Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you for my earc of this book. I like the premise but DNF because I found the writing style and drama a bit tiresome. I might try again on audio!

Was this review helpful?

The Favourites is an incredible read and one of my absolute favourites this year so far! I adored this story and its characters! The documentary style is reminiscent of Daisy Jones and the Six, but the competitive ice skating world is a perfect new twist. I found this book incredibly difficult to put down, there were so many twists, turns and shocking moments, I couldn't get enough! I loved how dramatic and immersive it was! A brilliant read, I can't recommend it enough!

Was this review helpful?

Wuthering Height gets an update in this romantic and intense reimagining set in the American world of ice-skating with some I,Tonya vibes.
This is an immersive story that sucks you in with its Netflix documentary style narrative. It’s quick and pacy. I did feel that you do need to suspend your disbelief a little, but it’s just the perfect escapist, romantic and heady read.

Was this review helpful?

Katarina Shaw made up for in passion and raw talent what she lacked in wealth and legacy. Her determination to become an Olympic ice skater began at a young age and she was just as equally committed to taking her foster brother and partner, Heath Rocha, along with her. No matter the odds stacked or foe standing against them, they were a force to be reckoned with when placed together. However, every home relies on the foundations it was built upon and Katarina and Heath might find theirs rocked as they raise themselves far from their meagre beginnings.

I adored this novel's layout which felt very reminiscent of Taylor Jenkins Reid's Daisy Jones & The Six. Each chapter began with an interview transcript from various individuals the pair encountered in their life, leading the reader to acknowledge early on that they became household names and that drama had dogged them on their rise to the top of their sport.

The focus remained on the sport however and I found the character's ambition, dedication, hard work ethic, and drive to be very uplifting. It also made for harrowing reading when they fell short of what they aimed to achieve or they encountered injury or illness that made them unable to perform at their bests. This really showcased how gruelling the sport is and the limits all will surpass, even when unhealthy or unwise to do so, in reaching their goals.

This was a tragic romance like few others I have read and I was captivated by the duo at its centre throughout. This was full of sorrow and heartache and time and time again the characters hurt each other viciously but the reader could feel the passion and love that still remained, although depleted, after every argument and row. Years passed as the novel did and the characters altered but the seeds of love remained. It made my chest ache to see them distant and removed before reconciling once again but with seeds of doubt or mistrust that then blossomed into more years of separation.

I had no idea where the story would take me but I was surprised and delighted by the direction it took and the realistic, although slightly bittersweet conclusion, the author provided them with.

Was this review helpful?

I can see why this is being recommended for people who love Taylor Jenkins Reid! The angst and the drama got a bit much for me at times but there were moments where my jaw literally dropped. I also thought the tension between the characters was well written.

Was this review helpful?

So I'm going to start by saying I watch a *lot* of figure skating, and although I'm not a skater, I know a fair amount about how the sport works and the politics of it all. And my experience of fiction featuring skating has been a bit mixed - but I couldn't resist this because it was getting comparisons to Daisy Jones and the Six, which I really, really loved. So I took a chance. And it's really good. Everything is turned up to eleven, but apart from all the (on ice partner) swapping the skating details felt pretty flawless and as an alternative universe of the early 2000s Olympic cycles it's a real page turner. I wouldn't say that all the characters are tremendously deep or well developed, but there's so much plot and it moves so fast that you don't really notice until you're looking back at the end.

Was this review helpful?

I really wanted to love this as there was so much buzz around it, but it just didn't land with me. I wasn't engaged with the characters who all seemed a bit vacuous and it was very long length wise for such a continuous parade of low level drama. It made more sense that I didn't enjoy this once read some reviews noting that this was a Wuthering Heights retelling, because I hated that book. Shame because the format of Kat's POV intermingled with the documentary footage of interviews and talking heads was really great.

Was this review helpful?

It was good, I just felt it could have gone further with the twists? I dunno what that says about me that I wanted more drama and nothing really surprised me 😂 I did love the daisy jones and the six style storytelling. I also feel the author did her job in me not particularly gravitating towards any of the characters as they were all problematic in their own right - but that’s what made it feel real! It was a nice break from romance, and I did love reading about the competitions and the rivalries! It was fast paced and never felt drawn out.

Was this review helpful?

This is the story of two ambitious young people who want to become Olympic figure skaters, we meet Katarina and Heath as young children learning to skate separately and then together and follow them throughout their figure skating career.
Setting the novel in the world of competitive dance skating is immediately interesting to me. It’s a highly Visual sport and easy to imagine. The author describes both the active figure skating and the relationships of her characters beautifully , she has a clear easily read flowing prose style and the novel progresses at quite a fast rate throughout. I was very quickly invested in the characters wanted to know more. I read the book in one sitting I didn’t want to put it down .
The book starts with various characters commentary as if a documentary is being made about the ice skaters I rather like this other day an element of unusualness to the book. The book continues to be told in this format interwoven with the story being seen from the point of view of Katarina.
I love the on off element of the relationship with the two main characters . There are times when the relationship is a wee bit far-fetched but this is a novel and if you allow for the needs of the story this is something that you easily overlook.
I loved the ending which builds to a crescendo, which is quite exciting the Russian teams apparent attempt to throw the competition that comes in increasingly sinister as our main characters attempts to win the gold medal or sabotaged. Again this is a little bit over the top, but it’s fun and kept me entertained.
The main characters are well described and their relationship is vital to the story. There’s also a selection of minor characters who are also well described.
I read an Ellie copy of the novel or NetGalley UK in return for an unbiased review. The book was published in the UK on the 16th of January 2025 by Random house UK vintage.
This review will appear on NetGalley UK, StoryGraph, Goodreads, and my book blog bionicSarahSbooks.wordpress.com. It was also appear on Amazon UK and Waterstones.

Was this review helpful?

I LOVED this! So fast paced, likeable characters that evoke genuine feeling for the reader! I’d never read anything with a ‘narrator’ or comments from other characters in this format before and I found I was able to understand more of the story as I was able to experience the thoughts and feelings of other characters. I hate to compare authors because they are all unique, but this gave me very strong Taylor Jenkins-Reid vibes and I thoroughly enjoyed it! Brilliant!

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately this just wasn’t for me, i’m not sure if it was the interview style or all the drama but i couldn’t wait for it to end.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this my grandmother was a figure skater and grew up with her stories of life on the ice. The rivalry the competitiveness amazing. And the style of story telling was so unique and interesting.

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely gripping. I seriously couldn't stop reading, deep into the night.
A story of obsession, love, hate, passion and envy, all wrapped up into a world of competition rarely exposed. I'd love to know how much is reality and how much is fiction.
Brilliant writing, superb character building and just when you think it must be all over, there's more.

Was this review helpful?

This started off so promising with the messy, obsessiveness and romance of figure skating!

It lost me with that stupid pregnancy subplot, there was just no point in it! I wasn’t a fan of the 2 MCs getting together in the end but of course they did…

Was this review helpful?

The first thing that drew me to this book was the ice dancing. I unfortunately spend a lot of time online and a few years ago I saw the viral video of Tessa and Scott performing their final routine. This led me down various rabbit holes and, long story short, my husband and I are taking ice skating lessons.

The second thing was the synopsis ringing Taylor Jenkins Reid alarm bells in my head. TJR is one of my favourite auto buy authors and I constantly crave books that can give me a similar feeling to hers.

The Favourites delivered.

The way the author mixed the interview style and the first person POV worked well, and as cheesy as this sounds, the pacing and tension of the book followed a similar progression to an ice dance performance, which ended with everything on fire. Fargo's thriller background really showed up here.

Kat isn't a likeable person but she's a great character to read. She has passion, ambition, and focus. I don't think we learnt enough about Heath, and I don't think this is an epic love story as the US marketing is trying to portray. Unless that love story is between Kat and ice dancing.

Was this review helpful?

Really enjoyable and quick read. The book is written in a mix of first person pov chapters and multi-character interviews. Interesting format which reminded me of Daisy Jones and The Six. The story certainly drew inspiration from the Tonya Harding/Nancy Kerrigan rivalry…
Overall it was a fast paced and gripping read but I would have liked the ending to pack more of a punch

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely adored this book. The documentary style writing was perfect for the drama. I loved the titbits that were given in the documentary before something big happened. It also made the story come to life and left me feeling as though this was a non-fiction book. I’d love to be able to Google Kat and Heath and read all of Ellis Deans articles.
The blend of gossip, ambition, and suspense was perfectly executed. I could not stop reading, it pained me to pause and put the book down. If you love a dramatic, fast-paced romance with a unique structure, this is a must-read!

Was this review helpful?

I was hooked from the beginning, the drama! Oh my goodness it was so good, the drama, the betrayal….it was toxic and messy but so so good. I couldn’t put it down

It was a whole experience, I loved the format with the interview/documentary type sessions alongside the first person format.

Katrina Shaw, intense, passionate and not so perfect, she felt so real. Heath Rocha is a more complicated character, there was mystery around his character made. Their relationship together? So much tension, obsessive, almost suffocating. It just added to how the story played out

Was this review helpful?

I heard a lot of hype about the book. Once you know it’s a retelling of Wuthering Heights you can really see it. I loved the setting of the ice skating world and that it was from Kat’s POV. Plus the documentary style was good. While I was reading it I kept thinking is it really as good as the hype. But I kept thinking about it after I finished it.

Was this review helpful?

Loved loved loved this… as mentioned on the cover very much in the vein of Daisy and the Six and Songs in Ursa Major . The Favourites is about having the drive to fight for what you believe in, to believe in yourself at all costs and never let your dreams die all set to the background of competitive ice dancing. A new author for me but will definitely be finding her other books.

Was this review helpful?