Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Burn After Reading by Catherine Ryan Howard
I give this book 4.25 stars.

The night Jack Smyth ran into flames in a desperate attempt to save his wife he was too late.
Suspicion has stalked him ever since.
A year on, he's signed a book deal. He wants to tell his side of the story, Emily has never ghostwritten anything before, but she's about to learn that there are some stories that should never be told .

A slow burn start that picks up and had me racing towards the end of the story. Cleverly written so it felt like true crime.Told in dual narratives, with flawed characters ( don’t you just love them ) and a past and present timelines. There is plenty of tension and unease in the isolated environment and both Jack and Emily’s reasons for being there. Filled with deception who should we trust and what is the real truth.l loved the addition of early insights into what was to come for me this added to my reading experience as did the authors note.
Thank you to Netgalley, the author and Random House UK, Transworld Publishers | Bantam for my chance to read and review this book.

Was this review helpful?

Burn after Reading is the first Catherine Ryan Howard book that I have read but I very much doubt it will be the last. From the opening chapter you are drawn into something that will keep you hooked until the end.
Emily Joyce has written a successful book but has been struggling to follow up with her second and she is worried that her publishers will want their advance back and its money she just doesn’t have. When she is called to a meeting with them, they offer her a solution to her problems. They need a ghostwriter for former professional cyclist Jack Smyth. Jack lost his wife in a terrible fire and although he has never been charged with her murder there has always been rumour and doubt following him. He has decided to tell his story to prove his innocence. Feeling that she has no choice Emily soon finds herself in Florida with Jack to get the information needed for the book. It should have been a straightforward assignment but from the empty half-built town of Sanctuary to the mysterious messages and the feeling of being watched Emily wonders just what she has been caught up in.
I am not sure what I was expecting from this book but what I got was a story that kept me on my toes. What was clear from the start was that Emily seemed out of her depth. She had no idea what it took to be a ghost writer, and she seemed permanently on edge both with the situation and with Jack himself. When she starts getting anonymous messages it becomes evident that she is also harbouring a secret that she does not want to come out and if she will be able to protect herself from any fall out.
On the surface Jack seems to be being persecuted by the police and the press over the death of his wife, and he is going out of his way to be nice to Emily and get his story out there and maybe he is being too nice. His assistant is very controlling, and you have to wonder if it is to protect him or to prevent something coming out that may be detrimental to any case that may be brought at a later date.
As details come out about the true cause of his wife’s death and the events running up to it via a dual timeline, the strange incidents in Florida start to add a more sinister edge to the book with the tension building right until the very end and it was not something I was expecting. If you like psychological thrillers then this book will be for you.

Was this review helpful?

Catherine Ryan Howard is one of my favourite crime thriller writers and the synopsis for Burn After Reading intrigued me. We follow an author who has been tasked with ghostwriting a book for a man who has been accused of killing his wife.

Catherine Ryan Howard is incredible at writing tension and suspense. I was hooked from the first chapter! I loved the slow build-up and how it switched between perspectives and timelines. I also appreciated how it brought up questions on morality within the publishing industry.

Would strongly recommend if you're looking for a cleverly written story with a layered plot.

Was this review helpful?

This is probably somewhere between a 3-4 star but I'm feeling generous and it is one of the better thrillers I've read lately so 4* it is.

It had all of the elements of a good thriller - fast paced, twists and turns, dual narratives and just enough creepy and strange goings on to keep me on my toes. I think what made me appreciate this one more than other thrillers I've read lately in that the twist was actually quite good. I was concerned at points that it was going to end up going down a pretty typical thriller plot twist route - but I was pretty impressed with the twist and with how things played out in the end. I do like it when the main character has at least some trustworthy and reliable people in her life. (sorry if that's vague but I'm trying to avoid using the spoiler tag).

I also liked that the main character didn't make too many stupid or nonsensical decisions for the point of the plot. Some things were questionable, yes, but for the most part she seemed to have her head screwed on and was fairly smart about things.

All in all - a solid thriller. It won't change your life but it's definitely one of the better ones.

Was this review helpful?

Emily is a writer, but she has only written one book. She is struggling to write the second and is constantly worried because she has already spent all the money she was paid in advance. When her publisher approaches her with an offer to ghostwrite for a famous cyclist, she feels she has to take the job, even though she doesn't want to and it seems a bit fishy. Jack was a famous cyclist in his day, but when his wife died in a fire, the police quickly focused on him, but there was not enough evidence. Now he wants to write a book and tell the story from his point of view. And Emily is to write it for him. But she is not sure if she can trust Jack. Maybe he did kill his wife.

I have read several of the author's books over the years. I have to say that this was not her strongest. Unfortunately, nothing happens for many pages and it's also quite boring. I also found the parts from Jack's wife's point of view a bit confusing. I could not relate to any of the characters because Emily is a very dull person and Jack is not as mysterious as the author wants us to believe. The twist is quite obvious. All in all, this is a decent thriller, but nothing new or exciting.

Was this review helpful?

3.5/5

Emily was only able to deliver one book of her two book contract. However, as it’s been years, as her second book she is tasked with ghost writing the story of Jack Smyth who has been accused of murdering his wife and setting his house on fire. Well, it’s that or she has to return the £25k advance on book 2 (which she doesn’t have).

Her previous release, The Trap was a tough act to follow. This story has taken some inspiration from OJ Simpson’s book, If I Did It.

I thought that this was a little something different compared to your standard thriller. I loved the plot idea and the setting was interesting!

I did struggle to engage at times with the writing and the ending was a bit of a disappointment. It was too long yet too short at the same time. Some elements of the story dragged, yet there were other things I wanted to know more about!

Thank you Bantam and Netgalley for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you SO much to Catherine Ryan Howard and Random House UK for my copy of Burn After Reading. When I saw that she had a new book out I HAD to have it! This book was about famous cyclist Jack Smyth, a man who lost his beautiful wife in a fire. When it came out that she was dead before the fire started, the nation’s sympathy turned to rage, and though Jack was never charged, he was surrounded by suspicion. The only way out is for him to tell his story.

When Emily is offered a job as his ghostwriter, she needs the money more than she wants to say no. She’s flown to a remote location, holed up with Jack for a week to learn his story in order to write his way into the hearts of the public. But soon she isn’t sure what is right and what is wrong, and Emily is part of a dangerous plot that she never wanted to be a part of.

Thoughts: I loved this book! It had so many similarities to the OJ Simpson/ Nicole Brown case that I actually went back and watched a documentary about it. Did you know that OJ even wrote a book about “if” he did it? I didn’t! Anyway, this story was intriguing, and about Jack wanting to tell the story of how he didn’t kill Kate. He wants to explain his side of the story, in hopes that he can get the public on his side.

I liked that Emily also had a past, and the way it was mixed in with the story. I wish there was more of it that came into play, because I think it would have made the story more interesting. I also think there could have been even more of a build up of tension. I thought the structure of this book was really well done, and it was creatively written like all of Howard’s books. 4-stars for this one!

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book, I think it was really cleverly written, and I kept waiting to read it!!!!

I haven't read anything previously by this author, but I will now.

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

When I read a book by Catherine Ryan Howard I always have a nagging feeling at the edge of my mind that I’m reading a true crime book and not a fictional one due to the incredible way she tells her stories. This was no exception, in fact it has me wondering if this author was ‘Roxie’ and wondering which of her books was her ‘The Witness’! Silly I know but her books tell amazing stories which do fire my imagination and keep the pages turning ever faster in my quest to know all she will tell me!
This story is told in two timelines after the flash forward to Emily’s last night in Florida. We have the now where we are hearing Jack’s version of his life and the then where we see what did happen to Kate.. The story is totally engaging and the characters are so well drawn that they felt real as I struggled to figure out who to believe and place my trust in.

Was this review helpful?

A brilliant, tense and exciting concept. I really enjoyed the alternating perspectives which took us closer to finding out what happened to Kate. Gripping story, twists along the way and plenty of secrets - what I love in a thriller.

Was this review helpful?

I heard good things about this book so was excited to get an arc of it but I just was not into the descriptive writing and I was waiting for a twist or something surprising but it never came. Unfortunately it was too slow of a read that I ended up dnfing half way through.

Was this review helpful?

This is the eighth thriller from Catherine Ryan Howard and I’ve had the privilege of being able to follow her career from the start with the excellent Distress Signals. This book isn’t the first time she has dabbled in the world of the writer – the excellent The Nothing Man had a similar idea, but this is a very different book.

I’ll be honest – that’s the idea of reviews after all – this took a while to get going for me. The tension is on a low boil for most of the book and a number of the reveals didn’t catch me out like some of… no, most of Catherine’s books have.

Emily is a strong central character and while the surprises weren’t that surprising, her story – and Jack’s – is still a good read. I suppose the problem here is that I’m inevitably comparing it to the writer’s other books, like the excellent Run Time, and this is “just” a perfectly good thriller (if a tad slow in places).

Was this review helpful?

Catherine Ryan Howard is an auto buy author for me and I have read and enjoyed most of her books, so when she has a new release it immediately becomes one of my most anticipated reads of the year.
I had the same excitement going in to this one and I purposely went into it blind.
Unfortunately I found this to be not one of her best books.
For a start nothing really happens for the first half of the book. I found the pacing and plot to be actually really dull and slow. However I was intrigued by where the plot would go so I kept on going.
My main issue on finishing the book was that I thought it to be so unbearably dull, flat and lacking any tension, mystery or thrills.
I thought that both of the main characters Emily and Jack lacked any depth or personality and were really boring 2D characters to follow. I just never cared about them.
I feel like the story could have benefitted from chapters from Jack's perspective as this would have added some depth to the plot and character.
This could have been so much better than it was and I ended it feeling really disappointed. It's not that the writing was bad, just how dull the story was.
This wasn't my favourite by this author but I would read from her again.
But the cover is great though!

Was this review helpful?

Catherine Ryan Howard is always an auto read author for me. Her book, The Nothing Man is still one of my favourite thriller books. If you haven’t read it then what are you doing? You are seriously missing out. Anyway, Burn After Reading has such an intriguing plot, I dare you to pick this up and not be hooked. I had so many ideas and theories going around in my head it was crazy. Her books are always a wild ride and this one was no different.

We have 2 main characters in Burn After Reading.. first we have Jack. He is an Olympic cycling champion, a businessman and a very charismatic man . But is he also a killer? His wife died less than a year ago in a tragic house fire, but the autopsy revealed that she was already dead before the fire started. The guards haven’t been able to charge him yet but the public opinion is that he is guilty. Enter Emily, the writer of a very successful book who is struggling to get that second book written. Her publishers offer her the chance to wipe her debt with them by ghostwriting Jacks story.

Tell me that doesn’t make you want run out and get this book now! There is a lot more to it but that is all you need for now. We find out that Jack isn’t the only one with secrets as we get further into the book, we learn why Emily is struggling with another novel.

It is a dark and very cleverly written story that will keep you in the edge of your seat and turning pages well past your bedtime.

Thank you so much to Random House UK, Transworld Publishing on NetGalley for my advanced copy of this fantastic book to read. Publishes on April 10th,

Was this review helpful?

Not going to lie, I struggled with this one quite a bit. I even thought about DNFing but I really wanted to know what happened since the starting chapter got me hooked.

The premise and the setting of this book is interesting in itself. Writing a book wuth a murderer confesion? I foubd this quite mysterious and the suspense made me keep going.

However, the execution did fail me a bit. Some bits of the storyline related to cycling made me skip those parts. And definitely the characters drove me mad and I felt no sympathy for anyone. Despite the subplot of the main character in relation to her own book.

Entertaining enough. I did finish it but the ending was as well a bit all over the place.

Was this review helpful?

I am Catherine Ryan Howard’s biggest fan!!

After reading every book Howard has put out I freaked out when I got the email about this so a huge thank you!!

This isn’t like your typical Howard book she’s definitely known for her huge twists although there is twists in this it’s nothing ground breaking which I can see being abit controversial but me personally loved that it wasn’t anyone so crazy to take away from the story!

Always expect the unexpected when it comes to Howard’s books!!

Was this review helpful?

This book kept my attention throughout and I didn't know which characters to trust. The plot does veer into the unbelievable and the end became predictable around halfway through, but I read it all so that's a good sign! Thanks for the ARC. 4.5 rounded up.

Was this review helpful?

Sinister, Compelling..
Jack Smyth is haunted by suspicion. Losing his wife in a house fire, unable to save her, he was initially branded a hero but when it was found that she was dead before the fire Jack then fell under suspicion. When he signs a book deal to tell his side of the story, he knows that he needs a ghostwriter. Enter Emily, who has her own secrets. A suspenseful and immersive thriller, claustrophobic and compelling, with a well crafted and credible cast of characters populating a propulsive and menacing plot. Wholly atmospheric, sinister and engaging.

Was this review helpful?

"Burn After Reading" by Catherine Ryan Howard is a thriller that promises a lot of intrigue with its "book within a book" narrative structure. The plot revolves around Jack Smyth, who is perceived as a hero after trying to save his wife from their burning home, only for it to be revealed that she was already dead before the fire started. Suspicion has haunted him since, and he decides to write a book to clear his name, with the help of Emily, a first-time ghost-writer with her own guilty secrets.

The story offers a tantalizing mix of mystery and suspense, drawing readers into the complexities of the characters' lives and secrets. However, while the premise is engaging, the execution sometimes teeters on the edge of credibility. The characters, didn't fully capture my empathy, leaving me somewhat detached from their struggles and experiences.

Despite its shortcomings, the book had much to recommend it, not least that the ending of the book is satisfying.

Was this review helpful?

ooh this was a goody. it built tension so well. its also had me flip flapping and 2nd guessing who was innocent or not. i wasnt sure from the get go who i could trust. but i found the stroyline was just so yummy because of that. and it made me more nervous of the plot too. like i was in this maze not knowing which turn would come up with an enemy.
the story is told in dual timelines too, where we get two very different people in this plots point of view. and how slowly the comin together of these give you the actual picture...or does it? i was also worried this would end on a " you decide" kind of vibe. which i dont usually like because i want to know the authors ACTUAL decision and not trust my own, ha.
so firstly we have emily. she is one of the points of view. she has been given the task of ghost writing for someones else after her first and only succces landed her in a funk.
the book will be of Jack. he was hailed a hero for running into the burning building to save his wife. but sadly for him the forensics say his wfie was already dead. so ermmmm whats going on Jack? murder?
the build up of what comes next is superb. and i dont want to reveal any of the little "oh!" moments to come. as each chapter slips in a few.
Catherine is an author you can trust with this type of thriller and its the type of thriller thats when done well, a win win win ding ding ding for me.

Was this review helpful?