Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you to Random House UK, Bantam, and NetGalley UK for an eARC of this book in exchange for an honest review!

I absolutely flew through this book, which is quite peculiar in its dream-like writing, where one scene seamlessly shapeshifts into the next as the characters follow the different threads of their quest to uncover what happened in the protagonist's pawnshop / ramen restaurant. While really whimsical and charming, it is also dark and tense in parts, so it's best not to go into this expecting a cosy fantasy. I really enjoyed some of the world-building and awe-inspiring scenes constructed in this book, and the romance was also endearing. I had a really positive reading experience although I don't think this book is a new favourite; but I am sure it will be for many people, especially for its themes around regret and choice, some of the full-circle moments and the puzzle-like plot. I definitely recommend giving this book a go if you are a fan of speculative and/or Japanese fiction and I am really happy to have read it!

Was this review helpful?

**Watermoon** is a fantastical, soul-stirring adventure that will sweep you into a world brimming with magic, mystery, and heart. Imagine a market held on a cloud, stars turned into kites, and paper cranes that seem to take on lives of their own—this is the breathtaking world that Hana must navigate when she inherits her father’s magical pawn shop. But there’s a twist: on her first day running the shop, Hana discovers it's been ransacked, and her father has disappeared. What follows is a mind-bending journey that takes Hana and her unlikely companion, Kei, from one enchanted location to another in search of answers.

Kei, a curious physicist from the "real world," stumbles into Hana’s shop and soon finds himself caught up in the adventure of a lifetime. Together, they dodge the ominous Shiikuin, masked figures who collect the "choices" that people pawn—choices tied to their regrets and burdens. The worldbuilding here is nothing short of magical, as each new setting Hana and Kei visit feels like stepping into a living dream.

But this isn't just a whimsical fantasy—it's a deep, contemplative exploration of regret, connection, and the lives we live between the lines of magic and reality. The chemistry between Hana and Kei adds a warm, touching element to the plot, and the romance that blooms feels as natural and ethereal as the world they explore.

With a pace that keeps you hooked and a plot that unravels beautifully, **Watermoon** is a story full of surprises, twists, and powerful life lessons. It’s cozy yet thrilling, light yet profound. If you're a fan of magical realism, fantasy with heart, and adventures that leave you thinking long after the last page, **Watermoon** is the book you didn't know you needed. Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

Sadly, it was only on starting this that I realised it just wasn’t for me. I try to read widely but some genres are those I just can’t get through, however much I might want to. Fantasy can be just too ‘other’.

A lovely idea for a plot and I hope it finds its audience.

Was this review helpful?

Magically hidden at the end of a Ramen restaurant queue is a Pawnshop, a place where you can rid yourself of you deepest regrets for a price

Hana is waking up as the new owner of the shop, now her father has retired, but finding the place ransacked and a strange man at her door is not what she expected

The stranger, Kei, offers her his help to track down her missing father and Hana is reluctant to accept but sees it is her best chance

The two will make a magical journey across worlds Kei could never have imagined, but to what end for the pair....

I loved this book, couldn't put it down. The writing and the world just drew me right in and unravelling the story with Hana and Kei was amazing

Perfect for Ghibli or whimsical story fans

Out January 16, thank you to NetGalley and Random House/Bantam for the review copy. All opinions my own

Was this review helpful?

There is a clear popularity at the moment for cosy Japanese novels with a hint of fantasy. A great example of this is the Toshikazu Kawaguchi series about a magical cafe where a cup of coffee lets you revisit moments from your past (Before the Coffee Gets Cold) but also books like The Nakano Thrift Shop by Hiromi Kawakami. In what feels like a bit of a combo of these two ideas specifically comes Samantha Sotto Yambao's Water Moon, a fantasy set in a magical pawnshop which you find yourself in rather than the ramen shop you thought you were entering and in which people come to trade away poor decisions that they continue to live with for a box of green tea.
Hana wakes up on the first day on which she is to take over the family pawnshop to find the place ransacked and her elderly father missing. Not long after that Kei, a physics student, finds his way into the shop and without blinking, offers to help her in her quest. That quest is to find her father and recapture the magical item that went missing with him, but also, possibly to find out what actually happened to her mother. And so begins a fantastical journey through various weird places and (of course) a romance.
Water Moon is a cosy, romantic fantasy that draws on Japanese myth and culture. There are plenty of beuatifully rendered scenes and riffs on real world ideas (prayer candles that remember prayers, a world that exists in the form of a black and white painted scroll). Water Moon could be more than this but fails to be. The characters are poorly drawn and not at all engaging (or believable as human beings), there is more telling than showing and the plot progression, while peppered with surprises, is kind of obvious. The book feels deliberately designed to appeal to a particular type of reader. And those who just want to go with the vibe, this book will be perfect. Others should look somewhere else.

Was this review helpful?

This is such a fantastical novel and the world building is incredible. Reviewers say it gives Studio Ghibli vibes but I can’t comment as I have never seen any Studio Ghibli work. All I can say is the pictures that the words created in my mind were amazing - a market held on a cloud, stars that are kites, flocks of paper cranes and paper houses that fold up and disappear. Hana’s father runs a magical pawn-shop - a shop that people from the outside world find when they need it - but they do not pawn items, they pawn choices, regrets, all that is holding them back and making them unhappy. In the pawnshop, these choices become birds, birds that are caged and are collected at intervals by the Shiikuin - scary masked figures who speak with the voice of many. On the day that Hana is to take over the shop - her father has retired - she finds evidence of a break-in. One of the birds, the choices is missing as is her father. Her assumption is that he has run into the outside world chasing the thief. But a second look makes her think that this is not the case. At the same time a stranger enters the shop - Kei - and this time he is not there to leave a choice - he chooses to help Hana go to find her father. And the quest starts with them jumping in a puddle to take them to a place where they may find answers, at the same time avoiding the Shiikuin who are now looking for Hana to punish her for breaking their rules. As Hana and Kei move from place to place in their search the descriptions of these magical places - they are just superb as is the relationship that develops between Kei and Hana. There are twists and revelations along the way because as Hana says to Kei at some point, nothing is as it seem. A really excellent fantastical adventure with a sprinkling of romance and magic.

Was this review helpful?

Water Moon is an experience. The dreamscape like world that Samantha Yambao has created is nothing short of a marvel. Each character and element is straight out of our wildest dreams. Travelling through puddles, markets in the clouds, and origami that’s alive..these are just some of the stupendous things you’ll find in the book.

But it’s not all walk in the park. Underneath this mesmerizing world where everyone seems satisfied is a dark secret. Devoid of choice and dictated in their life by a preordained path of duty, the inhabitants of this world don't know any other way to live.

It’s perfect if you love the mystical worlds of Studio Ghibli or if you are looking for an adventure. This story is sure to suck you right in and leave you wanting for more. Can't recommend it enough.

Was this review helpful?

4.5⭐

Hana just inherited her father's magical pawn shop, but on his first day of retirement Hana found the pawn shop ransacked and her father missing. Keishin was a wunderkind physicist standing before the open door of a ransacked magical pawn shop, defying everything that was logical to him he went to help Hana into her magical world.

Water Moon was a magic girl x normal guy fantasy romance set (mostly) in a very Ghibli-esque other world existing on the other side of modern-day Tokyo. It was cozy but not low-stakes, contemplative, adventurous, heartwarming, wistful, exciting, and of course magical. It was light and easy to read but the subject matter went quite deep. I really enjoyed it! The story unfolded really well, with a steady but fast pacing and a central mystery as the driving force. The romance and worldbuilding was very well-developed but a bit rushed at the beginning and end (barely mattered to me because it was very cute). I liked how in-depth we got to know the main characters; the narrative sometimes went back in time to examine some significant events in their lives. I especially liked how the normal guy was a physicist, and his character offered very interesting perspectives as the story went deeper into the magical world. The dialogues sometimes went a little too deep (think The Alchemist) compared to normal conversation, but it is the nature of the story.

eARC provided by NetGalley and Transworld Books.

Was this review helpful?

“Happiness does not exist in a place. It lives in every breath we take. You need to choose to take it in, over and over again.”

This is one of those wonderful fantasy stories, which we often come across in Japanese, Korean or other South East Asian fiction. It is a story entwined with magic but also speaks to the heart of great life truths like the quote (from the book) above. In general I am not a reader of fantasy but these kind of stories are my exception to that statement and this was another book I adored and would wholeheartedly recommend.

In Water Moon Keishin, a boy from the human world, gets transported to Hana’s magical world through a portal in a ramen shop in Tokyo. It is Hana’s first day of running the family pawn shop where people from the human world can come and trade burdensome regrets and return to the human world lighter, without memories of these, going forward. When Keishin enters the shop, he finds it in an absolute mess. Hana’s father is missing, it appears that he has chased away some intruders but we soon realise that he has, in fact, gone in search of his wife who Hana believed had died many years ago. Keishin decides to try and help Hana find her mother and father and together they go on a magical adventure through Hana’s world where nothing is as it seems. Through the journey a bond develops between the two of them and Keishin finds he feels more alive than he has ever felt before. Hana’s world is dangerous though so will the pair succeed in finding Hana’s parents and what will happen when they do, for Keishin cannot remain in a world he doesn’t belong to…

This is such a wonderful book. I did not want to the adventure to end!

Was this review helpful?

I don't want to say too much about this because I found so much love for this book was in the not knowing. I was absolutely enchanted by this and could totally see this being one of my favourite reads of 2025.

Was this review helpful?

I clearly hadn't read the blurb properly as this wasn't anything like what I was expecting. Instead, I got something better.

The comparisons to Ghibli are apt, you can definitely see the fantastical world becoming an excellent film adaptation.

I really enjoyed this and would love to re-read it in print (it feels more serious in print!) to see what I'd missed.

I really enjoyed Hana's journey and the relationship with Kei. It definitely kept me guessing as I didn't see the twist coming. The world building was fantastic, each new place was captured so well - a few places were a quick chapter and could have been longer but the story moved quickly. I couldn't get a sense of the time though - they had 3 days to solve the mystery but they stayed at least 3 nights in places - maybe the Shiikuin didn't want to collect all the other birds? It felt like there was a deadline that was ignored, but that's really a minor quibble.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an advanced ebook copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Watermoon is like being in a dream. It’s beautifully written with vivid imagery and stunning descriptive language that feels like a big warm hug. It’s utterly whimsical and completely Studio Ghibli coded.

I loved how the book focuses on choices and how we make them, what choices we make and how that can change the path of destiny. I also loved how our protagonist, Hana, is always sought out for help, but eventually she finds someone who wants to help her, which I thought was a really nice touch.

Throughout the whole book you feel like you’re going on an adventure. There are lots of different worlds/scenes played out and flashbacks and time bending moments that I was so invested in!

The ending was a twist that I didn’t necessarily expect but definitely welcomed it, it became quite dark and the pace really picked up which left me gasping out loud!

This is a phenomenal read, it’s cozy, and cute, and interesting, and unique, and diverse and 100% one for the TBR!

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved every second of it!

Water Moon was magical, whimsical, adorable, interesting, thought provoking - so many things in one book! I saw another review describe the author as a storyteller and I couldn’t think of a better word to describe her. The magical world she created was just wonderful, I loved the depth of this book and how it discusses choices and regrets in a magical but still impactful way. It was steeped in Japanese mythology references and honestly it felt like I was watching a Studio Ghibli film while I was reading.

This book was one of the easiest 5⭐️ of the whole year from me. I could reread it immediately and I don’t even reread books! I don’t have a bad word to say at all.

Was this review helpful?

A whimsical, waterfall of a novel that carries you from one charmingly visual location to the next. The atmosphere shifts from breezy and awe-inspiring, like you were in one of the many forests depicted in a Studio Ghibli movie, to sharp and tense as metallic humanoid guardians hunt down our runaway pawnshop heir, Hana, and (our) other-worlder, Keishin. A ceaselessly contemplative effort into choice, existential purpose, life's paths, "what ifs", and having the courage to make the choices that ring truest to you and your happiness. Highly enjoyable and immersive.

Thanks to Netgalley and Bantam Books/Random House UK for providing me with the e-ARC/DRC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book sweeps you into a magical realm where choices and regrets hold transformative power. Hana's journey to uncover the truth behind her father's disappearance becomes a poignant exploration of love, loss, and self-discovery, with each twist revealing deeper emotional stakes. Beautiful world-building and lyrical prose will transport readers into a vivid, dreamlike adventure that stays with you long after the last page. I could not put this book down! I will be recommending this book to everyone! Especially fans of Studio Ghibli!

Was this review helpful?

Whimsical, disorienting, emotional experience. This book is something else, a twisting turning journey that gets very dark as it explores cause and effect across two very different worlds. Hana has always known her fate, and has an important if disturbing role to play in her own world, But that changes when her father disappears and Kei, a stranger from another world, appears at her door.

Hana and Kei's fates become tied together as they journey through a series of incredible adventures and revelations as they search for Hana's father . After a slowish start, I found myself becoming more and more invested in what was happening as the reader is taken breathlessly from scene to scene in search of a truth that is always more complicated than it at first seems. Totally fascinating and absorbing, this is a very visual book on a grand scale and yet is also able to manipulate the smallest of emotions.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Random House UK and Netgalley for an arc of Water Moon! Publishing date 16th January 2025!

If you're into cosy fantasy, whimsy prose and Studio Ghibli- you will adore this book!

This book follows Hana who has just inherited her family's magical pawnshop and a physicist who wants to answer all of science's mysteries. They are thrown into an adventure when Hana awakens on her first day as the owner of the shop to find it has been ransacked, an important item has been stolen and her father is missing. The story then goes from there and we are thrown into the Studio Ghibli-esque "Other World" as the pair first meet and then have go on an adventure to solve what has happened!

The world building was whimsy, atmospheric and was complemented by a lyrical writing style that matched the story perfectly (I highlighted so many quotes). I enjoyed the sprinkling of humour throughout- the perceptions of items/customs in our world were fun and the humour was weaved into the storyline so seamlessly that it did not feel out of place. The mix of vibes✨ and plot are well balanced!

I also love that this is a cosy fantasy but with high stakes- the story never seemed slow and I would suggest this to anyone trying to get into the cosy fantasy sub-genre!

Now on my list of my top fantasy reads of this year!

Was this review helpful?

Water moon is such a breath taking experiencing taking you through a magical fantasy. I loved the descriptions so much it felt as though I was Hanna and I was the one going along the journey. I feel like this book is meant to be dissected and cherished individually because it just has that effect. The studio ghibli reference had me kicking my feet and going 'YES THIS THIS'.
I went into this book completely, utterly blind and I rarely do that but I was left awestruck at how such beautiful concepts were dealt with expecially the concept of regret.
Overall such a wonderful exprience, it was fast-paced and unlike most japanese set reads, this wasn't boring at all.

The dedication had me sit there and stare at the wall, because it touched me so deeply. Although just a dedication I feel like Samantha knew exactly what she was doing.
This book is definitely for anyone having a hard time with regrets and for someone who is searching for new beginnings in life<3

Thank you so much to the publisher and Netgalley for the arc!!

Was this review helpful?

Huge thank you to netgalley for allowing me an eARC cooy of Water Moon. I love books set in japan and just japanese fiction in general so seeing this and reading the synopsis i was straight to request it and i am so glad i did. I loved the element of magical realism, and i especially love books where its just like a little glitch in the world. As the story progressed it was just getting better and better, it was so atmospheric and i lived the character work and you coukd really feel for the characters. Absolutely delicious book and im so interested in reading more work by this author

Was this review helpful?

Water Moon is one of those books that as soon as you start reading it’s so hard to put down. This book was so whimsical and I loved how it had Studio Ghibli vibes as I could picture every single moment and description so vividly and visually in my mind. The writing is so beautiful and made it such a joy to read.

This is a story of love and life steeped around a lot of mystery and though the pacing is a little up and down and where it moves fast in some scenes in others it slows down considerably I personally didn’t find this too much of a problem as the story takes you on an adventure and it suits it perfectly. I would have loved maybe a little more development in the romance but again that is probably more of a me thing as it really was a sweet romance and I loved how satisfying the ending was.

Water Moon is a delight of a book that asks thought provoking questions about choices, regrets and where we belong and will stay with me for a long time.

Thank you so much to the publisher and NetGalley for the gift of reading this arc.

Was this review helpful?