Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Wonderful historical novel, with characters linked across time by region and water(rivers and raindrops). It covers some horrific events against the Yazidi people and also the discovery and translations of The Epic of Gilgamesh. All this is brought together with great characters. A brilliant read.

Was this review helpful?

The story follows 3 seemingly unrelated characters, all linked by a single drop of water.

1840 - Arthur born into poverty and mud on the Thames but goes on to do great things despite his hardships

2014 - 9 year old Narin who with her beloved grandmother travels into unknown dangers to Iraq

2018 - on a houseboat in London troubled scientist Zaleekha has lost her way until she meets a tattooist and is inspired by her passion

This really was an epic read spanning continents, cultures and centuries. Which perspective I enjoyed the most changed throughout the book, but it was Narin’s tragic story which gripped me the most and would have liked more of.

Would recommend to those who enjoy a bit of a slower paced but beautifully written historical fiction read

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publishers for sending me a copy in exchange for a review.

This was such a touching and moving book, flowing between time periods flawlessly and across the world. It covered so many topics, so much social history, and with so much heart. My favourite character was Arthur simply because he was clearly autistic coded but also aroace in the victorian era when men were to marry and be masculine, not holed up with shards of pottery obsessing over poetry.

Was this review helpful?

💬 My Bookish Thoughts
Having adored The Island of Missing Trees, my expectations were high—and oh my days, Elif Shafak did not disappoint.

CW/TW: Genocide, Racism, Child abuse, Domestic abuse, Death of loved ones, Slavery, Sexual violence.

This novel is a beautifully crafted tapestry, weaving together timelines and characters with the fluidity of water itself. Shafak tackles tough subjects with sensitivity, never shying away from the harsh realities. It's heartbreaking and, quite simply, genius.

Elif's use of water as a connecting thread between different timelines had me utterly beguiled. I'm fascinated by molecular memory—a concept I encountered during my holistic facial studies—and she illustrates it so elegantly through a single drop of water linking diverse narratives.

The characters, from ancient Mesopotamia to modern-day London, are richly drawn and deeply human. I felt so invested in each of their stories; they became like family to me. Narin's journey, in particular, enlightened me about the atrocities faced by the Yazidis in contemporary Turkey—a history I was previously unaware of.

This novel is more than just a read; it's an experience that will stay with you, reshaping your understanding of history, memory, and connection. It's earned a place among my all-time favourites, and I wholeheartedly recommend it.

I could gush forever, but I'll simply say: pick up a copy—you won't regret it. This book will change you and your heart. It's now proudly displayed among my all-time favourite books, and I'll be recommending it to everyone.

🙏🏼 Big thanks to @netgalley, @penguinukbooks and @shafakelif for the gifted digital copy in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I had already experienced the magic of Shafak’s writing in Island of Missing Trees and was eager to have another taste of her exceptional storytelling.

Rivers is an epic story embracing three threads stemming from a story about a Mesapotamian King and a raindrop. 1800s London and Arthur is born beside the Thames in desperate poverty. He is unusually clever with the power to recognise patterns. His talent is recognised by a publishing company and scholars at the British Museum. 2014 in Turkey Narim and her Grandmother are in a group of Yazidis travelling from Turkey to Iraq. Narim is losing her hearing; the Yazidis are fleeing persecution. In 2018 Zaleekhah is a hydrologist. She has left her husband and is living on her a houseboat.

Shafak’s writing is stunning and draws us in from the start. Inevitably where there are multiple stories the reader ponders the link between them throughout the book and will probably have a preference for one of the storylines. For me Arthur’s story was the strongest and most fascinating at first. This felt rather Dickensian - and indeed Dickens does make a cameo appearance! - He is a rag to not quite riches story with a cruel father and a kindly benefactor and a very unique talent. It is a magical moment when he turns his attention to the tablets in the British Museum and begins to trace lines of the ancient Epic of Gilamesh.

Shafak threads the pieces of her story together so beautifully through the imagery of rivers and water, links to the Yazidis and to Mesopotamia. As she draws these together I felt all three storylines gaining power.

And oh the history in this book! This is as wide-ranging as its geography. I was constantly looking up references to explore histories which I had never known. Just as the story which is powerful and devastating, so too histories of persecution.

A unique and unforgettable read. Highly original, vast in its ambition and perfect in its execution. With huge thanks to Penguin Fig Tree for my digital copy. I bought myself a beautiful hardback edition - this is a keeper!

Was this review helpful?

I love Elif Shafak's generous and warm way of telling stories, which feels like your relative has asked you to gather around their feet while they tell you stories of old. In this book, this is on fine display, where her loving portrait of art, history, culture and wonder is so beautifully rendered. I found the central story of the young man and his dreams so tender and beautiful, and she is in great form again!

I received an advanced copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Elif Shafak’s There Are Rivers in the Sky is a thought-provoking novel that intertwines three compelling storylines, each with the potential to become a separate book. The narrative spans across Mesopotamia and England, where Shafak explores themes of loss, resilience, and the complex connections between human cultural decline and environmental destruction. The stories are sad, but in the end is a sense of hope that not everything is lost. The book beautifully emphasizes the importance of living in harmony with the world around us. For me, this is Shafak’s best work brilliantly capturing the intersection of personal and global struggles.

Was this review helpful?

Where can I start? The story of three distinct characters Arthur, Zaleeka and Narin spanning from water dropped in Ancient Mesopotamia, through the 19th Century to modern day. Two rivers,Thames and Tigris and the text of Gilgamesh are what flows through their stories.

From the opening sentence to to last word Elif Shafak took me on a journey that will life in my heart. The beautiful writing had me mesmerised. Themes of love and loss and how we can be healed from our hurts.

A five star read and I don’t want to explain too much, as it is an epic novel you need to read with as little information to be taken on a journey that will touch your heart.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an eARC for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Penguin Viking Books and to Netgalley for this advance copy of 'There are Rivers in the Sky'.

I'm going to be honest here - I'm late in writing this review for There are Rivers in the Sky, because, as usual: Elif Shafak ripped my heart out through her glorious prose. I read this book in little bursts, fearing my heart would truly be ripped from my chest. And I love the fact I read it slowly, as I got to savour every little detail. Shafak is so good at the little details.

This book is an ode to the little unassuming details we see everyday, and Shafak turns them into protagonists and the foundations of her stories; like trees, like water. It's beautifully written as always, and ventures from Ancient Nineveh to London in 2018. This book deals with heavy topics, like ISIS and other terrorist organisations, as well as tackling other hard topics such as deafness and the destroying of rivers and other bodies of water.

Instant 5 stars. Another Shafak book that will stay with me for a longggg time.

Was this review helpful?

Water remembers.

It is humans who forget.

I am a massive fan of Elif Shafak so there was never any doubt that I was going to love There Are Rivers in the Sky. I don't even know where to begin when reviewing this beautifully written novel.

The book begins with the reader following a single raindrop as it falls onto the ancient city of Nineveh in the region of Mesopotamia.

"Remember the drop, inconsequential though it may be compared with the magnitude of the universe. Inside it's miniature orb, it holds the secret of infinity, a story of it's own. When it finally musters the courage, it leaps into the ether. It is falling now fast, faster. Gravity always helps."

The raindrop falls upon the head of King Ashurbanipal as he looks upon a tablet inscribed with an ancient poem about a hero called Gilgamesh. Both the raindrop and the poem will appear time and time again within the novel, threads woven throughout, linking the different timelines together.

'King Arthur of the Sewers and Slums' was born into a poor family in Victorian London. He was gifted with an extraordinary memory and remembers everything, including the very moment of his birth. When he is given an opening as an apprentice at a prestigious printers Arthur is able to open his horixzons and began to explore the world around him.

"Arthur Smyth is gifted with an extraordinary memory - visual, verbal and sensory. Just as of rain or a pellet of hail, water in whatever form will always remember, he, too, will never forget. What he sees or what he hears or what he feels, even once, he retains forever. A blessing from God, others may hasten to add. But also a terrible curse, as he will soon find out."

The second timeline takes place in 2014, with Narin, a young Yazidi girl, waiting to be baptised. Indeed every timeline within the book takes place with some body of water in the background, whether it be the Thames, or in this case the River Tigris.

Over 80 thousand people have been displaced in the area and foreign companies have pulled out of investments in the area due to concerns about human rights, cultural heritage and environmental destruction.

"A 12,000-year-old history will be obliterated by a dam that will last 50 years - the lifespan of a mule. This region - home to churches, chapels, mosques, monasteries, synagogues and shrines - has already lost so much heitage. Most local populations have migrated to cities, near and far, where they have been swallowed by the currents of urban life, severed from the traditions that always sustained them."

I loved the relationship between Narin and her grandma Besma, how she shielded her as much as possible from the persecution of the Yazidis.

Since time immemorial, the Yazidis have been misunderstood, maligned, mistreated. Ours is a history of pain and persecution. Seventy-two times we have been massacred. The Tigris turned red with our blood, the soil dried up with our grief - and they still haven't finished hating us.

The final timeline takes place in 2018 in London with a hydrologist named Zaleekhah moving into a houseboat on the Thames after the breakdown of her marriage. She was orphaned at an early age and her uncle has taught her the very important lesson that immigrants can't afford to fail, a lesson she has internalised. Zaleekhah has spent her life feeling like she has to prove herself to be worthy of her uncles generosity within her life.

There wasn't a single aspect of this novel that didn't move me in some way. I absolutely loved it.

When you have set your eyes on the journey

Let your heart have no fear, keep your eyes on me.

Was this review helpful?

It took me a while to finish this book but wow… all I can say is that Elif Shafak outdone herself. This is such a special, magical book. The power of a drop of water…

Was this review helpful?

A stunning story spanning centuries, faraway lands, and different cultures and peoples. The stories of the protagonists are all sewn together by the common factor of water. A single drop of rain traverses rains, rivers, and oceans, giving and taking life. People forget, but water always remembers. Absolutely beautifully crafted story. #thereareriversinthesky #elifshafak #netgalley

Was this review helpful?

Honestly, a bit disappointed in this one. Stories were, ok, a too detailed in my opinion, but I just couldn't connect with any characters. Not a bad book, Just....an ok one.

Was this review helpful?

There are Rivers in the Sky begins with water, and it’s water that weaves throughout the times, locations, and characters of this novel — rising from a single drop to a torrent to a mighty (and emotional) ocean.

This was a gorgeous novel written by a true contemporary master of fiction, writing at the top of her game. Shafak takes ancient Mesopotamia and the Epic of Gilgamesh, London (both in 2018 and in the Victorian age), and 2014 Türkiye to guide us through interlinked characters, histories, memories, and relationships. Some of the subject matter is challenging, but it’s all handled sensitively, and the way Shafak tells stories is mesmerising. A truly beautiful and evocative tale, with vivid characters and, at the centre of it all, an homage to water in all its mercurial magic and glory.

I received an e-ARC from the publisher, Viking, through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Synopsis —-In the ruins of Nineveh, that ancient city of Mesopotamia, there lies hidden in the sand fragments of a long-forgotten poem, the Epic of Gilgamesh.

In Victorian London, an extraordinary child is born at the edge of the dirt-black Thames. When his brilliant memory earns him a spot as an apprentice at a printing press, the world opens up far beyond the slums and across the seas.

In 2014 Turkey, Narin, a Yazidi girl living by the River Tigris, waits to be baptised. The ceremony is cruelly interrupted, and soon she and her grandmother must journey across war-torn lands in the hope of reaching the sacred valley of their people.

In 2018 London, broken-hearted Zaleekhah, a hydrologist, moves to a houseboat on the Thames to escape the wreckage of her marriage – until an unexpected connection to her homeland changes everything.
In Victorian London, an extraordinary child is born at the edge of the dirt-black Thames. When his brilliant memory earns him a spot as an apprentice at a printing press, the world opens up far beyond the slums and across the seas.

In 2014 Turkey, Narin, a Yazidi girl living by the River Tigris, waits to be baptised. The ceremony is cruelly interrupted, and soon she and her grandmother must journey across war-torn lands in the hope of reaching the sacred valley of their people.

In 2018 London, broken-hearted Zaleekhah, a hydrologist, moves to a houseboat on the Thames to escape the wreckage of her marriage – until an unexpected connection to her homeland changes everything. living in a house boat on the Thames.

My thoughts - I am ashamed to say I started this book in June in kindle format and dipped in and out because of it ! So a different format a different month this was a great read again from this author...  Following three different people in years apart from each other the story is narrated through the eyes of 
1.Arthur king of the slums a young boy/man who has an interest in NIneveh and the museums, 
2.Zaleekah a young woman estranged from her In the ruins of Nineveh,
3. Nasim a young Yazidi girl living with her grandmother on the banks of the Tigris.

The water is a fundamental part of the story , the history , and the individuals all intertwined in a beautiful woven story told by a first class story teller.
A heart felt story with some lovely characters Arthur my favorite, a historical novel of importance is it long yes is it worth it yes!
'Water remembers it is humans who forget '

Was this review helpful?

Excellent historical epic from an exceptional storyteller, beautifully drawing together ancient legends, religions and cultures, and spanning continents and centuries.

Fragments of an ancient poem, the Epic of Gilgamesh, are discovered in the ruins of Nineveh; an ancient city of Mesopotamia, lost to flooding but which gradually re-emerges, revealing its secrets. These ancient tablets create bonds across centuries and continents, intertwined throughout by the water and its many memories.

In Victorian London, a remarkable child is born into abject poverty and against all odds becomes devoted to deciphering these ancient tablets.

In Turkey in 2014, Narin is only 9 years old. She carries a revered gift and affinity with water, passed down from her grandmother, but she is drawn into unimaginable horror by oppressive regimes.

In 2018, Zaleekhah is a water scientist, heartbroken and living in London where she moves to a houseboat while she considers ending it all. She has a great interest in quietly proving her colleague's ridiculed theory that water has memory, not least because of the tragic events which befell her as a 7 year old.

Many difficult subjects are covered, but the well drawn characters and skilfully woven storyline shine through.

Was this review helpful?

Elif Shafak is such a great storyteller, I have loved everything I read. I love the way she weaves different stories together with different times and places, with the thread of water bringing the story together. Not only does she write beautifully but the history she brings to life makes reading her books a joy.

Was this review helpful?

An astonishing, epic novel- the story of a drop of water and so much more: the power of religion to break apart communities and individuals; of family and enduring connections; of the continuous search for knowledge and enlightenment amongst artefacts from previous times and the people involved. Elif Shefak has researched widely gathering stories of water and The Epic of Gilgamesh and drawing the strands into this incredible book. Each story within the book was beautifully written with vivid protagonists that you immediately aligned yourself with- and rooted for as their stories took darker turns.

There is heartbreaking content within these pages and an important message to a world that never seems to listen- the need to live peaceably alongside those from whom we differ- and to try and avoid making the lives of others ( near and far) more difficult in travelling along our own timelines. To counterbalance there is love, compassion , connection , loyalty and kindness here too. The stories of Arthur, Narin and Zaleekhah will remain with me.

My thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the eARC of this book. I would strongly recommend it to other readers.

Was this review helpful?

There are Rivers in the Sky starts with a single drop of water and becomes an epic of a story. I've become a big fan of Elif Shafak and love the way she can write a line or phrase. I loved the story of Arthur and enjoyed the stories of Narin and Zaleekah and the way that their stories intertwined over the different periods. I was so interested in the Mesopotamia, the Lamassu and coniform I went to the British Museum to take a look for myself! I really enjoyed this book and was a bit sad once it ended. It has has an important story of the Yazidis and what happened to them and I think this will be a book that stays with me for some time.

Was this review helpful?

Another absolutely stunning novel from Shafak, who beautifully weaves together history and nature to tell this mesmerising story of human connections.

Was this review helpful?