Skip to main content

Member Reviews

How can you review Agatha Christie after all this time? Nothing new can be said beyond her books - including this one - being bestsellers for a reason. Love the new concept for this in hardback with the envelope at the back. Looking forward to seeing what this looks like.

Was this review helpful?

This is one of my favourite books of all time. Such a clever concept and proves just how dark and sinister Christie can be. It was a joy to reread

This new edition looks beautiful and the concept of the letter at the end is a great gimmick. It's gimmicky but fun and a clever tie in with the story events.

This is a great gift idea for the criminally minded in your circle of friends or family!

Was this review helpful?

Agatha Christie one of the greatest mystery writer . I loved the book . I was happy to have guessed right the murder.
It was complicated murder mystery set on Soldier Island. Ten guests are invited all of them have something they are trying to escape and they all take the opportunity they are provided with . One after another all are murdered.
There is a mystery of who murdered all of them and did they set everything back in certain order and left the island ? Did they escape ? But how did they do that ? There is a last concealed chapter that leads to the answer.
Thank you to NetGalley and HarperCollins UK for the opportunity to read the book . Would love to read more such books and dive into Agatha Christie’s world .

Was this review helpful?

A well plotted crime, fully rounded characters with succinct back stories and their crimes. Thoroughly absorbing. Got to the end and then found myself looking back again at some of the characters trying to find the clues to let me know who was responsible. Very cleverly done.
Many thanks to Netgalley/Agatha Christie/HarperCollins UK for a digital copy of this title. All opinions expressed are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Thoroughly enjoyed this read and loved getting the final chapter later. I had no idea who it was - kept jumping between them all and then realised it couldn't be them. Never realised how clever someone could be. Great twist...

Was this review helpful?

In Christie's 'And Then There Were None' 10 people are lured to an island off the coast of Devon. They have all committed a crime but have not faced justice. One by one they are killed. Who is the killer? Christie's brilliant plot guards the identity of the killer and in this edition the reader is invited to guess who it is before the ending is revealed,
The plot and island setting has several modern imitators but no-one does it quite like Chistie - the Queen of Crime.
A masterpiece.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an arc in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

An absolute classic, probably one of the best mysteries ever written.

Ten people are invited to Soldier Island under various guises, they have all been written to by the mysterious Mr Owen, once they are all assembled a a recording is played accusing them of various crimes. One by one people start to die.

Timeless

Was this review helpful?

And Then There Were None is widely regarded as one of Agatha Christie’s finest works, and it’s not hard to see why. The story is a masterclass in suspense and tension, bringing together ten strangers who are gradually picked off in accordance with a sinister nursery rhyme. With each murder, the noose tightens as paranoia sets in, and everyone starts to suspect one another.

One of the novel's great strengths is how Christie manages to give each of the characters enough depth and distinct traits that they stand out, despite the fact that they’re all doomed from the start. Each is guilty of a crime, whether through malice, negligence, or circumstance, and the island becomes a place where justice is served—though not in any form they could have imagined. The isolated setting creates an eerie atmosphere, amplifying the sense of entrapment as the characters' numbers dwindle.

What makes And Then There Were None so brilliant is how Christie plays with the reader’s expectations. The pace of the killings, the growing paranoia, and the way in which she drops clues and red herrings ensure that you’re constantly trying to solve the puzzle, second-guessing yourself until the final shocking twist. Even those familiar with the conventions of the mystery genre may find themselves surprised by the end.

The nursery rhyme motif that runs throughout the novel is a stroke of genius, adding a darkly playful tone to the unfolding horror. Every death mirrors the verses in the rhyme, creating a grim sense of inevitability that keeps you turning the pages. The methodical nature of the murders and the underlying question of whether there’s any justice being served make this much more than a simple whodunnit—it’s a haunting exploration of guilt, accountability, and fate. The fact that we're left unsure of some people's guilt or innocence adds an uneasy layer to the story. Christie's writing style is notably direct and to the point, eschewing the in-depth character development and world-building often found in modern fiction.

This particular edition, with its sealed letter revealing the solution only after the reader finishes, adds an interactive element, making the experience feel almost like a puzzle that you’re invited to solve alongside the characters. Even if you’ve read the story before, this version adds a fresh layer of fun.

For recommendations:

Book: The Silent Patient by Alex Michaelides – For its psychological tension and masterfully built suspense with a surprising twist.
Movie: Clue (1985) – For a murder mystery with a twist of dark comedy and an isolated setting where the cast is whittled down one by one.

Was this review helpful?

This is an original and old-fashioned Agatha Christie book, and the twist is that you don't find out who did it until you have made a guess as to the identity of the murderer.
I have never worked out the villain in an Agatha Christie book yet, but a fun concept for readers who might enjoy this concept.

Was this review helpful?

Agatha Christie at her best!
A gripping, complicated murder mystery set on Soldier Island. Ten guests invited who have played some part in a murder in the past. One by one they are all murdered.
To find out the identity of the murderer, there is a sealed envelope in the back of the book with the final chapter. Will you guess right?
Thank you to NetGalley and HarperCollins UK for an ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I am not going to review this, I was expecting a reimagining of the novel as a murder mystery, not a simple reprint with the end cut off.

Was this review helpful?

I don't read a lot of mysteries but I love this book. The setting is haunting and I was gripped till the end

Was this review helpful?

I watched the series of this ages ago but I couldn’t remember what happened so it was fun trying to figure out the killer all over again.

A select group of individuals are invited to Soldier Island. But not for the purpose they think and one by one, they meet their demise. I will say at the start it was abit confusing. A lot of characters with backstories, it was hard to keep track but I feel like this was done on purpose so you couldn’t figure out who the killer was too quickly. But such a great story with twists turns and really gets you thinking on every page. The killer isn’t who you think but it is who you think. They are in plain sight but hidden as well. Brilliant book.

I absolutely loved this edition. Being given the whole book except the last chapter such a unique experience. This reprint adds a twist with an electronic reveal; I imagine the hard copy edition with the solution in the envelope will be a gem. Such a Christiesque thing to do. Brilliant, sneaky and mysterious.

Was this review helpful?

Even though I have read the previous iteration of this many years ago I could not remember what happened so I got to enjoy it all over again.

There are many characters and initially it was difficult to keep track of who they were and what they had done, intentional I am sure.

A very clever story as one would expect from this very great author. I liked the quirky qr code and vote for the final chapter. It added extra anticipation and a bit of added interest.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publishers for the DRC

Was this review helpful?

An engrossing mystery novel where ten strangers meet on an island. All have caused the death of others in the past lives and one of their number goes about bumping them off until there are none. I didn’t guess the killer…

Was this review helpful?

And Then There Were None was the very first Agatha Christie book that I read and it is still my absolute favourite. She was a fantastic writer and it is so sad that there will never be any new stories from her. Still, it was lovely to revisit this wonderful story again, thank you NetGalley and the publishers.

Was this review helpful?

Agatha Christie's And Then There Were None is a literary masterpiece that has captivated readers for generations. While the language can be challenging due to its historical context, the remarkable depth and complexity of the narrative truly shine through. The effort and meticulous thought that Christie put into crafting this story is nothing short of extraordinary.

The intricacies of the plot and the attention to detail elevate this mystery to one of the best in literary history. Each character is meticulously developed, with layers that gradually unfold as the story progresses, drawing readers into a web of suspense and intrigue. Christie’s ability to weave together the various threads of the plot creates an engaging experience that keeps readers on the edge of their seats.

The setting—an isolated island with a chilling atmosphere—serves as a perfect backdrop for the unfolding drama. As tensions rise and the stakes grow higher, the sense of dread becomes palpable. The carefully constructed narrative leads to an unexpected and thrilling conclusion, solidifying the book's status as a classic.

http://thesecretbookreview.co.uk

Was this review helpful?

I first read this probably some 50 years ago and reading it again reminded me why Agatha Christie’s books have endured. This is a true crime classic, it’s a premise which has proved the basis for numerous books, plays and films since. A select group of individuals are invited to Soldier Island. But not for the purpose they think and one by one, they meet their demise. The story is so carefully crafted; Christie writes with elegance which hardly seems dated in many respects. It’s easy to visualise her characters and her motivations are appropriate. This reprint adds a twist with an electronic reveal; I imagine the hard copy edition with the solution in the envelope will be a gem.

I really enjoyed this and it’s prompted me to look again at a few more of her titles, just an amazing author. .

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this one and it put my detective skills to the test! Although I had heard a lot about this classic I had never engaged and this this would be the perfect opportunity!

I managed to guess the culprit correctly which is always a confidence boost!

Overall a solid classic murder mystery

Was this review helpful?

Well that was a fun read.

Didn’t expect to enjoy the story that much. Probably because I am still constantly reminded of how much my family did not enjoy Mousetrap when I booked us West End tickets a couple of years backs.

Anyway, very easy and enjoyable read.
And the little digital scan & reveal at the end was a very nice modern twist on a classic.

Thank You NetGalley and HarperCollins UK for a Review Copy.

Was this review helpful?