Skip to main content

Member Reviews

One of my favorite Susanna Kearsley titles!

The setting is unique and the details make an immersive read. Readers can tell the effort Kearsley puts into research even without reading the note for the author.. I have a list of historical figure, places, and facts to research about early 1600s England and Scotland. The perfect mix of character driven storylines and plot with a dash of romance and pinch of magic.


Perfect for fans of Outlander, historical fiction readers, and magical realism lovers.

Was this review helpful?

The King's Messenger blends historical intrigue with rich storytelling. Kearsley’s lush prose and well-developed characters make it an immersive, captivating read.

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy from Sourcebooks Landmark in exchange for a fair review. Publish date March 4th.

Picked this book out since I was intrigued by the historical romance plot set in the early seventeenth century. In The King’s Messenger, the titular king's messenger, Andrew Logan, is sent to Scotland with his nemesis and her father to arrest a man in connection with the death of the late prince. But as both Logan and Phoebe begin to realize, Sir David Moray might be no more than a scapegoat for the ruthless King James, and they may not be able to escape from the dangerous games of kings...

Kearsley does an excellent job with the 1613 setting, and it's obvious that she's done her research. I learned several new things about how riding pillion worked historically. I was also entertained by learning in the author's note that the brave and mysterious organization of the King's Messengers still exists today in the modern British government--as part of the Foreign, Commonwealth, and Development Office (FCDO Services). I also enjoyed seeing a period depicted that's a bit off the beaten track, as I tend to see either the Elizabethan period or the English Civil War get much more attention.

The novel itself is structured effectively as an understated romance novel between Logan and Phoebe while they spend the majority of the novel travelling on horseback from Scotland to London. The romance did suffer a bit from being jammed into the enemies to lovers trope, as it reflects on Phoebe poorly to hate a perfectly nice guy for no reason. However, the arc is compellingly depicted overall. I liked how Logan discreetly gifts Phoebe a plaid wrap, notes multiple times in his POV that she doesn't know how to do the traditional folds, and then finally puts it on her properly with her permission as a symbol of their growing intimacy. Secondarily, The King’s Messenger is an examination of the death of Prince Henry, James' son, through flashbacks narrated by Sir David Moray and POV sections by Queen Anna. There is also a minor fantasy element included, that of Logan's Second Sight, but it's not a major part of the plot. Although I did like the delightfully morbid detail of Logan experiencing visions of people who are fated to die imminently with their winding sheets advancing farther up their bodies as their time approaches.

A subtle and compelling historical romance set in the early seventeenth century. If you enjoyed this book, I'd recommend checking out Stella Riley's historical romances set in the English Civil War.

Was this review helpful?

Another beautiful love story from Susanna Kearsley! In the King's Messenger she explores the lives of the ancestors of characters from The Winter Sea a century before they will become embroiled in the Jacobite Rebellion. The central love story is between Andrew Logan, a King's Messenger and Phoebe Westaway, the daughter of a scribe who works in the king's court. Their relationship develops from one characterized by antagonism and irritation to one of mutual respect then love in such a lovely, natural way. Susanna Kearsley is so skilled at writing love stories that feel cozy and intimate while sweeping historical events happen around them. She places her characters in a time and place that adds stakes to their story but ultimately the story is about Andrew and Phoebe and how they grow to love each other. This was a very enjoyable read and will likely spark a re-read of all my Kearsley favorites.

Was this review helpful?

One of Kearsley's most tightly plotted stories, I was enthralled from start to finish. It differs somewhat from many of her other books in that it remains firmly rooted in the past and doesn't have her more typical duel plots and shifting timelines. We enter in the 17th century and stay there to enjoy the alternating narrative points of view of four distinct characters. I ended up loving all of them and thought that each offered a new perspective on the events surrounding the main story. Like A Desperate Fortune, my favorite Kearsley, this one centers on a road trip in which two reserved people grow to understand and love each other through the intense survival experience they share.

On the surface, the story is about Andrew Logan's errand to travel to Scotland as the King's Messenger to bring back the man the king says is responsible for his son's death. The errand quickly gets complicated by a bit of a motley crew accompanying Andrew, including an elderly and ailing scrivener with hidden motives, his daughter and Andrew's antagonistic love interest, a young apprentice they pick up along the way, and David Moray, the possible Prince-killer. Seeing this group cohere and become deeply loyal to each other is such a pleasure. The trip itself is filled with thrilling moments of danger as they are hunted and pursued through rough territories. There is so much tension too trying to determine all of the political jockeying that takes place among the King's men, the Moray clan of Scotland, and the divided loyalty Andrew feels for his King alongside his growing belief that he is a mere pawn in a treacherous campaign.

No Kearsley novel would succeed without a riveting love story at its center, and Andrew and Phoebe are as compelling as any characters she's written. I did struggle a little initially with Phoebe's dubious attraction to another man, who is revealed very early to be a shady character. Her belief in him causes her to distrust Andrew, and much of their story requires them to work through their prejudices and appreciate each other.

If I had one criticism of the book, the paranormal element of Second Sight that Andrew was born with confused me at times. It plays a key role in a number of the more exciting moments in the novel, but I felt that I didn't always understand the rules of when it appears, or often even what it reveals, and why. In all honesty though, I might feel this way about paranormal elements in her other novels too.

Overall, this is a fabulous book that I didn't want to finish. All of Kearsley's books are comfort reads for me, but The King's Messenger manages to be deeply romantic, politically thrilling, and edge-of-your-seat reading all at once. I could not believe the ending that is based on actual events and raced through the author notes at the end to verify that the stories she shared in the final pages are factually based. Highly, highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

This historical fiction based on real events during King James reign was amazing! The author blended historical fiction, slow burn romance, and magical realism in a way that made it difficult to put the book down. Lovable fictional characters and historical figures become entangled in the real-life tragedy surrounding the death of the beloved young Prince Henry, who was loved by his subjects. Multiple points of view, enemies to lovers romance, well written and researched.
I loved the author's note on her inspiration for the book and historical background regarding King's messengers, Sir David Moray, Prince Henry, King James and Queen Anne.

Thank you to NetGalley and Sourcebooks Landmark for the advanced copy!

Was this review helpful?

The King's Messenger is another hit out of the park for one of my favorite authors, Susanna Kearsley. I am always amazed at how well Kearsley can weave modern day storylines in seamlessly with historical facts and events! In The King's Messenger, you are immediately drawn in to the story of Andrew Logan who is sent on a mission from King James to arrest Sir David Moray. Using his secret "second sight" and with the help of new friends, Andrew finds that his mission is not exactly as it seems to be at first glance. The story is told from the different point of view of the characters. The vibrancy of these characters and their relationships with each other jump to life off the page. I loved reading this book and can't wait for her next novel !

Was this review helpful?

I can’t even begin to tell you how much I enjoyed this book. With many books it takes me 20-30% to really become invested and I loved these characters and the writing style within the first few pages. All I can say is that Logan is my new book boyfriend! I will absolutely be recommending this book to all of my friends. Beautifully written! This is my first solid 5 star review of the year.

Was this review helpful?

This historical fiction book based in the 17th century is absolutely endearing!! I loved the rich detail, great character arc, superb plot and the flow of the story. Simply a great and wholesome read. My first book by Kearsley but certainly not my last book.

Was this review helpful?

This is another well-written, well-researched, and just plain enjoyable Historical Fiction by Susanna Kearsley. Based on historical events, this book brings together a cast of characters who were delightful to know. Reading this book made me want to research the events on which the book was based.

I received an ARC for free and gave my honest opinion voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

The King’s Messenger by Susanna Kearsley is a historical fiction with a touch of magical realism, and I couldn’t put it down. This book is about medieval intrigue as the death of a healthy, young prince of Wales causes suspicions to run wild. Sir David Moray, the prince’s First Gentleman, is wanted for questioning surrounding the suspicious death of the otherwise healthy prince. This book is told from several POVs and it primarily follows Andrew Logan, the King’s Messenger, and his scribe and daughter as they are sent on a mission to collect Sir David Moray and return him to the king.

As the travel, it becomes more and more apparent that Sir David is not only innocent, but is the only living person who can attest to what did happen in the Prince’s final days, and this knowledge makes him a threat to those responsible. And the guilty will stop at nothing to cover their tracks.

Full of intrigue, closed door romance, and medieval adventure, this book checks all the boxes. It did take about 15% of the book the adjust to the vernacular used throughout. I’m not at all Scottish, but I was impressed with the consistency in which Kearsley utilizes it - I would have assumed she was a Scottish native. Her ability to pull the language into the story really adds to the world building and allows the reader to sink into it. I really enjoyed this story and the manner in which Kearsley adds color to King James— the son of Mary Queen of the Scots and King of England after the death of Queen Elizabeth I of England.

I would like to thank Sourcebooks Landmark and NetGalley for the eARC in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

An interesting perspective on an overlooked time in British History. The characters were well developed and the scenery was so well described as to be a character in itself. I enjoyed how their personalities were revealed and evolved as the plot went on. The mystery of what truly happened to Prince Henry and the fate of an innocent man accused of his murder kept the plot moving along rapidly.

Was this review helpful?

Though not my favorite genre, this book was really good….even to me! Filled with adventure, fans of historical fiction, fantasy, and romance will enjoy this!!!

Was this review helpful?

I've come to expect novels from Susanna Kearsley to be extensively researched and about an aspect of history that I knew little about. The King's Messenger was no exception! The novel follows one of King James I's messengers after the death of Prince Henry Frederick, as he's dispatched to Scotland to arrest Sir David Moray (part of Prince Henry's household).

We jump back and forth between the viewpoints of Andrew Logan, the messenger; Sir David; Phoebe, the daughter of the scribe accompanying Logan; and Queen Anna, wife of King James. Besides jumping POVs every chapter, the story also jumps around from the present in 1613 to earlier times, especially in David and Queen Anna's POV sections, which became a little confusing at times.

I was expecting more intrigue and suspense surrounding Logan's mission, but that aspect of the story was fairly straight-forward. Logan's Second Sight added Kearsley's usual supernatural/magical realism to the story, and I liked how what he Saw often played out differently in reality.

The romance was maybe the weakest point for me, because Phoebe is a rather unlikeable character at the beginning. Over the course of the novel, we come to understand why she behaves that way, and she does change, but I found her initial attitude off-putting.

I really enjoyed Kearsley's Author's Note at the end, and looked up several things while reading. I don't think The King's Messenger is in my top tier of Kearsley novels, but it was still an intriguing read.

Was this review helpful?

3-1/2 stars

Andrew is The King’s Messenger. He goes wherever King James tells him to go to complete the King’s bidding. This time, Andrew is instructed to pick up Sir David Moray who is accused of being involved in Prince Henry’s death and bring him to the King to stand trial. Joining Andrew on this journey will be a scrivener instructed to write down everything Sir David says as well as the scrivener’s daughter, Phoebe, to help care for her ailing father. Phoebe and her father are actually neighbors of Andrew’s and the ongoing general ill will between Phoebe and Andrew is sure the add discomfort to the days ahead. The trip is filled with adventure and the traveling members get to know each other better, often changing opinions of each other, during their long journey.

I’ve read and enjoyed ten novels written by Susanna Kearsley so I was thrilled to receive a galley of this novel! This is the first new novel I’ve read by her in six years. As with her other novels, the characters are wonderful and the historic settings are very clearly imagined. The romance was satisfying as the relationship altered and grew between Phoebe and Andrew. (And had no detailed sexual descriptions, as usual, for those who don’t like that.) The rest of the people in their traveling band were particularly loveable and I enjoyed journeying with them through their adventure. Historically, this book wasn’t as rich as Kearsley’s other novels in terms of history I learned. But the real people were imagined by Kearsley in a way that felt true to their roles and time, and I was satisfied just learning about the people. Sadly, while I know some of these characters appeared in previous Kearsley novels, I read them so long ago that I can’t remember them. The aspect of fantasy in this one was fun and peppered into the novel just enough. <chef’s kiss>

If you like Kearsley’s novels, you’ll like this one! Although, this one doesn’t follow her typical formula of dual storylines which I’ve described in reviews of her other books. But the structure of this book was perfect for this story. I’m so glad she has published a new novel!

Thank you to NetGalley and Sourcebooks for allowing me to read this before it’s publication date of 3/4/2025!

I'll add my blog post link once it gets posted there.

Was this review helpful?

COMING SOON: "The King's Messenger" - 5 Stars - Historical Fiction / Magical Realism

Susanna Kearsley does an excellent job of creating very real characters, in a historical context, while also including magical elements organically so that this story is very much a work of historical fiction with a touch of "other" rather then a fantasy story set in a historical setting. Kearsley does this in all of her novels and it's one of my favorite things about her work.

What Works: The characters in this story feel very real and the fact that they aren't speaks to Kearsley's ability to take detailed historical research and tease out people and places, events and dialogue that feel accurate and believable. She also always has some element of 'other', in this case with a main character having the ability to 'see', in flashes, the future. This detail is just part of the character, like his job, and his family relationships. I love the natural treatment of something considered unnatural. I also love the inclusion of real historic people in the story line.

Opportunities: This is a little bit of a slow burn as the characters trek towards their historically accurate futures. Granted, I was reading at a snails pace this fall, so this could partially be on me. I typically never have an issue with thorough backstory and character development though, and this could have been snappier, but might have lost some of the GAF that I wanted.

I'm always excited when a new Susanna Kearsley books comes out, and I will always read them, but I do wish she would write faster, but I'll be patient if it means that the level of historical research and accuracy continues. Quality over quantity.

As always, I appreciate the opportunity afforded me to have an early read by netgalley and Sourcebooks Landmark. The opinions in this review are expressly those of ButIDigressBookClub and are intended for use by my followers and friends when choosing their next book. #butidigress #butidigressbookclub #thekingsmessenger #susannakearsley #netgalley #netgalleyreviewer #arc #arcs #historicalfiction

Was this review helpful?

The King's Messenger opens in England in 1613, the Prince of Wales has died recently and King James tasks one of his messengers, Andrew Logan, with arresting Prince Henry's chief advisor, Sir David Moray, to find out what he knows about the suspicious death. The bulk of the book follows Andrew, and his motley crew from the highlands of Scotland back to London after the arrest of Sir David, as they attempt to evade David's Scottish cousins who are determined to free David before he can be brought before the King. This is a complicated tale where all is certainly not as it seems, primarily because of political intrigue and corruption that is at play. Logan has the Sight but must hide it from his King for fear of the superstitions about witchcraft that would follow him.
The book is told in alternating chapters from the perspective of Andrew, as well as Sir David Moray, and Phoebe Westaway, the daughter of the scrivener sent to take David's testimony about working for the young Prince. We are given brief glimpses back in time from David's perspective about how he came to be part of the prince's household and the plot of corruption behind those who truly murdered the prince are slowly revealed. The plotting is tense and well written, and the conclusion was very satisfying as well. I enjoyed learning more about a time period I have not read much about previously, and in particular the author's note at the end of the book was very educational.
Thank you to Sourcebooks Landmark and NetGalley for the electronic ARC of this novel for review.

Was this review helpful?

Royal Messenger Andrew Logan is ordered to Scotland by King James the first in 1613 to find and take into custody, Sir David Moray, close companion, and advisor to the late Prince Henry. It seems the King and some of his counselors want Sir David Moray arrested for the young prince’s implied murder. Andrew knows that not only his mission is of the utmost secrecy, but his own propensity for Second Sight which has served him in ways not always easy to endure. On the long journey back from Leith, Andrew is joined by one of the King’s Scriveners and his daughter, Phoebe Westaway.

The Westaways live in the same area as the Logans where Phoebe and Andrew have long had a contentious relationship. As the difficult and often perilous journey progresses, both Andrew and his companions, which also includes a young stable lad, begin to question not only the veracity of Sir David’s supposed guilt, but the complicity of those who would see him hang. While on the long journey which includes having to avoid some of Sir David’s Scottish cousins who take exception to his detention, Phoebe begins to change her opinion of Andrew Logan whom she always thought of with disdain.

This story is told by four POVS combining fact with fiction to portray the life of a King’s messenger, Court intrigue as well as the Queen’s own often contentious relationship with King James, David Moray and Prince Henry’s history, and life in general in the late 1500’s and early 1600’s of England and Scotland.

While Ms. Kearsley weaves the known historic facts in the tale, it is the relationships of the characters that add vibrancy and interest to the time. The author’s skill at bringing these historical people so vividly to life will enhance the knowledge of and entertain well readers of this genre. In addendum, the author’s end notes, "About the Characters" make a fascinating supplement giving salient information to the historical aspects. They are well worth a read supplying more background to the story as well as giving examples of the historical characters’ own words.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley! This is my first book by this author, although several of her others have been on my TBR list for quite a while. Set in the late 1500s to early 1600s in England and Scotland. Phoebe Westaway lives a quiet life with her frail father who serves the King as a scribe. Obliged to accept a new assignment, Phoebe demands to come and attend to him on his mission. Andrew Logan, a huge, strong man, is the messenger her father is to attend during his travels to Scotland to capture and return Sir David Moray to the kingdom for trial. Sir David was the companion of the late Prince Henry. The story is filled with intrigue and relationships that evolve as the truths are revealed. Very well done and highly recommend,

Was this review helpful?

The writing masterfully evokes the atmosphere of the 17th century while remaining accessible to modern readers. The story is a captivating blend of historical fiction and magical realism, and I was completely drawn into the mystery surrounding Prince Henry’s death and the gripping court intrigue that followed.

Andrew Logan’s character was fascinating, especially with the added layer of his Sight. This subtle fantasy element complemented the historical setting beautifully, enhancing the tension and stakes. The slow-budding romance between Andrew and Phoebe was tender and well-paced, adding just the right touch of emotional depth to the story.

What truly stood out to me were the many layers of love explored throughout the book—romantic, platonic, and familial. They added a richness to the narrative that was both heartwarming and heartbreaking.

Overall, The King’s Messenger is a beautifully written tale of treachery, betrayal, and love. If you enjoy historical fiction with a dash of magical realism, this one is not to be missed! Highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?