This is the third book in the series and I was excited to be given the chance to read it. However, I have been really disappointed because a great deal of the story is simply repeated from the previous books. Yes, it is told from different points of view but I had to check that I had not read it before everything was so familiar It is only the last third where the story starts to continue and I felt really short changed. This could be read as a stand alone book but beware if you have read the previous instalments.

Another brilliant story in this series! I’ve read the previous books so was keen to carry on to find out what happened next, there’s no need to read the others as this recaps quite nicely , however from a different persons perspective.

Perfect read at any time of the year and interesting to read about the evacuation of st Kilda in 1930. This book ends on a real cliffhanger with a surprise twist….i really can’t wait for the next book now! There’s certainly lots more to follow to finish off the story of these Scottish lasses!

Thank you to Netgalley the author and publishers for an arc in exchange for an honest review

So pleased to read this instalment, and now cant wait for the next one, having been left with a cliff hanger ending! The descriptions of the island are fascinating, even though some of the story was repeated from the previous book. It makes one realise how little one knows of these wild places where life was so very different and desperately hard. Flora is beginning to emerge and we wait to see what comes next. Thank you for the chance to read and review this book.

I love Karen Swan and have loved every book in this series so far! So happy book three is on the way already! Cannot wait to share my full thoughts and review very soon! What a gorgeous premise and cover! Readers are going to love this installment as well.