainbow Rowell special and it didn't disappoint - especially as it follows one of my favourite tropes: the friends to lovers storyline. Although a little slow to get started, which meant I found it more difficult than some of her other books to get into, once the story got fully up and running and I got to know our central characters, I flew through the pages. Hopefully we won't have as much of a wait for the next Rainbow Rowell book!

Was this review helpful?

Rainbow Rowell has unsurprisingly done it yet again. She has crafted a beautiful love story that transverses the passage of time efficiently, and delivers fully developed characters into the palm of your hand. Her dialogue for the children characters was a big highlight whilst reading, I was sitting there with a big smile on my face whenever they entered a scene, especially when they interacted with Cary. Shiloh was a great protagonist, and her overall journey, along with her exploration of sexuality, was an amazing aspect that really elevated the story. As did Cary’s family subplot. There is also so much more to the story than the initial blurb suggests, which is an incredibly welcome surprise.
Overall, just a really well crafted love story. A solid four stars from me. I think the book could have benefited from a bit more resolution at the end in regards to its secondary characters, as they kind of fade away — which is a shame as they were great side characters!

Was this review helpful?

I've enjoyed all of Rainbow Rowell's books and was thrilled to learn she's returning to adult fiction. Her previous works in this genre left a lasting impression on me.

The narrative centers on Shiloh and Cary, who have been each other's soul mates since their teenage years but never quite managed to unite. They reunite at a friend's wedding as adults, complete with careers, families, and pasts, and it's evident they still share a bond...

The story is a beautifully woven narrative of two individuals discovering their importance to each other and contemplating their potential actions. Due to the skillful crafting, Shiloh and Cary, as well as the supporting characters, are depicted with a genuine sense of realism.

I extend my gratitude to Netgalley and Rainbow's publishing team for the opportunity to read this advance reader's copy. Eagerly anticipating the acquisition of a physical edition.

Was this review helpful?

My first adult Rainbow Rowell book and I'm definitely not disappointed. Vastly different to any of her other books I've read but just as absorbing. Heartfelt and poignant, I couldn't put it down.

Thank you Netgalley and Michael Joseph for providing me with a free digital copy in exhachge for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

(Review below to be published two weeks prior to publication)

Rainbow Rowell writes with the upmost efficiency yet still manages to make you feel every syllable of a sentence to the very marrow of your bones.

This was like reading Attachments for the very first time. I wholeheartedly love the characters. I love their story. I love their heartache and their joy and their patience, but most of all I love that they endured.

A true adult romance, not because it was spicy but because it was real and it was raw.

A story about moving on but also not. About second chances and missed opportunities and longing yet getting on with life.

The timeline was all over the place but never once did it feel off or out of sync or did I feel lost. It just felt right from start to finish. Shiloh and Carey will forever be tucked neatly in my heart next to Lincoln and Beth, Eleanor and Park and of course Levi and Cath.

Was this review helpful?