Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This was so unique and fun, the humour was perfect too! I love the concept so much I need a book 2.

I went into this a little blind and I wasnt disappointed. It had a Jumanji feel due to the FMC being thrown into the plot of a book unfolding and it had a game like feel to that. I enjoyed the FMC playing into the plot of evil and scheming her way through the story. I couldnt put it down it was brilliant! Key however was my no.1 character and he deserves more than he got!

Was this review helpful?

This book had such an interesting concept and as soon as i read the blurb i knew i had to get my hands on a copy. It's something i've only seen done in anime/manga, where the main character gets Isekaied into a different realm. I hope this has a really positive impact on the romantasy genre and inspires authors to take more creative risks and have more freedom/fun with what they write instead of following trends and formulas.
Throughout reading this i was laughing, swooning, screaming and freaking out multiple times! There was always something happening to keep me interested and never a dull moment.

It was also really refreshing to see the 'villain' being played by a FMC, especially in this case where they're simultaneously the hero and protagonist of their own lives!
It was such an insanely fun plot fill of chaos, political intrigue, plot twists and madness. I genuinely couldn't predict what was going to happen around the corner and loved every single second my assumptions about the plot were proved wrong.

Every single character, especially the core few, were so freaking interesting and added something unique to the story, while at the same time not getting in the way of the main plot and our psychotic villain. I loved that the focus was almost always on her.

I finished this book almost immediately after starting it. I simply couldn't put it down and needed to know what was going to happen.
I cannot stress enough how much i enjoyed this book and how similar it felt to other books like A TEMPEST OF TEA and SHADOW & BONE, except better because the villains are technically the good guys and she ends up falling for the most morally grey of them all.

A massive thank you to the author, publisher, and netgalley for giving me the opportunity to read this book! It has quickly become one of my favourite reads of the whole year!

Was this review helpful?

Wheee! This book was fun. And funny! It did for Romantasy what Scream did for horror films - it gently played with the genre conventions whilst still staying smack bang in the middle of the genre itself.

Rae is dying in the real world. A mysterious woman appears and gives her the chance to find the magic Flower of Life and Death which would save her life. She ends up in Eyam, inside a story that she knows very well, even if she can't remember details from the first book very well. She has to survive until the Flower of Life and Death blooms, pick the flower and go home.
She finds herself in a lovely healthy body of one of the villainesses. Some might say THE villainess of the piece. She embraces her villainy and starts making allies.

I raced through this book. The world building is intriguing, especially as Rae looks at it through the eyes of someone reading the book as well as someone living what's going on. The characters are delightful, especially the villains. I think the Cobra is my favourite.

I got an ARC from Netgalley and thoroughly enjoyed reading it. I can't wait for this book to come out properly. I might even buy a print copy for the keeper shelf.

Was this review helpful?

Argghhh, this book was WiLd! Fun, feisty and fast moving, I've not read a book quite like Long Live Evil. With plenty of morally grey characters and a plot packed full of mayhem and trickery, you're continuously kept on your toes, scrambling to figure out what'll happen next. Admittedly, I sometimes got a bit lost within the story, but if you embrace the chaos, I can guarantee you'll end up having a hell of a time! 💜

Was this review helpful?

This book was so amazingly chaotic and unexpected; so many twists and turns - nothing turned out the way I thought it would and I loved it!

This is a book about being trapped in a book… picture an Alice in Wonderland senario but instead of smiling cats and rabbits with watches, you’ve got politics and the undead and magic and heroes and villains… with me so far? Rae is 20 and is dying of cancer in a hospital in America. The only thing that gets her through is her sister Alice reading her favourite romantasy series to her.

As she lies dying, a mysterious woman tells Rae that she can have a chance to save herself… enter the story and retrieve the flower of life and death. Rae jumps at the chance, but on entering the fictional realm, finds out she has been cast into the role of evil stepsister, beautiful seductress and general harlot, the Beauty Dipped in Blood. Who is due to be executed tomorrow… Of course Rae, furious at the world after years of illness, and angry that even in a fictional world she’s slated for death, she embraces the villainy and decides to decimate the plot to survive and thrive.

I thought the way the story turns the traditional romantasy ideas of purity and gender roles on their heads (Similar to In Other Lands!) and explores the idea of what makes a hero, or a villain. I loved Key of the Cauldron, the psychopathic assassin, and The Golden Cobra, the playboy with a world-changing secret. The whole gang (I hesitate to call them a found family as they just keep stabbing each other in the back lol) were fascinating and I loved the slow burn relationships that started to form throughout this story (we have FF and MF rep and an MM that I really hope happens in the next book!)

The only reason this doesn’t get 5 stars from me is because I just didn’t feel like I connected with all the characters? I kind of wanted more from Rae (she was the big bad villain but still relied on Key a lot) and Emer just annoyed me (so obsessed with the rules for a villain, ugh). Otherwise, an amazing book!

Read Long Live Evil for:
✨ A story that takes place in a story
✨ FF, MF and (heavily hinted) MM romance pairings
✨ Magic, mayhem, pure chaos
✨ Pokes fun at the romantasy genre
✨ Lies, plots, scheming
✨ Villian takes it all!

Thank you to NetGalley for an ARC of this book 💕

Was this review helpful?

I immediately wanted to read this because one, Leigh Bardugo and Holly black blurbed this, and two, I LOVE ISEKAI STORIES. I’ve only ever read them in manhwa form so reading one for the first time in a novel form was an exciting experience.

I highly recommend reading this if (like me) you like reading historical fantasy manhwas with a reincarnated/isekai plot AND the main character takes over the body of the VILLAINESS!!!!

Overall the plot and characters were so fun and I was ultimately here for the vibes. The plot unfolding always kept me intrigued and entertained while the humour was just exactly my taste because I randomly bursted out laughing so many times.

There was also a found family trope which I’m a sucker for and this book developed the found family dynamic so well. It was so heartwarming at times that I started tearing up a lot.

Speaking of tearing up, I even got emotional in some scenes. I was not expecting this book to make me even be on the verge of crying sad tears.

Most of the plot twists had me literally gasping. There were some predictable plot twists and some unpredictable ones but I loved both kinds nonetheless because I liked the directions the plot was going in!!

Was this review helpful?

I can’t stop thinking about this book. It lodged itself into my brain and is probably going to live there rent free for a while. It’s a story that takes you in the most unexpected direction and then surprises you with steering away from that path. It’s a tale where the villains are not just the bad guys, they are also heroes and full blooded characters, with backstories and circumstances that shaped them into who they are. Where there are reasons for them to be the way they are. Where they are allowed to take the centre stage and lead the way.
Rae is dying. It’s not that she doesn’t have any more will to fight, she’s simply tired. And of course she doesn’t want to be dead, it would mean her little sister is left alone, without her fiercest protector and that’s not something she can accept easily. So when she gets a chance to become a character in her favourite book series in order to obtain a Bloom of Life and Death and live, she takes it. Obviously she takes it. That means though she gets to be one of the most evil characters in the series, a character who’s supposed to die the day after she arrived. Lovely. But since she’s not a weak damsel in distress, she will do everything she possibly can to save herself. The choices could be difficult, maybe wrong, but they are definitely hers.
I loved the storytelling, the characters, the premise and the writing style. The perspective of a villain is so different, makes the story genuinely unique. It gives a chance for a reader to explore the characters they would otherwise not have paid attention to. The characters that get to show their choices are not just results of their “awful” personalities but rather calculated risks based on their knowledge, experience and abilities. And then the writing itself - absolutely stunning way of thinking, of designing the world and describing it. I’m absolutely in love with this book.
It’s 5/5 easily.

Was this review helpful?

"You don't have to kill if you don't like it" Key promised. "I'll kill them for you."
"Kill who?"
Against her hair, she felt his mouth curve.
"Everyone"

THE SCREAM I SCRUMPT

Okay, so I'll start of with saying - this was one of my most anticipated reads of this year and I'll admit I don't think it went the way I thought it was going to go? But I LOVED it none the less. Perfect perfect vibes

In the book we follow Rae, who has been dealt a hard hand in life, and is dying way too soon in life. However, when a mysterious figure appears to her in hospital offering her a second chance at life by going into the story of her favourite book series she jumps at the chance of this magical bargain.

However, when Rae awakens in this war torn realm, she soon realises she is the villain of the story and how so moves next can change the course of everything.

This booked scratched that little p[ace in my brain that always wishes Alina in shadow and bone went evil and got with the darkling, and honestly if that doesn't sell this I don't know what will.

PROs
Villain POV
Revenge SCHEMING plots
DGAF attitudes
KEY!!!!!!
Found family (?) lmao

CONs
Modern language in fantasy setting (shudders)
the FMC was ridiculous - this can also be a pro
that ONE scene where I was like what is happening here?!?!?

Solid 4.5stars for me

Was this review helpful?

It felt like a very unique place to be in the villain's shoes and I was surprised how much I enjoyed the the villains side of things.

Was this review helpful?

The blurb & cover combination are very good at advertising the sexy villainy pitch of the story. It's perfectly legit to pick this up on this pitch, however I wanted to recap what ELSE is in the book, for those who are similarly frustrated by the blurb economy.

* I have picked this up because I really wanted to know what SRB did with a premise of isekai. She has written some things that I love to bits (ask me how many copies of In Other Lands I have given to friends as a gift), and some things that fell flat to me, but I definitely came into this book with a sense of curiosity and not scepticism.

*I had not realized that it is, in many ways, SRB's cancer book. The author lived through stage four cancer, and the protagonist, Rae, is a late stage cancer patient as well. The book opens in the hospital ward, and it's a pretty grim opening: while it's not unusual for isekai protagonists to transmigrate at the point of death, this hits very different to a generic "chocked on a bun and got yeeted into a medieval fantasy" openers. The references to cancer inform quite a number of Rae's reflections and observations once she transmigrates into the world of Time of Iron, and mainly they relate to her body. They were often quite jarring, but I consciously refrain from passing any opinions on them because I don't want to judge something I don't know and the author would have firsthand experience with. Let's leave it at that.

* you have to roll with the premise that Rae doesn't remember some key developments of the book she transmigrates into, even if Time of Iron is a superfandom in-universe and a big interest for her and her sister. Some of these omissions are believable, some of them could be explained by the changes triggered by events of the book, some of them strain suspension of disbelief. One of them relates to a key plot point, which made me raise eyebrows multiple times through the narration.

* the tone of the narration is very uneven. Opener: cancer ward. First thirty or fifty percent or so: sheer chaos, with Rae essentially LARPing on a sugar high while book characters are very earnestly living their high-drama lives of a dark fantasy with high passions. It's exacerbated by uneven sprinkling of POVs for Time of Iron characters, and introduction of another transmigrator. There is a barrage of rapidly-aging pop culture references in the dialogue. At one point the book becomes a musical. If you love it, you love it. I found the mood whiplash was very discordant, like the book couldn't decide what it wanted me to experience so it carouselled through everything at top speed. As the story progresses the ratio of tongue in cheek razzle dazzle decreases and gives way for pathos more suited to Time of Iron universe levels, but Rae largely continues to operate like it's a dress-up but with waning conviction.

* I was also not sold on the sexy villainy, both as rhetoric and fact. To be more specific: there are a lot of overwrought, florid speeches about acceptance of self and rejection of prescribed roles framed as villainy, often cheeky but sometimes earnest, done with loads of flaire by characters who are not, in fact, particularly villainous. It's a big dress-up party with theatre kids, who are in it for the viper aesthetics and scandalizing the stuffy adults. Or maybe it's several theatre productions with different levels of earnestness, one for transmigrators and generally deranged folks, and the others for the crowd with serious High Fantasy agonies who use villain to mean discontent with their lot in life. The book wanted to show you that moral schmoes are not usually card-carrying villains, but introduced the latter via an Aladdin-style procession with dancing elephants and monkeys.

What worked for me was the B plot with the second transmigrator, and generally the characters surrounding Rae who belong in the world of Time of Iron. As my investment for the characters of Time of Iron world grew as they were allowed to be their own people and exist beyond the confines of in-universe book archetypes, Rae herself was left behind in terms of any emotional attachment. The magic of In Other Lands didn't happen; where Elliot the outsider was endlessly fascinated with the fairy-tale like world around him, Rae trampled through it like paper scenery. I realize it's a part of her arc, but it's not one I warmed up to.

Thank you for Netgalley and the publisher for the early copy of the book.

Was this review helpful?

finished this book and immediately ran to Goodreads because I HAD to see if it was standalone or a series... The Time of Iron #1 instills hope that the story will continue because dear lord I need to know what happens now.
I really had no expectations going into this book, I've never read anything by the other, but being this was their adult debut- felt like a good place to start.
First off I LOVE VILLAINY. Rae just decided to play the antagonist was so fun and starting her secret little club of vipers- positively delicious. It felt a bit much at times when she was continuously saying she was going to be bad (in a way only a person who isn't really going to be evil can).
I took me a second to get into the book, the beginning was a bit confusing- when you are trying to situate yourself in the narrative (Time of Iron was a real series it would be reminiscent of like LOTR or GOT for sure). Which means it was easy to get lost in the details, but once I figured it out, it was game over. I was obsessed- I had to know what happened to Key and Emer and all the other fun side characters.
All in all I was delighted by the concept and the story, the world building was fun and I cannot wait for the next one. Because like- what now???

Was this review helpful?

Rating: 3.5

I was highly interested in the description of the book - an isekai into the villainess' body? Yes please! The cover is also gorgeous, and the title is just spot on. However, I felt a little led astray by the blurb and the actual plot of the story, the main thing being Rae was given a mission in her story life rather than just starting anew.

Speaking of Rae...she's supposed to be the protagonist, and she has a tragic backstory which leads to her mission of playing out the villainess' role to obtain the item which will let her return to her world and body. But, maybe it's because of the copious amount of webtoons and manga I have read previously in this particular genre, Rae falls flat. She talks a lot of smack about being evil and doing bad things, but then is surprised when things don't turn out the way it should. Is it not obvious to her that by changing things (such as a plot line where the villain dies) is changed, things won't turn out like what she knows? Especially when she talks to the Cobra and finds out his version of things. She's also very insistent that everything is just part of a story, but at least she eventually realises that she needs to stop dismissing things because it's not a story for those she begins to care for.

The supporting characters, the Cobra, Key and Marius to name the main few, held the story together for me. The interactions they had with each other and Rae kept the plot and book going. Honestly, the Cobra was a lifeline thrown in - if the early reveal hadn't had happened, I don't believe I could have coped with Rae alone. Weirdly enough, he felt more fleshed out and had a larger character than Rae did. His backstory was as tragic as Rae's, and they could have fought to both be protagonists.

Nevertheless, it was a good venture into a new area of written works. Hopefully there is a sequel which explores the other characters more, especially Emer who got (pretty much) robbed of an interesting career change.

Was this review helpful?

The most fun I've had with a book for a long time. Long Live Evil provides an absolutely jam packed story full of action, intrigue & humour, I devoured the start of this book then had to pace myself as I just didn't want the story to end! Rae is transported to the world of Eyam, her sister's favourite book and a slight issue is that Rae has read the later books but does not have a full grasp on the 1st novel where she finds herself on the night before her execution.

Assembling her crew of villains to achieve her goal of returning home, we meet an absolutely amazing cast of characters. Emer, the soon to be Iron Maid, Key, the unhinged killer & Cobra, the extravagant criminal spymaster. Their motley crew expands across the novel as more and more complications arise as they work to help Rae achieve her goals.

The last quarter of the book was an absolute emotional rollercoaster with so many twists and turns and I loved it all! Thanks so much to Netgalley & the Little Brown Book Group for letting me read this arc. I'll be posting my review on Waterstones/Storygraph/Goodreads on the 25th July & Amazon upon release.

Was this review helpful?

Long Live Evil was a very fun book. Who didn't daydream about living in their favorite book world? I still do.

Rae was an excellent character. She embraced the villainess character, and she enjoyed it. She was a breath of fresh air after the morally good heroines from other books. The first chapter almost made me cry.

I didn't give it a five-star rating because I do not love the writing style. There were too many analogies, and Emer's and Marius' POVs were very long and unnecessary, in my opinion.
The conversations between Marius and the Gooden Cobra were repetitive many times.
I would have preferred a little bit more seriousness from Rae, but after that ending, I think this will change in the next book.
I'm very excited to read the sequel. I think there will be a lot of exciting things in it. Key's character wasn't my favorite at the beginning, but I loved his character development.

Was this review helpful?

As soon as I read the synopsis for this book I knew I'd love it. The premise is exactly my style and the cast of characters had me enraptured fairly early on. SRB has managed to weave a seductive tale about villains and heroes and perception, all whilst managing to make me laugh and fall in love with the chaotic but endearing MCs. The only thing that pulled my rating down from 5 to 4 stars was that I found the early stages of the story a little unclear and difficult to follow, but once it got going I couldn't put it down. VERY excited for book two after that ending!

Was this review helpful?

I saw someone say this is a great book for those who loved Assistant to the Villain and I think that is very much true. I was incredibly intrigued by the beautiful cover for this book, as well as the premise for this book. A girl falls into her favourite book to save her life in the real world by becoming the villain, and hijinks ensue? I am sold.

I have to say, the first 30% of this book is incredibly slow and somewhat meandering. Similarly to how some of the lines in ATTV made me cringe, the same happens here especially early in the book. However, this is a book worth sticking with. When things truly started going I was throughly enthralled. I do have to say, Rae was not as villainous as she sounds from the blurb - it is mainly her breaking social conventions like showing cleavage that is her evilness. The real stars of this novel are the side characters such as the Cobra, Emer, Key and Marius. I really loved how they were fleshed out and developed as Rae realised that these weren't just puppets to the plot she knew and loved but living, breathing people who change as the plot moves forward and they have new experiences. I look forward to their characters being further developed in the next story.

Thank you to NetGalley and Orbit for letting me read this early and enjoy the story

Was this review helpful?

I need to fangirl and scream in someones DMs because that ending left me wide awake at midnight. Like FIRST, PLEASEEEE Sarah can you give us loads more Eric and Marius content in the next book because I was devouring all the crumbs you threw at us in the book 😭❤️ I so 110% ship it. I need them and their banter like air. And then SECOND. Rae and Key 😍 holy shit I’m so obsessed. THE TENSION was just *chefs kiss* How can I wait for so long until the next book I am devastated.

Thank you to the publisher for sending me a wonderful and villainous proof.

Was this review helpful?

I've got mixed feelings about this book. As I picked it up and read through the first half or so, I thought it might go straight to join my favourites. But I am on the fence about it now, so... lemme break it down

Liked:
* The concept. I love portal fantasies / isekai, so this was a great match for me!
* The main character, Rae. She was strong, she was fierce, she was determined to live and to be a force of nature. I couldn't help but root for her from the start
* Rae's sociopathic bodyguard, Key.
* The absurdity of it all (brought back memories of Wonderland, what can I say)
* The ending, which left me looking forward to the sequel

Not my cup of tea:
* The middle was slow, and it deviated from Rae for a bunch of long chapters, to the point where I didn't feel connected to her anymore, and the final scenes didn't have the emotional impact I would have liked.
* Repetition of certain phrases and ideas. I think this book could do with some trimming, and trusting the reader to pick up on themes rather than being so on-the-nose with them

So, should you pick this up? This is what I think, based on the ARC:

You will like this if...
you like a strong FMC and morally grey characters, you are into portal fantasy and isekai, you want to see stereotypes and preconceptions subverted, and you enjoy cheeky / snarky humour

You might want to take a rain check if...
you are not in the mood for narratives with multiple POVs, or for stories with a loose plot that meander quite a bit and can feel at times like "nothing is happening"

Was this review helpful?

An action packed tale with magic and villains; this book will keep you entertained.

I enjoyed the read, it was fast moving and entertaining.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Following a desperate bargain, Rae is dropped into the world of her favourite novel and must use her wits to survive. The cast are riotously outrageous, and very morally grey. The tropes are constantly played with keeping Rae, and the reader, on their toes, as the characters refuse to stick to their designated storylines. While a tongue in cheek romp through a fantasy kingdom at surface level, Sarah Rees Brennan manages to deftly weave more serious undertones throughout.

Was this review helpful?