Skip to main content

Member Reviews

The False Pawn by A. E. Asavi, is probably one of the most conflicting books I have read in a long while. Honestly, I couldn't decide until probably three-quarters of the way through, if I actually liked the book or not. And it has nothing to do with the story, because Ms. Asavi's writing style is great. She brings depth and life to her characters, and it's obvious early on, most eadters will either lover or hate her story. Since I didn't hate the the book, it still gave me room to warm up to the story, which I did finally, about the last quarter of the way through the book.

Lies run rampant throughout this book. In fact, lies abound so much, it's hard to tell if anyone ever knows how to tell the truth about anything, or if everyone is going to grow a nose longer than Pinocchio. Physical torture is another tool that is used liberally in this book for most of this new world that the main female character finds herself trapped on.

The main female character, while she does the right thing and steps up for her family, putting food on their table and clothes on back, is a weak enabler. And by that I mean, she spins stories for people that intentionally hurt others, i.e. men who sexually assault women, and claim that the victim is the one really at fault, not the perpetrator. The enabling portion comes into play when you realize the main female character lets her youngest sister just laze around the house doing what she wants without contributing, yet the oldest sister keeps getting angry at her and yelling at her about getting a job, but never does anything to enforce her getting one, nor does she try to help her get a job - she'd rather stay home, get drunk and resent her sister.

The one time the female character does goes out, she does so more out of spite against her sister than anything. Then, before she knows it, she wakes up on some other world where humans are practically sub-par "citizens", and most are used as slaves, and those not slaves are considered
rebels.

Most of us, when we think of Elves, we think of either Christmas or Lord of the Rings and Middle Earth by J. R, Tolkien. You need to forget all about those preconceived notions of Elves when you read The False Pawn.

Elves in this book, like Mr. Tolkien's books are split into realms, but that is about where the similarities end. The False Pawn's Elves are angry, vindictive, manipulative, human slave-trafficking, and they don't care who gets in their way as long they get what they want, especially the royalty.

Now, there are a couple of decent Elves thrown in, but you see their decentness AFTER they were told to help torture the main female character, with one breaking her hand and the other whipping her fourteen times instead of twenty because she passed out and she couldn't learn her lesson unconscious. A Queen is also decent, and does her best to try and help the main female character, explaining what is going on, why everyone is behaving the way they are, not that that excuses their behavior in the least.

By the end of the book, the main female character has a choice to make, and she realizes she has some major growing up to do at the same time. She finally comes to terms that she is probably not going to see her sisters again, so she could at least use her position to help the humans where she currently is, and make sure they are finally able to be treated fairly. But to do that she must learn how to do things she never thought possible, and become someone she never thought she could become.

Even though it took me a while to determine if I actually liked the story, Ms. Asavi did a remarkable job bringing an entire new world to life. Her characters are full of depth and make you think about where you are in your own life and the injustices that go on in the world.

If you want a book that is full of spirit, action, survival, hope, and most of all growth and love, then The False Pawn is just the book for you. I don't know when book will come out, but in my opinion, it won't be out soon enough.

Was this review helpful?

Anthea Clark has a sense of obligation to her sisters, to work and pay the bills since their parents have died. After a fight she has with one of them she decides that she needs a night out on the town. While drunk and disoriented she stumbles out of the bar only to be confronted by a man who knows her name. As the man proceeds to draw strange burning marks on her skin, Anthea too stunned to move, the man continues the outrageous interaction by reciting a prophecy that she is unable to comprehend. Anthea is finally able to break free of this entanglement only to suddenly fall into another realm with Elven princes. She must quickly adjust to live in this new realm if she has any hope to return to the one she knows. But there is more to her than they all thought. Can she be this new realm's prophecy? Can she do what they want of her or can she break free and make it back home?
Overall rating 5/5
This book had me up multiple nights enraptured in Anthea’s story. There were points in the book that I felt mirrored ACOTAR’s plot which was both appealing and a bit too similar for me. I did enjoy the world building done by Asavi, and would love more dual POVs in the next installment.
*Thank you to A.E. Asavi, and Netgalley for the ARC copy. I am freely leaving my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Themes and tropes: enemies to lovers, feisty FMC, Broody Prince, Hot Commander, realm travel, prophecies and fate, dragons, elves, caste system, politics, betrayal

I enjoyed this book and would recommend if the above themes and tropes interest you. The books gives you exactly what is described and is written well. It starts off with a human FMC who gets abducted from her world and tossed into a foreign magical realm. The first half of the book is centered around a “feisty” FMC trying to figure out how to get back home, what she can leverage or negotiation to aid her goal. Despite not having magic, the FMC is protected against magic being used against her and uses it as a way to navigate her attempt at freedom. A lot of the book is her not knowing much about this new world, her surroundings or the elven royalty who are holding her. However, the second half of the book sets it up very nicely for you to want to continue reading the next book in this series. You learn about the political history of the realm, past and present betrayals, prophecies and fate that have led to this series of events, and there’s DRAGONS.

I really enjoyed: The writing style and pace, mixing it up with Eleven royalty rather than Fae.

I disliked: I wish some of the context from the later half of the book came a bit sooner.

Was this review helpful?

oh man, I really don’t like to give out bad reviews but I could not continue with this book anymore. The False Pawn had all the right things I love in a book: fantasy, mystery, and romance. However, there were a lot of missing details and information that confused me. The pacing also felt all over the place.

I did like the FMC, especially her fun attitude. I made it to 40% before I had to put this book down. I had no desire to keep going on to find out how everything ended up, and that was so hard for me. I was hoping to enjoy this story more.

Writing reviews like these breaks my heart, but I am trying to read more for pleasure and am learning to put a book down if I am not enjoying it.

Was this review helpful?

Anthea gets swept up by another world mistakenly and has to save the world. Can she survive.

If you liked court of thorns and roses this book is for you.
It has a very similar vibes to the story. Girl ends up in a world of elves. She’s different than them and has to save them.

We have two love interest. Where immediately 50% in you have to start hating the first one because you can’t have two decent love interest. (Which I hate)

Anthea was fine I guess. Not my favorite character ever written but she was fine. One thing that pissed me off near the end of the book was the self doubt. Like in the beginning of the book okay, but then end no. That’s like a main character in a horror film crying at the last 15 minutes just standing there. At that point you have to keep fighting. Also, I saw in one review someone mentioned that she was too forgiving and I have to agree but also why did all the characters need to do something that made her either angry or need to be forgiven. Like I just want one character that I don’t have to hate for 5-10 pages

I was also upset she spent so much talking about her sisters but after the first 20ish pages we never see them in the book again. we just have to listen to the main character miss them

But I do want to thank the author, publisher and NetGalley for the ARC of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Overall I loved it. Some of the names were very similar, and difficult to keep straight. But the author does a great job of making you feel everything that Anthea feels. The story itself moves along at a good pace, with some mystery, some adventure, some banter, and a good bit of sexual tension. Definitely worth reading, and I can't wait to read more!

Was this review helpful?

An unusual portal story. Anthea is attacked as she leaves a nightclub and suddenly finds herself in an alternate dimension where elves are the dominant caste and humans are mere slaves.
Sometimes the scenes in the story can be intense with the slavery and dominance of humans such that some readers may be put off and as such clear trigger warnings may be required up front.
I found the romantic element a bit forced as it seemed too convenient and quick to develop especially as there was significant trust issues being portrayed.
Despite that I enjoyed the book an look forward to the next one so see if Anthea can locate the elusive dragons.

Was this review helpful?

I'm afraid I had to DNF this at 11%, chapter 6.
It's a really interesting premise and though I fall within the target audience, there were a lot of aspects once reading that immediately put me off.

Firstly, Anthea is completely unlikeable from the start. My first note at 1% was "Am I supposed to dislike her?". I don't know if that's the case but for the next 10%, I did not begin to warm to her nor did I get the sense that I would.

I found that where a cliche could be packed in, it was. As a writer, I empathise with how easy it can be to fall into that pit but in combination with my other pet peeves, it made it hard to read without rolling my eyes.

I took issue with a scene early in the book - and this harks back to Anthea's likeability (or lack thereof) - where she is drinking whilst handling a work harassment case. Statistically speaking, this is very likely a sexual assault if not SA-adjacent.. I don't care how 'skilled' you are at your job or how well you handle your drink, that's not okay. I don't think this is something Asavi should have written in at all; what was the point? As I DNF'd the book, maybe it was important and came back later on. However, I doubt it.

The use of 'rump' from a protag who is young enough to go clubbing yanked me HARD from the story. At this point, I really was willing to put aside my small grievances but then an on-page SA takes place and it becomes very clear that it was written to give Anthea an excuse to leave the club by herself. This scene was handled in a very irresponsible way and what happened to her comes across as being inconsequential.

Descriptions were so lacklustre and at times, it was giving wattpad. Furthermore, Anthea was portrayed as being incredibly drunk (literally slurring) and yet she was taking note of several occurrences that no drunk person could possibly have processed. Her recall was good. She then seemed to instantly snap out of her drunkness (remember, slurring) minutes later. Anthea wakes up in a situation that is dangerous and life-threatening; one move and she could end up seriously harmed if not killed. And the first thing she does...is comment on the fact that she can see two moons? Yeah, no. It only goes downhill from there because, despite the situation she has found herself in, there is just a complete and utter lack of urgency.

She sees pointed ears and assumes...alien. This is initially set in an urban city and there is just no way that Anthea would not have even heard of humans with pointed ears signalling Elves (i.e. in movies or games etc.).

Essentially, I couldn't get into the book for more than a few minutes before something illogical or strange pulled me out. I couldn't suspend my disbelief at any point which is a shame because I feel there could have been potential. The lack of trigger warnings is also something I take issue with considering the mention of harrasment and then an actual on-page assault right at the start.

However, I will say that I love the cover and I also really enjoyed the little sister's sass.

Was this review helpful?

I was able to read about 45% of this book before I unfortunately had to dnf, and there were many times before that when I wanted to put this down for good. But I always try and give books and their authors a fair shot.

There are a few reasons why I decided to discontinue reading this book. One of the main reasons is because the pacing and plot development don’t match up at all. The story will have progressed weeks or months but not much has happened in regards to plot. And characters form attachments that, in truth, don’t make much sense, because there is no emotional buy-in between characters. While the main love interest is obvious from the start, that isn’t because the author wrote them to be a love interest, it’s because the author follows typical tropes from other fantasy authors.

Another thing that confused me was how under developed the main character is. One moment she is strong and fiery, the next she is petulant and childish, and then she becomes a woe-is-me damsel in distress. I couldn’t get to know her because I felt whiplash in all the ways she presented herself unevenly throughout the scenes.

To give some credit- I do think that, of what I read, the author has a good idea in mind of where this story will go. It’s an interesting thought to have a human in another realm and impervious to the realm’s magic, yet able to understand their spoken and written language. If I could look past my other qualms, I think I would be interested to see where the story goes.

This book might be good for readers who are new to fantasy, like smut for smut’s sake, and who don’t mind looking past mid-quality writing.

Was this review helpful?

This book pulled me in a few different direction and was very much a world building first installment. There is a ton of lore, character introduction, and surprising turns jammed into this book.

Anthea lives with her two sisters, acting as a pseudo mother to them after their parents died and going to work for a paycheck but not much fulfillment. I’m not sure what I expected, but it wasn’t her going to a club and then falling through a portal in to an elf-run world. Once there, she is imprisoned, forced to be a slave (or act as one, it’s confusing and edges close to Stockholm syndrome), kidnapped, tortured, betrayed, and then sort-of/kind-of revered? This book takes you through all the feels.

The overall story revolves around a prophecy and lots of court intrigue. Turns out humans exist in this world but they are a slave race, doing the bidding of the elves (who also have magic). It is quickly discovered that Anthea is immune to magic, so they quickly put her to work. Is there romance? Yes? I guess? Again, she is everyone’s prisoner so how much is her own bidding and how much is questionable consent? It toes a line there, but if you can put that aside, there are more than enough very attractive elves who could easily be in the running for Anthea’s partner.

None of this truly pans out as this is just book 1 and we need to set up a lot of things all at once. I’m not the best high fantasy reader, so admit that a lot of the very similar names ended up blurring together a times, but the author did convince me I should be rooting for our unlikely hero, Anthea. It will be interesting to see what other trouble she gets into in future books.

Was this review helpful?

It's been a looooong time since I've read a portal fantasy and very often they are quite predictable and become quite boring pretty fast. But let me tell this book was everything BUT boring and predictable.
Not gonna lie at times the FMC infurme me but there's definitely strong character development which I enjoyed.
Ivrealy like that the author didn't try to be similar to anyone or tried toimic whats popular these days - the story is authentic and captivating. It finishes on cliffhanger so Im looking forward to the next book.

Was this review helpful?

Considering this is the author’s debut, I feel they have strong potential. Many people with more patience with the genre will like this book.

I DNF because the dialogue felt pretty awkward, mostly due to the author’s greedy pacing and lack of subtlety. You really get hit over the head with the plot, whether you like it or not. However, to the author’s credit, they don’t fall prey to many romantasy genre traps, such as a ridiculously young heroine with no real responsibility, or overuse of weird vocabulary to describe hair and “orbs”. Overall, I think the author needs to work on their dialogue, vocabulary, and pacing in the long term.

Was this review helpful?

Struggling to enjoy her life and desperate for a way out of her rut, Anthea finds herself in over her head in a world she never thought possible. Lost and confused in an unknown realm where nothing is as it seems, she embarks on a journey that forces her to examine herself and embrace the inevitable change as she tries to find her way home. Entangled with elves, magic, and prophecy, Anthea must unravel layers of deception and betrayal while trying to find her footing in a brand new world.

This was a really great introduction to a new fantasy series. Asavi excels in world-building, creating a vivid and immersive setting. The attention to detail in the political, cultural, and social structures of the world enhances the realism of the fantasy setting and makes the reading experience much more immersive. The plot felt very well paced, with perfectly timed twists, reveals of information, and moments that built character development. This book has the perfect balance of romance and fantasy, sprinkled with political intrigue and spice. I can’t wait for this series to continue so we can see where Anthea ends up.

I’d highly recommend this for anyone who loves strong FMCs, magical courts, elves, dragons, and broody swoony bodyguards.

Was this review helpful?

This story… was not what I expected. The pacing is reasonable and lots happens and it’s not really a plot I have come across before. But oh my days do we go from 0-60, from very little tension to sudden sexual advances in the name of “you’re my property”. Now this would be fine, but the whole human-is-slave concept is dialled up to 90 in the beginning, with every other utterance talking about obedience and discipline and other buzz words that really kill the mood. Less is more, more or less. Nothing, and I mean nothing, is left to the imagination, which is a shame.

Characters are interesting, though. I like Anthea’s stubbornness and unwillingness to bend. It’s done in a very good way, and whilst I didn’t resonate with her life experiences (how could I?), I did appreciate and sympathise with her. I liked her. She is a good MFC and I kept turning the proverbial pages to see what happened to her… I also loved how Anthea grows in strength, both politically and physically. She has an immense journey and is not just some meek creature out of her depth. The first third of the book was a challenge for various reasons but the payoff in the latter two thirds is significant and worth the wait. We are not dealing with a self-insert character, which is what I initially feared.

Now. The nomenclature has to be mentioned, because to me this was the biggest problem with the book. The names themselves seem to follow a phonetic and graphemic system that is acceptable for the average English reader can understand. The issue is that about 75% of the characters have names starting with “A” or “E”. It’s like the inspiration was LotR but it was taken one step too far. Even the horse’s name starts with an E. This is a problem for me keeping up with who is who.

Overall? I really enjoyed it as a book to escape into another world. Despite my negative points above, it did not detract from my general ability to switch off and enjoy story for the sake of the story and not overanalyse too much. I would advise warnings to be attached to this book as it is certainly not for everyone, but there is a large fan base who I know will love it. I am more than a little curious to see how the series progresses.

Was this review helpful?

Poor Anthea, she just can't catch a break! I love every minute of her journey and can't wait to see if she can wake up the dragons. She's a total badass FMC!

I'd rate it a high 3.6. While I understand she's in a tough situation, her frequent complaints made her seem slightly naive at times and draining.

Was this review helpful?

This book falls under the genre of romantasy - my favourite - and it has all the important points for that but I just didn't love it as much as I do other books. Overall I struggled a lot with the time jumps and the quite repetetive writing style because they slowed down readings drastically for me. The characters were ok but I needed some time to get warm with them und understand where they're coming from.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley for providing an ARCI'm giving this book 1.5 stars.

I actually enjoyed the first 4 chapters and the last 4 chapters of this book. The rest of this was very difficult for me to get through. I don't believe the synopsis of this book fit for what actually happens in this book. I also believe this book and its future companions would greatly benefit from some trigger warnings. This felt more like a dark romantsy when I was not expecting it. The parts of the book that I liked were the parts where the MC was trying to figure things out on her own and not thinking about the "romantic interests". I really feel like the author could write some interesting fantasy writing but was trying to balance it with men for our MC to have romance with. I think the romantic interests are not great and should stay far away from the MC.

This book was very long and repetitive at times to the point I almost DNF'ed a few times.

I don't see myself reading this again or reading the rest of this series.

Trigger warnings I think other readers should be wary of are: Emotional manipulation, dubious consent, sexual assault, torture on page, violence to the MC and towards others, and human sacrifice in some pretty graphic detail.

Was this review helpful?

"The False Pawn" by A.E. Asavi is a gripping fantasy novel that captivates with its intricate blend of political intrigue, mystery, and slow-burn romance. The story follows Anthea Clark, a PR specialist whose life takes a dramatic turn when she's swept into a treacherous realm of court politics and Elven conflicts. As Anthea navigates this dangerous new world, her resilience and cunning are tested, making for a compelling protagonist. While the time jumps can be a bit disorienting, the immersive world-building and vivid emotional landscape make this a standout read that leaves you eagerly anticipating the next installment.

Was this review helpful?

I don't like giving bad reviews, but this book could just not hold my attention! I got well over a quarter into it and I was BORED. The writing was okay (not bad, but not great) used a lot of skips - where there would be one scene, then it would fast forward to later in the day with no real substance. It just felt too choppy and nothing interesting really happened. (I mean if you count her being thrust into a new world interesting then yes that is interesting, but after that nada) I'm not asking for everything to go so quickly, but she spends a full month just being a prisoner and them testing her with their magic. The connection between her and the 2 elves also just felt off and that there was no real substance there either. Unfortunately, I had to put it on the shelf for now. Maybe I will try again another day.

Was this review helpful?

The False Pawn is a fantasy slow-burn romance that has a lot of political aspects in it. The romance took a backseat to the political plot and it was rather refreshing with books nowadays. The storyline was decent and the characters were interesting enough. The book is set up well to span over multiple books and I can’t wait to see where book 2 takes us. The FMC was easy to connect and empathize with, but she is a tad annoying at the beginning of the book. With politics playing a big part in the book, I didn’t find myself trusting anyone. The twist in the book took me completely by surprise which I loved because I can usually guess the twists and turns of books. Altogether The False Pawn is a great debut book and I can’t wait for the next in the series.

Thank you NetGalley and A. E. Asavi for providing the eARC.

Was this review helpful?